Name	Known for
Brittany Tomkin Myrtle Myrtle See fewer	Dimension 20 (2018)
Jorja Hudson Willoughby Willoughby See fewer	Sexiest Man Alive
Will Hines Captain Kipperary Captain Kipperary See fewer	The Sex Lives of College Girls (2021)
Dom Manzolillo Sam Goodguy Sam Goodguy See fewer	Breaking Up (I) (2014)
Rich Armstead Shmih Shmih See fewer	The Blacklist (2013)
Sharon Spell Sybil Sybil See fewer	Adam Ruins Everything (2015)
Jake Hyland Phil Collins Phil Collins See fewer	The Cicada Hunk (2015)
Louie Aronowitz Bushwick Cop Bushwick Cop See fewer	The Sandwich (I) (2021)
Ezequiel Asnaghi Bushwick Cop Bushwick Cop See fewer	The Big Sale (2012)
Gabriella Rose Basile Young Willoughby Young Willoughby See fewer	The Wrong Path (2021)
Alberto Burgos Bushwick Cop Bushwick Cop See fewer	Myrtle & Willoughby (2018)
Andy Bustillos Security Hipster Security Hipster See fewer	Most Likely to Murder (2018)
Adrienne Cooper Mrs. Flipp Mrs. Flipp See fewer	Ambition (II) (2014)
Matt Czap Drunken Snako Drunken Snako See fewer	My Brother, My Brother and Me (2017)
Brett Davis Sleepy Tourist Sleepy Tourist See fewer	Our Cartoon President (2018)
Ryland Duncan Dustin Flipp Dustin Flipp See fewer	Myrtle & Willoughby (2018)
Marshall Finch Bushwick Cop Bushwick Cop See fewer	Book Club (II) (2018)
Drew Freed Box Box See fewer	Agressive Standing (2012)
Stephen Gardella Bushwick Cop Bushwick Cop See fewer	Low Budget Sketch Show (2014)
Lucas Harvie Bushwick Cop Bushwick Cop See fewer	Night Crew (2017)
Morgan Hill Bushwick Cop Bushwick Cop See fewer	Myrtle & Willoughby (2018)
Lauren Kahn Willoughby's Mom Willoughby's Mom See fewer	The Sisters Karras (2023)
Marshall Louise Pink Pink See fewer	The Passing Drummers (2007)
Andy Mills Bushwick Cop (as Andrew Mills) Bushwick Cop (as Andrew Mills) See fewer	Peanut (2020)
Peter Monica Mr. Flipp Mr. Flipp See fewer	Night Crew (2017)
Manolo Moreno Roger Smith Roger Smith See fewer	The Butcher Baker and Candlestick Maker (2014)
Dave Murray Bushwick Cop Bushwick Cop See fewer	Ramsey Has a Time Machine (2014)
Mamoudou N'Diaye Bushwick Cop Bushwick Cop See fewer	Queens (2021)
Alex Otis Bushwick Cop Bushwick Cop See fewer	Myrtle & Willoughby (2018)
Justin Perez Bushwick Cop Bushwick Cop See fewer	NPR Phone Sex (2015)
Micah Phillips Gloucester Dickbird Gloucester Dickbird See fewer	Red Hot Video Fun Time: Tony Hawk's Underground - Promo 2 (2014)
Austin Rye Rye Rye See fewer	Southern Comfort (2018)
Mia Ryvkin Young Myrtle Young Myrtle See fewer	There Was a Beginning