Amityville: An Origin Story - Production & Contact Info

Cast	+ Add Cast
75 cast members

Name	Episodes	Known for
Ronald DeFeo Self - Mass Murderer (archive footage) (as Ronnie 'Butch' DeFeo Jr.) Self - Mass Murderer (archive footage) (as Ronnie 'Butch' DeFeo Jr.) See fewer	4	In Search of... (1976)
George Lutz Self - Owner, 'Amityville Horror' Home (archive footage) Self - Owner, 'Amityville Horror' Home (archive footage) See fewer	4	The Amityville Horror (2005)
Kathy Lutz Self - Owner, 'Amityville Horror' Home (archive footage) Self - Owner, 'Amityville Horror' Home (archive footage) See fewer	4	The Amityville Horror (2005)
Tommy Maher Self - Friend of Ronnie DeFeo Jr. Self - Friend of Ronnie DeFeo Jr. See fewer	4	Amityville: An Origin Story (2023)
James Brolin Self - Actor, The Amityville Horror (archive footage) Self - Actor, The Amityville Horror (archive footage) See fewer	3	Traffic (2000)
Carol Soviero Self - Lutz Family Friend Self - Lutz Family Friend See fewer	3	Amityville: An Origin Story (2023)
Christopher Lutz Self - Son of Kathy Lutz / Self - Kathy Lutz's Son Self - Son of Kathy Lutz / Self - Kathy Lutz's Son See fewer	3	History's Mysteries (1998)
Laura DiDio Self - Investigative Reporter Self - Investigative Reporter See fewer	3	My Amityville Horror (2012)
Paula Uruburu Self - Friend of Dawn DeFeo Self - Friend of Dawn DeFeo See fewer	3	American Experience (1988)
Gloria Gangitano Self - DeFeo Family Friend Self - DeFeo Family Friend See fewer	3	Shattered Hopes: The True Story of the Amityville Murders - Part III: Fraud & Forensics (2014)
Erik Davis Self - Author & Cultural Scholar Self - Author & Cultural Scholar See fewer	3	A Scanner Darkly (2006)
Lorraine Warren Self - Psychic Investigator (archive footage) Self - Psychic Investigator (archive footage) See fewer	2	The Conjuring (2013)
Ed Warren Self - Psychic Investigator (archive footage) Self - Psychic Investigator (archive footage) See fewer	2	Amityville II: The Possession (1982)
David Hartman Self - Host, Good Morning America (archive footage) Self - Host, Good Morning America (archive footage) See fewer	2	The Island at the Top of the World (1974)
Merv Griffin Self - Host, The Mere Griffin Show / Self - Host, The Merv Griffin Show (archive footage) Self - Host, The Mere Griffin Show / Self - Host, The Merv Griffin Show (archive footage) See fewer	2	Jeopardy! (1984)
Don Lane Self - Host, The Don Lane Show (archive footage) Self - Host, The Don Lane Show (archive footage) See fewer	2	All Together Now (1991)
Daniel Lutz Self - Kathy Lutz's Son (archive footage) Self - Kathy Lutz's Son (archive footage) See fewer	2	My Amityville Horror (2012)
Dawn DeFeo Self - Sister (archive footage) Self - Sister (archive footage) See fewer	2
William Weber Self - Defense Attorney for Ronnie DeFeo Jr. / Self - Defense Attorney for Ronald DeFeo Jr. (archive footage) Self - Defense Attorney for Ronnie DeFeo Jr. / Self - Defense Attorney for Ronald DeFeo Jr. (archive footage) See fewer	2	History's Mysteries (1998)
Hans Holzer Self - Author & Parapsychologist (archive footage) Self - Author & Parapsychologist (archive footage) See fewer	2	The Amityville Curse (2023)
Ralph Pecoraro Self - Lutz Family Friend (archive footage) Self - Lutz Family Friend (archive footage) See fewer	2
Thomas Stark Self - Trial Judge for Ronnie DeFeo Jr. (archive footage) (as Judge Thomas Stark) Self - Trial Judge for Ronnie DeFeo Jr. (archive footage) (as Judge Thomas Stark) See fewer	2	Killing Mum & Dad (2005)
Joe Vetter Self - Friend of George Lutz Self - Friend of George Lutz See fewer	2	Shock Docs (2020)
Carol Beamer Self - Friend of Dawn DeFeo Self - Friend of Dawn DeFeo See fewer	2	Amityville: An Origin Story (2023)
Ellen Stark Self - Author & Daughter of Judge Thomas Stark Self - Author & Daughter of Judge Thomas Stark See fewer	2	Amityville: An Origin Story (2023)
Jonathan Greenaway Self - Author & Academic. Culture & Theology (as Dr. Jonathan Greenaway Ph.D) Self - Author & Academic. Culture & Theology (as Dr. Jonathan Greenaway Ph.D) See fewer	2	Amityville: An Origin Story (2023)
Joel Martin Self - News Director, WBAB Radio Self - News Director, WBAB Radio See fewer	2	Planetquake (2024)
William Chavez Self - Religious Studies Lecturer, UC Santa Barbara Self - Religious Studies Lecturer, UC Santa Barbara See fewer	2	The UnXplained (2019)
Alexandra Holzer Self - Paranormal Investigator Self - Paranormal Investigator See fewer	2	The Amityville Curse (2023)
Ryan Reynolds Self - Actor, The Amityville Horror (archive footage) Self - Actor, The Amityville Horror (archive footage) See fewer	1	Deadpool 2 (2018)
Jordan Peele Self - Horror Director (archive footage) Self - Horror Director (archive footage) See fewer	1	Nope (2022)
Eddie Murphy Self - Stand Up Comedian (archive footage) Self - Stand Up Comedian (archive footage) See fewer	1	Harlem Nights (1989)
Roger Ebert Self - Host, Sickle & Ebert (archive footage) Self - Host, Sickle & Ebert (archive footage) See fewer	1	Siskel & Ebert (1986)
Walter Cronkite Self - Host, CBS Evening News with Walter Cronkite (archive footage) Self - Host, CBS Evening News with Walter Cronkite (archive footage) See fewer	1	Liberty's Kids (2002)
Al Capone Self - Former Amityville , NY Resident (archive footage) Self - Former Amityville , NY Resident (archive footage) See fewer	1
Tom Snyder Self - Host, The Tom Snyder Show (archive footage) Self - Host, The Tom Snyder Show (archive footage) See fewer	1	McCloud (1970)
Louise DeFeo Self - Mother (archive footage) Self - Mother (archive footage) See fewer	1
Peter Hurkos Self - Psychic Detective (archive footage) Self - Psychic Detective (archive footage) See fewer	1	Bitter Heritage (1979)
Bryan Thomas Norton Self Self See fewer	1	All Hallows' Eve 2 (2015)
Maharishi Mahesh Yogi Self - Popularized Transcendental Meditation (archive footage) Self - Popularized Transcendental Meditation (archive footage) See fewer	1	Aliens from Spaceship Earth (1977)
Jay Anson Self, The Amityville Horror Novel (archive footage) Self, The Amityville Horror Novel (archive footage) See fewer	1	The Amityville Horror (1979)
Roger Mudd Self - CBS News Anchor (archive footage) Self - CBS News Anchor (archive footage) See fewer	1	CBS Reports (1959)
Ronald DeFeo Sr. Self - Father (archive footage) Self - Father (archive footage) See fewer	1
Allison DeFeo Self - Sister (archive footage) Self - Sister (archive footage) See fewer	1
Marc DeFeo Self - Brother (archive footage) Self - Brother (archive footage) See fewer	1
Michael Brigante Sr. Self - Father of Louise DeFeo (archive footage) Self - Father of Louise DeFeo (archive footage) See fewer	1
John Matthew DeFeo Self - Brother (archive footage) Self - Brother (archive footage) See fewer	1
Missy Lutz Self - Kathy Lutz's Daughter (archive footage) Self - Kathy Lutz's Daughter (archive footage) See fewer	1	History's Mysteries (1998)
Ethel Johnson-Meyers Self - Spiritual Medium (archive footage) Self - Spiritual Medium (archive footage) See fewer	1
Mary Pascarella Self - Psychic (archive footage) Self - Psychic (archive footage) See fewer	1
Raymond Buckland Self - Occult Leader & Author (archive footage) Self - Occult Leader & Author (archive footage) See fewer	1	Witchcraft: Rebirth of the Old Religion (1970)
Barbara Cromarty Self - Owner of Amityville Horror Home After the Lutz Family (archive footage) Self - Owner of Amityville Horror Home After the Lutz Family (archive footage) See fewer	1	The Last Race (2018)
Herman H. Race Self - Private Investigator (archive footage) (as Herman Race) Self - Private Investigator (archive footage) (as Herman Race) See fewer	1
Dennis Rafferty Self - Detective, Suffolk County Police Dept. (archive footage) Self - Detective, Suffolk County Police Dept. (archive footage) See fewer	1	The Serial Killers (1995)
Alberta Riley Self - Psychic (archive footage) Self - Psychic (archive footage) See fewer	1
Jim Cromarty Self - Owner of Amityville Horror Home After the Lutz Family (archive footage) Self - Owner of Amityville Horror Home After the Lutz Family (archive footage) See fewer	1	The Last Race (2018)
Chris Gugas Self - Polygrapher (archive footage) Self - Polygrapher (archive footage) See fewer	1	The Red Rowe Show (1959)
Alex Tanous Self - Author & Psychic (archive footage) Self - Author & Psychic (archive footage) See fewer	1	In Search of... (1976)
Patrick Mellon Self - Suffolk County Chief of Detectives (archive footage) Self - Suffolk County Chief of Detectives (archive footage) See fewer	1
Jackie Stone Self - NBC News (archive footage) Self - NBC News (archive footage) See fewer	1
Christopher Neil-Smith Self - Priest and Exorcist of St. Saviour's (archive footage) Self - Priest and Exorcist of St. Saviour's (archive footage) See fewer	1	Midweek (1972)
Gerard Sullivan Self - Suffolk County Prosecutor (archive footage) Self - Suffolk County Prosecutor (archive footage) See fewer	1
Seth Purdy Self - Director, Amityville Historical Society (archive footage) Self - Director, Amityville Historical Society (archive footage) See fewer	1
Michael Rice Self - Polygrapher (archive footage) Self - Polygrapher (archive footage) See fewer	1
Daniel Schwartz Self - Trial Psychiatrist for the Defense (archive footage) (as Dr. Daniel Schwartz) Self - Trial Psychiatrist for the Defense (archive footage) (as Dr. Daniel Schwartz) See fewer	1
Victor Niemi Self - Amityville Mayor (archive footage) Self - Amityville Mayor (archive footage) See fewer	1
Harold Zolan Self - Trial Psychiatrist for the Prosecution (archive footage) (as Dr. Harold Zolan) Self - Trial Psychiatrist for the Prosecution (archive footage) (as Dr. Harold Zolan) See fewer	1
John Carpenter Self - Horror Director Self - Horror Director See fewer	1	The Fog (1980)
Diane Franklin Self - Actress, Amityville II: The Possession Self - Actress, Amityville II: The Possession See fewer	1	Better Off Dead (1985)
Daniel Genis Self - Fellow Inmate of Ronnie DeFeo Jr. Self - Fellow Inmate of Ronnie DeFeo Jr. See fewer	1	Very Scary People (2019)
Michael Race Self - Ret. Homicide Detective Self - Ret. Homicide Detective See fewer	1	Shattered Hopes: The True Story of the Amityville Murders - Part III: Fraud & Forensics (2014)
Marvin Scott Self - News Reporter, PIX 11 Self - News Reporter, PIX 11 See fewer	1	In the Mouth of Madness (1994)
T.K. Young Self - Granddaughter of Father Ray's Secretary Self - Granddaughter of Father Ray's Secretary See fewer	1	Amityville: An Origin Story (2023)
Jennifer Sweeton Self - Forensic Psychologist (as Dr. Jennifer Sweeton) Self - Forensic Psychologist (as Dr. Jennifer Sweeton) See fewer	1	Amityville: An Origin Story (2023)
Shea Vassar Self - Writer & Cultural Critic, Citizen of the Cherokee Nation Self - Writer & Cultural Critic, Citizen of the Cherokee Nation See fewer	1	Julie Takes a Walk