The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre - Production & Contact Info

Cast	+ Add Cast
47 cast members

Name	Episodes	Known for
Christopher Rhoden Sr. Self - Murder Victim, 40 Years Old (archive footage) (as Chris Roden Sr.) Self - Murder Victim, 40 Years Old (archive footage) (as Chris Roden Sr.) See fewer	3
George Wagner III Self - Jake Wagner's Father / Self - Jake Wagner's Father & Suspect / Self - Murder Suspect (archive footage) (as Billy Wagner) Self - Jake Wagner's Father / Self - Jake Wagner's Father & Suspect / Self - Murder Suspect (archive footage) (as Billy Wagner) See fewer	3
Dana Rhoden Self - Murder Victim, 37 Years Old & Hanna Rhoden's Mother / Self - Murder Victim, 37 Years Old (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim, 37 Years Old & Hanna Rhoden's Mother / Self - Murder Victim, 37 Years Old (archive footage) See fewer	3
Hanna May Rhoden Self - Murder Victim, 19 Years Old (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim, 19 Years Old (archive footage) See fewer	3
George Wagner Self - Jake Wagner's Brother / Self - Jake Wagner's Brother & Suspect / Self - Jake Wagner's Brother & Murder Suspect (archive footage) Self - Jake Wagner's Brother / Self - Jake Wagner's Brother & Suspect / Self - Jake Wagner's Brother & Murder Suspect (archive footage) See fewer	3
Christopher Rhoden Jr. Self - Murder Victim, 16 Years Old (archive footage) (as Chris Rhoden Jr.) Self - Murder Victim, 16 Years Old (archive footage) (as Chris Rhoden Jr.) See fewer	3
Jake Wagner Self - Hanna May Rhoden's Boyfriend / Self - Hanna May Rhoden's Ex- Boyfriend & Suspect / Self - Confessed Murderer (archive footage) Self - Hanna May Rhoden's Boyfriend / Self - Hanna May Rhoden's Ex- Boyfriend & Suspect / Self - Confessed Murderer (archive footage) See fewer	3
Hannah Gilley Self - Murder Victim, 20 Years Old (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim, 20 Years Old (archive footage) See fewer	3
Frankie Rhoden Self - Murder Victim, 20 Years Old (archive footage) (as Clarence "Frankie" Rhoden) Self - Murder Victim, 20 Years Old (archive footage) (as Clarence "Frankie" Rhoden) See fewer	3
Kenneth Rhoden Self - Murder Victim, 44 Years Old (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim, 44 Years Old (archive footage) See fewer	3
Angela Wagner Self - Jake Wagner's Mother / Self - Jake Wagner's Mother & Suspect / Self - Confessed Murderer (archive footage) Self - Jake Wagner's Mother / Self - Jake Wagner's Mother & Suspect / Self - Confessed Murderer (archive footage) See fewer	3
Benjamin Suver Self - BCI Special Agent In Charge Self - BCI Special Agent In Charge See fewer	3	The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre (2023)
Chris Newcomb Self - Angela Wagner's Half Brother Self - Angela Wagner's Half Brother See fewer	3	The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre (2023)
Joseph Morgan Self - Death Investigator Self - Death Investigator See fewer	3	The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre (2023)
Angenette Levy Self - Journalist, Law&Crime Network Self - Journalist, Law&Crime Network See fewer	3	On Trial: The Idaho College Killer (2025)
Kenny Rhoden Self - Gary Rhoden's Brother Self - Gary Rhoden's Brother See fewer	3	The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre (2023)
John Parker Self - George Wagner's Defense Attorney / Self - Defense Attorney Self - George Wagner's Defense Attorney / Self - Defense Attorney See fewer	3	The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre (2023)
Chris Stone Self - Rhoden Family Member Self - Rhoden Family Member See fewer	3	The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre (2023)
Randa Hughes Self - Chris Newcomb's Fiancée Self - Chris Newcomb's Fiancée See fewer	3	The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre (2023)
Whitney Galloway Self - Hannah Gilley's Friend Self - Hannah Gilley's Friend See fewer	3	The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre (2023)
Mike DeWine Self - Former Ohio Attorney General (as Governor Mike DeWine) Self - Former Ohio Attorney General (as Governor Mike DeWine) See fewer	3	I Am Evidence (2017)
Samantha Staley Self - Rhoden and Wagner Family Friend Self - Rhoden and Wagner Family Friend See fewer	3	The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre (2023)
Mary Jane Dotson-Rutledge Self - Dana Rhoden's Friend Self - Dana Rhoden's Friend See fewer	3	The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre (2023)
Mike Allen Self - Legal Analyst, Cincinnati Fox 19 Self - Legal Analyst, Cincinnati Fox 19 See fewer	3	The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre (2023)
Randy Deering Self - Pike County Common Pleas Court (archive footage) (as Judge Randy Deering) Self - Pike County Common Pleas Court (archive footage) (as Judge Randy Deering) See fewer	2
Gary Rhoden Self - Murder Victim, 38 Years Old (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim, 38 Years Old (archive footage) See fewer	2
Richard Nash Self - George Wagner's Defense Attorney (archive footage) Self - George Wagner's Defense Attorney (archive footage) See fewer	2
Charles Reader Self - Pike County Sheriff (archive footage) Self - Pike County Sheriff (archive footage) See fewer	2
Angie Canepa Self - Pike County Special Prosecutor Self - Pike County Special Prosecutor See fewer	2	The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre (2023)
Stephanie Stanley Self - Reporter, The Pike County News Watchman Self - Reporter, The Pike County News Watchman See fewer	2	The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre (2023)
Corey Clemmons Self - Pike County Deputy Sheriff Self - Pike County Deputy Sheriff See fewer	2	The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre (2023)
Christina Howard Self - George Wagner's Ex-Sister-In-Law Self - George Wagner's Ex-Sister-In-Law See fewer	2	The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre (2023)
Billy Spencer Self - Mayor of Piketon Self - Mayor of Piketon See fewer	2	The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre (2023)
Eric Evans Self - Reporter / Self - Trial Reporter Self - Reporter / Self - Trial Reporter See fewer	2	The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre (2023)
Joaquín Guzmán Loera Self (archive footage) (as Juan "El Chapo" Guzman) Self (archive footage) (as Juan "El Chapo" Guzman) See fewer	1	The Weekly (2019)
William J. Bodziak Self - Forensic Examiner (archive footage) Self - Forensic Examiner (archive footage) See fewer	1	E! True Hollywood Story (1996)
Matthew White Self - Ballistics Expert, BCI (archive footage) Self - Ballistics Expert, BCI (archive footage) See fewer	1	Gone: The Forgotten Women of Ohio (2017)
Bobby Jo Manley Self - Rhoden Family Member (archive footage) Self - Rhoden Family Member (archive footage) See fewer	1
Tabitha Claytor Self - George Wagner's Ex-Wife (archive footage) Self - George Wagner's Ex-Wife (archive footage) See fewer	1
Elizabeth Armer Self - Jake Wagner's Ex-Wife (archive footage) Self - Jake Wagner's Ex-Wife (archive footage) See fewer	1
Fredericka Wagner Self - Jake & George Wagner's Grandmother (archive footage) Self - Jake & George Wagner's Grandmother (archive footage) See fewer	1
Caleb Cinereski Self - Pastor (archive footage) (as Pastor Caleb Cinereski) Self - Pastor (archive footage) (as Pastor Caleb Cinereski) See fewer	1
Charlie Gilley Self - Hanna Rhoden's Former Boyfriend (archive footage) Self - Hanna Rhoden's Former Boyfriend (archive footage) See fewer	1
Mike Irwin Self - Pike County Dogwood Festival President Self - Pike County Dogwood Festival President See fewer	1	The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre (2023)
Kyle Galloway Self - Whitney's Husband Self - Whitney's Husband See fewer	1	The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre (2023)
Krista Jones Self - Trauma Therapy Counselor Self - Trauma Therapy Counselor See fewer	1	The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre (2023)
Dennis Lowe Self - South Central Ohio Major Crimes Unit (as Commander Dennis Lowe) Self - South Central Ohio Major Crimes Unit (as Commander Dennis Lowe) See fewer	1	The Pike County Murders: A Family Massacre (2023)