Showing posts with label Brodkorb. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Brodkorb. Show all posts

Thursday, July 26, 2012

The School for Scandal, 2012 style?

It should be interesting to see who blinks first, Brodkorb or the GOP leadership. 

I don't see how Brodkorb can have much of a case; there are no similar positions of power to the one he held, so comparisons to women staffers seems a stretch.   The amount of power and authority he held would seem to be a valid issue for such comparisons, and whether or not the relationship was one involving direct reporting would be as well.

Winning or losing seems secondary to pure revenge for Brodkorb.  Apparently he has no shame, but that should come as no surprise; he also doesn't seem to have much going for him in terms of personal ethics or integrity either, just sleaze.  That Brodkorb is a thoroughly unsympathetic figure, and to a degree from the way she has responded to being caught, Amy Koch as well, for their refusal genuinely to take responsibility for DOING SOMETHING WRONG seems key to appreciating the flaws in this
litigation.

If the MN GOP majority settles.....it would seem pretty clear they have skeletons in their closet they are trying to cover up, which will come out anyway.  If the MN GOP settles, it will show them to be without the moral courage to oppose this shakedown of taxpayer money as well.  The actions of two of their key leadership has alread called into question the moral values to which they give loud lip service.  Failure on the part of the rest of the party, especially the leadership, to stand up to this suit would only compound that moral failure, especially when it involves accusations of other people sleeping around like sluts.  No one hates sex, or feigns hatred of sex as sin unless they are the ones doing it,  like the righties.

 No one in their right mind should expect Brodkorb to go away quietly with a payoff; he wants to do damage.  If the GOP engages in a legal battle, they will face criticism for the expense, as well as the very public focus on their 'values' and 'good governance' failures.  Speculation about other scandals being covered up could be worse than the scandals themselves, in eroding confidence and support, even from the most blind party faithful.  Brodkorb wants to hurt a lot of people on the right for DARING to hold him accountable for having an affair ....and apparently for being a less than pleasant and cooperative staff member, a claim which this suit only seems to make more credible.

This is a no win for the MN GOP; and apparently Koch doesn't have the political sense to at least pretend to be ashamed of having engaged in adultery, even if she is quitting politics....or is she?  But there is no real win possible for Brodkorb in this either; even an unlikely legal award of damages would probably be eaten up by his lawyer's fees.  It seems a stupid act of revenge with no real up side for anyone, a classic lose/lose situation.  I don't see any way for Brodkorb to get back in the power, if not the good graces of the GOP this way; if he had quietly gone away for a time, he might have made a below the radar return later.  But this? Who in their right mind would want to give him a second chance after this? Who would foolishly trust Brodkorb in politics ever again?

Between this scandal and the failure of transparency by the MN GOP not performing an audit to straighten out their financial disaster under Tony Sutton....the fiscal failure of responsibility........and their debt? Who will hear anything the right has to say in the next four months, or care?  The family values party has shot itself in the foot with their own hypocrisy; the fiscal responsibility party has shown itself massively irresponsible; and jobs, jobs, jobs, 'its the economy stupid' was a bait and switch for government shut down and endless culture wars and special interest legislation.

Could there be a greater overreach by the MN GOP?  It beggars the imagination to see how.

Pop the popcorn; put your feet up, the sex and politics soap opera is on.  I'm waiting for the twisty sub plot where the MN GOP try to devise a way to blame this on the Democrats....

Sunday, March 25, 2012

Brodkorb's Law Suit is Necessary

WHY is it necessary?  Because we should have ONE standard for all of our politicians, regardless of party affiliation.

Because Republicans, the party which loves to give empty lip service to family values when it supports their bigotry, but never when it matters, and NEVER when they are responsible for violating family values, THOSE Republicans will hide and obstruct any attempt to hold the participants and the members of their party in the legislature accountable.
Brodkorb threatened to blow the lid off the hot steamy sex at the capital.  Brodkorb specifically is challenging that the people having hot steamy sex at the capital are male legislators having sex with female staffers, apparently, because he is attempting to make the case that is dealt with differently, according to a double standard where men get a pass with having illicit sex with women, but that it is not the case with women who have sex with men.  That may be correct; we don't know about those cases, but presumably Brodkorb's was not the only hanky-panky.  And Brodkorb, a specialist in sleaze would know; he made his bones on other people's scandals.  Admittedly, he was often lying or exaggerating those scandals.  He had a different standard for scandals involving democrats, and apparently for behavior by other people than himself.  Brodkorb was nothing if not holier than thou when pointing at other people while doing as bad or worse things himself - very much like the Nut job Gingrich in the days of the Clinton incident.  Clinton was wrong; Gingrich was worse.

Now, those same Republicans that employed Brodkorb to be their dirty dealer are fighting hard against holding their own associates accountable.  They have let Amy Koch off the hook; no ethics investigation for her.  Do you think for a heartbeat that would be true if she were a Democrat? I don't.

Their explanation is that 'it is in the past'.  SO WHAT? They didn't have an ethics violation when it was happening either, and other than Amy Koch voluntarily resigning, there were no consequences, no public censure, nothing.  Being 'in the past' is not an excuse for strenuously avoiding an ethics investigation and a sanction, a penalty, a consequence.

Brodkorb was the subordinate, and he received a far, far more severe punishment than Koch did.  The problem here is not that male staffers are treated differently than female staffers in receiving punishment.  It is that superiors are treated differently than staffers in receiving consequences.  It is that Republicans are treated differently than Democrats.  It is that hypocrisy and secrecy and privilege are occurring for the family values legislators who aren't acting in family values ways by having office adulteries in our state capital, while receiving salaries paid for by taxpayer dollars.  A statement from the PiPress online sums it up:

"We had to be very careful, and very mindful and...I really tried to bend over backwards to not reveal identities, to not give precise timelines, and I do not believe I was false or misleading or did anything to dishonor the Senate," he said.


I don't believe that there would have been a similar effort to avoid revealing identities had the participants been /Democrats, and I don't believe that withholding identities was desirable.  It obscured transparency, and in turn obscuring that honesty about what happened allowed for preventing accountability.  Brodkorb appears to have been scapegoated, given his subordinate position.  Other men in superior positions aren't fired, and other women in subordinate positions aren't fired.  Amy Koch wasn't fired, effectively; she continues to keep her job.  That is not sexism; that is crooked elitism, that is partisan privilege, and it is wrong and it is corrupt.

This is a problem with Republicans NOT HOLDING THEMSELVES ACCOUNTABLE TO THE STANDARDS THEY PROFESS AND THE STANDARDS TO WHICH THEY PENALIZE OTHERS.

This is one more case of failed Republican Government, and one more case of false Republican values, and one more case of blatant Republican hypocrisy.  Republicans talk a big values talk, they hold big noisy hypocrite Values summits where  they pat each other on the back for their morals.  And then they return to government and put those morals back in their little dusty cardboard boxes and stuff them back under their beds.

Put those values you claim to have back on the desk, back on the table, and use them for a change, Republicans.  Hold staffer and superior EQUALLY accountable.  Stop covering up for the other inappropriate relationships.  Support the ethics investigation of Koch, support the ethics complaint about the cover up.  That is why Brodkorb shouldn't receive a dime, but his law suit should proceed.

Thursday, March 22, 2012

Michael Brodkorb, Update

Earlier, in a sarcastic parody of the kind of behavior condoned, or at best only very mildly demurred by the far right wing (including our current GOP contestants for Presidential candidate) when it was done by Rush Limbaugh.

In point of fact, Michael Brodkorb isn't precisely trying to get paid for having sex.  He's trying to extort money for getting fired for having sex, on the pretext that he was treated differently than other staffers who had inappropriate sexual relationships, on the basis of gender.  In that direction, he has now filed the necessary paperwork required for a law suit.

The reality is that any comparison between Michael Brodkorb is superficial.  No other staffer was even remotely like him, and while nominally subordinate, he was a power player in the Republican caucus out of all proportion to his nominal title and duties.  It was in the course of fulfilling those duties that he over-reached, and went too far, in addition to the adultery in which he engaged.

Michael Brodkorb was a sleazy, bullying, and not particularly honest jerk on his blog, behavior which got him sued back in 2006.  Michael Brodkorb was a sleazy, bullying husband, and that caused his wife and kids to call the cops on him for verbal abuse and violent domestic behavior that broke a door frame in 2011.  And now Michael Brodkorb is playing his same one trick pony act on his former buddies in the Republican party.  I hope they have the balls to stand up to him; I hope they have the sense not to spend taxpayer money on their error in judgment in ever associating with Brodkorb.  Brodkorb has shown his true colors; he believes he will bounce back from his disgrace.  He might be right, but anyone who joins him in that happening should remember Brodkorb is long on nasty, but very short on loyalty.  That is a dangerous and ugly combination.  Anyone who gives his hand to Brodkorb gets what they deserve.

I almost feel pity for Amy Koch; I DO feel pity for Brodkorb's wife and kids.  Hopefully for them, they'll learn the same lessons as his partner in adultery and his partners in politics, and dump him - permanently.

The City Pages covered the news here:
Minnesota Politics

Michael Brodkorb files paperwork to begin lawsuit against Minnesota Senate

 
brodkorbpress.JPG
Michael Brodkorb took the first step toward filing a federal discrimination lawsuit
Michael Brodkorb declined to take questions at a press conference this afternoon announcing that he has filed paperwork with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission to begin a lawsuit against the Minnesota Senate.Through his attorney Gregory Walsh, Brodkorb announced that he will be suing Secretary of the Senate Cal Ludeman for defamation after Ludeman accused Brodkorb of trying to "extort" a payment.
Walsh said the Senate has been "unwilling" to move the process along so they've filed a request with the EEOC for a "right-to-sue" notice, a necessary first step to formally filing a federal gender discrimination lawsuit.
"Our goal is to have the Senate agree to mediation," Walsh said.
That, Walsh said, is nothing new. Brodkorb's goal has always been to "get quietly to the table."
carlludeman.jpg
Cal Ludeman fired Michael Brodkorb, then he accused him of extorting the Minnesota Senate
Brodkorb was fired by the Minnesota Senate last December, following former Senate Majority Leader Amy Koch's resignation after her fellow Republicans confronted her with allegations she was having an affair with Brodkorb.
Brodkorb claims his termination amounts to gender discrimination and has said he will depose female staffers who have had affairs with male legislators to prove his claim.
Secretary of the Senate Ludeman personally fired Brodkorb last December at the Moose Country restaurant in Lilydale.
A Republican senator spoke to City Pages earlier this week and said Brodkorb wasn't fired for having an affair with Amy Koch.
According to that senator, Brodkorb had been protected by Koch from being punished for "abusive" behavior around the statehouse even though "numerous" senators complained about the former Senate Republican caucus communications director.
Brodkorb has denied those claims.
Previous
Sharing this page …
Thanks! Close

Friday, March 16, 2012

Republicans, Rutting Like Pop Go the Weasles, on the Taxpayer Nickel

Minnesota celebrated the Ides of March with this article in the STrib about the peccadilloes at the Capital building, encompassed in THIS DOCUMENT.

Not only were the Republicans taking our money for not getting any important legislation done, causing the government stoppage last summer - and taking paychecks while they did nothing during it - now they want to ......oh, now what was it that Rush Limbaugh called it so very recently that conservatives did NOT criticize him for except with the mildest reproofs for the words slut and prostitute?

Oh, yes. I remember now.  Limbaugh made a very large, ugly noise about a female law student wanting to be paid to have sex, lots and lots and lots of sex.  Rush suggested a lack of ability to walk as a result, and he also called for on-line videos of it. 

He was insisting that Sandra Fluke was trying to get paid with tax payers money for having sex.

Now, of course she wasn't.  She was trying to get urgent and serious health care that involved hormone replacement therapy in the form of birth control pills for a friend who had a problem with cystic tumors on her ovaries, her GAY friend who was not likely to be at risk for conception in her romantic relationship, her gay friend who lost her ovary because of a lack of pharmaceutical coverage.

But isn't that exactly what Michael Brodkorb is doing, after actually having staffer sex - making a grab for taxpayer money?  Someone alert the media over at Clear Channel and Premier Radio!!!!  Dittoheads! Alert! Alert! By all means call your fearless leader, Viagra swilling Rush Limbaugh IMMEDIATELY!  I'm sure that the Rushjob and all of you dittohead conservatives are TERRIBLY CONCERNED about the abuse of the taxpayers when it is a conservative trying to get paid for his private sex life, right?

Oh, my! what a resounding NO that appears to be, when it is a conservative, a Republican.  Oh, my! What a resounding lack of the same treatment from conservatives for a man instead of a woman, a man WHO ACTUALLY HAD LOTS AND LOTS OF ILLICIT, ADULTEROUS SEX,  compared to the abuse given to a woman who hadn't done what Limbaugh accused her of doing.  Give males preferential treatment much, conservatives?   Double-standard much, ditto-heads?

I'd like to believe that you simply agree that what Limbaugh did was so wrong that Republicans don't care to repeat it, but that doesn't appear to be the case.  Republicans are still waging culture war on women, while giving men a free pass, regardless of men being the superior or the subordinate.

So, according to the STrib, Brodkorb is admitting what he did, which is wrong, and which actually WAS reasonable and legitimate grounds for firing him. 

The Republicans are claiming that wasn't why he was fired, he was fired because his position was eliminated - I'll skip the easy ugly word play - but they don't seem to deny that his position was eliminated precisely because he had an adulterous affair with Amy Koch, who then resigned her position, but continued to take money after.....what was that phrase that Limbaugh kept going back to over and over - after getting paid by taxpayers while apparently having wild adulterous sex with her subordinate co-worker for a period of time.
popsie
weasel

Having sex with your boss is wrong, and it does not appear that Brodkorb is alleging it was non-consensual, which would of course be a hard claim to sell.   So this is NOT sexual harassment being alleged for the payout and the payoff to Brodkorb.

Amy Koch is not admitting who her partner was, but she's been outed.  I'd like to know why she's still on the job after that kind of misconduct.  Presumably sleeping with your staffer violates the Human Resources rules in the legislature the same way it usually does in the private sector or union jobs in the public sector.  She should be removed from office through the ethics violation procedure, not simply self-demoted.

It is wrong for superiors to have sex with their subordinate employees because there is a conflict of interest in the supervision of that employee, there are questions about raises and job evaluations being compromised by a physical sexual relationship.  There are issues of favoritism, to the subordinate, that differ from the treatment of other employees, and there are issues of unequal power in the relationship.  There is the inappropriateness of sex in a workplace relationship.

And now there is the risk of a payout of $500,000 plus legal fees, plus the costs to the taxpayer for the legislature lawyering.

Michael Brodkorb, in a rare display of exactly how sleazy he is, is claiming that he was treated differently from ALL THE OTHER staffers and elected politicos who were going at it like minks on the desks and behind every marble column lining the hallways.

Really?  I don't approve of this rampant illicit tax-payer funded, tax-payer-$-risking illicit sex, no matter what partisan affiliation the participants espoused, and no matter if they had a spouse or not.  Because hopefully, those who are doing so will stop, if they have not already ceased their misconduct.

But NONE OF THEM were fired because their bosses were the leader of the Senate who voluntarily stepped down.  Those nameless, faceless, oversexed others MAY very well be guilty of misconduct, but apparently they are more discreet, they did not make it the same problem.  Wrong is wrong.  But someone else being wrong, someone else DOING wrong, doesn't excuse Michael Brodkorb.

He was an at-will hire, he can be fired for cause, or not for cause.  He was fired because his assignment was ended, in part through his own damned fault, for behaving badly.

We should all be extremely grateful that the legislature presumably provides health care coverage that includes contraception and STD testing, unlike college students, unlike so very many ordinary citizens, unlike at least some of the women victimized by Rush Limbaugh.

I suppose we should be grateful he had fewer involvements than Herman Cain; that was expensive, but not that I recall $500,000 worth.

Brodkorb is trying to do through legal means what would under other circumstances amounts to extortion.

I say bring it.  If he wants to play that game, do it.  I hope very much that the Republicans will not shield any more of their own from the consequences of their misconduct, and I wouldn't expect them to shield any Democrats.  Rather, I'd be expecting them to exploit any Democratic misconduct.

Some people feel that the Republican Party was really who hired and employed Michael Brodkorb.  I suppose we could expect them to pay for a settlement with the legal extortioner Brodkorb, except that the party of fiscal responsibility wasn't responsible, and is in the hole a few million dollars, not to mention the stiffing of the counties for those recount expenditures back in 2010, courtesy of power puppeteer Tony Sutton, who should depart into well deserved disgrace and oblivion.

That terrible raging concern you have to PRESERVE marriage by restricting legal relationships to one man and  one woman, denying anyone who is same-sex oriented the same loving committed LEGAL relationship?  That would better be served in our legislature by married people not committing adulter, and costing us up the sweet wazoo.

Botched and irresponsible fiscal dealings; family values boasting adulterers and fornicators; and of course the party of good government proving that they can't keep government running after the shut-down last summer, and that they cannot manage their employees, their Human Resources tasks either.  The Republicans are NOT the party of family values, they are the party of bigotry, hatred, and hypocrisy.  The Republicans are NOT the party of fiscal responsibility, they are the party of financial disaster and spending money they do not have.  The Republicans are NOT the party of good government; they've botched one thing after another.  They have failed to address the issues for which they were elected, notably jobs; and they have waged an unpopular culture war that parallels the one on the national scene that has earned the right such high disapproval ratings (except for the extremist fringies).

Michael Brodkorb is a sleazy, grasping, greedy gigolo who is trying to rip off the tax payers, the citizens, the residents of Minnesota.  Amy Koch is best left to Rush Limbaugh to characterize.  Tony Sutton is incompetent, and the GOP should get their outrageous salary back from him for his failures, and use it to pay the GOP debt.  The Republicans in the legislature should straighten up and start doing a better job than they have treated us all to - on our own nickel - since 2010 for the remaining time they have in office before they are kicked out in the November election.  At that time I expect them to take their ALEC-legislating corrupt selves off our public stage, get off their backs on their desks and sofas in their Capital office and meeting spaces, and take themselves OUT of our government.  YOU HAVE FAILED.

Unless they have the decency to do so sooner, but there isn't much indication of that happening; only more of the same old same old.

WE should not be out of pocket one nickel.  We should not be spending tax payer dollars that could better be spent to serve the citizens of Minnesota.  It is not the politicians and staffers who are screwing each other; WE are the ones being screwed, and that is what has to stop.  Or at the very least, they should provide us contraceptives and other reproductive care the way they do themselves, that allow the legislators and the staffers to have lots of wild sex on the taxpayer $, services that should be available as a public health concern, to benefit us, with our own money.

And the hypocrite windbag Limbaugh is silent on the topic.  Such sweet silence, and all the quieter without the noise from those advertisers marketing those goods and services.