What do you think?
Rate this book
I, Eliza Hamilton
In this beautifully written novel of historical fiction, bestselling author Susan Holloway Scott tells the story of Alexander Hamilton's wife, Eliza--a fascinating, strong-willed heroine in her own right and a key figure in one of the most gripping periods in American history.
"Love is not easy with a man chosen by Fate for greatness . . ."
As the daughter of a respected general, Elizabeth Schuyler is accustomed to socializing with dignitaries and soldiers. But no visitor to her parents' home has affected her so strongly as Alexander Hamilton, a charismatic, ambitious aide to George Washington. They marry quickly, and despite the tumult of the American Revolution, Eliza is confident in her brilliant husband and in her role as his helpmate. But it is in the aftermath of war, as Hamilton becomes one of the country's most important figures, that she truly comes into her own.
In the new capital, Eliza becomes an adored member of society, respected for her fierce devotion to Hamilton as well as her grace. Behind closed doors, she astutely manages their expanding household, and assists her husband with his political writings. Yet some challenges are impossible to prepare for. Through public scandal, betrayal, personal heartbreak, and tragedy, she is tested again and again. In the end, it will be Eliza's indomitable strength that makes her not only Hamilton's most crucial ally in life, but also his most loyal advocate after his death, determined to preserve his legacy while pursuing her own extraordinary path through the nation they helped shape together.
"Love is not easy with a man chosen by Fate for greatness . . ."
As the daughter of a respected general, Elizabeth Schuyler is accustomed to socializing with dignitaries and soldiers. But no visitor to her parents' home has affected her so strongly as Alexander Hamilton, a charismatic, ambitious aide to George Washington. They marry quickly, and despite the tumult of the American Revolution, Eliza is confident in her brilliant husband and in her role as his helpmate. But it is in the aftermath of war, as Hamilton becomes one of the country's most important figures, that she truly comes into her own.
In the new capital, Eliza becomes an adored member of society, respected for her fierce devotion to Hamilton as well as her grace. Behind closed doors, she astutely manages their expanding household, and assists her husband with his political writings. Yet some challenges are impossible to prepare for. Through public scandal, betrayal, personal heartbreak, and tragedy, she is tested again and again. In the end, it will be Eliza's indomitable strength that makes her not only Hamilton's most crucial ally in life, but also his most loyal advocate after his death, determined to preserve his legacy while pursuing her own extraordinary path through the nation they helped shape together.
757 pages, Library Binding
First published September 26, 2017
1,674 people are currently reading
12.2k people want to read
About the author
Susan Holloway Scott
9 books756 followersAka Miranda Jarrett
Aka Isabella Bradford
Susan Holloway Scott is the author of over fifty historical novels and historical romances. Writing under several pen names, she has received numerous awards and honors for her bestselling books. With more than three million copies of her books in print, she has been published in nineteen foreign countries around the world and translated into fourteen different languages.
Susan has also written as half of the Two Nerdy History Girls (twonerdyhistorygirls.com), a popular book & history blog with a worldwide following. Follow her on Instagram (https://www.instagram.com/susan_hollo...) and Twitter (https://twitter.com/2nerdyhistgirls). She is a graduate of Brown University, and lives with her family outside of Philadelphia, PA.
Aka Isabella Bradford
Susan Holloway Scott is the author of over fifty historical novels and historical romances. Writing under several pen names, she has received numerous awards and honors for her bestselling books. With more than three million copies of her books in print, she has been published in nineteen foreign countries around the world and translated into fourteen different languages.
Susan has also written as half of the Two Nerdy History Girls (twonerdyhistorygirls.com), a popular book & history blog with a worldwide following. Follow her on Instagram (https://www.instagram.com/susan_hollo...) and Twitter (https://twitter.com/2nerdyhistgirls). She is a graduate of Brown University, and lives with her family outside of Philadelphia, PA.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 990 reviews
November 26, 2023
Oh, how I do love a good Alex/Eliza historical romance. Buddy read this one with my mom! Yay, we both loved it! Two thumbs up! The execution was quite well done, with a good mix of history, romance between the two lovers, bits of individual character, details on the war, the economic crisis that followed, and the founding of the United States, and just really good pacing. I have such admiration for authors like Scott who can present long passages of historical fact, provide just enough wonderful bits of detail about hair powder, dress descriptions, passages about the terrible winter weather in New Jersey and the woes of the Continental Army not getting paid, and keep it fresh and entertaining chapter after chapter. This was masterfully done and managed to balance everything just right.
But the very best thing about this was the intense connection presented between Alex and Eliza. As we all know from history, Alexander Hamilton was a brilliant, passionate, but flawed man, and the book stayed true to that while still keeping the love story a love story. All in all, one of my favorite historical romances!
But the very best thing about this was the intense connection presented between Alex and Eliza. As we all know from history, Alexander Hamilton was a brilliant, passionate, but flawed man, and the book stayed true to that while still keeping the love story a love story. All in all, one of my favorite historical romances!
July 25, 2017
I was fortunate enough to receive an advanced copy of this book and feel compelled to share my thoughts on it. Susan Holloway Scott has written an excellent, well-researched book about best of wives and best of women, Eliza Hamilton. In typical biographies (or musicals), Eliza is seen as a peripheral character, but she deserves much more recognition than is normally given to her and Scott has done just that. Normally, I am not one to read historical fiction, but this one pulled me in from the very first page. It is obvious that Scott admires the real life Alexander and Elizabeth, but through her research and understanding, she gives a new perspective on two now well-known people.
Susan Holloway Scott set out on an ambitious project to give the reader an insight into the mind and motives behind two beloved people, but in particular, Eliza. Written in first person from Eliza’s perspective, it allows the reader to experience the joy, longing, and sorrow that Eliza felt throughout her life. This is not always an easy task as there are few letters written by Eliza; however, Scott certainly accomplishes this. Somehow through Scott’s writing, she manages to include snippets from Alexander’s letters seamlessly into dialogue and still retains an 18th century feel through the entire book which makes it a true joy to read.
As Scott is an author of other popular works of historical fiction, I can think of no one better to write this book. Though it should not be taken as historical fact, I still found it helpful for understanding Alexander and Eliza as real people instead of characters on a path of historical inevitability. My normal stoic heart felt joy and sorrow with Eliza even though I knew what would come to pass and that truly takes skill. I can’t remember the last time I’ve cried from reading or watching something, but I admit that a few tears were shed for Eliza.
For anyone interested in Alexander and Eliza, this is an excellent book to provide a new perspective and breathe life into this fated couple who celebrated together, suffered together, and loved each other deeply.
Susan Holloway Scott set out on an ambitious project to give the reader an insight into the mind and motives behind two beloved people, but in particular, Eliza. Written in first person from Eliza’s perspective, it allows the reader to experience the joy, longing, and sorrow that Eliza felt throughout her life. This is not always an easy task as there are few letters written by Eliza; however, Scott certainly accomplishes this. Somehow through Scott’s writing, she manages to include snippets from Alexander’s letters seamlessly into dialogue and still retains an 18th century feel through the entire book which makes it a true joy to read.
As Scott is an author of other popular works of historical fiction, I can think of no one better to write this book. Though it should not be taken as historical fact, I still found it helpful for understanding Alexander and Eliza as real people instead of characters on a path of historical inevitability. My normal stoic heart felt joy and sorrow with Eliza even though I knew what would come to pass and that truly takes skill. I can’t remember the last time I’ve cried from reading or watching something, but I admit that a few tears were shed for Eliza.
For anyone interested in Alexander and Eliza, this is an excellent book to provide a new perspective and breathe life into this fated couple who celebrated together, suffered together, and loved each other deeply.
September 21, 2017
An absolutely brilliantly written historical fiction novel! This was very hard to put down! I was unaware of the life's story of Eliza Hamilton before I read this. She has to have been one of the strongest women in history mentally. She was so ahead of her time. Author, Susan Holloway obviously meticulously researched every detail from the time period,to clothing styles,military and political moves to housing and child care.This book leaves me feeling as if I spent years getting to know this family as it started out with Elizabeth as a 17 year old and gives details of their life together and the separations they had to endure over the years. This book was highly anticipated by me and it did not disappoint at all. Word heavy, I delighted in all the detail this book provided me about a historical family I didn't know to much about. Amazingly, after Alexander's death Eliza went on to live til she was 97 years old which was another half century. She had a long life that spanned from the colonial era to the eve of the Civil War,dying in 1854. She died as the last remaining widow of a Founding Father.I can't give this book enough stars, absolutely magnificent!!!!! Historical fans this in one you can not miss!
Pub Date 26 Sep 2017
Thank you to NetGalley and Kensington Books for a review copy in exchange for my honest review.
Pub Date 26 Sep 2017
Thank you to NetGalley and Kensington Books for a review copy in exchange for my honest review.
March 24, 2018
I love historical fiction, especially in the early days of the USA. I enjoyed this novel very much and highly recommend it!
This is the story of Alexander Hamilton's wife Eliza. A fictional (but believable) story told from her point of view. The author wrote with much charm how Eliza meets and is captivated by a young Alexander Hamilton. They have a hurried wedding due to the time period, on the cusp of the American Revolution. Eliza is Alexander's best friend and due to her infectious personality- she quickly rises in stature and social standing. Something that will benefit her greatly. She outwardly gracefully handles the duties of being "The Lady of the House" but inside she is fighting to stay strong. She has many hats to wear though as the wife of Alexander Hamilton and not all are easy or will give her the credit she is due. This book shows just how vital women were for the birth of America and hers is just one story of many.
Free copy given by publisher and NetGalley for a fair & honest review.
This is the story of Alexander Hamilton's wife Eliza. A fictional (but believable) story told from her point of view. The author wrote with much charm how Eliza meets and is captivated by a young Alexander Hamilton. They have a hurried wedding due to the time period, on the cusp of the American Revolution. Eliza is Alexander's best friend and due to her infectious personality- she quickly rises in stature and social standing. Something that will benefit her greatly. She outwardly gracefully handles the duties of being "The Lady of the House" but inside she is fighting to stay strong. She has many hats to wear though as the wife of Alexander Hamilton and not all are easy or will give her the credit she is due. This book shows just how vital women were for the birth of America and hers is just one story of many.
Free copy given by publisher and NetGalley for a fair & honest review.
September 15, 2017
With Hamilton: An American Musical taking the US by storm, I knew it wouldn't take long for someone to capitalize on the idea of a novel about Eliza. I also knew I would be first in line to get it. Eliza in the musical is sweet, loyal, devoted and the perfect person to balance the ambitious, fiery Hamilton. I loved the idea of focusing on her point-of-view and learning more about her story beyond Alexander.
Historical facts not treated as spoilers.
I heard the soundtrack of the musical playing in my mind the entire time I was reading this, and was thoroughly disappointed when they ended at the same time. After looking forward to reading about Eliza's life after Hamilton - she outlived him by 50 years - I discovered that this author has decided that only the Alexander years were interesting. In fact, the entire story reads that way. Eliza is almost obsessed with her husband and has no interests or passions of her own besides bearing his children. Some of this is appropriate. Eliza was a woman of her time and was devoted to her husband, but that's why it would have been nice to learn more about her life after his death.
When Alexander meets the Schuyler sisters, it is a bit different than the vision of Angelica, Peggy, & Eliza sneaking into downtown NYC to find an 'urchin who can give you ideals.' In fact, anyone who knows their history primarily from the musical will be disappointed to discover that Angelica did not decide to introduce Alexander to Eliza after her epiphany of 'three fundamental truths.' She was Angelica Church long before she met Hamilton, though she did famously flirt with him and seemingly most men she came into contact with. (This and a few other themes are repeated incessantly. Angelica flirts. Alexander works too hard & is so much smarter than anyone else. Eliza is soooo in love....and always pregnant.)
This novel adheres more strictly to historical truths than the musical, which is probably its greatest strength. Hamilton comes across largely the same. 'I prob’ly shouldn’t brag, but dag, I amaze and astonish. The problem is I got a lot of brains but no polish. I gotta holler just to be heard. With every word, I drop knowledge!' Eliza almost manages to remain a supporting character in her own story. And maybe there's a reason she is not usually brought to the forefront. Her story is bland. Her never-ending pledges of undying love and telling the reader how handsome and brilliant her husband is just doesn't captivate. I found myself waiting for the big moments that I knew were coming so that the novel would get an injection of drama.
Except that didn't happen. When Eliza reads the Reynolds Pamphlet, she takes less time to get over it than it takes Phillipa Soo to sing 'Burn,' and Philip's death did not create anywhere near the emotional impact that I expected. This Eliza can accept anything as long as Alexander still pledges his love to her.
And then it's over. Of course, I had guessed this based on the remaining pages shrinking to a point that there was no way another 50 years was going to be covered, but I held out irrational hope until the bitter end. More of Eliza's post-Alexander life is revealed in 'Who Lives, Who Dies, Who Tells Your Story.'
Admittedly, I do not typically read romance novels, and this seems to be getting great ratings from readers who look more specifically for this genre. In my opinion, there was a bit too much gloss and not enough emotion to get a reader truly involved. Still, it is a quick read for 400ish pages and has some good historical nuggets included.
I received this book through NetGalley. Opinions are my own.
Historical facts not treated as spoilers.
I heard the soundtrack of the musical playing in my mind the entire time I was reading this, and was thoroughly disappointed when they ended at the same time. After looking forward to reading about Eliza's life after Hamilton - she outlived him by 50 years - I discovered that this author has decided that only the Alexander years were interesting. In fact, the entire story reads that way. Eliza is almost obsessed with her husband and has no interests or passions of her own besides bearing his children. Some of this is appropriate. Eliza was a woman of her time and was devoted to her husband, but that's why it would have been nice to learn more about her life after his death.
When Alexander meets the Schuyler sisters, it is a bit different than the vision of Angelica, Peggy, & Eliza sneaking into downtown NYC to find an 'urchin who can give you ideals.' In fact, anyone who knows their history primarily from the musical will be disappointed to discover that Angelica did not decide to introduce Alexander to Eliza after her epiphany of 'three fundamental truths.' She was Angelica Church long before she met Hamilton, though she did famously flirt with him and seemingly most men she came into contact with. (This and a few other themes are repeated incessantly. Angelica flirts. Alexander works too hard & is so much smarter than anyone else. Eliza is soooo in love....and always pregnant.)
This novel adheres more strictly to historical truths than the musical, which is probably its greatest strength. Hamilton comes across largely the same. 'I prob’ly shouldn’t brag, but dag, I amaze and astonish. The problem is I got a lot of brains but no polish. I gotta holler just to be heard. With every word, I drop knowledge!' Eliza almost manages to remain a supporting character in her own story. And maybe there's a reason she is not usually brought to the forefront. Her story is bland. Her never-ending pledges of undying love and telling the reader how handsome and brilliant her husband is just doesn't captivate. I found myself waiting for the big moments that I knew were coming so that the novel would get an injection of drama.
Except that didn't happen. When Eliza reads the Reynolds Pamphlet, she takes less time to get over it than it takes Phillipa Soo to sing 'Burn,' and Philip's death did not create anywhere near the emotional impact that I expected. This Eliza can accept anything as long as Alexander still pledges his love to her.
And then it's over. Of course, I had guessed this based on the remaining pages shrinking to a point that there was no way another 50 years was going to be covered, but I held out irrational hope until the bitter end. More of Eliza's post-Alexander life is revealed in 'Who Lives, Who Dies, Who Tells Your Story.'
Admittedly, I do not typically read romance novels, and this seems to be getting great ratings from readers who look more specifically for this genre. In my opinion, there was a bit too much gloss and not enough emotion to get a reader truly involved. Still, it is a quick read for 400ish pages and has some good historical nuggets included.
I received this book through NetGalley. Opinions are my own.
August 21, 2017
I'm not sure this book is actually about Eliza Hamilton. It's basically a banal romance without any character detail with Wikipedia facts about Alexander Hamilton thrown in. It was so lacking in specificity, that it could have been a boring book about anyone with names swapped in to make it "about" Eliza Hamilton. And apparently her life is only important from the moment she meets Alexander until he dies. What an insult to the real Eliza Hamilton, who actually did a lot of wonderful things in real life. So boring. And if readable at all, at least 250 pages longer than necessary.
November 24, 2017
Here we go again, where H.G. rants about a Hamilton-related book.
I maybe went into this book a little biased - after "Alex and Eliza", which I truly and sincerely disliked, I was not really open to the idea of another revolution romance book between these two. However, this one went into their later lives as well, so I was a little more open to it - since that was always the period of their relationship I actually wanted to read about. This book is basically broken into three parts: the Revolution, the time Alexander spends as Treasury Secretary, and the years between that and the duel (an issue we'll get back to later). The entire thing is narrated, as the cover imples, by Eliza, which means there's none of the annoying back-and-forth that we got from "Alex and Eliza."
So I started the book, and we open up with scenes set during the Revolution. Alexander visits the Schuyler Mansion to attend one of their parties and bring news about how everyone has disparate views of Eliza's father because of a recent battle. Eliza is ticked off, but eventually when they spend maybe ten, maybe fifteen minutes alone together, she simply cannot resist the charm in his blue-green (blue-green? *glances at biography stating blue-violet) eyes. They become friends, and he says he will call her Betsey, to stand apart from the rest of her friends who merely call her Eliza. Alexander leaves, Eliza waves goodbye, and we skip two years.
Two years later, Alexander and the other officers and soldiers in the Revolution are camped at Morristown, near to the residence of Eliza's aunt and uncle. They invite her to their home to spend a few months, and Eliza and her father set out in a carriage with her slave (referred to, like all slaves in this book, as "A Negro") and her trunks. The entire ride there, Eliza speculates about meeting Alexander again, while her father tells her that he will not object to their marriage if she desires it. Considering they've only met once, this seems to be... rushing things. Just a tiny bit.
Once Eliza settles in Morristown, her aunt reveals that the literal only reason she invited Eliza here was so that she could meet Alexander again, and drills her in all the ways that she will have to win his apparently worldly heart. Ignore the fact they've only met once. Ignore the fact that he's probably sleeping around, if town gossip is to be trusted. Ignore John Laurens - oh, wait, Scott already ignores John Laurens. No problem, then. After a few staged and awkward encounters, Alexander and Eliza have been reunited and have fallen in insta-love, knowing that they are so right for each other that there is literally no stupid pet name he cannot call her by. On page 62, they swear their undying love in the moonlight and make out near a house full of people who are probably staring out the window going "What the heck". Alexander wants to marry her. Eliza loves this idea. Roll credits. Oh wait, we're not even to page 100 yet.
The two spend the rest of the war with this repetitive cycle of "Alas, when shall we be able to get married?" during which they write each other practically every day and Eliza cries frequently. When they're together, they do practically nothing except cuddle and talk about (in albiet flowery and uncrude language) how much they want to get married so they can have sex. Ick. At long last the wait is over, they do get married, we are treated to a very uncomfortable few pages that explain how the couple spend an entire two days in bed after their wedding night, and then Alexander goes back to fighting. For a few more chapters, we return to the letters and the sporadic returns Alexander can make. At one point, Eliza and Alexander share a house near the fighting, but this ends pretty quickly as things heat up with battles, and she goes home. Finally her father wakes her up in the middle of the night so all the Schuylers can hold a midnight fiesta (apparently in Eliza's room, since her mother is sitting in a chair by her bed for some reason) to celebrate that THE WAR IS OVER! BREAK OUT THE SPARKLING CIDER AND ENDLESS TOASTS TO HIS EXCELLENCY!!!! YAAAAAAAAAAY!!!! (So it wasn't exactly like that when Eliza was woken up. That was the aftermath which continued for another chapter at least.) Everything is good now - Alexander's alive, Eliza's had a baby, and the happy couple has engaged in a truly spectacular make-out session. Roll credits. Wait, we're still not done.
From here we move into the second third of the book. I won't descibe the transition to this, mostly because I don't really remember it, even though I just finished the book yesterday. The entire second third blurred together for me, and I can't say it left two much of an impression.
At any rate, Alexander and Eliza are head-over-heels in love and living in a tiny little house while Alexander tries to make it big as a lawyer. (Spoiler alert: he makes it as a lawyer and they move into this freaking huge house that Eliza often worries is too small). The second third is pretty repetitive, and even though it's accurate and Scott obviously did an enormous amount of research, I still wish she had found a way to spice this portion up. Throughout the second third, we are treated to a description of all Alexander's deeds, as seen through Eliza's supportive and unimportant eyes. Paragraph after paragraph read like Wikipedia has been thrown up by a lovesick anime schoolgirl, interrupted by scenes of Alexander and Eliza curled up in bed talking about their day. Eliza usually reveals that she is pregnant at this book. She's pregnant basically the entire book. Also coloring this portion of the book are visits from Eliza's beloved sister Angelica, who is flamboyant, wealthy, and probably sleeping with Alexander. When she manages to make it across the sea, she and Eliza angst together, she and Alexander flirt in french, and then she leaves and Eliza angsts alone.
All this goes on for quite some time - Alexander's deeds, Eliza's pregnant, Angelica comes and goes, repeat - and it gets a little tedious. One thing I can't complain about though is the fact that Scott is a really really good writer. Her prose (and there is quite a lot of it) is flowy and reads well, if a little simply (which fits Eliza). Her dialogue is a little less dazzling, and I often found it hard to imagine real people saying some of the stuff she had written. Granted, it was the 18th Century. But still. In spite of all this, I didn't mind the second third. I actually kind of liked it, and devoured most of it in a single sitting late at night. It lost me at some points, but the writing and research were both good, so I wasn't ranting and screaming like for the other two thirds.
Finally out of love for Eliza and his fifty million adorable kids, Alexander resigns his post as Treasury Secretary. Roll credits - wait, no, there's more. This is like "Return of the King" all over again. At long last we move into the final third of the book. Throughout this third, Alexander has a lot of kindergarten fights with his various enemies - Thomas Jefferson, James Madison, James Monroe, John Adams, the entire United States (minus NYC), the world, the universe at large, God, Aaron Burr - basically, there is pretty much no one Alexander hasn't offended. Eliza continues to have kids or to take in others, such as a little girl named Fanny Antill, or the refugee son of the Marquis de Lafayette. Considering that Lafayette was Alexander's close friend, I was a little disappointed that he didn't get any screentime, and even more that his son was sort of in and out of their house. But I digress.
Against Eliza's far better judgement, Alexander keeps sending out pamphlets and rebukes and whatnot. He does this in the second third, too, but here his stupidity knows no bounds, and he comes *this close* to getting involved in a duel at least twenty times. Ever-pregnant Eliza is concerned to no end. Finally things go from bad to worse when James Monroe and other enemies claim that Alexander has been embezzling from the government, and to dissaude this, Alexander writes the infamous Reynolds Pamphlet. He brings home his original copy so Eliza can read it before the world at large. Eliza does, and this is where I started hating this book again (gratned, I hated the Revolution third too). Eliza is mollified when Alexander's pamphlet explains that he had an affair. She flees the house with her baby and goes to Angelica's, since Angelica has at last settled permanenetly. There, she cries, and Angelica reveals that she already knew (how is never quite revealed). Throughout the five pages it takes for Eliza to forgive Alexander, she declaims Maria Reynolds, the mistress, as everything from "harlot" to "whore", ungenorous terms, esspecially from someone so sweet as Eliza. She and Scott try to pass over the infidelity as "Oh, but it was a trap set by Madison, so it's okay", and very quickly, Eliza and Alexander are back in love and the pamphlet is never discussed again. Roll credits - or not.
I hated that, because by that point the story was no longer about Eliza - not that it ever had been. The first third was about the fact that love and desire triumph all. The second was about Alexander. This part had just shown that Eliza literally serves no purpose in this narrative except to be The Wife tm, and no matter what awful thing Alexander did, there would always be forgiveness, because literally nothing in Eliza's life was more important than this man and their love. I so completely despised that. It was an eraser swiping across Eliza. Forget about the other characters Scott erased, like my dead gay son John Laurens, like all of the slaves who served as decorations in the background, like every other wife in the story, like Maria Reynolds, like my sense of innocence. By now, the main character too had fallen prey to the giant red "YOU DO NOT MATTER" eraser. I wanted to see Eliza's strength. I wanted to watch her go through a process to forgive Alexander, and I definitely wanted her to forgive Maria. But there was neither process nor forgiveness for the "strumpet", as Maria was also called. There was just triumphant overwhelming fake consuming insta-love that lasted all these years and could not even now be broken. In the words of my editor, gag me with a spoon.
The book wraps up with more and more sad things happening - Aaron Burr wrecks one of Alexander's projects, Philip, the eldest Hamilton son, dies within the course of two hundred words, Eliza joins an amazing charity and that fact is glossed over quickly, their daughter goes insane (not in that order). Finally, Alexander and Eliza are alone a few pages after losing their son and daughter to death and madness, and Alexander reminds Eliza that he will always love her and whatnot. By now things with Aaron Burr are pretty bad, but not so bad that Eliza has any idea that anything's going on. (Something's going on? Good thing I know history or I would be confused too.) Alexander delivers the "best of wives and best of women" line. We all cry. Next page, a friend rides up to tell Eliza that Alexander has been shot. Eliza goes to him, sits crying, brings in her children to say goodbye, and then he dies. Cut to afterword where she reinstates the title for no reason. Roll credits - wait, WHAT?
The book ends there. We get an afterword from Scott describing the things Eliza did later in life. H.G. fumes.
Because by making the book end with the death instead of the amazing things Eliza did, Scott has literally confirmed my suspcions that this book is all about Alexander, not his incredible wife. Eliza is a prop, and now we have no chance to see her as anything else. I felt robbed and angry and terribly sorry for Eliza, who, thanks to that big eraser, no longer exists. This book is not about an incredible woman. It's not even really about triumphant love, though it seems that way at times. This book is all about glorifying a man who didn't really deserve it for those latter two thirds, a man who cannot fall from grace, because no matter how far over the edge he goes, Eliza will always be able to grab him and haul him back up.
So I am disappointed. And I am really sick and tired of all this.
Someone write a book about John Laurens, for God's sake. Someone write a book about the Revolution that I don't despise. Someone write about Eliza post-duel, Eliza and her steadfast love, Eliza and her refusal to let Alexander's memory die, Eliza and her charities, ELIZA, not Eliza-the-wife. I want to read that. I want to read something that is true, and fair, and good.
And if no one else will write it, I swear to God I will.
I maybe went into this book a little biased - after "Alex and Eliza", which I truly and sincerely disliked, I was not really open to the idea of another revolution romance book between these two. However, this one went into their later lives as well, so I was a little more open to it - since that was always the period of their relationship I actually wanted to read about. This book is basically broken into three parts: the Revolution, the time Alexander spends as Treasury Secretary, and the years between that and the duel (an issue we'll get back to later). The entire thing is narrated, as the cover imples, by Eliza, which means there's none of the annoying back-and-forth that we got from "Alex and Eliza."
So I started the book, and we open up with scenes set during the Revolution. Alexander visits the Schuyler Mansion to attend one of their parties and bring news about how everyone has disparate views of Eliza's father because of a recent battle. Eliza is ticked off, but eventually when they spend maybe ten, maybe fifteen minutes alone together, she simply cannot resist the charm in his blue-green (blue-green? *glances at biography stating blue-violet) eyes. They become friends, and he says he will call her Betsey, to stand apart from the rest of her friends who merely call her Eliza. Alexander leaves, Eliza waves goodbye, and we skip two years.
Two years later, Alexander and the other officers and soldiers in the Revolution are camped at Morristown, near to the residence of Eliza's aunt and uncle. They invite her to their home to spend a few months, and Eliza and her father set out in a carriage with her slave (referred to, like all slaves in this book, as "A Negro") and her trunks. The entire ride there, Eliza speculates about meeting Alexander again, while her father tells her that he will not object to their marriage if she desires it. Considering they've only met once, this seems to be... rushing things. Just a tiny bit.
Once Eliza settles in Morristown, her aunt reveals that the literal only reason she invited Eliza here was so that she could meet Alexander again, and drills her in all the ways that she will have to win his apparently worldly heart. Ignore the fact they've only met once. Ignore the fact that he's probably sleeping around, if town gossip is to be trusted. Ignore John Laurens - oh, wait, Scott already ignores John Laurens. No problem, then. After a few staged and awkward encounters, Alexander and Eliza have been reunited and have fallen in insta-love, knowing that they are so right for each other that there is literally no stupid pet name he cannot call her by. On page 62, they swear their undying love in the moonlight and make out near a house full of people who are probably staring out the window going "What the heck". Alexander wants to marry her. Eliza loves this idea. Roll credits. Oh wait, we're not even to page 100 yet.
The two spend the rest of the war with this repetitive cycle of "Alas, when shall we be able to get married?" during which they write each other practically every day and Eliza cries frequently. When they're together, they do practically nothing except cuddle and talk about (in albiet flowery and uncrude language) how much they want to get married so they can have sex. Ick. At long last the wait is over, they do get married, we are treated to a very uncomfortable few pages that explain how the couple spend an entire two days in bed after their wedding night, and then Alexander goes back to fighting. For a few more chapters, we return to the letters and the sporadic returns Alexander can make. At one point, Eliza and Alexander share a house near the fighting, but this ends pretty quickly as things heat up with battles, and she goes home. Finally her father wakes her up in the middle of the night so all the Schuylers can hold a midnight fiesta (apparently in Eliza's room, since her mother is sitting in a chair by her bed for some reason) to celebrate that THE WAR IS OVER! BREAK OUT THE SPARKLING CIDER AND ENDLESS TOASTS TO HIS EXCELLENCY!!!! YAAAAAAAAAAY!!!! (So it wasn't exactly like that when Eliza was woken up. That was the aftermath which continued for another chapter at least.) Everything is good now - Alexander's alive, Eliza's had a baby, and the happy couple has engaged in a truly spectacular make-out session. Roll credits. Wait, we're still not done.
From here we move into the second third of the book. I won't descibe the transition to this, mostly because I don't really remember it, even though I just finished the book yesterday. The entire second third blurred together for me, and I can't say it left two much of an impression.
At any rate, Alexander and Eliza are head-over-heels in love and living in a tiny little house while Alexander tries to make it big as a lawyer. (Spoiler alert: he makes it as a lawyer and they move into this freaking huge house that Eliza often worries is too small). The second third is pretty repetitive, and even though it's accurate and Scott obviously did an enormous amount of research, I still wish she had found a way to spice this portion up. Throughout the second third, we are treated to a description of all Alexander's deeds, as seen through Eliza's supportive and unimportant eyes. Paragraph after paragraph read like Wikipedia has been thrown up by a lovesick anime schoolgirl, interrupted by scenes of Alexander and Eliza curled up in bed talking about their day. Eliza usually reveals that she is pregnant at this book. She's pregnant basically the entire book. Also coloring this portion of the book are visits from Eliza's beloved sister Angelica, who is flamboyant, wealthy, and probably sleeping with Alexander. When she manages to make it across the sea, she and Eliza angst together, she and Alexander flirt in french, and then she leaves and Eliza angsts alone.
All this goes on for quite some time - Alexander's deeds, Eliza's pregnant, Angelica comes and goes, repeat - and it gets a little tedious. One thing I can't complain about though is the fact that Scott is a really really good writer. Her prose (and there is quite a lot of it) is flowy and reads well, if a little simply (which fits Eliza). Her dialogue is a little less dazzling, and I often found it hard to imagine real people saying some of the stuff she had written. Granted, it was the 18th Century. But still. In spite of all this, I didn't mind the second third. I actually kind of liked it, and devoured most of it in a single sitting late at night. It lost me at some points, but the writing and research were both good, so I wasn't ranting and screaming like for the other two thirds.
Finally out of love for Eliza and his fifty million adorable kids, Alexander resigns his post as Treasury Secretary. Roll credits - wait, no, there's more. This is like "Return of the King" all over again. At long last we move into the final third of the book. Throughout this third, Alexander has a lot of kindergarten fights with his various enemies - Thomas Jefferson, James Madison, James Monroe, John Adams, the entire United States (minus NYC), the world, the universe at large, God, Aaron Burr - basically, there is pretty much no one Alexander hasn't offended. Eliza continues to have kids or to take in others, such as a little girl named Fanny Antill, or the refugee son of the Marquis de Lafayette. Considering that Lafayette was Alexander's close friend, I was a little disappointed that he didn't get any screentime, and even more that his son was sort of in and out of their house. But I digress.
Against Eliza's far better judgement, Alexander keeps sending out pamphlets and rebukes and whatnot. He does this in the second third, too, but here his stupidity knows no bounds, and he comes *this close* to getting involved in a duel at least twenty times. Ever-pregnant Eliza is concerned to no end. Finally things go from bad to worse when James Monroe and other enemies claim that Alexander has been embezzling from the government, and to dissaude this, Alexander writes the infamous Reynolds Pamphlet. He brings home his original copy so Eliza can read it before the world at large. Eliza does, and this is where I started hating this book again (gratned, I hated the Revolution third too). Eliza is mollified when Alexander's pamphlet explains that he had an affair. She flees the house with her baby and goes to Angelica's, since Angelica has at last settled permanenetly. There, she cries, and Angelica reveals that she already knew (how is never quite revealed). Throughout the five pages it takes for Eliza to forgive Alexander, she declaims Maria Reynolds, the mistress, as everything from "harlot" to "whore", ungenorous terms, esspecially from someone so sweet as Eliza. She and Scott try to pass over the infidelity as "Oh, but it was a trap set by Madison, so it's okay", and very quickly, Eliza and Alexander are back in love and the pamphlet is never discussed again. Roll credits - or not.
I hated that, because by that point the story was no longer about Eliza - not that it ever had been. The first third was about the fact that love and desire triumph all. The second was about Alexander. This part had just shown that Eliza literally serves no purpose in this narrative except to be The Wife tm, and no matter what awful thing Alexander did, there would always be forgiveness, because literally nothing in Eliza's life was more important than this man and their love. I so completely despised that. It was an eraser swiping across Eliza. Forget about the other characters Scott erased, like my dead gay son John Laurens, like all of the slaves who served as decorations in the background, like every other wife in the story, like Maria Reynolds, like my sense of innocence. By now, the main character too had fallen prey to the giant red "YOU DO NOT MATTER" eraser. I wanted to see Eliza's strength. I wanted to watch her go through a process to forgive Alexander, and I definitely wanted her to forgive Maria. But there was neither process nor forgiveness for the "strumpet", as Maria was also called. There was just triumphant overwhelming fake consuming insta-love that lasted all these years and could not even now be broken. In the words of my editor, gag me with a spoon.
The book wraps up with more and more sad things happening - Aaron Burr wrecks one of Alexander's projects, Philip, the eldest Hamilton son, dies within the course of two hundred words, Eliza joins an amazing charity and that fact is glossed over quickly, their daughter goes insane (not in that order). Finally, Alexander and Eliza are alone a few pages after losing their son and daughter to death and madness, and Alexander reminds Eliza that he will always love her and whatnot. By now things with Aaron Burr are pretty bad, but not so bad that Eliza has any idea that anything's going on. (Something's going on? Good thing I know history or I would be confused too.) Alexander delivers the "best of wives and best of women" line. We all cry. Next page, a friend rides up to tell Eliza that Alexander has been shot. Eliza goes to him, sits crying, brings in her children to say goodbye, and then he dies. Cut to afterword where she reinstates the title for no reason. Roll credits - wait, WHAT?
The book ends there. We get an afterword from Scott describing the things Eliza did later in life. H.G. fumes.
Because by making the book end with the death instead of the amazing things Eliza did, Scott has literally confirmed my suspcions that this book is all about Alexander, not his incredible wife. Eliza is a prop, and now we have no chance to see her as anything else. I felt robbed and angry and terribly sorry for Eliza, who, thanks to that big eraser, no longer exists. This book is not about an incredible woman. It's not even really about triumphant love, though it seems that way at times. This book is all about glorifying a man who didn't really deserve it for those latter two thirds, a man who cannot fall from grace, because no matter how far over the edge he goes, Eliza will always be able to grab him and haul him back up.
So I am disappointed. And I am really sick and tired of all this.
Someone write a book about John Laurens, for God's sake. Someone write a book about the Revolution that I don't despise. Someone write about Eliza post-duel, Eliza and her steadfast love, Eliza and her refusal to let Alexander's memory die, Eliza and her charities, ELIZA, not Eliza-the-wife. I want to read that. I want to read something that is true, and fair, and good.
And if no one else will write it, I swear to God I will.
July 21, 2017
There are a few rather strict prerequisites I have in place with respect to reading historical fiction, especially historical romance. First (and it goes without saying), I must have a genuine affinity for the period in which it is set. Second, I have to be deeply interested in the characters at the center of the story. Third, I have to feel as if the facts have been meticulously researched. And of course, it must be compellingly written. There’s also the fact that I am, admittedly, a bit of a voyeur when it comes to reading about the lives of people who once actually existed and whom I greatly admire, so I want details – real ones, and plenty of them – and they must have much more than just a ring of truth.
The era of our nation’s founding is my favorite historical period, and there is no historical figure whose life story fascinates me more than Alexander Hamilton. And since discovering the stunning musical "Hamilton" (and the Ron Chernow biography which inspired it) I have been most curious about his wife Eliza – or his “Betsey,” as he called her. I have enjoyed getting to know her by reading the letters Alexander wrote to her (and to their children) throughout their life together – they give such intimate insight into their remarkable relationship. When I first heard, then, about Susan Holloway Scott’s "I, Eliza Hamilton," I was understandably more than a little intrigued.
I was very fortunate to have received an advance copy of the book, and I was not in the least disappointed. Told in the first person by Eliza herself, the story has been deeply researched and is richly detailed, without sounding like an academic biographical study. There is a cinematic quality to the writing, especially the dialogue, which makes it easy to visualize the unfolding events of that dynamic time during which a new nation was being fashioned, with no guarantees it would survive its earliest years. Eliza’s narrative speaks directly to us readers, as if we were sitting with her, listening to her tell us the story of her life with her most brilliant of geniuses, whose best qualities – his directness, his honesty, his generosity – could also be some of his most problematic and troubling. The dialogue is never stilted, yet manages to somehow convey the voice of some of Alexander’s original letters to her. Their deep love for each other is depicted with great sensitivity, from their breathless young courtship through the times of their later trials. There is an authentic eighteenth-century tone throughout the telling which makes it a pleasure to read (even out loud, as I sometimes found myself doing).
"I, Eliza Hamilton" is the story of a marriage, of a remarkably strong relationship between two very different people who seem to have been fated for one another. Alexander’s brilliance and genius are never downplayed, yet his flaws are unflinchingly depicted as well. Eliza is a strong woman, very supportive of her husband, but with a mind of her own, never fawning. Their marriage survives extreme challenges, only to end in a tragedy which is the stuff of American legend.
The author obviously cares very much for her characters, and has presented their story in a most sympathetic, readable manner. There were many joyous moments during which I found myself smiling or laughing out loud, and there were also a number of absolutely heartbreaking moments, during which (I’m not ashamed to say) I shed copious tears, even though I knew what was coming. In short, Susan Holloway Scott’s "I, Eliza Hamilton" met and exceeded all my rather rigid requirements for good historical fiction. I strongly recommend it to anyone interested in the beginnings of our American identity, and in the story of the man who did so much to forge that identity, and, more importantly, of the woman who supported him in so many ways.
The era of our nation’s founding is my favorite historical period, and there is no historical figure whose life story fascinates me more than Alexander Hamilton. And since discovering the stunning musical "Hamilton" (and the Ron Chernow biography which inspired it) I have been most curious about his wife Eliza – or his “Betsey,” as he called her. I have enjoyed getting to know her by reading the letters Alexander wrote to her (and to their children) throughout their life together – they give such intimate insight into their remarkable relationship. When I first heard, then, about Susan Holloway Scott’s "I, Eliza Hamilton," I was understandably more than a little intrigued.
I was very fortunate to have received an advance copy of the book, and I was not in the least disappointed. Told in the first person by Eliza herself, the story has been deeply researched and is richly detailed, without sounding like an academic biographical study. There is a cinematic quality to the writing, especially the dialogue, which makes it easy to visualize the unfolding events of that dynamic time during which a new nation was being fashioned, with no guarantees it would survive its earliest years. Eliza’s narrative speaks directly to us readers, as if we were sitting with her, listening to her tell us the story of her life with her most brilliant of geniuses, whose best qualities – his directness, his honesty, his generosity – could also be some of his most problematic and troubling. The dialogue is never stilted, yet manages to somehow convey the voice of some of Alexander’s original letters to her. Their deep love for each other is depicted with great sensitivity, from their breathless young courtship through the times of their later trials. There is an authentic eighteenth-century tone throughout the telling which makes it a pleasure to read (even out loud, as I sometimes found myself doing).
"I, Eliza Hamilton" is the story of a marriage, of a remarkably strong relationship between two very different people who seem to have been fated for one another. Alexander’s brilliance and genius are never downplayed, yet his flaws are unflinchingly depicted as well. Eliza is a strong woman, very supportive of her husband, but with a mind of her own, never fawning. Their marriage survives extreme challenges, only to end in a tragedy which is the stuff of American legend.
The author obviously cares very much for her characters, and has presented their story in a most sympathetic, readable manner. There were many joyous moments during which I found myself smiling or laughing out loud, and there were also a number of absolutely heartbreaking moments, during which (I’m not ashamed to say) I shed copious tears, even though I knew what was coming. In short, Susan Holloway Scott’s "I, Eliza Hamilton" met and exceeded all my rather rigid requirements for good historical fiction. I strongly recommend it to anyone interested in the beginnings of our American identity, and in the story of the man who did so much to forge that identity, and, more importantly, of the woman who supported him in so many ways.
July 21, 2024
This is a well-written, entertaining, meticulously researched historical fiction novel about Eliza Hamilton. Ms. Holloway Scott's writing brings to light Eliza's strength and bravery, and allows the reader to experience Eliza's joys, heartbreak, and sorrow. It vividly describes the homes and the cities where the Hamiltons lived. I listened to the audio book, narrated by the truly talented Saskia Maarleveld, who does an outstanding job depicting the voices of the characters. Ms. Holloway Scott's extensive research is apparent, and has inspired me to delve further into this notable woman's story. I have included a link to the author's fascinating blog post about Eliza's wedding ring.
https://susanhollowayscott.com/blog/2...
https://susanhollowayscott.com/blog/2...
November 2, 2017
Elizabeth Schuyler Hamilton was a woman who was so in love with her husband. She fell in love with Alexander Hamilton almost at first sight of him during his visit to the Schuyler home. Eliza was no stranger to the dictates of socializing with the many well known people of the day. Her father was a General and her parents were much involved in Eliza's life as well as that of her siblings. Hamilton was an up and coming aide to George Washington. Alexander was brave, charismatic, handsome, and brilliant. He captures her heart and he is very much in love with her. They carry that love and devotion for almost twenty five married years through all the sorrows and joys of our early American nation.
Eliza and Hamilton go on to having seven children, losing their eldest son to a duel shortly before Hamilton's ill fated duel with Aaron Burr. They move to many places but always maintain strong ties with her family especially her sister, Angelica.
Eliza was a product of her times. She was perfectly content in her marriage, and in her role as a mother, daughter, and wife. Her devotion to Alexander did not end with his untimely death. She kept his memory and his brilliant works, on behalf of our nation, alive and was active in his stead up until her death in her early nineties.
Ms Scott has presented a wonderful portrait of Eliza. Through her writing we come to know the person Eliza was as well as see what made her continual devotion to Hamilton awe inspiring. Alexander was a complex man always striving to do what was right in his mind. Because of his outspokenness and his prodigious writing, Alexander was able to infuriate many within the new government. Those like Jefferson, Monroe, and Governor Clinton of New York, and of course Aaron Burr, hated Hamilton and did all within their power to bring about his downfall with rumor, innuendo, and scandal. However, Eliza with Hamilton beside her was able to rise above all and continue to be wholly in love with Hamilton. Theirs seemed to be a true love story and with Hamilton's death, Eliza crumbled. She was utterly devastated and for a time let that despair overtake her. However, Eliza was a strong woman and her strength came from the love she always had forever with Hamilton and the love she had for their children. This was a wonderful look into the life of a woman who survived the early days of our county's founding with determination, courage, and most of all a love for her husband that nothing would change.
Eliza and Hamilton go on to having seven children, losing their eldest son to a duel shortly before Hamilton's ill fated duel with Aaron Burr. They move to many places but always maintain strong ties with her family especially her sister, Angelica.
Eliza was a product of her times. She was perfectly content in her marriage, and in her role as a mother, daughter, and wife. Her devotion to Alexander did not end with his untimely death. She kept his memory and his brilliant works, on behalf of our nation, alive and was active in his stead up until her death in her early nineties.
Ms Scott has presented a wonderful portrait of Eliza. Through her writing we come to know the person Eliza was as well as see what made her continual devotion to Hamilton awe inspiring. Alexander was a complex man always striving to do what was right in his mind. Because of his outspokenness and his prodigious writing, Alexander was able to infuriate many within the new government. Those like Jefferson, Monroe, and Governor Clinton of New York, and of course Aaron Burr, hated Hamilton and did all within their power to bring about his downfall with rumor, innuendo, and scandal. However, Eliza with Hamilton beside her was able to rise above all and continue to be wholly in love with Hamilton. Theirs seemed to be a true love story and with Hamilton's death, Eliza crumbled. She was utterly devastated and for a time let that despair overtake her. However, Eliza was a strong woman and her strength came from the love she always had forever with Hamilton and the love she had for their children. This was a wonderful look into the life of a woman who survived the early days of our county's founding with determination, courage, and most of all a love for her husband that nothing would change.
July 13, 2017
Eliza first encounters the charismatic Alexander Hamilton in the home of her parents, who are fighting for the liberty of the country. In the midst of the American Revolution, she chooses to marry her love and from then on, her love is tested again and again.
From the start, Eliza leaps off the page as a woman of her times. She is proud to support her husband and raise her children, because that was what she was raised to do. She was an excellent hostess, and knew what it was to be a soldier's daughter and a soldier's wife. The author does a phenomenal job in showing what her life was like, with her being concerned about making ends meet and keeping her family well and together. Eliza is not portrayed as perfect, she makes mistakes just as anyone else does.
The pace of the book is just as it should be, not too fast nor slow enough to bore a reader. The attention to detail, without dumping the reader with too much information at one time, is perfect. I learned a great deal about the time period that I didn't know before, which I always appreciate when I pick up a book based on a historical figure.
For readers of historical fiction, this a must read.
I received an ARC from Net Galley for reviewing purposes.
From the start, Eliza leaps off the page as a woman of her times. She is proud to support her husband and raise her children, because that was what she was raised to do. She was an excellent hostess, and knew what it was to be a soldier's daughter and a soldier's wife. The author does a phenomenal job in showing what her life was like, with her being concerned about making ends meet and keeping her family well and together. Eliza is not portrayed as perfect, she makes mistakes just as anyone else does.
The pace of the book is just as it should be, not too fast nor slow enough to bore a reader. The attention to detail, without dumping the reader with too much information at one time, is perfect. I learned a great deal about the time period that I didn't know before, which I always appreciate when I pick up a book based on a historical figure.
For readers of historical fiction, this a must read.
I received an ARC from Net Galley for reviewing purposes.
August 13, 2017
Some books are like spending time with old friends. You feel an immediate connection, the time flies by, you feel better for the time you got to spend together, and you're a bit bereft when it's over. I, ELIZA HAMILTON qualifies on all counts.
One thing I love about reading Susan Holloway Scott's historical fiction is that she's a true history fan — she researches the heck out of her work, and it shows. When you know you're in good hands like hers, you can relax and enjoy, without worrying that some jarring anachronism is coming along to pull you out of the story. So you're on extraordinarily solid footing here, which is such a relief. And such a delight! The historical details are exquisite, really. I love the attention that gets paid to the interiors of houses, and the particulars of dress. Scott really knows how to make it all come so alive.
But that's just the foundation. Build on top of that a great story (we already know it's a great story, and here it's told particularly well), told from an often-forgotten character's point of view, peopled with a whole cast of characters you'll know from other tales. I *loved* how Eliza's POV gave us a totally different lens to watch the astonishing events of her day through, and loved watching how she grew and changed as a person over time, while remaining true to who she was and how her society, class, family, and experiences shaped her.
Look, we all know how this story ends. But it's how we *get* there that's so fascinating. And Eliza takes you deep into her world to give her side of the tale. I thoroughly enjoyed the time I spent in her company. Thoroughly enjoyed the time I spent with her whole extended circle, in fact. I suspect I'll be reading this one again, just to hang out with the gang for a few days again.
One thing I love about reading Susan Holloway Scott's historical fiction is that she's a true history fan — she researches the heck out of her work, and it shows. When you know you're in good hands like hers, you can relax and enjoy, without worrying that some jarring anachronism is coming along to pull you out of the story. So you're on extraordinarily solid footing here, which is such a relief. And such a delight! The historical details are exquisite, really. I love the attention that gets paid to the interiors of houses, and the particulars of dress. Scott really knows how to make it all come so alive.
But that's just the foundation. Build on top of that a great story (we already know it's a great story, and here it's told particularly well), told from an often-forgotten character's point of view, peopled with a whole cast of characters you'll know from other tales. I *loved* how Eliza's POV gave us a totally different lens to watch the astonishing events of her day through, and loved watching how she grew and changed as a person over time, while remaining true to who she was and how her society, class, family, and experiences shaped her.
Look, we all know how this story ends. But it's how we *get* there that's so fascinating. And Eliza takes you deep into her world to give her side of the tale. I thoroughly enjoyed the time I spent in her company. Thoroughly enjoyed the time I spent with her whole extended circle, in fact. I suspect I'll be reading this one again, just to hang out with the gang for a few days again.
April 27, 2017
Thanks Edelweiss for this ARC.
Eliza's love, faith, and genuineness shines thru this novel. She's unforgettable as a narrator, and you'll think of the birth of the country differentially forever.
Eliza's love, faith, and genuineness shines thru this novel. She's unforgettable as a narrator, and you'll think of the birth of the country differentially forever.
August 11, 2017
I, Eliza Hamilton is an in-depth look into the romance and marriage of Eliza and Alexander Hamilton. Historical fiction at its finest, personalizing the people, the events, at the birth of our nation. The details and the language are representative of colonial America, told with passion and revealing the layers of the Hamilton's relationship. This book should appeal to all readers of historical fiction, especially those with an interest in American history. The time frame of the book serves as an interesting background in this beautifully written story. I received a copy of this book from the author, and I'm reviewing this novel on behalf of "A Novel Bee." All opinions are my own.
August 10, 2017
After the unparalleled success of the smash hit musical “Hamilton”, the renewed interest in this founding father has inspired several other works of fiction, this novel being one of them. With the now better studied Founding Father having been particularly vocal in his lifetime, even on very intimate details of his private life when circumstances forced him, the most interesting feature of this book is to try to give voice to the woman who shared more than half his life and was responsible for the preservation of his writings and legacy, but left very little of herself known.
Let me first praise Susan Holloway Scott for the extended research that she has put into this book, the general historical accuracy she has consistantly pursued throughout the novel and the respect she has shown to the historical figures portrayed in her novel: Eliza Hamilton’s and her husband’s lives were remarkable and documented enough without adding unnecessary flights of fantasy. The author’s poetic licences, like the suggestion that the Reynolds’ affair had been orchestrated by Hamilton’s political enemies from the start rather than being the all too lucky endeavour of a couple of swindlers with unexpectedly far-reaching repercussions, can be forgiven.
The prologue shows Eliza shortly after her husband’s funeral thinking back of her Alexander and the story unfolds as a long flashback narrated in first person, with some exchanges of their youth seen with hindsight as an omen of Hamilton’s flaws and future tragedies looming in the distance. The novel is extensive in terms of length and strives to depict the whole quarter of a century that Eliza and Alexander shared together, with a good share of love and happiness to balance out the most grievous moments in their life. Eliza’s presence and voice is a constant balm of steady affection and sense in the life of her more restless and ambitious husband, who nonetheless at some point did step back from a public office he cared about out of love for her after the loss of their unborn child in late November 1794. This gesture, among others, more than words proves Eliza’s love and devotion for her Alexander was requited and deserved despite the undoubtedly despicable blemish of Hamilton’s one-year affair to briefly marr their almost 25 years marriage.
I enjoyed this novel enormously and literally could not put it down, but I can understand it may not be everybody’s cup of tea. First person narration is not to everybody’s taste even if this is less felt in the first half of the novel where a more detailed account of the first one and a half year of the Hamiltons’ courtship and marriage is delivered through several fictional episodes and a lot of dialogues. However, it makes for an almost one sided diary-like report in the second half where the author’s attempt to encompass almost 23 years of hectic political life, growing family and personal turmoil and tragedies is squeezed in the same amount of pages as their first encounter and first months of marriage. The non Hamilton or historical fiction fan might not feel at complete ease with this uneven approach even if the writing style is always pleasant and smooth, but even I felt somewaht frustrated at how e.g. the Reynolds Pamphlet aftermath was dismissed in a few pages with a very speedy forgiveness on Eliza’s part – these are the moments when the historical fiction writers should express themselves in filling the gaps between the known parts and depict in more detail the psychological devastation and following very probably slow reconciliation process that such episode must have brought for Eliza but also for Hamilton.
All in all, this novel is a very good work deserving a 4.2 stars that I rounded up to 5/5 because of Ms Scott’s sense, delicacy and respect in tackling the life of two real, albeit deceased, human beings and delivering a generally accurate historical fiction, a feature that seems to be rare considering other works, even on the same subject, that I have read, both fiction and alas so called non-fiction… How can I conclude if not with Congratulations!
Let me first praise Susan Holloway Scott for the extended research that she has put into this book, the general historical accuracy she has consistantly pursued throughout the novel and the respect she has shown to the historical figures portrayed in her novel: Eliza Hamilton’s and her husband’s lives were remarkable and documented enough without adding unnecessary flights of fantasy. The author’s poetic licences, like the suggestion that the Reynolds’ affair had been orchestrated by Hamilton’s political enemies from the start rather than being the all too lucky endeavour of a couple of swindlers with unexpectedly far-reaching repercussions, can be forgiven.
The prologue shows Eliza shortly after her husband’s funeral thinking back of her Alexander and the story unfolds as a long flashback narrated in first person, with some exchanges of their youth seen with hindsight as an omen of Hamilton’s flaws and future tragedies looming in the distance. The novel is extensive in terms of length and strives to depict the whole quarter of a century that Eliza and Alexander shared together, with a good share of love and happiness to balance out the most grievous moments in their life. Eliza’s presence and voice is a constant balm of steady affection and sense in the life of her more restless and ambitious husband, who nonetheless at some point did step back from a public office he cared about out of love for her after the loss of their unborn child in late November 1794. This gesture, among others, more than words proves Eliza’s love and devotion for her Alexander was requited and deserved despite the undoubtedly despicable blemish of Hamilton’s one-year affair to briefly marr their almost 25 years marriage.
I enjoyed this novel enormously and literally could not put it down, but I can understand it may not be everybody’s cup of tea. First person narration is not to everybody’s taste even if this is less felt in the first half of the novel where a more detailed account of the first one and a half year of the Hamiltons’ courtship and marriage is delivered through several fictional episodes and a lot of dialogues. However, it makes for an almost one sided diary-like report in the second half where the author’s attempt to encompass almost 23 years of hectic political life, growing family and personal turmoil and tragedies is squeezed in the same amount of pages as their first encounter and first months of marriage. The non Hamilton or historical fiction fan might not feel at complete ease with this uneven approach even if the writing style is always pleasant and smooth, but even I felt somewaht frustrated at how e.g. the Reynolds Pamphlet aftermath was dismissed in a few pages with a very speedy forgiveness on Eliza’s part – these are the moments when the historical fiction writers should express themselves in filling the gaps between the known parts and depict in more detail the psychological devastation and following very probably slow reconciliation process that such episode must have brought for Eliza but also for Hamilton.
All in all, this novel is a very good work deserving a 4.2 stars that I rounded up to 5/5 because of Ms Scott’s sense, delicacy and respect in tackling the life of two real, albeit deceased, human beings and delivering a generally accurate historical fiction, a feature that seems to be rare considering other works, even on the same subject, that I have read, both fiction and alas so called non-fiction… How can I conclude if not with Congratulations!
June 24, 2017
Because I work for a bookseller, I don't like to leave public reviews like this (every book we sell is supposed to be great), but of all the galleys I picked up at BookExpo last month, this one has been my absolute favorite. Sure, I wanted to like it because it's HAMILTON, duh, but it's so much better than a bandwagon-book. It's insanely, insanely good. Elizabeth Hamilton here is a real-life woman. She's definitely a woman of her times in her beliefs and actions. She's proud and happy being a supportive wife and devoted mother, because that's what she was raised to do, and she's good at it. She loves her brilliant, handsome husband dearly, sometimes even desperately, but the author makes Elizabeth's devotion understandable. It isn't sappy. These two really were soul-mates.You see every one of Alexander Hamilton's flaws (and he has plenty, including the biggie that I won't mention here in case it's still a spoiler to some people) and yet it's easy to see why Elizabeth cares so much for him even. Unlike some of the other Hamilton-inspired novels out there, Elizabeth's life here during the revolution and afterwards seems sweat-and-dirt real, with kids spitting up on fancy clothes and her having to scrimp to make ends meet when her husband spends beyond their means. The author doesn't info-dump, but I did learn things I never knew about the past, like colonial birth control (there wasn't any) and George Washington's major temper-tantrums. You know how it's going to end, but it still made me cry. Seriously recommended!
***Thanks to Kensington Books for the early galley***
***Thanks to Kensington Books for the early galley***
August 26, 2017
The story of Elizas life with Alexandra Hamilton from her side of the events, as it only covers her life whilst she shared it with him. SO this leaves a lot of Elizas story untold and hopefully a future part 2 to follow. This is a fascinating take of her life and the unseen life of one of the Founding Fathers of America and the relationship of the Washingtons with the Hamiltons and other relationships that played out in the birth of America. The personal things from Elizas view shows the heartache and dedication that effected her husband's decisions and the compassion for his wife and children and the hard fought battles and passion he had for his nation. This is a great read and we'll worth while for anyone that wants to know more about the war and follow on from the war of independence, plus the incredible love story of the Hamiltons, the war fought by those holding the fort can be as compelling as that on the battlefield but without the glory.
There is no less passion wether you are Alexandra Hamilton, Eliza the bride to be or even the newly wedded bride there will be a story to tell and here is a novel to that fills in so many gaps not reached by many other history books.
I have been given a free copy of this book from NetGalley in return for a honest review.
There is no less passion wether you are Alexandra Hamilton, Eliza the bride to be or even the newly wedded bride there will be a story to tell and here is a novel to that fills in so many gaps not reached by many other history books.
I have been given a free copy of this book from NetGalley in return for a honest review.
August 28, 2017
What a wonderful read. You don't have to be a "Hamilton " fan to enjoy this book. This telling of Eliza Schuyler Hamilton's marriage to the charismatic Alexander Hamilton grabbed me from the first sentence to the last. But this is so much more than a love story. The story of the early years of the American republic is also here with both its triumphs and flaws, and I enjoyed seeing a different and more human side to people like George Washington. But it is Eliza herself who steals the spotlight from her famous husband and comes to life here as a strong and admirable real woman. A special book I won't soon forget.
Thank you to the publisher for letting me read this early in exchange for a fair review.
Thank you to the publisher for letting me read this early in exchange for a fair review.
August 23, 2017
I absolutely loved this book! It felt so real that it was like I was sitting with Eliza (or Betsey, as Alexander called her) herself and listening to her tell me the story of her life and of her love for Alexander Hamilton and their children. There was so much detail about the times and history but it was all woven together into the story and never boring. Even though I thought I already knew what would happen, there was still things that surprised me and made me keep reading to find out how Eliza would react or handle things. She was a great character! I was sorry to see this book end, and I know I'll go back and read my favorite parts again.
March 12, 2019
"If it weren't for your Hamilton [and my John], we wouldn't have known the pride, the pleasure, the endless satisfaction and frustrations large and small of sharing our lives with extraordinary men."
4.5 stars
Eliza Schuyler is used to being around dignitaries and high ranking officials. Her father, General Philip Schuyler, often hosts them at their home in Albany and there is where she meets the eloquent aide de camp to George Washington, Colonel Alexander Hamilton. Something about the young colonel catches her atention and when she meets him again in Morristown a few years later, he also captures her heart. As war plagues the nation and a new country is being formed Eliza and Hamilton venture on an iconic love story.
I am not unfamiliar with Eliza Schuyler and Alexander Hamilton. Last year I read 'My Dear Hamilton' by Stephanie Dray (which I greatly enjoyed) and one of my concerns was that I would be comparing that book to this one and that it would not measure up. While I did compare them initially, this book that have its own voice and it absolutely meets the mark. Eliza Schuyler is a remarkable woman. So much has been said about Hamilton (Lin Manuel Miranda's musical has got to be one of the best retellings) but not enough about Eliza. Hamilton was not an easy man to keep up with but Eliza did. She ran her household and was a partner to Hamilton in all matters (which I absolutely love). She had just as an indomitable spirit and strong will as her husband. Given all the (personal and professional) triumphs and tribulations she faced with Hamilton, she needed to be a pillar for her children and husband. The tone of the book is one of love and pride. The majority of the information was mostly known to me but the delivery was on point. This is a great historical retelling but its also the narrative of one amazing woman.
Eliza Schuyler not only advised Hamilton on professional matters but had great acomplisments of her own. Aside from being a devoted mother, wife, daughter and sister she was Hamilton's greatest defender. She fought to preserve his legacy. After his death, she became involved with orphaned children. She, along with other women, founded the New York Orphan Asylum Society. She held important roles for the organization for over twenty years and championed the cause like no other (in large part because of her husband's childhood). The charity still exists today under the name of Graham Windham. Eliza outlived her husband and most of her family. She was 97 years old. Even into her nineties, though she still worked tirelessly for her husband and her orphans. Now, ths is what I call an exceptional woman.
4.5 stars
Eliza Schuyler is used to being around dignitaries and high ranking officials. Her father, General Philip Schuyler, often hosts them at their home in Albany and there is where she meets the eloquent aide de camp to George Washington, Colonel Alexander Hamilton. Something about the young colonel catches her atention and when she meets him again in Morristown a few years later, he also captures her heart. As war plagues the nation and a new country is being formed Eliza and Hamilton venture on an iconic love story.
I am not unfamiliar with Eliza Schuyler and Alexander Hamilton. Last year I read 'My Dear Hamilton' by Stephanie Dray (which I greatly enjoyed) and one of my concerns was that I would be comparing that book to this one and that it would not measure up. While I did compare them initially, this book that have its own voice and it absolutely meets the mark. Eliza Schuyler is a remarkable woman. So much has been said about Hamilton (Lin Manuel Miranda's musical has got to be one of the best retellings) but not enough about Eliza. Hamilton was not an easy man to keep up with but Eliza did. She ran her household and was a partner to Hamilton in all matters (which I absolutely love). She had just as an indomitable spirit and strong will as her husband. Given all the (personal and professional) triumphs and tribulations she faced with Hamilton, she needed to be a pillar for her children and husband. The tone of the book is one of love and pride. The majority of the information was mostly known to me but the delivery was on point. This is a great historical retelling but its also the narrative of one amazing woman.
Eliza Schuyler not only advised Hamilton on professional matters but had great acomplisments of her own. Aside from being a devoted mother, wife, daughter and sister she was Hamilton's greatest defender. She fought to preserve his legacy. After his death, she became involved with orphaned children. She, along with other women, founded the New York Orphan Asylum Society. She held important roles for the organization for over twenty years and championed the cause like no other (in large part because of her husband's childhood). The charity still exists today under the name of Graham Windham. Eliza outlived her husband and most of her family. She was 97 years old. Even into her nineties, though she still worked tirelessly for her husband and her orphans. Now, ths is what I call an exceptional woman.
September 19, 2017
Required reading for Hamilton fans, and highly recommended for all historical fiction fans and history buffs in general!
Thanks to Kensington Books for this review copy - all opinions are my own.
Let's start out with the fact that I am a major Hamilton geek. My kids and I have the complete soundtrack to the musical memorized, and we have spent hours and hours discussing the musical itself, as well as the Revolution book and numerous other titles about Hamilton's life. When I reviewed a young adult title last winter about Alex and Eliza I actually had Chernow's biography of Hamilton open next to me to fact-check that title (and it didn't match up, by the way). All of this means that my review is either incredibly biased, OR it just means that I have a lot of background knowledge to use in my review - you choose.
Scott manages to include incredibly detailed historical narrative along with her telling of Eliza's story, beginning with the events where Eliza and Alexander meet. The romance and relationship are compelling enough on their own, but this book also serves as a primer on much of the Revolutionary War, sure to satisfy even the most stickler of history buffs. At over 400 pages, this novel is NOT a light romance story despite what the cover may convey - it is a political tome that absolutely fascinated me, especially the medical details (I'm a medical history fan - give me a book about Bellevue Hospital and I'm in heaven). Fans of Hamilton the musical will be compelled to have the soundtrack playing at all times during the reading of this book, and will then be forced to compare the differences between these two accounts of events - for readers like me, that's a dream job!
Scott wowed me with this book - she chatted with me numerous times on Instagram about Eliza while I was reading it and I can not say enough about her devotion to historical detail and this story - she is amazing! We chatted about how this book is not at all inspired by the musical and is in no way fan fiction, but the musical has definitely helped bring attention to this title. Her website provides such wonderful details about her research and additional historical background on the events and places in the book - it's a treasure trove for history-lovers and gives such a rich extended reading experience. I highly recommending checking out her blog along with this title.
If you love US history and can't get enough of Hamilton in your life, I can't recommend this book highly enough. If you are expecting a frothy romance, however, this will surely surprise you with its academic nature.
Thanks to Kensington Books for this review copy - all opinions are my own.
Let's start out with the fact that I am a major Hamilton geek. My kids and I have the complete soundtrack to the musical memorized, and we have spent hours and hours discussing the musical itself, as well as the Revolution book and numerous other titles about Hamilton's life. When I reviewed a young adult title last winter about Alex and Eliza I actually had Chernow's biography of Hamilton open next to me to fact-check that title (and it didn't match up, by the way). All of this means that my review is either incredibly biased, OR it just means that I have a lot of background knowledge to use in my review - you choose.
Scott manages to include incredibly detailed historical narrative along with her telling of Eliza's story, beginning with the events where Eliza and Alexander meet. The romance and relationship are compelling enough on their own, but this book also serves as a primer on much of the Revolutionary War, sure to satisfy even the most stickler of history buffs. At over 400 pages, this novel is NOT a light romance story despite what the cover may convey - it is a political tome that absolutely fascinated me, especially the medical details (I'm a medical history fan - give me a book about Bellevue Hospital and I'm in heaven). Fans of Hamilton the musical will be compelled to have the soundtrack playing at all times during the reading of this book, and will then be forced to compare the differences between these two accounts of events - for readers like me, that's a dream job!
Scott wowed me with this book - she chatted with me numerous times on Instagram about Eliza while I was reading it and I can not say enough about her devotion to historical detail and this story - she is amazing! We chatted about how this book is not at all inspired by the musical and is in no way fan fiction, but the musical has definitely helped bring attention to this title. Her website provides such wonderful details about her research and additional historical background on the events and places in the book - it's a treasure trove for history-lovers and gives such a rich extended reading experience. I highly recommending checking out her blog along with this title.
If you love US history and can't get enough of Hamilton in your life, I can't recommend this book highly enough. If you are expecting a frothy romance, however, this will surely surprise you with its academic nature.
September 27, 2017
Thank you so much to Kensington for providing me with an advance copy - all opinions are my own.
You can certainly tell that this is a passion project for Scott. Every last detail and amount care put into this historical fiction novel is IMPRESSIVE. I enjoyed reading about Eliza and Alexander's courtship and the deep love they had for one another. I especially loved learning about a tremendous historical figure through the eyes of the woman he loved.
The first half of the book reads more like a historical romance and the second focuses more on Alexander Hamilton's career and accomplishments. The novel shows the amazing loyalty and devotion Eliza had for her husband.
My only criticism is that I would have liked to see the book continue past Alexander's death, not just in the epilogue and afterword. I feel like it focused on only their relationship and not Eliza as an independent figure. But that being said, I thought it was a well written, BEAUTIFUL novel that is a love letter to this AMAZING historical couple!
For my full review, check out my blog: shereadswithcats.com
Also, check out the author interview with Kate at theloudlibrarylady.com
You can certainly tell that this is a passion project for Scott. Every last detail and amount care put into this historical fiction novel is IMPRESSIVE. I enjoyed reading about Eliza and Alexander's courtship and the deep love they had for one another. I especially loved learning about a tremendous historical figure through the eyes of the woman he loved.
The first half of the book reads more like a historical romance and the second focuses more on Alexander Hamilton's career and accomplishments. The novel shows the amazing loyalty and devotion Eliza had for her husband.
My only criticism is that I would have liked to see the book continue past Alexander's death, not just in the epilogue and afterword. I feel like it focused on only their relationship and not Eliza as an independent figure. But that being said, I thought it was a well written, BEAUTIFUL novel that is a love letter to this AMAZING historical couple!
For my full review, check out my blog: shereadswithcats.com
Also, check out the author interview with Kate at theloudlibrarylady.com
July 27, 2017
I am a huge fan of historical fiction and absolutely loved 'I.Eliza Hamilton'. From the beginning pages Susan Holloway Scott has you interested in the wife of Revolutionary War Hero Alexander Hamilton. This book is written from a wife's perspective. It allows you to walk with Mrs Hamilton and see through her eyes. The book describes in detail the beginning of their life together as a couple and continues through their 25 year marriage. It gives an interesting point of view regarding Alexander Hamilton. While this book is set during the Revolutionary War and after, the book doesn't focus on the war. It's main focus is the Hamilton Family. 'I, Eliza Hamilton' was well written and an absolutely absorbing read.
August 26, 2017
What a great read! Many are familiar with Alexander Hamilton, but less well known is his wife, Elizabeth. Scott tells the story of one of American's founding fathers through the eyes of someone who knew him intimately as they lived through the Revolution to the struggle to shape America into the country we know today.
Far too many of us have a quaint picture of the founding fathers shaking hands and like magic the colonies are transformed into the United States. Scott shows the reality as well as what life was like. Elizabeth came alive in the pages of this book, and I felt that I knew her.
I enjoyed this book.
Far too many of us have a quaint picture of the founding fathers shaking hands and like magic the colonies are transformed into the United States. Scott shows the reality as well as what life was like. Elizabeth came alive in the pages of this book, and I felt that I knew her.
I enjoyed this book.
September 1, 2017
"Love is not easy with a man chosen by Fate for greatness. My Alexander was such a one, a man so bold and brilliant that all others dulled in his company, just as the brightest comet that shoots across the night sky will make the other stars fade meekly in its trail."
Not going to lie, I squealed a little bit when I received an advanced copy from Kensington Press.
Why you should read this book:
-It is diligently researched
-It is 400 pages packed with story
-Eliza Hamilton kicks butt
-The writing is beautiful without being purple
-My list tells you that you should
I'm excited to pick up more of Scott's historical fiction in the future.
Not going to lie, I squealed a little bit when I received an advanced copy from Kensington Press.
Why you should read this book:
-It is diligently researched
-It is 400 pages packed with story
-Eliza Hamilton kicks butt
-The writing is beautiful without being purple
-My list tells you that you should
I'm excited to pick up more of Scott's historical fiction in the future.
July 14, 2017
This was one galley I'd planned to get, and I'm lucky I did since the publisher ran out. Like half the world I'm a huge fan of the Hamilton Musical, and I was curious to see if the author (who is new to me) could pull off a whole hist-fic novel that wasn't one more retread of the show. Did she ever! I saw the show in Chicago and so I knew the story, but somehow this book made it all new and fresh, and although it's a long read, I couldn't read it fast enough. Alexander and his Betsey (what he calls Eliza) are even more real here than in the show, remarkable people with great strength but also great flaws and love and heartache. There are so many details and history that the show glossed over that I loved being able to learn more. I respected that the author didn't try to make Eliza into a modern woman out to change the world (sorry, Angelica!) but made her a traditional colonial woman whose life is centered around her husband and children. But Eliza is the glue that holds everything together, and seeing her juggle her huge family, their rocky finances, and Alexander himself, who probably took a whole lot of juggling to keep happy, makes for a great story. Highly recommended.
I received this book as a giveaway from the publisher at BEA 2017 in NYC.
I received this book as a giveaway from the publisher at BEA 2017 in NYC.
August 16, 2017
What a wonderful book - perfectly brings this quietly remarkable woman to life. Filled with fly-on-the wall historical details that never overwhelm the characters or the story, all the way to the inevitable tragic conclusion. Many historical novels can be dry, but this one is filled with emotion. Eliza Hamilton survived and thrived another fifty years after Hamilton's death (my only wish was that the author had written about Eliza's numerous achievements later in life, but maybe she's planning a sequel), but I'm not sure he could have gone on without her. My only wish was that the author had written about Eliza's numerous achievements later in life, but maybe that means there's a sequel in the works. Easily the best book I've read this summer.
October 9, 2017
DNF 42%. This book was not about Eliza. It was a book about Alexander told by Eliza. I didn’t want to read a book about A.Ham (I’ve already read the 900+ page bio.) It was wordy, it did a lot of telling, and it did not represent the strong woman Eliza actually was with and without Alexander. I am disappointed that it did not live up to expectations.
I received this book from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
I received this book from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
December 5, 2022
Thank you edelweiss.com for letting me read a netgalley. Very well done. Historical Fiction at its finest. Loved Eliza, she was strong and independent, but also head over heels for Alexander. I think Susan did a great job at staying true to history while writing a beautiful love story of her own. Definitely a must read for romance and history lovers.
September 2, 2020
The book is beautifully written, but the pace is very slow. This drawn-out style of writing is not the style of writing I like to read. Therefore, I’m not the right reviewer for this book. There are others who appreciate this style of writing and they will reveal veracious reviews.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 990 reviews