Scary Tales of New York - Production & Contact Info

Cast	+ Add Cast
64 cast members

Name	Episodes	Known for
Colm Meaney Storyteller Storyteller See fewer	6	Star Trek: Deep Space Nine (1993)
Nell Darby Self - Crime Historian (as Dr Nell Darby) Self - Crime Historian (as Dr Nell Darby) See fewer	2	Murder by the Sea (2018)
Harold Schechter Self - Author of 'The Mad Sculptor' / Self - True Crime Writer Self - Author of 'The Mad Sculptor' / Self - True Crime Writer See fewer	2	Law & Order (1990)
Eoin Lynch William O'Dwyer William O'Dwyer See fewer	2	The Shamrock Spitfire (2024)
Al Capone Self - Mob Boss (archive footage) Self - Mob Boss (archive footage) See fewer	1
J. Edgar Hoover Self - Director of the FBI (archive footage) Self - Director of the FBI (archive footage) See fewer	1	The Next of Kin (1942)
Bugsy Siegel Self - Murder Inc. Hitman (archive footage) Self - Murder Inc. Hitman (archive footage) See fewer	1
John Dillinger Self - Bank Robber (archive footage) Self - Bank Robber (archive footage) See fewer	1	Dillinger: Public Enemy No. 1 (1934)
Lucky Luciano Self - Mob Boss (archive footage) Self - Mob Boss (archive footage) See fewer	1
Shane Redondo Daniel Kriesberg Daniel Kriesberg See fewer	1	Idyllic (2025)
Morgan C. Jones Dr. James Brussel Dr. James Brussel See fewer	1	TWIG (2024)
Thomas E. Dewey Self - Prosecutor (archive footage) Self - Prosecutor (archive footage) See fewer	1	Gillette Cavalcade of Sports (1944)
Vito Genovese Self - Mob Boss (archive footage) Self - Mob Boss (archive footage) See fewer	1	Kefauver Investigation (1951)
Albert Anastasia Self - Mob Boss (archive footage) Self - Mob Boss (archive footage) See fewer	1
Paul Glavin Anthony 'Tony' Marino Anthony 'Tony' Marino See fewer	1	Scary Tales of New York (2023)
Albert Tannenbaum Self - Murder Inc. Hitman (archive footage) Self - Murder Inc. Hitman (archive footage) See fewer	1
Joseph Bonanno Self - Mob Boss (archive footage) Self - Mob Boss (archive footage) See fewer	1	Bonanno: A Godfather's Story (1999)
Joseph Profaci Self - Mob Boss (archive footage) Self - Mob Boss (archive footage) See fewer	1
Vincent Mangano Self - Mob Boss (archive footage) Self - Mob Boss (archive footage) See fewer	1
Morris 'Moishe' Diamond Self - Union Official (archive footage) Self - Union Official (archive footage) See fewer	1
Giuseppe Masseria Self - Mob Boss (archive footage) Self - Mob Boss (archive footage) See fewer	1
Abe Reles Self - Murder Inc. Hitman (archive footage) Self - Murder Inc. Hitman (archive footage) See fewer	1
Liam Gaffney John McNally John McNally See fewer	1	Joey Had Never Been Out of the City (2024)
Louis Lepke Self - Murder Inc. Hitman (archive footage) Self - Murder Inc. Hitman (archive footage) See fewer	1
Noel O'Brien Joseph Murphy Joseph Murphy See fewer	1	Paddy Power: The Irish are coming! (2020)
Sean Diarmaid Giacomelli O'Dwyer Joe Maglione Joe Maglione See fewer	1	The Pope's Exorcist (2023)
Tommy Gagliano Self - Mob Boss (archive footage) Self - Mob Boss (archive footage) See fewer	1
Arnold Schuster Self - Amateur Sleuth (archive footage) Self - Amateur Sleuth (archive footage) See fewer	1
Raymond Fernandez Self - Murderer (archive footage) Self - Murderer (archive footage) See fewer	1
Martha Beck Self - Murderer (archive footage) Self - Murderer (archive footage) See fewer	1
William Lyons George Metesky George Metesky See fewer	1	Thick As Thieves (2017)
Harry 'Happy' Maione Self - Murder Inc. Hitman (archive footage) Self - Murder Inc. Hitman (archive footage) See fewer	1
Paul Boyle Michael Malloy Michael Malloy See fewer	1	Scary Tales of New York (2023)
Philip Corcoran Anthony 'Tough Tony' Bastone Anthony 'Tough Tony' Bastone See fewer	1	Scary Tales of New York (2023)
Peter Panto Self - Union Official (archive footage) Self - Union Official (archive footage) See fewer	1
Anthony 'Dukey' Maffetore Self - State Witness (archive footage) Self - State Witness (archive footage) See fewer	1
Abraham 'Pretty' Levin Self - State Witness (archive footage) Self - State Witness (archive footage) See fewer	1
Pittsburgh Phil Strauss Self - Murder Inc. Hitman (archive footage) Self - Murder Inc. Hitman (archive footage) See fewer	1
Mendy Weiss Self - Murder Inc. Hitman (archive footage) Self - Murder Inc. Hitman (archive footage) See fewer	1
Robert George Irwin Self - Murderer (archive footage) Self - Murderer (archive footage) See fewer	1
Blue Jaw Magoon Self - Murder Inc. Hitman (archive footage) Self - Murder Inc. Hitman (archive footage) See fewer	1
Frank DiMatteo Self - True Crime Author Self - True Crime Author See fewer	1	American Godfathers: The Five Families (2024)
Michael Cannell Self - Author Self - Author See fewer	1	The Limit (I)
Mark Lavery Robert Irwin Robert Irwin See fewer	1	Foundation (2021)
Rachel Ellen Martha Beck Martha Beck See fewer	1	Scary Tales of New York (2023)
Michael Greco Raymond Fernandez Raymond Fernandez See fewer	1	EastEnders (1985)
Sheila Moylette Ethel Kudner Ethel Kudner See fewer	1	Our Father (II) (2025)
Shane Serrano Abe Reles Abe Reles See fewer	1	Cari's Tattoo
Carla Foley Ruth Snyder Ruth Snyder See fewer	1	Mayfair Witches (2023)
Diarmuid Noyes Judd Gray Judd Gray See fewer	1	Christy (I) (2025)
Margaret Kane-Rowe Esther Henne Esther Henne See fewer	1	Scary Tales of New York (2023)
Kevin Flanagan Dr. Fredric Wertham Dr. Fredric Wertham See fewer	1	Scary Tales of New York (2023)
Dermot O'Sullivan Joe Gideon / Frank Byrnes Joe Gideon / Frank Byrnes See fewer	1	Storyland (2009)
Joanne White Delphine Downing Delphine Downing See fewer	1	Scary Tales of New York (2023)
Jake Wallace Young Albert Anastasia Young Albert Anastasia See fewer	1	Scary Tales of New York (2023)
Elizabeth Rose-Browne Lillian 'Ma' Hickey Lillian 'Ma' Hickey See fewer	1	Scary Tales of New York (2023)
Rachel Walshe Ronnie Gedeon Ronnie Gedeon See fewer	1	The Letters (2021)
Jude Mcclean Lorraine Snyder Lorraine Snyder See fewer	1	Scary Tales of New York (2023)
Joseph Power Bradford Young Hoodlum Young Hoodlum See fewer	1	Scary Tales of New York (2023)
Wesley O'Duinn Albert Snyder Albert Snyder See fewer	1	Summon Her Children (2016)
Sarajane Mcternan Mrs. Gedeon Mrs. Gedeon See fewer	1	Harry Wild (2022)
Martin Crowe Assassin Assassin See fewer	1	Scary Tales of New York (2023)
Niall Brewster Joe Kudner Joe Kudner See fewer	1	Harry Wild (2022)
Tom McInerney Barber Barber See fewer	1	Scary Tales of New York (2023)