by Georgia Hunter
Pamela Dorman Books, 2025. 417 pages. Historical Fiction
Italy, 1941. Lili and Esti have been best friends since meeting at the University of Ferrara. When Esti's son Theo is born, they become as close as sisters. Mussolini's Racial Laws have deemed Lili and Esti descendants of an 'inferior' Jewish race, but life somehow goes on—until Germany invades northern Italy, and the friends find themselves in occupied territory. Esti, older and fiercely self-assured, convinces Lili to flee first to a villa in the countryside to help hide a group of young war orphans, then to a convent in Florence, where they pose as nuns and forge false identification papers for the Underground. When disaster strikes at the convent, a critically wounded Esti asks Lili to take a much bigger step: to go on the run with Theo. Protect him while Esti can't. Terrified to travel on her own, Lili sets out on an epic journey south toward Allied territory, through Nazi-occupied villages and bombed-out cities, doing everything she can to keep Theo safe.
Georgia Hunter's One Good Thing is World War II historical fiction that's going to stay with me for a while. I appreciated learning about the plight of the Italian Jewish community, and learning about the underground movement in Italy. An especially interesting piece was the inclusion of a real-life renowned Italian cyclist, who stored forged paperwork in the frame of his bicycle and worked as a runner in the underground network. Where this novel really shines, though, is in its portrayal of the bond of Lili and Esti. Esti is brave and determined, while Lili is much more afraid of consequences. It's Lili's love of both Esti and Theo that encourages Lili to overcome her fear and face terrifying situations with courage. While this book is obviously sad and tragic, I appreciated the hopeful message of the power of love that drives the novel.
If you like One Good Thing you might also like:
Our Darkest Nightby Jennifer Robson
William Morrow, 2021. 362 pages. Historical Fiction
Hiding from the Nazis in the guise of a Christian farmer's wife, a Jewish woman is met with suspicion by a Nazi official who harbors a vendetta against the former seminary student posing as her husband.
Once We Were Homeby Jennifer Rosner
Flatiron Books, 2023. 278 pages. Historical Fiction
Four Jewish individuals—Ana, Oskar, Roger, and Renata—are all trying to move on from trauma and loss of loved ones during World War II. Twenty years later, the four connect in Israel. As their stories converge in unexpected ways, they begin to question where and to whom they truly belong.
MB