Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders - Production & Contact Info

Cast	+ Add Cast
60 cast members

Name	Episodes	Known for
Dan Rather Self - Host, CBS Evening News (archive footage) Self - Host, CBS Evening News (archive footage) See fewer	3	The CBS Evening News (1941)
Leann Lewis Self - Wife of James Lewis (archive footage) Self - Wife of James Lewis (archive footage) See fewer	3
James Burke Self - Chief Executive Officer, Johnson & Johnson (archive footage) Self - Chief Executive Officer, Johnson & Johnson (archive footage) See fewer	3
Jeff Flock Self - Reporter, CNN Self - Reporter, CNN See fewer	3	CNN NewsStand (1998)
James Lewis Self - Tylenol Murders Suspect Self - Tylenol Murders Suspect See fewer	3	Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders (2025)
Michelle Rosen Self - Daughter of Victim Self - Daughter of Victim See fewer	3	Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders (2025)
Tyrone Fahner Self - Illinois Attorney General Self - Illinois Attorney General See fewer	3	Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders (2025)
Richard Brzeczek Self - Superintendent, Chicago Police Self - Superintendent, Chicago Police See fewer	3	I Didn't Do It (2012)
Gardiner Harris Self - Author, No More Tears: The Dark Secrets of Johnson & Johnson Self - Author, No More Tears: The Dark Secrets of Johnson & Johnson See fewer	3	Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders (2025)
Roy Lane Self - Special Agent FBI Self - Special Agent FBI See fewer	3	Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders (2025)
Grey Steed Self - Special Agent FBI Self - Special Agent FBI See fewer	3	Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders (2025)
Mary Reiner Self - Tylenol Poisoning Victim (archive footage) (as Mary Lynn Reiner) Self - Tylenol Poisoning Victim (archive footage) (as Mary Lynn Reiner) See fewer	3
Ronald Reagan Self - 40th President of the United States (archive footage) Self - 40th President of the United States (archive footage) See fewer	2	Kings Row (1942)
Bill Kurtis Self - Co-Host, The CBS Morning News (archive footage) Self - Co-Host, The CBS Morning News (archive footage) See fewer	2	Anchorman: The Legend of Ron Burgundy (2004)
Toni Ann Lewis Self - Daughter of James and Leann Lewis (archive footage) Self - Daughter of James and Leann Lewis (archive footage) See fewer	2
David Collins Self - Chairman, McNeil Consumer Products Company (archive footage) Self - Chairman, McNeil Consumer Products Company (archive footage) See fewer	2
Michael Schaffer Self - Chief Toxicologist, Cook County, IL (archive footage) (as Dr. Michael Schaffer) Self - Chief Toxicologist, Cook County, IL (archive footage) (as Dr. Michael Schaffer) See fewer	2
Frederick Miller McCahey Self - Owner of Lakeside Travel (archive footage) Self - Owner of Lakeside Travel (archive footage) See fewer	2
Joy Bergmann Self - Journalist Self - Journalist See fewer	2	Wicked Attraction (2008)
David Barton Self - Sergeant, Kansas City Police Department Self - Sergeant, Kansas City Police Department See fewer	2	Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders (2025)
Nicholas Mennuti Self - Author, The Tylenol Murders: An Over The Counter American Crisis Self - Author, The Tylenol Murders: An Over The Counter American Crisis See fewer	2	Weaponized
Pete Siekmann Self - Deputy Coroner, DuPage County, IL Self - Deputy Coroner, DuPage County, IL See fewer	2	Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders (2025)
Adam Janus Self - Tylenol Poisoning Victim (archive footage) Self - Tylenol Poisoning Victim (archive footage) See fewer	2
Stanley Janus Self - Tylenol Poisoning Victim (archive footage) Self - Tylenol Poisoning Victim (archive footage) See fewer	2
Theresa Janus Self - Tylenol Poisoning Victim (archive footage) Self - Tylenol Poisoning Victim (archive footage) See fewer	2
Maury Povich Self - Host, A Current Affair (archive footage) Self - Host, A Current Affair (archive footage) See fewer	1	Maury (1991)
Bryant Gumbel Self - Co-Host, Today (archive footage) Self - Co-Host, Today (archive footage) See fewer	1	Contact (1997)
Greta Van Susteren Self - Guest Host, On the Record w / Self - Brit Hume (archive footage) Self - Guest Host, On the Record w / Self - Brit Hume (archive footage) See fewer	1	Notorious (2016)
Bob Schieffer Self - Host, CBS Evening News, Saturday Edition (archive footage) Self - Host, CBS Evening News, Saturday Edition (archive footage) See fewer	1	Morning Glory (2010)
Robert MacNeil Self - Co-Host, The MacNeil / Self - Lehrer NewsHour (archive footage) Self - Co-Host, The MacNeil / Self - Lehrer NewsHour (archive footage) See fewer	1	Hamlet (2000)
Robert Stein Self - Cook County Medical Examiner (archive footage) (as Dr. Robert Stein) Self - Cook County Medical Examiner (archive footage) (as Dr. Robert Stein) See fewer	1	The Mystery of Al Capone's Vaults (1986)
Jane Byrne Self - Mayor of Chicago (archive footage) Self - Mayor of Chicago (archive footage) See fewer	1	The Mike Douglas Show (1961)
Max Robinson Self - Host, ABC World News Tonight (archive footage) Self - Host, ABC World News Tonight (archive footage) See fewer	1	World News Tonight with David Muir (1953)
Frank Young Self - FDA Commissioner (archive footage) Self - FDA Commissioner (archive footage) See fewer	1	Dispatches (1987)
Edmund Donoghue Self - Deputy Chief Medical Examiner, Cook County, IL (archive footage) (as Dr. Edmund Donoghue) Self - Deputy Chief Medical Examiner, Cook County, IL (archive footage) (as Dr. Edmund Donoghue) See fewer	1
John Roland Self - Host, The 10 O'Clock News, WNYW (archive footage) Self - Host, The 10 O'Clock News, WNYW (archive footage) See fewer	1	The Object of My Affection (1998)
Wayne Nelson Self - Johnson & Johnson (archive footage) Self - Johnson & Johnson (archive footage) See fewer	1
Roger Arnold Self - Tylenol Poisoning Suspect (archive footage) Self - Tylenol Poisoning Suspect (archive footage) See fewer	1
John Stanisha Self - Murder Victim (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim (archive footage) See fewer	1
Donald Alexis Self - Librarian (archive footage) Self - Librarian (archive footage) See fewer	1
Ray West Self - Murder Victim, Friend of James Lewis (archive footage) Self - Murder Victim, Friend of James Lewis (archive footage) See fewer	1
Thomas N. Gates Self - Medical Director, McNeil Consumer Products Co. (archive footage) (as Dr. Thomas N. Gates) Self - Medical Director, McNeil Consumer Products Co. (archive footage) (as Dr. Thomas N. Gates) See fewer	1
Chuck Kramer Self - Fire Lieutenant, Arlington Heights Fire Department Self - Fire Lieutenant, Arlington Heights Fire Department See fewer	1	Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders (2025)
Joseph Janus Self - Brother of Victims Self - Brother of Victims See fewer	1	Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders (2025)
Monica Janus Self - Niece of Victims Self - Niece of Victims See fewer	1	Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders (2025)
Charlotte Dent Self - Friend of Ray West Self - Friend of Ray West See fewer	1	Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders (2025)
Helen Jensen Self - Public Health Nurse Self - Public Health Nurse See fewer	1	Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders (2025)
Thomas Kim Self - Chief of Critical Care, Northwest Community Hospital (as Dr. Thomas Kim) Self - Chief of Critical Care, Northwest Community Hospital (as Dr. Thomas Kim) See fewer	1	Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders (2025)
Bill Cosgrove Self - Crime Scene Investigation Unit, Kansas City Police Department Self - Crime Scene Investigation Unit, Kansas City Police Department See fewer	1	Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders (2025)
James Bell Self - Assistant Prosecuting Attorney, Jackson County, MO Self - Assistant Prosecuting Attorney, Jackson County, MO See fewer	1	Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders (2025)
Mike Giacoppo Self - Superintendent of Police, Cambridge Police Department Self - Superintendent of Police, Cambridge Police Department See fewer	1	Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders (2025)
Jeremy Margolis Self - Assistant U.S. Attorney, Northern District of Illinois Self - Assistant U.S. Attorney, Northern District of Illinois See fewer	1	Tokyo Joe: The Man Who Brought Down the Chicago Mob - Mafia wo utta otoko (2008)
Ann DiMascio Self - Investigator, Cambridge Police Department Self - Investigator, Cambridge Police Department See fewer	1	Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders (2025)
John Butts Self - Former Inmate, Cambridge Jail Self - Former Inmate, Cambridge Jail See fewer	1	Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders (2025)
Jean Regula Leavengood Self - Friend of Victim Self - Friend of Victim See fewer	1	Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders (2025)
Joseph Chavez Self - Deputy, Kane County Sheriff's Department Self - Deputy, Kane County Sheriff's Department See fewer	1	Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders (2025)
Diane Elsroth Self - Tylenol Poisoning Victim (archive footage) Self - Tylenol Poisoning Victim (archive footage) See fewer	1
Mary Kellerman Self - Tylenol Poisoning Victim (archive footage) Self - Tylenol Poisoning Victim (archive footage) See fewer	1
Mary McFarland Self - Tylenol Poisoning Victim (archive footage) Self - Tylenol Poisoning Victim (archive footage) See fewer	1
Paula Prince Self - Tylenol Poisoning Victim (archive footage) Self - Tylenol Poisoning Victim (archive footage) See fewer	1