What do you think?
Rate this book
O Sinners!
Not yet published
Expected 18 Mar 25A journalist investigates a seductive and mysterious cult and its leader, an enigmatic Vietnam War veteran, in this not-to-be-missed novel.
Faruq Zaidi, a young journalist reeling from the recent death of his father, a devout Muslim, takes the opportunity to embed in a cult called The Nameless. Based in the California redwoods and shepherded by an enigmatic Vietnam War-veteran named Odo, The Nameless adhere to the 18 Utterances, including teachings such as “THERE IS NO GOD BUT THE NAMELESS,” “ALL SUFFERING IS DISTORTION,” and “SEE ONLY BEAUTY.” Faruq, skeptical but committed to unraveling the mystery of The Nameless, extends his stay over months, as he gets deeper into the cult's inner workings, compassionate teachings, and closer to Odo. Faruq himself begins to unravel, forced to come-to-terms with the memories he has been running from while trying to resist Odo's spell.
Told in three seamlessly interwoven threads between Faruq’s present-day investigation, Odo’s time before the formation of the movement as a Black infantryman during the Vietnam War, alongside three other Black soldiers, and a documentary script that recounts The Nameless’ clash with a Texan fundamentalist church, O SINNERS! examines both longing and belonging. Ultimately the novel What is it that we seek from cults and, inevitably, from each other?
Faruq Zaidi, a young journalist reeling from the recent death of his father, a devout Muslim, takes the opportunity to embed in a cult called The Nameless. Based in the California redwoods and shepherded by an enigmatic Vietnam War-veteran named Odo, The Nameless adhere to the 18 Utterances, including teachings such as “THERE IS NO GOD BUT THE NAMELESS,” “ALL SUFFERING IS DISTORTION,” and “SEE ONLY BEAUTY.” Faruq, skeptical but committed to unraveling the mystery of The Nameless, extends his stay over months, as he gets deeper into the cult's inner workings, compassionate teachings, and closer to Odo. Faruq himself begins to unravel, forced to come-to-terms with the memories he has been running from while trying to resist Odo's spell.
Told in three seamlessly interwoven threads between Faruq’s present-day investigation, Odo’s time before the formation of the movement as a Black infantryman during the Vietnam War, alongside three other Black soldiers, and a documentary script that recounts The Nameless’ clash with a Texan fundamentalist church, O SINNERS! examines both longing and belonging. Ultimately the novel What is it that we seek from cults and, inevitably, from each other?
464 pages, Hardcover
Expected publication March 18, 2025
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 47 reviews
September 20, 2024
O Sinners! is one of the absolute best books I have read to date. 💚🐺
There was SO much depth to this story.
I can't believe I had the privilege to read this as an ARC.
*I will 100000% be buying the physical copy as soon as it is out so I can annotate it*
Three stories all interwoven together to bring a memorable conclusion.
I mean WOW. 👏🏼 I didn't expect to be as enamored with these subjects as I was.
I'm not usually interested in Wars or Documentaries... or cults for that matter. BUT I WAS.
The way Nicole crafted this story is unlike anything I have ever seen before.
The writing was PHENOMENAL. 🤌🏼✨
Every one of these characters felt SO real.
Faruq is now a permanent resident in my brain (as well as Odo). I am simply at a loss for words.
I've thought about this book every day since finishing it, and know I will be for the rest of my life.
If you are someone who loves DEPTH in your characters (and plots), as well as some twisty-turny plot points that keep you guessing, ADD THIS TO YOUR TBR! 🗣
I am not kidding around here.
🥳 This will now and forever be one of my favorite books of all time.
Nicole Cuffy is now and forever an instant purchase author in my book. 🛍
Thank you so much, NetGalley for this advanced readers copy (and for introducing me to Nicole Cuffy).
6⭐️ (I'm not kidding)
There was SO much depth to this story.
I can't believe I had the privilege to read this as an ARC.
*I will 100000% be buying the physical copy as soon as it is out so I can annotate it*
Three stories all interwoven together to bring a memorable conclusion.
I mean WOW. 👏🏼 I didn't expect to be as enamored with these subjects as I was.
I'm not usually interested in Wars or Documentaries... or cults for that matter. BUT I WAS.
The way Nicole crafted this story is unlike anything I have ever seen before.
The writing was PHENOMENAL. 🤌🏼✨
Every one of these characters felt SO real.
Faruq is now a permanent resident in my brain (as well as Odo). I am simply at a loss for words.
I've thought about this book every day since finishing it, and know I will be for the rest of my life.
If you are someone who loves DEPTH in your characters (and plots), as well as some twisty-turny plot points that keep you guessing, ADD THIS TO YOUR TBR! 🗣
I am not kidding around here.
🥳 This will now and forever be one of my favorite books of all time.
Nicole Cuffy is now and forever an instant purchase author in my book. 🛍
Thank you so much, NetGalley for this advanced readers copy (and for introducing me to Nicole Cuffy).
6⭐️ (I'm not kidding)
December 24, 2024
ARC for review. To be published March 18, 2025.
3 stars.
Faruq Zaidi, a young journalist has recently lost his father, a devout Muslim; Faruq pretended to be observant for his father’s sake. He reacts to the death by investigating then becoming involved with a California cult called the nameless. The group is led by a Vietnam vet, Odo, and they follow the 18 Utterances as laid out by him.
The story is told from three perspectives: Faruq’s experiences with the nameless, Odo’s time in Vietnam alongside other Black soldiers and portions of a documentary that chronicles a clash between the nameless/Odo and a fundamentalist church in Texas.
The novel examines belonging and what we seek in those whom we admire, looking at Faruq’s relationships with both his father and Odo. The strongest parts of the book are those set in Vietnam; Cuffy does an excellent job with the futility of the fight and the ongoing, never ending, low level terror. Soldiers no sooner meet someone than he has died. Cuffy also uses an interesting conceit in the Vietnam section that I won’t spoil, but I quite enjoyed it.
This may not appeal to the wide masses, but if the description sounds good to you, give it a try.
3 stars.
Faruq Zaidi, a young journalist has recently lost his father, a devout Muslim; Faruq pretended to be observant for his father’s sake. He reacts to the death by investigating then becoming involved with a California cult called the nameless. The group is led by a Vietnam vet, Odo, and they follow the 18 Utterances as laid out by him.
The story is told from three perspectives: Faruq’s experiences with the nameless, Odo’s time in Vietnam alongside other Black soldiers and portions of a documentary that chronicles a clash between the nameless/Odo and a fundamentalist church in Texas.
The novel examines belonging and what we seek in those whom we admire, looking at Faruq’s relationships with both his father and Odo. The strongest parts of the book are those set in Vietnam; Cuffy does an excellent job with the futility of the fight and the ongoing, never ending, low level terror. Soldiers no sooner meet someone than he has died. Cuffy also uses an interesting conceit in the Vietnam section that I won’t spoil, but I quite enjoyed it.
This may not appeal to the wide masses, but if the description sounds good to you, give it a try.
November 8, 2024
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for a free advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.
I think this book is going to be biggggg!! Faruq was a really interesting character to get to know, and I loved learning alongside him. The storyline, characters, and setting were all really well developed and I never quite knew where anything was going. I found the parts in the past and in the movie a little difficult to get into, but that’s more a me thing than the book’s thing. Overall it was really interesting and provided a lot of insight into religion as a concept (also can we talk about the genius it takes to create a fictional cult/religion) and What It Means To Be Human.
I think this book is going to be biggggg!! Faruq was a really interesting character to get to know, and I loved learning alongside him. The storyline, characters, and setting were all really well developed and I never quite knew where anything was going. I found the parts in the past and in the movie a little difficult to get into, but that’s more a me thing than the book’s thing. Overall it was really interesting and provided a lot of insight into religion as a concept (also can we talk about the genius it takes to create a fictional cult/religion) and What It Means To Be Human.
January 4, 2025
“O Sinners” is nothing like what you’d expect from the description (in a very, very good way). I went in thinking I was going to get a thriller about a journalist infiltrating an evil cult in the California redwoods and taking them down from within. Wrong. I was so wrong. It’s so much better than that.
I don’t want to give away too much. So I’ll impart some wisdom from “The Nameless”- strip yourself of distortion, see only beauty, seek the face of Mow Vutu and READ “O SINNERS!”
Thank you NetGalley and Nicole Cuffy for the ARC!
I don’t want to give away too much. So I’ll impart some wisdom from “The Nameless”- strip yourself of distortion, see only beauty, seek the face of Mow Vutu and READ “O SINNERS!”
Thank you NetGalley and Nicole Cuffy for the ARC!
January 19, 2025
I really struggled with getting into this one despite it being something that peaks my interest. I found the story pacing was incredibly slow and personally I could have done without the Vietnam flashbacks completely. It really broke the momentum of the story and took us away from our MC and him discovering things about the cult. I’m kind of disappointed with this ending because it just felt so bland. I really enjoyed Faruq as a character and his journey of processing his grief and trauma was incredibly well written. I just wish we got to delve further into the Nameless cult and uncover the unanswered mysteries that Faruq experienced. This book definitely wasn’t my cup of tea because I expected more mystery/cult inclusion but I can definitely see someone enjoying this if general fiction is their vibe.
Thank you Netgalley and Random House Publishing for this ARC in exchange for an honest review. “O Sinners!” will be published March 18, 2025.
Thank you Netgalley and Random House Publishing for this ARC in exchange for an honest review. “O Sinners!” will be published March 18, 2025.
November 1, 2024
In this story, Cuffy tells the struggles that Faruq faces after the loss of his mother and his cold father. Faruq goes to visit the nameless, a cult led by Odo. Will Faruq fall for their ideology, and what will Faruq learn about himself on this journey?
I loved the way this book was written: flashbacks, transcripts, and the current. Duffy adds such a level of depth to her characters. I think this novel will be a top seller in 2025. Excellent book for a book club discussion— this one will leave you thinking!
Thank you, NetGalley & Random House for an ARC of this book!
I loved the way this book was written: flashbacks, transcripts, and the current. Duffy adds such a level of depth to her characters. I think this novel will be a top seller in 2025. Excellent book for a book club discussion— this one will leave you thinking!
Thank you, NetGalley & Random House for an ARC of this book!
February 3, 2025
a decent look into a cult from a journalists POV, and then a look into the cult leaders start during the vietnam war
i really did enjoy each pov the book offered, giving a sort of circular view of the nameless cult. some parts dragged on, some questions left unanswered, and an ending that didn’t exactly satisfy me but i have a feeling that i expect perfection and that’s the distortion in me.
i really did enjoy each pov the book offered, giving a sort of circular view of the nameless cult. some parts dragged on, some questions left unanswered, and an ending that didn’t exactly satisfy me but i have a feeling that i expect perfection and that’s the distortion in me.
November 5, 2024
I’ve never read a book like this and I am still processing my sadness that it’s over. It’s impeccably told, transitioning between 3 stories, and the pacing is perfect. I was most drawn to the present day story, but it would not be the book it is without the other two. I felt the distraught nature of the soldiers in the Vietnam War sections; the performance aspect of the documentary script; the mystic vibes of the present-day story. We get to see the nameless through Faruq’s perspective, ostensibly a transparent one since he is a journalist, but the way he reacts and communicates is so human - it’s hard to fault him for that.
I was absolutely enthralled the entire time, and I cannot wait to buy a copy to loan out to friends - it’s such a unique, sensational book and I feel compelled to sing its praises!
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.
I was absolutely enthralled the entire time, and I cannot wait to buy a copy to loan out to friends - it’s such a unique, sensational book and I feel compelled to sing its praises!
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.
February 7, 2025
I’ve always been fascinated by cults—how one leader can manipulate a group into thinking and acting however they want. I’m currently taking a course called Deviant Minds, where we’re studying cults from both psychological and sociological perspectives, and it’s been really interesting so far. So when I read the summary for this ARC on NetGalley, I knew I had to read it.
For the most part, I enjoyed this book. The writing is beautiful, and the tone balances tension, dread, and hope. Faruq’s sections felt well developed, as did the documentary transcript narrative. However, Odo’s sections during the Vietnam War felt slightly repetitive and disjointed from the other sections—the writing style was noticeably different, sometimes even cryptic. But that was really my only issue with this book.
I had anticipated this to be an investigative thriller of sorts based on the summary, but it’s really not. It dives DEEP into Faruq’s trauma surrounding his family and his religious upbringing, and I was pleasantly surprised with where the story took me. This novel has a slow-burn quality that lingers and pulls you further into Faruq’s unraveling. By the end, it felt less like a mystery to solve and more like an exploration of identity, grief, and control.
For the most part, I enjoyed this book. The writing is beautiful, and the tone balances tension, dread, and hope. Faruq’s sections felt well developed, as did the documentary transcript narrative. However, Odo’s sections during the Vietnam War felt slightly repetitive and disjointed from the other sections—the writing style was noticeably different, sometimes even cryptic. But that was really my only issue with this book.
I had anticipated this to be an investigative thriller of sorts based on the summary, but it’s really not. It dives DEEP into Faruq’s trauma surrounding his family and his religious upbringing, and I was pleasantly surprised with where the story took me. This novel has a slow-burn quality that lingers and pulls you further into Faruq’s unraveling. By the end, it felt less like a mystery to solve and more like an exploration of identity, grief, and control.
February 13, 2025
Journalist Faruq takes on a new assignment to embed with a cult in California. He struggles to get straightforward information from Odo and his followers, but gets tangled up in culty things because of his own childhood trauma and vulnerability. At the same time, an alternate timeline of Odo's experiences fighting in Vietnam weave in and out, along with a documentary transcript about the cult's legal battles in Texas.
I may not have been in the mood for this. I didn't find Faruq to be a particularly sympathetic character, even with his personal struggles. He doesn't come across as a particularly good journalist, as he has a lot of trouble interacting neutrally and objectively (or heck, calmly) with his subjects, and doesn't acknowledge that he might be too compromised. I also found the world building around the cult a little tedious, although maybe necessary for fleshing things out. The Vietnam chapters were the most engaging, maybe because they didn't require a lot of embellishment to be effective. Anyone who has consumed other Vietnam media can picture those scenes.
I'm sure this has an audience but I got in too critical of a mindset to really enjoy it. Thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for the arc!
I may not have been in the mood for this. I didn't find Faruq to be a particularly sympathetic character, even with his personal struggles. He doesn't come across as a particularly good journalist, as he has a lot of trouble interacting neutrally and objectively (or heck, calmly) with his subjects, and doesn't acknowledge that he might be too compromised. I also found the world building around the cult a little tedious, although maybe necessary for fleshing things out. The Vietnam chapters were the most engaging, maybe because they didn't require a lot of embellishment to be effective. Anyone who has consumed other Vietnam media can picture those scenes.
I'm sure this has an audience but I got in too critical of a mindset to really enjoy it. Thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for the arc!
January 31, 2025
3.5 -Rating this book has presented as a bit of a challenge for me. I will start out by saying that I found it very well written, and it kept me engaged throughout the novel. However, upon completing the book I found myself feeling perplexed.
The novel consists of three stories that presumably weave together. One is told via a journalist’s experience with investigating a cult by immersing himself within it. Another story is a flashback of a character’s experiences in the Vietnam war, and one is told via the structure of a documentary.
The themes around religion, faith, religious persecution, racism, religiocentrism, religion in families, hypocrisy, and trauma were fascinating and thought provoking. That being said, I was so invested in this novel waiting for something to happen, and, in my opinion, it fell short. Perhaps I just missed something🤷🏻♀️, but I would have liked the interplay of the stories to be more clear and cohesive. There were also many mysteries within the cult that presented themselves with no follow up or resolution.
Overall, it was an enjoyable and provocative read, and I would definitely read more from this author. Thank you to NetGalley, One World Hardcover, and Nicole Cuffy for this free digital book in exchange for an honest review.
The novel consists of three stories that presumably weave together. One is told via a journalist’s experience with investigating a cult by immersing himself within it. Another story is a flashback of a character’s experiences in the Vietnam war, and one is told via the structure of a documentary.
The themes around religion, faith, religious persecution, racism, religiocentrism, religion in families, hypocrisy, and trauma were fascinating and thought provoking. That being said, I was so invested in this novel waiting for something to happen, and, in my opinion, it fell short. Perhaps I just missed something🤷🏻♀️, but I would have liked the interplay of the stories to be more clear and cohesive. There were also many mysteries within the cult that presented themselves with no follow up or resolution.
Overall, it was an enjoyable and provocative read, and I would definitely read more from this author. Thank you to NetGalley, One World Hardcover, and Nicole Cuffy for this free digital book in exchange for an honest review.
January 29, 2025
Wow. This book absolutely exceeded my expectations. I’m left feeling enlightened yet unsettled, and it’s that ambiguity that Cuffy excels at.
There is so much to unpack in this novel. Set in two time periods, the story unfolds slowly, and then all at once. The entire book felt like teetering on the precipice of something-but of what I am not sure.
Cuffy explores politics, racism, grief, religion and spirituality, and arguably most importantly, nature. How man and nature are not set apart, but rather, can operate as one; a tool of healing and oneness. This sentiment is written with such profound prose, enchanting lyricism, and a plot that truly just pulls you in.
*read if you like Midsommer, Stag Dance, Lapvona
There is so much to unpack in this novel. Set in two time periods, the story unfolds slowly, and then all at once. The entire book felt like teetering on the precipice of something-but of what I am not sure.
Cuffy explores politics, racism, grief, religion and spirituality, and arguably most importantly, nature. How man and nature are not set apart, but rather, can operate as one; a tool of healing and oneness. This sentiment is written with such profound prose, enchanting lyricism, and a plot that truly just pulls you in.
*read if you like Midsommer, Stag Dance, Lapvona
December 3, 2024
Oh man, this book ended up really hooking me. It's slow and tense and I was never sure what was going to happen next but I really adored the main character and was rooting for him. Would have loved to have had more insight into the cult and its motives, but understand that leaving it more vague lent to the larger story. I almost wish I hadn't ready this as an ARC because all I want to do is talk to people about this book and watch interviews with the author and get into her head about the story.! Overall really fantastic writing and storytelling, I think it's a book that will be worth re-reading.
Thanks for the ARC NetGalley!
Thanks for the ARC NetGalley!
December 31, 2024
I got this as an ARC from NetGalley, and I was so excited about its premise, but it just dragged on for me. I see what Cuffy was trying to do, but it often fell flat for me or was just too obvious. The Vietnam chapters were my favorite. They reminded me a bit of The Things We Carried. There were quite a few pop culture references (TikTok was mentioned multiple times), which just took me out of it. Faruq was an interesting character, but his development did not feel like true growth to me. Really cool concept just missed the mark for me unfortunately.
November 26, 2024
5/5 ⭐️ This was a hell of a great read! I really didn’t know what to expect because I didn’t read the synopsis so I went completely blind! The past and present chapters were phenomenal but I do have to say the past chapters were the best along with the recordings of old footage! The ending I was expecting but the execution of it was superb and psychological! And I’m a fan of psychological storytelling!
January 23, 2025
4.5 rounded up!
o sinners! was one heck of a book. what is billed as a young, middle eastern journalist’s quest to observe a cult in the redwoods turns out to be so much more. the story is told from three points of view: journalist faruq, various soldiers fighting in the vietnam war, and through a documentary on “the nameless” cult. each of the povs offer something different, which turns the book into an exploration of grief, violence, beauty, racism, family, and more.
o sinners! was unlike anything i’ve read before in the best ways. thanks to netgalley, the publisher, and the author for the arc in exchange for the review.
o sinners! was one heck of a book. what is billed as a young, middle eastern journalist’s quest to observe a cult in the redwoods turns out to be so much more. the story is told from three points of view: journalist faruq, various soldiers fighting in the vietnam war, and through a documentary on “the nameless” cult. each of the povs offer something different, which turns the book into an exploration of grief, violence, beauty, racism, family, and more.
o sinners! was unlike anything i’ve read before in the best ways. thanks to netgalley, the publisher, and the author for the arc in exchange for the review.
January 4, 2025
Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin Random House Publishing for this early read. I loved this book, I think Cuffy did a great job at making the characters human. They were likeable, hateable, infuriating, endearing, all at once. I would suggest this to anyone who’s interested in the alluring nature of cults and personal growth.
December 29, 2024
4.5 -
Thank you Netgalley for providing me with this advance reader copy.
O Sinners! is a story told in three parts. We’re following Faruq, a young journalist processing the recent loss of his father, as he travels to redwood forest to live among a cult that goes by The Nameless led by Vietnam war veteran Odo. As the mysteries of The Nameless begin to unfold Faruq’s stay is extended as he learns more of the cults teachings and begins to grow closer to Odo himself. Alongside this story set in modern day, we’re also following a documentary script about The Nameless’ time in Texas and their clash with a fundamentalist church as well as following Odo’s service in the Vietnam war and the infantry he fought alongside.
Cuffy’s ability to weave these stories together seamlessly, while allowing each section to feel very much separate from the other was incredibly impressive. While a sharp change in story telling can sometimes pull me out of the plot, this did not occur during my time with this novel.
While I didn’t find this O Sinners! to truly be a thriller, there were often drawn out moments of uncomfortablity the reader is forced to sit and witness, which is a tactic in horror I always find myself enjoying.
An exploration of grief processing, how we grapple with the world and unknowns around us, longing for human connection, and overall desire for one’s life meaning. This story will leave you understanding and sympathizing how those who are lost after tragedy can fall into the togetherness that a group like The Nameless can provide.
I’ll be shocked if this isn’t one of the most talked about lit fic books of 2025.
Thank you Netgalley for providing me with this advance reader copy.
O Sinners! is a story told in three parts. We’re following Faruq, a young journalist processing the recent loss of his father, as he travels to redwood forest to live among a cult that goes by The Nameless led by Vietnam war veteran Odo. As the mysteries of The Nameless begin to unfold Faruq’s stay is extended as he learns more of the cults teachings and begins to grow closer to Odo himself. Alongside this story set in modern day, we’re also following a documentary script about The Nameless’ time in Texas and their clash with a fundamentalist church as well as following Odo’s service in the Vietnam war and the infantry he fought alongside.
Cuffy’s ability to weave these stories together seamlessly, while allowing each section to feel very much separate from the other was incredibly impressive. While a sharp change in story telling can sometimes pull me out of the plot, this did not occur during my time with this novel.
While I didn’t find this O Sinners! to truly be a thriller, there were often drawn out moments of uncomfortablity the reader is forced to sit and witness, which is a tactic in horror I always find myself enjoying.
An exploration of grief processing, how we grapple with the world and unknowns around us, longing for human connection, and overall desire for one’s life meaning. This story will leave you understanding and sympathizing how those who are lost after tragedy can fall into the togetherness that a group like The Nameless can provide.
I’ll be shocked if this isn’t one of the most talked about lit fic books of 2025.
November 1, 2024
Once again I am asking Goodreads for half stars as this was closer to a 5…I’ll be thinking about this one for quite a while
Thanks to Netgalley for the free copy in exchange for an honest review
Thanks to Netgalley for the free copy in exchange for an honest review
December 15, 2024
Thank you to NetGalley and One World for providing me with this e-ARC.
3.5 stars rounded up
O Sinners! is an interesting and winding look at religion, community, and family where a journalist travels to California to learn more about the nameless, who are very cult-like despite them claiming otherwise (insert that "y'all with the cult?" King of the Hill clip).
Faruq is an interesting character. He is traumatized from the death of his mother, and he is still living in the wake of the death of his father, with whom he had a very complicated relationship. A lot of Faruq's journey in this book is coming to terms with everything that happened with his parents. Though he doesn't get sucked in to the nameless, as Faruq spends time with them he is repeatedly forced to face the past that he is trying to avoid.
Then there's Odo, the founder of the nameless. He's a Vietnam vet, and we get snippets of his past every other chapter in flashbacks. I wasn't a fan of the first two flashback chapters, but as I got further into the book my interest was piqued. I do think the author also managed to subtly slip in commentary of who tends to flock to these sort of new age religions (i.e., wealthy white people) and how some bigotry might seep its way in (see: Faruq's experience towards the end). The discussion of the similarities between the nameless' philosophy and those of other religions (Faruq immediately notices similarities to Islam), and even fairy tales put me in mind of discussions of white Wiccans appropriating deities and practices from religions like Hinduism. Also, in the wake of everything that Ruby Franke did, the use of the word "distortion" in this book was really interesting. I wonder if that was a coincidence or if Cuffy used that word as a purposeful reference.
I think one of my big hangups with this book is that there are a couple instances where Faruq catches the nameless in a lie, and those moments feel important, like they're going to come up again. I'm mainly thinking of . The former especially is such an "aha!" moment that I thought Faruq would bring it up during one of his many verbal sparring matches with Odo. Instead, those things never get much consideration outside of the general "I think this cult is fucking with me" thoughts that run through the whole book. It made the ending feel more unsatisfying than it should've been for me.
There's also the fact that the reveal of Odo's former identity didn't really have much impact for me. Of the characters we're introduced to in the Vietnam flashbacks, I don't think we got much of a sense of Odo as he was then. It's possible that I missed something, but I can really only pick out one consistency between Odo of the past and the present. There just didn't feel like there was enough of a tangible through-line between these flashback and the present. When talking with Faruq in the present, Odo is very cryptic about his past, so I think I would have liked to see just a bit more to bridge that gap between the past and the present.
Overall, I liked this book and thought it was well-written, but it introduced a lot of different threads, and I don't think it fully tied some of the most important threads up by the end of the book.
3.5 stars rounded up
O Sinners! is an interesting and winding look at religion, community, and family where a journalist travels to California to learn more about the nameless, who are very cult-like despite them claiming otherwise (insert that "y'all with the cult?" King of the Hill clip).
Faruq is an interesting character. He is traumatized from the death of his mother, and he is still living in the wake of the death of his father, with whom he had a very complicated relationship. A lot of Faruq's journey in this book is coming to terms with everything that happened with his parents. Though he doesn't get sucked in to the nameless, as Faruq spends time with them he is repeatedly forced to face the past that he is trying to avoid.
Then there's Odo, the founder of the nameless. He's a Vietnam vet, and we get snippets of his past every other chapter in flashbacks. I wasn't a fan of the first two flashback chapters, but as I got further into the book my interest was piqued. I do think the author also managed to subtly slip in commentary of who tends to flock to these sort of new age religions (i.e., wealthy white people) and how some bigotry might seep its way in (see: Faruq's experience towards the end). The discussion of the similarities between the nameless' philosophy and those of other religions (Faruq immediately notices similarities to Islam), and even fairy tales put me in mind of discussions of white Wiccans appropriating deities and practices from religions like Hinduism. Also, in the wake of everything that Ruby Franke did, the use of the word "distortion" in this book was really interesting. I wonder if that was a coincidence or if Cuffy used that word as a purposeful reference.
I think one of my big hangups with this book is that there are a couple instances where Faruq catches the nameless in a lie, and those moments feel important, like they're going to come up again. I'm mainly thinking of . The former especially is such an "aha!" moment that I thought Faruq would bring it up during one of his many verbal sparring matches with Odo. Instead, those things never get much consideration outside of the general "I think this cult is fucking with me" thoughts that run through the whole book. It made the ending feel more unsatisfying than it should've been for me.
There's also the fact that the reveal of Odo's former identity didn't really have much impact for me. Of the characters we're introduced to in the Vietnam flashbacks, I don't think we got much of a sense of Odo as he was then. It's possible that I missed something, but I can really only pick out one consistency between Odo of the past and the present. There just didn't feel like there was enough of a tangible through-line between these flashback and the present. When talking with Faruq in the present, Odo is very cryptic about his past, so I think I would have liked to see just a bit more to bridge that gap between the past and the present.
Overall, I liked this book and thought it was well-written, but it introduced a lot of different threads, and I don't think it fully tied some of the most important threads up by the end of the book.
December 31, 2024
Thank you to NetGalley and One World for the uncorrected proof copy of this book in exchange for my honest thoughts and opinions.
Told from three vantage points, O Sinners! confronts topics of belonging and finding meaning through examining the Vietnam War, religion, and family relationships. These three perspectives include: (1) Faruq Zaidi, an investigative journalist who has just recently lost his father. Struggling with the lack of grief he feels, he decides to investigate the new "cult" called the nameless (lowercase intentional); (2) A documentary titled "Nero", focusing on Nero as the antichrist and comparing the leader of the nameless to the antichrist; (3) The perspective of one team, mostly comprised of non-White soldiers, on the ground in Vietnam during the late Vietnam War. Faruq's perspective focuses on the present day and his investigation into belonging, the documentary focuses on the very recent past and the characterizations of the movement/cult in the media, and the war focuses on the distant past and the events that led to the creation of Odo - the leader of the nameless.
This won't be a book for everyone, but those who it is for will absolutely love this literary examination on what it means to be human. Cuffy does an excellent job distinguishing the three perspectives from one another, and in using them to create intentional confusion and unreliability in the characters. For example, was Minh-An raised Catholic or Buddhist? The documentary and the present-day perspective differ, creating controlled confusion for the reader as well as for Faruq. Similarly, the nameless' whole purpose is to fight distortion, yet the book itself uses the differing timelines and perspectives to distort the narrative as readers attempt to move forward. For example, which of the infantrymen is Odo meant to be? One of them? All of them? He's certainly not Brother Ned, but other than that our perspective as readers is constantly toyed with whether he's Bigger, Preach, Crazy Horse, or Silk right up until the end. One final thing I'll mention in this review is how well Cuffy creates a feeling of futility in this story. It doesn't matter what happens in any of the perspectives, there's this constant sense of futility that's pervasive and yet implicitly (sometimes explicitly) critiques society's reactions to our own existential priorities.
From a negative perspective, the main thing I want to raise is that I was left confused by the ending. I was left with more questions than answers, and with a sense of "wait, what just happened?". Essentially, for me personally, it felt anticlimactic compared to what I'd been experiencing in the rest of the book. However, I paradoxically think this is also the exact kind of ending this specific story needed. So, basically I disliked the ending, yet the ending was spot on for the story the book was telling. Take that however you decide to take it.
Told from three vantage points, O Sinners! confronts topics of belonging and finding meaning through examining the Vietnam War, religion, and family relationships. These three perspectives include: (1) Faruq Zaidi, an investigative journalist who has just recently lost his father. Struggling with the lack of grief he feels, he decides to investigate the new "cult" called the nameless (lowercase intentional); (2) A documentary titled "Nero", focusing on Nero as the antichrist and comparing the leader of the nameless to the antichrist; (3) The perspective of one team, mostly comprised of non-White soldiers, on the ground in Vietnam during the late Vietnam War. Faruq's perspective focuses on the present day and his investigation into belonging, the documentary focuses on the very recent past and the characterizations of the movement/cult in the media, and the war focuses on the distant past and the events that led to the creation of Odo - the leader of the nameless.
This won't be a book for everyone, but those who it is for will absolutely love this literary examination on what it means to be human. Cuffy does an excellent job distinguishing the three perspectives from one another, and in using them to create intentional confusion and unreliability in the characters. For example, was Minh-An raised Catholic or Buddhist? The documentary and the present-day perspective differ, creating controlled confusion for the reader as well as for Faruq. Similarly, the nameless' whole purpose is to fight distortion, yet the book itself uses the differing timelines and perspectives to distort the narrative as readers attempt to move forward. For example, which of the infantrymen is Odo meant to be? One of them? All of them? He's certainly not Brother Ned, but other than that our perspective as readers is constantly toyed with whether he's Bigger, Preach, Crazy Horse, or Silk right up until the end. One final thing I'll mention in this review is how well Cuffy creates a feeling of futility in this story. It doesn't matter what happens in any of the perspectives, there's this constant sense of futility that's pervasive and yet implicitly (sometimes explicitly) critiques society's reactions to our own existential priorities.
From a negative perspective, the main thing I want to raise is that I was left confused by the ending. I was left with more questions than answers, and with a sense of "wait, what just happened?". Essentially, for me personally, it felt anticlimactic compared to what I'd been experiencing in the rest of the book. However, I paradoxically think this is also the exact kind of ending this specific story needed. So, basically I disliked the ending, yet the ending was spot on for the story the book was telling. Take that however you decide to take it.
February 17, 2025
The plot centers around a Muslim journalist, Faruq, who decides to write an article about a cult named Nameless. He travels to a gated city in California built by the cult’s followers to stay with them, where the enigmatic leader, Odo, resides. The story unfolds through four parallel threads: 1) Odo’s history as a Black soldier during the Vietnam War; 2) Instagram posts from the cult’s official account; 3) A transcript from a documentary that highlights the clash between the cult and an Evangelical church in Texas; and 4) Faruq in the present day, attempting to uncover information about the mysterious leader, Odo, and the workings of the cult.
The documentary portion of the book is particularly well done, with footnotes containing song names/soundtrack information, captions for photographs and videos, and accompanying dialogue. While the documentary itself is not explicitly shown, these elements help paint a complete picture of it. One of the book’s strengths is its ability to illustrate how cults can make individuals feel "seen," especially during times of emotional turmoil. In Faruq’s case, he is grappling with the grief of losing his parents and unresolved trauma regarding his mother and religion. Faruq is both charmed and distrustful of the cult, and the book does an excellent job capturing his ambivalence.
The narrative also explores how cults, even when trying to distinguish themselves from organized religion, often take on the same toxic characteristics. There are moments of humor, such as when Faruq is surprised to see cult members using Dial Soap in the gated city, a place where everyone seems so detached from ordinary human life. The book further excels in capturing Faruq’s emotions toward his own religion. While he does not believe in the cult or its messaging, the cult members and their ways help him confront his trauma, which he had buried for so long.
While the book does a good job at depicting both the horrors of the Vietnam War and the harsh realities of how the soldiers lived, as well as the prevalent racism and complex interpersonal relationships they developed, this aspect of the narrative was a bit of a letdown for me.. The present-day sections with Faruq and the documentary were engaging, but the narrative about the soldiers became repetitive and disorienting. Despite its significance in explaining why Odo became a cult leader, this part of the story falls short. It touches on his past, but never delves deeply enough to clearly explain what drove him to start the cult. The book is very readable, but at times it becomes bogged down by excessive repetition and constant narrative shifts.
Thank you to Netgalley, the author (Nicole Cuffy), and the publisher (Random House Publishing Group - Random House | One World) for an advanced copy. Thoughts and review are completely my own.
The documentary portion of the book is particularly well done, with footnotes containing song names/soundtrack information, captions for photographs and videos, and accompanying dialogue. While the documentary itself is not explicitly shown, these elements help paint a complete picture of it. One of the book’s strengths is its ability to illustrate how cults can make individuals feel "seen," especially during times of emotional turmoil. In Faruq’s case, he is grappling with the grief of losing his parents and unresolved trauma regarding his mother and religion. Faruq is both charmed and distrustful of the cult, and the book does an excellent job capturing his ambivalence.
The narrative also explores how cults, even when trying to distinguish themselves from organized religion, often take on the same toxic characteristics. There are moments of humor, such as when Faruq is surprised to see cult members using Dial Soap in the gated city, a place where everyone seems so detached from ordinary human life. The book further excels in capturing Faruq’s emotions toward his own religion. While he does not believe in the cult or its messaging, the cult members and their ways help him confront his trauma, which he had buried for so long.
While the book does a good job at depicting both the horrors of the Vietnam War and the harsh realities of how the soldiers lived, as well as the prevalent racism and complex interpersonal relationships they developed, this aspect of the narrative was a bit of a letdown for me.. The present-day sections with Faruq and the documentary were engaging, but the narrative about the soldiers became repetitive and disorienting. Despite its significance in explaining why Odo became a cult leader, this part of the story falls short. It touches on his past, but never delves deeply enough to clearly explain what drove him to start the cult. The book is very readable, but at times it becomes bogged down by excessive repetition and constant narrative shifts.
Thank you to Netgalley, the author (Nicole Cuffy), and the publisher (Random House Publishing Group - Random House | One World) for an advanced copy. Thoughts and review are completely my own.
January 10, 2025
O Sinners! is a literary fiction / suspense novel that seems to be disguised as a thriller. It will make you think about life, love, spirituality, and relationships. Faruq is a young journalist who has recently lost his father, with whom he had a complicated relationship. Faruq becomes interested in a group called the nameless and starts writing a story about them. He travels to the compound to meet the leader, Odo, and writes an in-depth story on the group. The novel is written from three perspectives: Faruq’s experience with the nameless, Odo’s time in Vietnam with his fellow Soldiers, and parts of a documentary about a conflict between the nameless and a church in Texas.
The heart of this story is relationships and how we find where we belong. The author weaves the stories in and out very well. The strongest portions of the book were the scenes from Vietnam. They were riveting, descriptive, and visceral. The portions from Faruq’s perspective were somewhat confusing at times, but that is to be expected, as that was his journey. I can’t say more without giving anything away. My least favorite part was the documentary section. I felt the sections were disjointed and confusing with regards to their structure at times. I didn’t find that they added much to the story. I would have preferred a perspective from someone else in the nameless or Faruq’s family. Sometimes the pace lagged a little for me and I wished it had been a little faster and other times I couldn’t put it down. However, this is a special book and I look forward to reading more from this author. Thank you to One World for providing this book for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
The heart of this story is relationships and how we find where we belong. The author weaves the stories in and out very well. The strongest portions of the book were the scenes from Vietnam. They were riveting, descriptive, and visceral. The portions from Faruq’s perspective were somewhat confusing at times, but that is to be expected, as that was his journey. I can’t say more without giving anything away. My least favorite part was the documentary section. I felt the sections were disjointed and confusing with regards to their structure at times. I didn’t find that they added much to the story. I would have preferred a perspective from someone else in the nameless or Faruq’s family. Sometimes the pace lagged a little for me and I wished it had been a little faster and other times I couldn’t put it down. However, this is a special book and I look forward to reading more from this author. Thank you to One World for providing this book for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
January 20, 2025
Thank you to NetGalley and Random House Publishing Group for the advanced reader copy! All opinions are my own:
Journalist Faruq decides after losing his father to embed himself in a California cult called The Nameless, led by a Vietnam war veteran named Odo. O Sinners! takes us through three interwoven story lines: Faruq’s present-day investigation, Odo’s time during the Vietnam war, and a documentary about The Nameless’s clash with a Texas church.
I enjoyed Faruq’s development as a character throughout the book. But for me, the pace of the book was just too slow. Every time we went back to Odo’s war time, it just seemed like the same stuff for the most part, which I do understand can be a statement on the brutal effect on the mentality that war has, but nonetheless fell short for me. And the documentary was just difficult to read the way it was laid out.
Overall, I think I would’ve wanted a lot more information on the cult itself, maybe even just the whole book about The Nameless and Faruq’s investigation.
I can see that this has a lot of potential and will probably be a really good book for a lot of people, but it just fell a little flat for me.
2.5 stars rounded up
Journalist Faruq decides after losing his father to embed himself in a California cult called The Nameless, led by a Vietnam war veteran named Odo. O Sinners! takes us through three interwoven story lines: Faruq’s present-day investigation, Odo’s time during the Vietnam war, and a documentary about The Nameless’s clash with a Texas church.
I enjoyed Faruq’s development as a character throughout the book. But for me, the pace of the book was just too slow. Every time we went back to Odo’s war time, it just seemed like the same stuff for the most part, which I do understand can be a statement on the brutal effect on the mentality that war has, but nonetheless fell short for me. And the documentary was just difficult to read the way it was laid out.
Overall, I think I would’ve wanted a lot more information on the cult itself, maybe even just the whole book about The Nameless and Faruq’s investigation.
I can see that this has a lot of potential and will probably be a really good book for a lot of people, but it just fell a little flat for me.
2.5 stars rounded up
Read
November 21, 2024"O Sinners!" is a compelling and well-crafted novel that grabbed my attention from start to finish. The writing is sharp and engaging, and the alternating chapters between different storylines add a layer of intrigue and variety that kept me hooked. One standout feature is the inclusion of a documentary script format, which is not only creative but adds depth to the narrative.
The topic itself is fun to read about. The exploration of a cult is both fascinating and inventive, offering a fresh and creative perspective that makes the story stand out.
That said, my expectations may have been shaped by a misunderstanding of the genre. I found myself waiting for twists that never came, which left the ending feeling a bit anti-climactic. While the resolution was fitting in its own way, I couldn’t help but hope for a little more payoff.
Overall, "O Sinners!" is an enjoyable read with strong writing, unique storytelling elements, and a creative exploration of its topic. It’s perfect for readers who appreciate layered narratives and inventive formats, though it may not deliver the surprises some might anticipate.
The topic itself is fun to read about. The exploration of a cult is both fascinating and inventive, offering a fresh and creative perspective that makes the story stand out.
That said, my expectations may have been shaped by a misunderstanding of the genre. I found myself waiting for twists that never came, which left the ending feeling a bit anti-climactic. While the resolution was fitting in its own way, I couldn’t help but hope for a little more payoff.
Overall, "O Sinners!" is an enjoyable read with strong writing, unique storytelling elements, and a creative exploration of its topic. It’s perfect for readers who appreciate layered narratives and inventive formats, though it may not deliver the surprises some might anticipate.
November 25, 2024
A fluidly written and surprisingly harrowing story of an investigative reporter who digs deep into the life of a new religious movement (NRM). Faruq Zaidi has just lost his strictly orthodox Muslim parents and is following up on a movement that just calls themselves the nameless (small n intentional) and their founder, Odo. The novel slips back and forth between the present (told from Zaidi's point of view), third-person recollections of Odo's time as a grunt in Vietnam, and the script from a documentary about the nameless' clash with fundamentalist Christians in Texas. Cuffy artfully tells each story so that there is no clear answer to the novel's most important questions: Is the nameless a cult? Is Odo a prophet, a charlatan, insane, or all three? Will Faruq enter into the nameless' enlightenment or resist being sucked into their delusions? Cuffy never answers the questions of truth or veracity, leaving it to the reader to decide - much like anyone who has ever encountered an NRM, or had a family member become part of one. The reader can almost feel their own grip on reality sliding away. Whether they allow that to happen or resist it with rationality mirrors the journey of Faruq, of Odo, and of all of us.
November 30, 2024
This book was really solid and I can see why people are already raving about it! O Sinners! follows three interwoven narratives—the journey of a group of Black soldiers in the Vietnam war, a cult-exposé documentary (in script form!!! <3 ), and the efforts of our narrator, Faruq, to learn the truth about this controversial group, "the nameless."
You will see that, unlike the synopsis, I tragically did not refer to these narratives as "seamlessly interwoven." I found that, in an effort to have endings and reveals line up, some of the narratives felt incredibly stretched out, while others were prolonged. While they all had their brights spots, I wouldn't say that I was equally interested in the storylines throughout the whole book.
I also think cult-curious readers (like myself) should adjust their expectations to fully receive this different story. O Sinners! is much more a book of self-discovery than conspiracy-uncovering. It wasn't quite what I expected, but I did really enjoy it and will definitely be looking for more from Nicole Cuffy in the future!
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for an early copy in exchange for an honest review. <3
You will see that, unlike the synopsis, I tragically did not refer to these narratives as "seamlessly interwoven." I found that, in an effort to have endings and reveals line up, some of the narratives felt incredibly stretched out, while others were prolonged. While they all had their brights spots, I wouldn't say that I was equally interested in the storylines throughout the whole book.
I also think cult-curious readers (like myself) should adjust their expectations to fully receive this different story. O Sinners! is much more a book of self-discovery than conspiracy-uncovering. It wasn't quite what I expected, but I did really enjoy it and will definitely be looking for more from Nicole Cuffy in the future!
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for an early copy in exchange for an honest review. <3
November 3, 2024
I am not really sure how to categorize this novel, but I can say I really enjoyed it. The story follows Faruq, a young journalist who is writing a piece on a "religious" cult of some kind or is it? He is a tad lost after the death of his devout Muslim father, a devotion he himself never felt and prior to that, the death of his mother.
The leader of "The Nameless" is a former Vietnam vet and the story weaves his experiences in Vietnam with the the current cult life and a transcript of a documentary filmed before along with Faruq's daily interaction with the group. .
Faruq was going to take at most six weeks to gather enough material to write a really good article. Months go by and he is still there, but now he has a book to write. I found his trying to understand what was being taught and trying to make sense of his own life as the main struggle. The writing was very good and I would love to see more from this author.
Was the wolf real?
I would like to thank Penguin Random House for offering me this read through NetGalley.
The leader of "The Nameless" is a former Vietnam vet and the story weaves his experiences in Vietnam with the the current cult life and a transcript of a documentary filmed before along with Faruq's daily interaction with the group. .
Faruq was going to take at most six weeks to gather enough material to write a really good article. Months go by and he is still there, but now he has a book to write. I found his trying to understand what was being taught and trying to make sense of his own life as the main struggle. The writing was very good and I would love to see more from this author.
Was the wolf real?
I would like to thank Penguin Random House for offering me this read through NetGalley.
November 11, 2024
Thank you NetGalley and One World for this eARC of O Sinners!
Wooooooooooowwwwwww!!
The book follows three storylines. One about Faruq, a award-winning journalist, who decides his next big story will be about a cult rising in prominence. One about four black infantrymen in Vietnam. One following the script of a documentary about a clash the cult had a church in Texas. Weaving through all three of these storylines is the story of Odo, the leader of the cult who seems to be able to convice anyone to join his movement.
This book is just incredible. The way it dives into grief, and love, and trauma, and the ways others manipulate us. It's just . . . mwah! I can't find the words for how much I loved everything about this book. Never a slow spot, never a boring chapter, never a wasted word, a wasted detail.
I whole heartedly recommend this book to anyone and everyone. Go in with as little information as possible and just let the story take you with it. Its a long book, but it flies by and you won't regret picking it up.
Wooooooooooowwwwwww!!
The book follows three storylines. One about Faruq, a award-winning journalist, who decides his next big story will be about a cult rising in prominence. One about four black infantrymen in Vietnam. One following the script of a documentary about a clash the cult had a church in Texas. Weaving through all three of these storylines is the story of Odo, the leader of the cult who seems to be able to convice anyone to join his movement.
This book is just incredible. The way it dives into grief, and love, and trauma, and the ways others manipulate us. It's just . . . mwah! I can't find the words for how much I loved everything about this book. Never a slow spot, never a boring chapter, never a wasted word, a wasted detail.
I whole heartedly recommend this book to anyone and everyone. Go in with as little information as possible and just let the story take you with it. Its a long book, but it flies by and you won't regret picking it up.
November 10, 2024
Thanks to NetGalley and Random House Publishing for an advance copy of O SINNERS! All opinions are my own.
This book rocks. It's about a journalist, Faruq, who is trying to get through the losses of his parents, most recently, his father. Their complicated relationship leaves him ruminating on faith and family, and with that in mind, he goes on assignment in the woods of California to research a cult called the nameless.
As Faruq gets more and more entwined with the people in the nameless, especially their charismatic leader, Odo, he struggles to figure out what is real and what isn't.
I loved the prose and the characterization in this book. It isn't a typical "cult" book, and it looks at many different facets of cults and why people join them. A satisfying and compelling read.
This book rocks. It's about a journalist, Faruq, who is trying to get through the losses of his parents, most recently, his father. Their complicated relationship leaves him ruminating on faith and family, and with that in mind, he goes on assignment in the woods of California to research a cult called the nameless.
As Faruq gets more and more entwined with the people in the nameless, especially their charismatic leader, Odo, he struggles to figure out what is real and what isn't.
I loved the prose and the characterization in this book. It isn't a typical "cult" book, and it looks at many different facets of cults and why people join them. A satisfying and compelling read.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 47 reviews