Showing posts with label TomSavini. Show all posts
Showing posts with label TomSavini. Show all posts

Creepshow 2... Corrected!

So, Arrow recently licensed and released a new, limited special edition of Creepshow 2 in the US.  It's pretty sweet; and we'll delve into every detail.  But there also seems to be something a little amiss.  Something that will be familiar to owners of Arrow's Scarlet Box.  Yes, like Hellraiser 3, it not only reveals new picture information, but what looks to be too much picture information.  Now, I'm not the first to notice this.  I saw it brought up by user JohnCarpenterFan in the blu-ray forums back in October, but it seemed to get shot down fairly quickly.  Well, I hate to re-stir a calmed pot, but I've finally had a chance to sit down with my copy, and the "amateur sleuths" there seemed to have a legitimate point.

Update 2/23/17 - 5/9/17: This post isn't just about the framing issue, however.  And to that end, I've enriched it a little by including another older edition - Anchor Bay's original, 2001 DVD - for additional PQ comparison.

Update 11/21/25: Controversy concluded!  Arrow has - thank goodness - used the opportunity of their new 4k upgrade to fix their botched framing of Creepshow 2.  Plus, as a bonus, we get a new 4k upgrade.
Creepshow 2 isn't quite up to Creepshow, but hey, it's no Creepshow 3.  Gone are George Romero's stylish comic book scrims and lighting effects, leaving us with a more generic looking horror anthology.  There are only three stories this time around, and the first one's a bit of an old fashioned clunker (though charming enough), but the second two still pack a nice little punch.  It's not a great film, but still a fine, enjoyable time for more dedicated horror lovers.  We get plenty of cool effects, an animated wrap-around, a less impressive but still respectable cast including George Kennedy, Dorothy Lamour and cameos by Tom Savini and Stephen King himself.  For the longest time, this film had been relegated to barebones DVDs until Anchor Bay finally gave it a nice special edition in the UK only [Whoops!  They released it in the US, too.  See the comments].  That opened the doors for a blu-ray from 88 Films in the UK, and then the supposedly ultimate edition from Arrow in late 2016.  You tell me, which one looks incorrect to you?
1) 2001 Anchor Bay DVD; 2) 2005 Anchor Bay DVD; 3) 2016 Arrow BD.
Okay, to be fair, I just cherry-picked the very worst shot I could find.  But yeah, that's a big floating sea of random black space on the left-hand side of the Arrow blu.  It's a quick shot (just a couple seconds), so maybe whoever was doing Quality Control blinked.  Hey, it happens.  But you can't tell me (or the poor guys trying to bring this up in the blu-ray forums) that it's supposed to look like that.
1) 2001 Anchor Bay DVD; 2) 2005 Anchor Bay DVD; 3) 2016 Arrow BD.
Forget what the bullies are going to do to him, his face is disappearing!  See, for their new edition, Arrow made a new 2k scan from the original negatives.  And their version pulls in a lot of picture (most notably on the left, but really on all four sides), which sounds great.  Except, as with Hellraiser 3, they seem to have included a part of the frame that was intended by the filmmakers to be cropped out.  Sometimes it looks fine.  People and reviews have been saying it looks more centered and appealing.  But clearly they've gone at least a little too far.
1) 2001 Anchor Bay DVD; 2) 2005 Anchor Bay DVD; 3) 2016 Arrow BD.
Now there's some lighting equipment in shot.  And maybe you'd argue that the characters ran a shop full of all kinds of stuff, so maybe they'd have a big light standing in front of their door, but then it's not in other shots.
...Maybe the characters just moved it because they realized it didn't make sense to have a big light blocking their entrance.  There are plenty of shots where, if you stretch, you could argue a justification for the random stuff that was never visible before the Arrow release.
1) 2001 Anchor Bay DVD; 2) 2005 Anchor Bay DVD; 3) 2016 Arrow BD.
Maybe that orange safety stuff is supposed to be there.  Maybe the characters are driving past some road work, but it was only visible in the very left of frame in that one shot.  I really don't think so; but I'll concede it's open to interpretation.  The unfinished animation stuff is a lot harder to argue.
And sometimes it's on the right side, too.
Can anyone honestly say they think we're supposed to see where the animators stopped drawing the characters?  And there are so many examples throughout the whole film.  Sometimes it's much subtler cell lines in the animations where the colors don't match (you can see it in a bit on the left-hand side of that shot above with the boot and the unfinished tire), or just floating bits of negative space, like this:

1) 2001 Anchor Bay DVD; 2) 2005 Anchor Bay DVD; 3) 2016 Arrow BD.
To be fair, you could catch a fleeting glimpse of the crewman's hand even in the older editions, so go ahead and blame the original filmmakers on that one.  But only now can you really get a look at it and tell what it is, as opposed to a quick flash of what you'd just assume is the actress's knee or something.
This one might look okay as a still frame, but in motion, that out of focus white business on the left of the frame is clearly attached to the camera (my guess: a lens hood) and tracks with the actors through the whole moving shot.  Absolutely no way it's meant to be there.

But it has to be said that this isn't just like Arrow's Hellraiser 3 in that the framing is a bit off (or that Arrow coincidentally got both from Lakeshore Entertainment).  It's also like it in the sense that, even despite that issue, it had been the best, most definitive release of the film we've ever had.  Despite the adjusted framing, both the newer DVD and blu are framed to exactly 1.85:1 (the 2001 DVD is more like 1.81:1, with a little less on the left and a little more on the bottom).  The updated 2k scan though is so much clearer, with stronger detail and light but authentic grain.  The colors look much more natural, and actually a bit closer to the old DVD.
2025 Arrow UHD.
But now we have the UHD; no more compromises!  The aspect ratio is still exactly 1.85:1, but as you can see above, it frames the image tighter, matting the image more vertically, so it no longer has all the dead space, incomplete animation or crew equipment.  Except the crewman's hand in that one shot - that's just a flaw with the original film that's never going away.  But it still shows more around the edges than the older DVDs.  Arrow clearly paid close attention this time and got it exactly right.  And this is a new 4k scan of the original 35mm OCN in HDR10 and Dolby Vision, so we're upgrading the upgrade.  You know I'm always pointing out how HDR shots look darker when not viewed in HDR, i.e. on your computer screen.  But you would be right to look at the screenshots above and think this transfer is truly darker.  Both are true; this new 4k presentation is a bit darker.  But the colors are vivid, and it looks great in HDR.  The boost to 4k is even more obvious, with small edges and perfectly captured film grain, even in the animated segments.

The 2001 DVD just had the original mono track with no subtitles, while the special edition gave us mono, stereo and 5.1, though still no subtitles.  In 2016, Arrow made it all lossless, with the mono and a stereo mixes both in LPCM, and the 5.1 in DTS-HD.  They added optional English subtitles, too.  And they kept it all exactly the same on their new 2025 release.
And special features?  Yes sir!  The 2001 DVD just had the trailer and a stills gallery, but the 2010 Anchor Bay DVD had a engaging audio commentary by director Michael Gornick, who really lays the story of this film down in an excellent, direct manner.  In addition, there's a great featurette with Greg Nicotero and Howard Berger on the crazy, behind the scenes stories of this film's effects (they're not afraid to dish on who got fired, etc), plus a brief bonus featurette about Berger's friendship with Rick Baker, two trailers, and a nice, 4-page insert with notes by Adam Rockoff.
Thankfully, Arrow carried all of that over (except the insert).  When 88 Films released their blu-ray in the UK, they recorded two new interviews: one with George Romero and one with Tom Savini, including some extra behind-the-scenes footage of his as The Creep.  Arrow carried that over, too.  So it's got "all legacy extras," as Sony would say.  And they've got two new, on-camera interviews, with actors Daniel Beer and Tom Wright.  These new interviews are by Red Shirt and up to their top of the line quality.  The limited edition comes in a nice, hardbox sleeve in either red or purple (for the US and Canadian editions, respectively), has reversible cover art, a 20-page booklet with notes by Michael Blythe, and a really exciting additional comic book.  The comic is really substantial, has a square spine, and it gives you the complete lost "Pinfall" story that was supposed to be filmed for Creepshow 2 but got cut out for budgetary purposes.  I have to admit, I just quickly flipped through the comics Arrow included with Society and Bride of Re-Animator, but as this is the lost story from the film, it was a must-read for me, and a strong reason to spring for the limited edition instead of waiting for a standard release.
And all of that is the same in the new 2025 edition.  Nothing new except for the usual Arrow card (I got Excalibur), but everything is preserved, including the comic, reversible artwork and everything.  So, hey.  I kinda felt like Arrow should've issued replacement discs in 2016.  But the double-dip (or whatever number you're on personally) is a lot less painful when the correction is being paired with a strong 4k upgrade.  Both factors help justify the cost; it's all water under the bridge.  And we're left with an amazing edition of a fun little horror movie that still holds up.

Night Of the Living Dead, 1990: Bigger, Longer & Uncut

Perhaps the most exciting of all of Umbrella's fuller-than-their-competitors' special editions is their new release of Night Of the Living Dead, 1990. That's the remake of George Romero's original that was produced by Tom Savini. This time, the Australian blu seems to come out ahead in both picture quality and absolutely in the special features department. I mean, this is an early entry in the popular wave of unnecessary remakes, but this disc has made me re-evaluate and decide, you know, maybe there really is a place for NotLD90 in my collection after all.

Update 5/11/16 - 7/12/18: I've added the US DVD for comparison, confirming this definitely is the same root master.

Update 9/29/25: It's on, now!  Sony hasn't just upgraded the movie to 4k.  They haven't just enlisted the perfect man (Red Shirt's Michael Felsher) to create a slew of excellent, new special features.  They've also restored the gore Savini was originally forced to edit out for his R rating, meaning we're getting to see this film uncut for the very first time!  ...They may have also made an unfortunate decision, but we'll get into all that below.
Night '90 plays it very close to Night '68. It's not quite shot-for-shot Psycho, but it really plays it beat-by-beat, with cast members even cast for their resemblance to the original characters. So, what does Night '90 bring to the table? Like, why even watch it if you have the original? Well, updated effects for sure. Expect some new, awesome looking zombies like they never could've created in 1968. And the other thing are Savini's twists. Savini knows most fans are familiar with the original, so he's constantly subverting your expectations and giving you little surprises.

A great example of this is right in the beginning. Again, Night '90 follows Night '68 very closely, right down to the details. Barbara and Johnny are visiting their mother at the graveyard even though Johnny doesn't want to. He teases her, including the famous line, "they're coming to get you, Barbara," while pointing to a stumbling old man walking towards them in the distance. Of course, in '68, this turns out to be the first zombie, Bill Hinzman, who kills Johnny and chases Barbara to the farmhouse. But in the remake, it's just an old man who says "sorry," and walks away before the real zombie pops out of frame left and attacks zombie. Of course, he then kills Johnny by cracking his head against a tomb stone and then chases Barbara just like the original. The film stays on the original's tracks. But it's just got all these little alterations and tweaks to keep fans guessing. And the ending, which I won't spoil, is significantly different.
Seeing this for the first time in widescreen (I used to own the VHS, but Umbrella's 2016 blu was the first time I'd watched it since then), has improved by opinion of this film a little bit. Not that I hated it before, but it struck me as having a made for TV movie look. And it is pretty heavy on close-ups, but the cinematography's a tad more impressive now. Even said close-ups are now less boxy, and it's a fairly well-made production over-all. The soundtrack feels like a quick cable TV project, but it's serviceable. Patricia Tallman and especially Tony Todd are rather good in this film, and even the rest of the cast are a little hokey but express their characters well. And let's face it, the original had a lot of the same problems in that area, so we haven't lost any ground there. The original's stark, grainy black and white look is iconic, and this film can't recapture that; but '90 wisely doesn't try, and instead makes it's own, gentle color look. In a way, it makes the film feel a little delicate and old fashioned, but at least it's distinct rather than a poor man's knock-off.
Splat!
And now in 2025, my opinion has risen another little bit.  Because we're finally able to see it uncut.  And let's face it, more gruesome special effects is the whole selling point of Savini's remake.  So, the new running time is just twelve seconds longer, but there's more to the story than that.  It's not just a story of adding a few bloody frames back in, though there is that.  When Tallman and Todd are fighting the two zombies they find in the house, there's six of those extra seconds, which is essentially a single, nasty shot of Tallman wresting her fire-poker out of the farmer zombie's head, which again, is exactly what we were paying to see in 1990.  But other times footage has been replaced.  So when Tom is shotgunning zombies at the gas pumps, they cut to Tony Todd swinging his torch at zombies back at the porch.  But here, instead of that Todd shot, we get a big, gooey Maniac-style shotgun head explosion.  So, now addition to the run-time, but a big addition to the fun factor.
There's also one change I'm not so fond of.  The first four and a half minutes of this film have been turned black and white, as a tribute to the original.  Then it suddenly switches to color during the first attack.  And it's just cheesy; simply a bad idea in my opinion.  The opening shot of this film is a very low saturation shot of the moon, which I think was already there to suggest the film going from black and white to color, but also nice and subtle, just there for those who want to see it.  Now, eh, it's just revisionist "Greedo shot first" tinkering.  To be fair, Sony has included both this uncut director's cut and the original theatrical version for purists, both scanned in 4k, which is definitely the correct impulse.  But I just wish there was a way to watch the restored, uncut version without the black and white tinkering.  But oh well.  It's a compromise that still definitely beats never getting to see the original, censored footage.
So, like I said, Umbrella's blu was my first time with Night Of the Living Dead 1990 on disc. But it was hardly this film's first time at the rodeo. There was a fullscreen laserdisc, then Columbia Tristar put out a DVD release.  The first edition was a flipper disc, fullscreen on one side and anamorphic widescreen on the other.  It had a Savini commentary and 'making of' featurette, and was later reissued in 2006 as just a single sided widescreen disc, which was essentially duplicated in the UK and other regions. Then Twilight Time put it out on blu for the first time in 2012, with the commentary and ditching the featurette; but most notably it's very dark, with a strong blue hue over the entire picture. Then came Umbrella's blu from Australia in 2016.  I have the solo disc, but they also put out a limited edition 2-disc version which pairs this with the original 1968 Night Of the Living Dead, also on blu. That disc includes a full-length documentary on the original called Reflections On the Living Dead, which was originally released on VHS as The Night of the Living Dead 25th Anniversary Documentary. Anyway, finally, we have Sony's wicked new steelbook UHD/ BD combopack, just in time for Halloween.
1) 2006 US Columbia Tri-Star DVD; 2) 2016 Australian Umbrella BD;
3) 2025 Sony BD; 4) 2025 Sony UHD.


The good news is the blue overcast is thankfully gone from the 2016 release! It's still a detailed, HD transfer. It does have occasional speckling and noise (look closely at the zombies' forehead in that second shot), but it's relatively minimal. It's clearly an older master - as you can see, it's the same one they used on the DVDs - but it's fine even for blu-ray standards, possibly a bit better than Twilight Time's even if you take the dark blue shading out of the equation. Like, if I were giving letter grades, it would be a strong B. Oh, and a lot of sites are listing this as 1.85, but it's actually framed at 1.77:1, which to be fair, is what it says on the back of the case.  The DVD, meanwhile, is slightly window-boxed in the overscan areas to 1.81:1, so you can see Umbrella's blu restores a little bit of vertical information to the picture.

And now Sony frames it at exactly 1.85:1, like it should be.  As you can see, it's a little cooler than the other versions on this page, generally looking the most authentic of all (especially on the UHD, which retains a bit more of the reds than its accompanying BD).  That light film damage on the Umbrella disc has been cleaned up.  And thanks to being a fresh, 4k scan, the transfer finally retains the film grain, which helps this film look more genuinely filmic than previous releases, which help's this film's case for not just being a cheap knock-off.  Hey, look, it's a real movie!
Audio-wise, Sony has the core Dolby 2.0 mix, while Umbrella brings the same as Twilight Time gave us: DTS-HD 5.1.  Sony has it, too, but they've also gone big with a new TrueHD 7.1 mix.  And for purists, the theatrical version (only) also has the 2.0 mix in DTS-HD, as well as the 5.1 and 7.1s.  Only Twilight Time has the isolated musical score track, though, which is pretty much their thing.  Every disc offers optional English subtitles.

As for foreign language options, the DVD also has Chinese, Korean, Portuguese, Spanish and Thai subs, plus a Portuguese dub.  And the 2025 set has German, Italian and Spanish dubs along with Danish, Chinese, Dutch, Finnish, French, German, Italian, Korean, Norwegian, Portuguese, Spanish, Swedish, Thai, and Turkish subs.
But now let's get into extras, because there's some great stuff to dig into. First of all, again yes, Umbrella retains Savini's audio commentary, which except for a couple stretches of silence, is quite good, and addresses a lot of the topics viewers would have about the remake. And they also bring back the 'making of' featurette that Twilight Time dropped, which is also quite good, showing you a lot of the creation of the film. It's like a serious, 25-minute piece, not just one of those typical promo featurettes that plays like a padded version of the trailer.

But then Umbrella kicks in with a bunch of all new extras (which are, interestingly, credited to Severin Pictures). First off is a new on-camera interview with Savini. At first it seems like he's just going to rehash all the things he said in the commentary and featurette, and he does for the first couple minutes. But then he starts getting serious about all the plans he had for this film that the producers made him cut, why that happened and why he thinks they were wrong. He talks about the divorce he was going through during the shoot and his disappointments with the film, whether Romero really ghost-directed the film, and also how he's finally come around to really appreciating it only recently. It goes for almost half an hour and is much more open and honest - thanks I'm sure to the extra passage of time - than the other pieces. Really, if you only check out one extra about this film, this is the one.
Then you've got a fun interview with John Vulich & Everett Burrell, who're on camera together and clearly having a good time. They're very forthcoming, too; and you can imagine the scrutiny you must be under as the effects team when Tom Savini is your director. Patricia Tallman, who was interviewed in the 'making of' featurette, has her own on-camera piece here, too. She's very cheerful and proud of the film, but also addresses things like when Romero took over shooting at the end because Savini had to "go take care of" his divorce. And there's also an eight-minute "behind the scenes" featurette, which is really a collection of video tape footage that the special effects guys took of the shoot. It's tightly edited, so we really just get the interesting moments without like twenty minutes of set-up for an insert shot or actors asleep in their make-up chairs. There's also the original theatrical trailer and reversible cover art, clearly by the same artist as the Night Of the Creeps cover.

And now in 2025?  Sony carries over all of the old stuff from the DVD and yes, from the Umbrella, save one, but let's put a pin that.  Because, besides all that old stuff, we've got a bunch of new stuff, including a new Savini commentary, for the slightly longer director's cut.  And we've got all new, on camera interviews with co-stars Bill Moseley, William Butler, McKee Anderson & Heather Mazur, amiable zombies Greg Funk and Dyrk Ashton, producers John A. Russo & Russell Streiner and editor Tom Dubensky.  Now, Sony does seem to have dropped that eight-minute "behind the scenes" featurette, BUT Felsher has cut that footage into a couple of the interviews, so I'm not sure that every frame is accounted for, but you're really not missing anything.  Sony's disc also comes in a nice looking steelbook case.
I once called Umbrella's blu "the definitive release of Night Of the Living Dead 1990, at least for now." Well, that "now" has turned to "then," because Sony's new release is a strong improvement in every category: picture, audio, special features... and they're put the censored footage back in!  If you care enough to have this film in your collection, this is the one you have to have.