The Chosen Adventures Not What I Imagined (Season 1, Episode 4)
TV-PG
TV Episode | 12 min | Animation, Short, Adventure

The Chosen Adventures

Not What I Imagined (Season 1, Episode 4)

TV-PG

TV Episode | 12 min | Animation, Short, Adventure

Eema takes Abby to Synagogue while Abba looks for Sheep who has gone missing. Abby has big expectations about what synagogue will be like, but will it live up to her high expectations?

Creator

Ryan Swanson (developed by)

Director

Keith Alcorn (directed by)

Writers

Dallas Jenkins (based on 'The Chosen' by) | Kellen Erskine (written by)

Producers

Erin Elizabeth Gardner (producer) | Brent Hutchins (producer)

Composers

Dan Haseltine | Matthew S. Nelson

Cinematographer

Sam Michlap (director of photography)

Editor

Ahren Shaw

Casting

Christian Kaplan | Suzanne Yavuz

See all filmmakers & crew

Edit Released

Updated Oct 17, 2025

Release date

Oct 17, 2025 (United States)

Contacts

+ Add

Become a member to see contact information for Not What I Imagined.

Cast	+ Add Cast
10 cast members

Name	Known for
Jonathan Roumie Jesus (voice) Jesus (voice) See fewer	The Chosen (2017)
Romy Fay Abby (voice) Abby (voice) See fewer	The Chosen Adventures (2025)
Danny Nucci Abba (voice) Abba (voice) See fewer	Titanic (1997)
Zehra Fazal Eema (voice) Eema (voice) See fewer	How to Get Away with Murder (2014)
Assaf Cohen Vendor (voice) Vendor (voice) See fewer	Suits LA (2025)
Dan Istrate Capernaum Man (voice) Capernaum Man (voice) See fewer	StartUp (2016)
Jude Michael Rodricks Chlid (voice) Chlid (voice) See fewer	Connecticut's Connection to the Sea (2023)
Melissa Shoshahi Capernaum Woman (voice) Capernaum Woman (voice) See fewer	Facebook Intervention (2013)
Yvonne Orji Pigeon (voice) Pigeon (voice) See fewer	Insecure (2016)
Paul Walter Hauser Sheep (voice) Sheep (voice) See fewer	Richard Jewell (2019)