MAC Lip Pencils have a smooth, creamy texture that are perfect for shaping, lining or filling in the lip. The shade "Spice" is described as a pink cinnamon stick hue. It retails for $24 at Ulta, Nordstrom Rack & Amazon. The Dupes 1. Milani Color Statement Lip Liner "Spice" ($4.99) | Buy at MILANI, AMAZON