Name	Known for
Keegan-Michael Key Josh Skinner Josh Skinner See fewer	Keanu (2016)
Cecily Strong Melissa Gimble Melissa Gimble See fewer	Saturday Night Live (1975)
Fred Armisen Reverend Howard Layton Reverend Howard Layton See fewer	Portlandia (2011)
Dove Cameron Betsy McDonough Betsy McDonough See fewer	Schmigadoon! (2021)
Jaime Camil Doc Lopez Doc Lopez See fewer	La fea más bella (2006)
Kristin Chenoweth Mildred Layton Mildred Layton See fewer	Pushing Daisies (2007)
Alan Cumming Mayor Aloysius Menlove Mayor Aloysius Menlove See fewer	The Anniversary Party (2001)
Ariana DeBose Emma Tate Emma Tate See fewer	West Side Story (2021)
Ann Harada Florence Menlove Florence Menlove See fewer	Happiness (1998)
Jane Krakowski The Countess (credit only) The Countess (credit only) See fewer	30 Rock (2006)
Martin Short Leprechaun (credit only) Leprechaun (credit only) See fewer	Innerspace (1987)
Aaron Tveit Danny Bailey (credit only) Danny Bailey (credit only) See fewer	Les Misérables (2012)
Kevin McNulty Farmer McDonough Farmer McDonough See fewer	Snakes on a Plane (2006)
Viola Abley Freckle-Faced Girl Freckle-Faced Girl See fewer	Schmigadoon! (2021)
Alex Barima Freddy Freddy See fewer	Resident Alien (2021)
Bijou Brattston Tootie McDonough Tootie McDonough See fewer	Schmigadoon! (2021)
Cassandra Consiglio Nancy Nancy See fewer	Schmigadoon! (2021)
Nolen Dubuc Buck-Toothed Boy Buck-Toothed Boy See fewer	Prom Pact (2023)
Darcey Johnson Innkeeper Harvey Innkeeper Harvey See fewer	A Series of Unfortunate Events (2017)
Amitai Marmorstein Pete the Milkman Pete the Milkman See fewer	Wayward Pines (2015)
Ridley Havok McLeod Wild Hair Boy Wild Hair Boy See fewer	Schmigadoon! (2021)
Scott Patey Larry the Fireman Larry the Fireman See fewer	Sonic the Hedgehog 2 (2022)
Liam Quiring-Nkindi Carson Carson See fewer	Schmigadoon! (2021)
Michelle Rios Mrs. Lopez Mrs. Lopez See fewer	Dirt (2003)
Pedro Salvín Old Doc Lopez Old Doc Lopez See fewer	The Incredible Hulk (2008)
Garfield Wilson Henry the Iceman Henry the Iceman See fewer	The Irrational (2023)
Peyton Feltham Tap Dancer Tap Dancer See fewer	Schmigadoon! (2021)
Anthony Juo Tap Dancer Tap Dancer See fewer	Schmigadoon! (2021)
Ema Lake Tap Dancer Tap Dancer See fewer	Schmigadoon! (2021)
Jenna Lamb Tap Dancer Tap Dancer See fewer	Cruel Summer (2021)
Alisa Lymar Tap Dancer Tap Dancer See fewer	Schmigadoon! (2021)
Leah Park Tap Dancer Tap Dancer See fewer	Resident Alien (2021)
Inca Scott Tap Dancer Tap Dancer See fewer	Schmigadoon! (2021)
Matias Wong Tap Dancer Tap Dancer See fewer	Schmigadoon! (2021)
Kendall Goddard Theatre Critic (uncredited) Theatre Critic (uncredited) See fewer	The Little Death (2014)