The Real Murders on Elm Street - Production & Contact Info

Cast	+ Add Cast
50 cast members

Name	Episodes	Known for
Corinne DeCost Haile Kifer & Ashley Williams Haile Kifer & Ashley Williams See fewer	1	Party of Darkness
Olivia Abreu Sarah Clark Sarah Clark See fewer	1	Hurry Up Tomorrow
Adam Chisnall Detective Luberts Detective Luberts See fewer	1	The Upshaws (2021)
Dan Milam Nick Brady Nick Brady See fewer	1	Firelight (2025)
Billy Hirsch Patrick Cheadle Patrick Cheadle See fewer	1	Stalker (2004)
Peterson Mingo Self - Pastor, Community Activist Self - Pastor, Community Activist See fewer	1	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Alfonso Milanese Steve Schaeffel Steve Schaeffel See fewer	1	Robbin (2024)
Clifton French Self - Reporter, Real News Michiana Self - Reporter, Real News Michiana See fewer	1	Greg Kelly Reports (2020)
Jeffrey James Higgins Self - Reporter Self - Reporter See fewer	1	Your Worst Nightmare (2014)
Paul Anthony Turner Gerald Cruz Gerald Cruz See fewer	1	Bloody Bridget (2024)
Gary Deckard Self - Retired Detective Stanislaus County SO Self - Retired Detective Stanislaus County SO See fewer	1	Deadly Cults (2019)
Jeff Schare Self - Retired Detective Cincinnati PD Self - Retired Detective Cincinnati PD See fewer	1	The First 48 (2004)
Teayha Webb Self Self See fewer	1	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Mike Drapeau Self - Detective Spokane County SO Self - Detective Spokane County SO See fewer	1	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Sarah Katzenberger Self - Reporter, Brainerd Dispatch Self - Reporter, Brainerd Dispatch See fewer	1	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Sherry Musilek Self - Terry Anderson's Daughter Self - Terry Anderson's Daughter See fewer	1	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Jim Dresback Self - Spokane County Sheriff Office Self - Spokane County Sheriff Office See fewer	1	Making A Serial Killer (2021)
Steve Schaeffel Self - Nick and Haile's Grandpa Self - Nick and Haile's Grandpa See fewer	1	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Ashley Williams Self - Byron Smith's Neighbor Self - Byron Smith's Neighbor See fewer	1	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Keith Bond Self Self See fewer	1	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Daryl Farnsworth Self - Reporter Modesto PD Self - Reporter Modesto PD See fewer	1	How I Caught the Killer (2018)
Joe Lawless Self - Retired Police Detective Self - Retired Police Detective See fewer	1	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Dave Pehl Self - Husband of Laurie Self - Husband of Laurie See fewer	1	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Chris Amos Sr. Self Self See fewer	1	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Sharon Coolidge Self - Reporter Cincinnati Enquirer Self - Reporter Cincinnati Enquirer See fewer	1	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Tony Frye Self Self See fewer	1	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Dakota Vanhercke Self - Nick and Haile's Friend Self - Nick and Haile's Friend See fewer	1	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Jeremy Luberts Self - Retired Sergeant Morrison County SO Self - Retired Sergeant Morrison County SO See fewer	1	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Eric Musilek Self - Terry Anderson's Son-in-Law Self - Terry Anderson's Son-in-Law See fewer	1	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Eric Wallace Self - Chris' Friend Self - Chris' Friend See fewer	1	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Byron Smith Self Self See fewer	1	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Eric Roberts Self - Chief Greenville PD Self - Chief Greenville PD See fewer	1	Cold Justice (2013)
Troy Huizar Ricky Viera Ricky Viera See fewer	1	Crazy Love (2018)
Tom Pullins Self - Captain Randolph County SO Self - Captain Randolph County SO See fewer	1	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Katie Hays Self - Daughter of Laurie Self - Daughter of Laurie See fewer	1	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Kimberly Pittman Self - Franklin Raper's Daughter Self - Franklin Raper's Daughter See fewer	1	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Pam Ragsdale Self - Franklin Raper's Daughter Self - Franklin Raper's Daughter See fewer	1	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Ronald Pierson Byron Smith Byron Smith See fewer	1	Penny Dreadful: City of Angels (2020)
Randy Cerny Self - Self - Retired Detective Stanislaus County SO Cult Expert Self - Self - Retired Detective Stanislaus County SO Cult Expert See fewer	1	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Winnie Cartwright Self Self See fewer	1	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Myron Larson Self - Retired Police Sargent Self - Retired Police Sargent See fewer	1	Deadly Cults (2019)
Zachary Green Self - Franklin Raper's Grandson Self - Franklin Raper's Grandson See fewer	1	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Donald Jones Self Self See fewer	1	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Cameron Pehl Self - Tanner's Brother Self - Tanner's Brother See fewer	1	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Tom Christrian Self - Terry Anderson's Close Friend Self - Terry Anderson's Close Friend See fewer	1	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Thomas Lane Self - Retired Police Lieutenant Self - Retired Police Lieutenant See fewer	1	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Laurie Jennings Self - Homeowner Self - Homeowner See fewer	1	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Janice Monnin Self - Par Cheadle's Daughter Self - Par Cheadle's Daughter See fewer	1	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Steven Bezanson Self - Retied Police Officer Self - Retied Police Officer See fewer	1	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)
Mandy Brummels Self - Tennant Self - Tennant See fewer	1	The Real Murders on Elm Street (2024)