A Chrismystery - Production & Contact Info

A Chrismystery (2025)
86 min | Romance

A Chrismystery (2025)

86 min | Romance

A deputy sheriff's homecoming leads to a Christmas mystery, where a charismatic sheriff and hometown charm help her learn that love is the greatest gift.

Director

Matthew Toronto

Writer

Sean Wathen

Producers

Josh Brandon (producer) | B.L. Fleischer (producer) | Peter Foldy (producer) | Jen Lilley (producer)

Composer

Michael Gordon Shapiro

Cinematographer

Erik Van Lenten (director of photography)

Editor

Nathan D. Lee

Casting Director

Ricki Maslar

Production Designer

Brianna Spieldenner

See all filmmakers & crew

Become a member to see MOVIEmeter and news information about A Chrismystery.

Edit Released

Updated May 12, 2025

Release date

May 12, 2025 (United States)

Contacts

+ Add

Become a member to see contact information for A Chrismystery.

Cast	+ Add Cast
18 cast members

Name	Known for
Jen Lilley Annie Annie See fewer	Days of Our Lives (1965)
Cody Mayo Tom Tom See fewer	Runaways (2017)
Kylee Levien Leia Leia See fewer	Unknown Number: The High School Catfish (2025)
Betsy Hume Mayor Ruth Mayor Ruth See fewer	Split (I) (2009)
Shaun Holmes Reporter Nicole Reporter Nicole See fewer	Emergence 2028
Drew Pollock Doug Doug See fewer	Grey's Anatomy (2005)
Katie Kerr Karen Karen See fewer	Truth Be Told (2019)
Andreas Pliatsikas Mr. Anderson Mr. Anderson See fewer	The Christmas Lottery (2020)
Thesa Loving Millie Millie See fewer	Second Chances (I) (2022)
Michael Ashcraft Father Justin Father Justin See fewer	Silence (I) (2002)
Deneysha Richard Skylar Skylar See fewer	The Jurassic Games: Extinction (2025)
Rachael Londeree Zora Zora See fewer	A Chrismystery (2025)
Lisa Scott Mrs. Crinshaw Mrs. Crinshaw See fewer	Premonition (V)
Dale Krause Doug Son Doug Son See fewer	Gingerbread Men
Laurence X. Subelka Background Background See fewer	Rise and Shine
Kyra Subelka Child placing ornament on Christmas tree Child placing ornament on Christmas tree See fewer	Rise and Shine
Alden Anderson Herman 'The Hermit' Herman 'The Hermit' See fewer	The Last Days of Belle Starr
Laurence Subelka II Child placing ornament on Christmas tree Child placing ornament on Christmas tree See fewer	Rise and Shine