What do you think?
Rate this book
The Whys Have It
"His music holds the heart of America...but his soul holds a terrible secret."
Chart topping pop musician Cory Minor has it all—fame, money, more women at his disposal than time to spend on them. He’s living the life most American men only dream of. Until an ordinary concert in Springfield threatens to destroy everything he’s worked for.
As he and his band leave the arena for his next show, Cory’s tour bus crashes into two teenage girls, killing one girl instantly and leaving the other barely clinging to life. Lawsuits are threatened, tabloids are talking, and Cory’s idyllic world falls apart. But what no one knows is that this scene is all too familiar. Because this isn’t the first accident Cory has caused. This isn’t the first time he’s destroyed someone else’s life to save his own.
It’s just the first time he’s had to face it head on.
Small town girl Samantha Dalton has no one—no mother, no father, and now no sister. She’s lost everything in a world that celebrates excess. So when Cory Minor shows up at her doorstep offering money and apologies, she turns him away too. You can’t lose what you don’t have, and she can’t take another letdown, especially not from someone who has managed to rip away all she had left. Samantha has been fine on her own for years, she’ll be fine now too.
At least that’s what she tells herself.
But Cory won’t leave. He’s persistent in the worst possible way.
Will Cory’s determination to make things right pay off in the end, or will Sam keep pushing him away until there’s nothing left to fight for? How can two people learn to rely on each other when life keeps hurting them both?
Chart topping pop musician Cory Minor has it all—fame, money, more women at his disposal than time to spend on them. He’s living the life most American men only dream of. Until an ordinary concert in Springfield threatens to destroy everything he’s worked for.
As he and his band leave the arena for his next show, Cory’s tour bus crashes into two teenage girls, killing one girl instantly and leaving the other barely clinging to life. Lawsuits are threatened, tabloids are talking, and Cory’s idyllic world falls apart. But what no one knows is that this scene is all too familiar. Because this isn’t the first accident Cory has caused. This isn’t the first time he’s destroyed someone else’s life to save his own.
It’s just the first time he’s had to face it head on.
Small town girl Samantha Dalton has no one—no mother, no father, and now no sister. She’s lost everything in a world that celebrates excess. So when Cory Minor shows up at her doorstep offering money and apologies, she turns him away too. You can’t lose what you don’t have, and she can’t take another letdown, especially not from someone who has managed to rip away all she had left. Samantha has been fine on her own for years, she’ll be fine now too.
At least that’s what she tells herself.
But Cory won’t leave. He’s persistent in the worst possible way.
Will Cory’s determination to make things right pay off in the end, or will Sam keep pushing him away until there’s nothing left to fight for? How can two people learn to rely on each other when life keeps hurting them both?
328 pages, Paperback
First published June 1, 2017
84 people are currently reading
527 people want to read
About the author
Amy Matayo
26 books487 followersAmy Matayo is an award winning author of The Wedding Game, Love Gone Wild, Sway, In Tune With Love, A Painted Summer, and The End of the World. She graduated with barely passing grades from John Brown University with a degree in Journalism. But don't feel sorry for her--she's super proud of that degree and all the ways she hasn't put it to good use.
She laughs often, cries easily, feels deeply, and loves hard. She lives in Arkansas with her husband and four kids and is working on her next novel.
www.amymatayo
Twitter: @amymatayo
Instagram: @amymatayo.author
Facebook: www.facebook.com/amymatayo
She laughs often, cries easily, feels deeply, and loves hard. She lives in Arkansas with her husband and four kids and is working on her next novel.
www.amymatayo
Twitter: @amymatayo
Instagram: @amymatayo.author
Facebook: www.facebook.com/amymatayo
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 90 reviews
June 12, 2017
I know I'm weird, haha. I don't cry easily, especially in books, but this story ripped my heart out and stomped on it, before gradually restoring it. My emotions were all over the place....and I loved every single minute of this hauntingly beautiful book.
There's something about a music star befriending a small town girl, but that's just what happens and in a most unconventional way. The story is told from two points of view--Cory's and Sam's--and it's done in a way that isn't confusing at all. In fact, I felt a very deep connection to both characters by digging deep into their issues, their lives, their feelings, and their reasons why.
This author has a fantastic way of writing--an absolutely phenomenal skill using words to spin a web around a reader's heart and soul that isn't easy to break away from...not that I really wanted to. The words are practically poetry that speaks on deep levels and I just couldn't stop reading.
It seems that summertime is the perfect time for a heart wrenching novel and I daresay, this is the novel of Summer 2017. Break out that box of tissues and buckle in for laughs, tears, love, and forgiveness.
Content: mild romance (some innuendo, implied hookups, vague abuse/rape); mild violence (death, abuse); mild language.
*I received a copy, which didn't influence my opinion in any way. All thoughts are my own.*
There's something about a music star befriending a small town girl, but that's just what happens and in a most unconventional way. The story is told from two points of view--Cory's and Sam's--and it's done in a way that isn't confusing at all. In fact, I felt a very deep connection to both characters by digging deep into their issues, their lives, their feelings, and their reasons why.
This author has a fantastic way of writing--an absolutely phenomenal skill using words to spin a web around a reader's heart and soul that isn't easy to break away from...not that I really wanted to. The words are practically poetry that speaks on deep levels and I just couldn't stop reading.
It seems that summertime is the perfect time for a heart wrenching novel and I daresay, this is the novel of Summer 2017. Break out that box of tissues and buckle in for laughs, tears, love, and forgiveness.
Content: mild romance (some innuendo, implied hookups, vague abuse/rape); mild violence (death, abuse); mild language.
*I received a copy, which didn't influence my opinion in any way. All thoughts are my own.*
July 9, 2017
There are heavy themes that this book focuses on, including death, grief, secrets, and depression. Despite the bleakness of the characters' circumstances, there is gratitude and hope that motivates them to reach out and continue on. I admired Sam's genuineness. She faces the hard things in her life and perseveres through the process of acceptance of loss. Cory's regrets are eating him up inside, and getting to know Sam is a catalyst for his memories to surface, forcing him to deal with feelings that he has been repressing for years. His struggles are shown through his first person perspective, and the internal dialogue is realistic and gritty. The contrast of his inner goodness and the selfish persona he has embraced is stark, and with Sam's influence, he sees the emptiness of his life without the peace that good choices bring. They have a great chemistry, with banter and teasing and attraction and friendship and support. I also loved Phyllis, the health care worker that takes Sam under her wing whenever she visits her father suffering from Alzheimer's. Her caring and support is given freely and without hesitation. I particularly appreciated this piece of wisdom she shares and I think it represents what the book is all about:
"You can ask why all day long if you want to. You can ask God why and your friends why and yourself why until you're buried in nothing but that single question, but you'll never get an answer. This side of heaven, time is the only thing that helps a little bit. So don't give in. Don't let the whys have it. Don't let them take advantage of you. They'll crush your heart and steal your peace and mess with your mind and wrap around you so tight you won't be able to breathe. Don't let the whys ruin your life, child. Every time they try to sneak up, push them aside and move forward. Trust me, it's the only way you can get on with living."
I turn toward the window and think about her words. "What if I can't? Let it go, I mean?"
I don't see her smile, but I can hear it. "You can. I know you can. Because no matter how hard life gets, there's always goodness right around the corner. All you have to do is look for it."
Even though it's not light reading, I'm glad that I read this book and contemplated the questions that Cory and Sam face as they seek to cope with the haunting and devastating things in their lives.
(I received a complimentary copy of the book; all opinions in this review are my own)
"You can ask why all day long if you want to. You can ask God why and your friends why and yourself why until you're buried in nothing but that single question, but you'll never get an answer. This side of heaven, time is the only thing that helps a little bit. So don't give in. Don't let the whys have it. Don't let them take advantage of you. They'll crush your heart and steal your peace and mess with your mind and wrap around you so tight you won't be able to breathe. Don't let the whys ruin your life, child. Every time they try to sneak up, push them aside and move forward. Trust me, it's the only way you can get on with living."
I turn toward the window and think about her words. "What if I can't? Let it go, I mean?"
I don't see her smile, but I can hear it. "You can. I know you can. Because no matter how hard life gets, there's always goodness right around the corner. All you have to do is look for it."
Even though it's not light reading, I'm glad that I read this book and contemplated the questions that Cory and Sam face as they seek to cope with the haunting and devastating things in their lives.
(I received a complimentary copy of the book; all opinions in this review are my own)
June 11, 2017
Have you ever asked the question “Why?” Why is life so hard? Why does bad things happen to me? WHY!?
This is what happens to Sam as her life goes through so many loses. This is what Cory is trying hard not to ask.
I deeply LOVED this book! It brought so many emotions out.
At first, I wanted to really dislike Cory because of the selfish life he was living, but then I started to feel sorry for him because I saw how lost he was. I also felt deep emotions for Sam because of all the rotten stuff happening to her, she never seemed to get a break.
Amy Matayo has written a heart tugging story of true love and friendship, of forgiveness and healing, and of learning to let go of the lies which eat away at us.
This book has moments where you might want to scream at the characters and then cry because they are going through such tough stuff. It’s a book you won’t want to put down until you finish. It is a gripping story which will leave you hopeful of redemption, mercy, and grace.
I highly recommend getting this book!
I was given this book by the author for an honest review, all opinions are my own.
This is what happens to Sam as her life goes through so many loses. This is what Cory is trying hard not to ask.
I deeply LOVED this book! It brought so many emotions out.
At first, I wanted to really dislike Cory because of the selfish life he was living, but then I started to feel sorry for him because I saw how lost he was. I also felt deep emotions for Sam because of all the rotten stuff happening to her, she never seemed to get a break.
Amy Matayo has written a heart tugging story of true love and friendship, of forgiveness and healing, and of learning to let go of the lies which eat away at us.
This book has moments where you might want to scream at the characters and then cry because they are going through such tough stuff. It’s a book you won’t want to put down until you finish. It is a gripping story which will leave you hopeful of redemption, mercy, and grace.
I highly recommend getting this book!
I was given this book by the author for an honest review, all opinions are my own.
July 10, 2017
The Whys Have It is exquisitely heartwrenching and simultaneously layered with hope and subtle nudges of grace. It’s a picture of broken people living broken lives – and what it looks like when their brokenness intersects.
Amy Matayo seamlessly gets inside Samantha's & Cory's heads, and therefore so do we, the readers. As such, we are treated to their brokenness first hand and experience their reactions and unguarded thoughts. It makes for some uncomfortable paragraphs – the good kind of uncomfortable, the kind that stretches you out of your comfort zone. The kind of discomfort that eventually makes grace that much sweeter. (Some of Cory's unguarded thoughts may have you blushing and fanning lol)
Oh! And I can’t forget to mention Phyllis. I adore her! You will love her too, I just know it! She’s the type of character you wish could leap out of the page and into real life. Her hugs, her insight, the smile in her voice. Everyone needs a Phyllis.
Bottom Line: The Whys Have It by Amy Matayo is the kind of book that gets deep down in your heart and takes up residence. The smooth writing style instantly draws you in – and once the characters latch on, don’t expect to put this novel down until you’ve finished it. My Kindle copy has three pages worth of highlighted sentences that will linger with me for quite a while beyond this first read. It’s honest. It’s profound. It’s raw in places. And peeking through the melody of brokenness is a harmony of hope and restoration that will settle in your spirit like one of Phyllis’ hugs.
(I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book)
see my full review at Reading Is My SuperPower
Amy Matayo seamlessly gets inside Samantha's & Cory's heads, and therefore so do we, the readers. As such, we are treated to their brokenness first hand and experience their reactions and unguarded thoughts. It makes for some uncomfortable paragraphs – the good kind of uncomfortable, the kind that stretches you out of your comfort zone. The kind of discomfort that eventually makes grace that much sweeter. (Some of Cory's unguarded thoughts may have you blushing and fanning lol)
Oh! And I can’t forget to mention Phyllis. I adore her! You will love her too, I just know it! She’s the type of character you wish could leap out of the page and into real life. Her hugs, her insight, the smile in her voice. Everyone needs a Phyllis.
Bottom Line: The Whys Have It by Amy Matayo is the kind of book that gets deep down in your heart and takes up residence. The smooth writing style instantly draws you in – and once the characters latch on, don’t expect to put this novel down until you’ve finished it. My Kindle copy has three pages worth of highlighted sentences that will linger with me for quite a while beyond this first read. It’s honest. It’s profound. It’s raw in places. And peeking through the melody of brokenness is a harmony of hope and restoration that will settle in your spirit like one of Phyllis’ hugs.
(I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book)
see my full review at Reading Is My SuperPower
June 26, 2017
Wow.
The Whys Have It is an enthralling read. Matayo gives us a story of heartbreak, grief, and the transformative power of love that takes the reader on an emotional rollercoaster. Her two lead characters: Cory Minor and Samantha (just call me 'Sam') Dalton are complex and so true to life. I'm sure many women readers will fall in love with Cory and it didn't take me long to develop a book-crush for Sam. I'm in awe how Matayo is able to dive so deep so quickly with her characters.
Cory is a rockstar. Major, major rockstar, 5 Grammy-awards major. And he enjoys the fruits his success brings him. He enjoys the fine things but does exercise some restraint especially when it comes to women and drugs. He's a thinking-man's rockstar. He meets Sam through tragic circumstances which takes him back to his home town, one that is full of unpleasant memories and a secret that has haunted him for a decade.
He's drawn to Sam. Sam has a heart that's been refined by the fire of heartache and loss. It's given her perspective, courage and depth of character. But she's also fragile with a lovely playfulness that endears Corey to want more. Matayo captures the essence of those early courtship (I love this old-fashioned word) days, two seemingly mismatched individuals who want to know what makes the other tick. And yes, there is passion but Matayo writes this discretely and with tenderness.
And it's messy. But all good relationships are. Aren't they? And it only serves to make us want more of these two excellent characters.
The story is told in alternate first-person POV: Cory and then Sam's. I enjoy reading a romance this way. We get greater depth of insight into the 2 characters. The other cast members are relatively minor but Phyllis is a beauty and has a servant's heart and some fabulous Godly wisdom.
This is a powerful story of redemption, forgiveness (of others and self) and acceptance.
The Whys Have It is an enthralling read. Matayo gives us a story of heartbreak, grief, and the transformative power of love that takes the reader on an emotional rollercoaster. Her two lead characters: Cory Minor and Samantha (just call me 'Sam') Dalton are complex and so true to life. I'm sure many women readers will fall in love with Cory and it didn't take me long to develop a book-crush for Sam. I'm in awe how Matayo is able to dive so deep so quickly with her characters.
Cory is a rockstar. Major, major rockstar, 5 Grammy-awards major. And he enjoys the fruits his success brings him. He enjoys the fine things but does exercise some restraint especially when it comes to women and drugs. He's a thinking-man's rockstar. He meets Sam through tragic circumstances which takes him back to his home town, one that is full of unpleasant memories and a secret that has haunted him for a decade.
He's drawn to Sam. Sam has a heart that's been refined by the fire of heartache and loss. It's given her perspective, courage and depth of character. But she's also fragile with a lovely playfulness that endears Corey to want more. Matayo captures the essence of those early courtship (I love this old-fashioned word) days, two seemingly mismatched individuals who want to know what makes the other tick. And yes, there is passion but Matayo writes this discretely and with tenderness.
And it's messy. But all good relationships are. Aren't they? And it only serves to make us want more of these two excellent characters.
The story is told in alternate first-person POV: Cory and then Sam's. I enjoy reading a romance this way. We get greater depth of insight into the 2 characters. The other cast members are relatively minor but Phyllis is a beauty and has a servant's heart and some fabulous Godly wisdom.
This is a powerful story of redemption, forgiveness (of others and self) and acceptance.
September 6, 2017
I always know that a book by Amy will be one that is impossible to put down. This one was no exception. I received an advanced copy of the book but it in no way influenced my review. To say I loved the book is putting it mildly, I absolutely LOVE, LOVE, LOVED it. It is so thought provoking, so full of emotion, so very well written that I plan to read it again even though I just finished it. This isn't a "fluff" book. It is the kind of book that makes you think. You won't be disappointed when you read this book.
June 27, 2017
Loved it
Everyone that knows me or reads my book reviews can see my addiction to rock star books and while most consists of the bad boy hotter than hell panty melting misunderstood musicians, this book was bought based on all of the above but was so refreshingly different.
This book deals with loss. Sam Dalton is twenty five going on fifty, she is practically raising her seventeen year old sister Kassie after the death of their Mom and their Dad in the final stages of Alzheimer's. Upon her sister's graduating high school, Sam gifted Kassie two tickets to see her favorite
Artist Cory Minor. Sam changes her mind about going so Kassie and her best friend Meghan go instead.
Cory Minor loves his life, he's talented, rich and adored by millions but playing a concert so near his hometown is bringing back memories he left behind ten years ago when he vowed never to return. When Sam and Cory's world collide bringing two unlikely people together in grief each must get passed their pain if they have any chance of moving forward.
This book resonated with me as someone who had lost everyone in my life, and it doesn't matter the circumstances or the timing, loss is loss. A beautifully written book and although I would have liked a more in depth epilogue, I highly recommend this book.
Everyone that knows me or reads my book reviews can see my addiction to rock star books and while most consists of the bad boy hotter than hell panty melting misunderstood musicians, this book was bought based on all of the above but was so refreshingly different.
This book deals with loss. Sam Dalton is twenty five going on fifty, she is practically raising her seventeen year old sister Kassie after the death of their Mom and their Dad in the final stages of Alzheimer's. Upon her sister's graduating high school, Sam gifted Kassie two tickets to see her favorite
Artist Cory Minor. Sam changes her mind about going so Kassie and her best friend Meghan go instead.
Cory Minor loves his life, he's talented, rich and adored by millions but playing a concert so near his hometown is bringing back memories he left behind ten years ago when he vowed never to return. When Sam and Cory's world collide bringing two unlikely people together in grief each must get passed their pain if they have any chance of moving forward.
This book resonated with me as someone who had lost everyone in my life, and it doesn't matter the circumstances or the timing, loss is loss. A beautifully written book and although I would have liked a more in depth epilogue, I highly recommend this book.
July 26, 2017
Why did I wait to read this, I now ask myself, the answer is I have no idea, all I know is I did and so should you.
I was gripped by the prologue, well invested by chapter 2 and was utterly hooked every chapter thereafter.
There is nothing cliche about this book, Amy manages to bring her characters to life in a style that I'm in awe of, its real, it's raw, and it's heartbreakingly beautiful.
This book has all the feels, it will reel you in before you know it and there's isn't anything you can do to prevent it. It has the power to break your heart, mend your heart, make you laugh, make you cry, and still leave you wanting more.
I was gripped by the prologue, well invested by chapter 2 and was utterly hooked every chapter thereafter.
There is nothing cliche about this book, Amy manages to bring her characters to life in a style that I'm in awe of, its real, it's raw, and it's heartbreakingly beautiful.
This book has all the feels, it will reel you in before you know it and there's isn't anything you can do to prevent it. It has the power to break your heart, mend your heart, make you laugh, make you cry, and still leave you wanting more.
June 20, 2017
Once again, Amy Matayo sucked me in. This book had me from the beginning until the end. I could feel the connection between Cory and Sam and I was rooting for them the entire book. Sometimes the depressing parts of the book were hard to read through but it made you want to root for them all the more. I loved the way Kyle was there for his brother at the end. It is hard to put this book down and you will want to read it in all on sitting. Definitely a must read!
I was provided a copy of this book by the author. All opinions in this review are my own.
I was provided a copy of this book by the author. All opinions in this review are my own.
August 2, 2017
An incredible story which grips you from the first page and never releases you. I'm still thinking about it several hours after finishing and plan to read it again soon. The struggles and heartbreak that Cory and Sam suffer emotionally connect the reader to their story. I've rarely read a book which is so hard to read and yet completely unputdownable. Massive credit to Amy Matayo for an inspiring difficult read which allows you to go through a tumult of emotions with each character - and make you want to go back for more!
An excellent read but not if you like an easy uncomplicated romance. This is SO much better than that!
An excellent read but not if you like an easy uncomplicated romance. This is SO much better than that!
September 3, 2018
I have wanted to read The Whys Have It since I first heard about it. I love a good cover and title, both really grabbed my attention. The writing style is different than what I'm used to so it took me a while to settle in and enjoy. I'm not sure if enjoy is really the right word for me. While I think this story is good It just wasn't my "cup of tea". It was just a bit too heavy for me. I also did not connect with Sam. I can't really put my finger on why. I also felt like this might be too edgy for sensitive readers. There are a lot of sexual innuendos that just did not seem necessary in drawing out the plot.
June 27, 2017
Wow. This book takes you on an emotional roller coaster of a journey! There is so much heartbreak and sadness but it is carefully balanced with just enough hope that I didn't become too overwhelmed. This definitely isn't a light and easy book to read. Be prepared! I loved it but again, it was a bit heart wrenching.
Also a caution- this book is full of weighty topics. Alcohol, drugs, references to sexual relationships, death, mental illness.
I picked this one up on kindle unlimited.
Also a caution- this book is full of weighty topics. Alcohol, drugs, references to sexual relationships, death, mental illness.
I picked this one up on kindle unlimited.
June 13, 2017
Amy Matayo's writing is amazing, you immediately get sucked in by real characters with real problems. You can totally relate to how they are feeling and what they are going through. Cory is famous, and in this book, instead of focusing on how great it is (like most books would), Amy writes about how it is not as glamorous as it is cracked up to be. This book is more focused on the downside, which is how I would imagine fame to be.
Sam is the responsible mother/big sister type who has way more on her plate than anyone should...again you relate, because who's plate is not overflowing? They come together in the most unlikely way with so many truths and one-liners that you find yourself agreeing with, even if your circumstances look nothing like theirs.
While I may not be eloquent with my words, Amy is and The Whys Have It is a MUST read. I blocked out an entire afternoon where I was able to read most of it without interruptions. This is what you will want to do as well, because once you pick up this book you will not want to put it down. Thanks Amy, for another well-written, page-turning masterpiece! You are a rock star!
**I was given an early advance reader in return for my honest review of this book.**
Sam is the responsible mother/big sister type who has way more on her plate than anyone should...again you relate, because who's plate is not overflowing? They come together in the most unlikely way with so many truths and one-liners that you find yourself agreeing with, even if your circumstances look nothing like theirs.
While I may not be eloquent with my words, Amy is and The Whys Have It is a MUST read. I blocked out an entire afternoon where I was able to read most of it without interruptions. This is what you will want to do as well, because once you pick up this book you will not want to put it down. Thanks Amy, for another well-written, page-turning masterpiece! You are a rock star!
**I was given an early advance reader in return for my honest review of this book.**
June 21, 2017
Sam was an incredible young woman. Cory was so blessed with her in his life, that is for sure. It all borders on implausible but I've lived life long enough to see stuff like this happen. The author manages to write intimate moments without sex scenes that I really didn't miss. Looking back, I think we as readers had enough going on as did the characters that it just hadn't happened or was necessary to grow intense feelings (respect, empathy come to mind). Nice.
A great read.
A great read.
June 25, 2017
Once again Amy writes a story where the characters become like friends. You want them in your life and their heartaches become your heartaches and their joys are your joys.
I didn't want Cory and Sam's story to end- I want more.
I didn't want Cory and Sam's story to end- I want more.
June 20, 2017
I didn't just like it; I loved it.
It was equal parts infuriating, heartbreaking, touching and swoon-worthy.
I find that while Matayo's books are among my favorites to read (and re-read), writing a review for them is difficult because in the course of her ripping out my heart and then piecing it together one painstakingly S-L-O-W piece at a time... there are no words leftover in the end. Just feels. ALL the feels.
You'll feel grief and at times you might find yourself buried in the same despair the characters are facing. It's brutal!! But then... there's hope. There's always hope. (And a good first kiss helps, too... *wink*)
I honestly think Matayo is such a phenomenal writer because she writes in layers. There are just layers and layers and layers of backstory, events, emotions...all of them woven so beautifully together in this story. In all of the books I've read in my lifetime--especially in the last few years when I really starting paying attention to the art of story-telling--I've never quite been able to pinpoint what it is that makes one book more emotional than another, as if what I'm looking for is some simple skill that you've either got or you don't. I'm no expert, but I think it's something that goes beyond one's ability to weave words. Beyond skill alone. I believe you have to write with heart. It sounds cliche, but...somehow, whether it's something magical that happens or not, in books written with heart--with authenticity, passion, and spirit--the profound beauty of the written word just spills off the pages and onto the reader. And that's what the experience of reading The Whys Have It was like for me. I opened it up, read it, and closed it up afterward completely covered in raw emotion.
Matayo has a beautiful way with words. ALL the words.
So read the book. Ride the emotional waves. Relish the way it tugs at your heartstrings all the way from grief and despair to love and hope. And when you get to the brink of where the whys have it ... grab a tissue and power through. It's absolutely beautiful.
It was equal parts infuriating, heartbreaking, touching and swoon-worthy.
I find that while Matayo's books are among my favorites to read (and re-read), writing a review for them is difficult because in the course of her ripping out my heart and then piecing it together one painstakingly S-L-O-W piece at a time... there are no words leftover in the end. Just feels. ALL the feels.
You'll feel grief and at times you might find yourself buried in the same despair the characters are facing. It's brutal!! But then... there's hope. There's always hope. (And a good first kiss helps, too... *wink*)
I honestly think Matayo is such a phenomenal writer because she writes in layers. There are just layers and layers and layers of backstory, events, emotions...all of them woven so beautifully together in this story. In all of the books I've read in my lifetime--especially in the last few years when I really starting paying attention to the art of story-telling--I've never quite been able to pinpoint what it is that makes one book more emotional than another, as if what I'm looking for is some simple skill that you've either got or you don't. I'm no expert, but I think it's something that goes beyond one's ability to weave words. Beyond skill alone. I believe you have to write with heart. It sounds cliche, but...somehow, whether it's something magical that happens or not, in books written with heart--with authenticity, passion, and spirit--the profound beauty of the written word just spills off the pages and onto the reader. And that's what the experience of reading The Whys Have It was like for me. I opened it up, read it, and closed it up afterward completely covered in raw emotion.
Matayo has a beautiful way with words. ALL the words.
So read the book. Ride the emotional waves. Relish the way it tugs at your heartstrings all the way from grief and despair to love and hope. And when you get to the brink of where the whys have it ... grab a tissue and power through. It's absolutely beautiful.
June 13, 2017
*I received an ARC in exchange for my honest review*
At first I was a little confused about the title, but once it made sense it was so perfect! How often do we lose so much time to the "what ifs" and "whys" of life?
If I were to sum up this book, I would say that it is a lesson in not letting your circumstances dictate your future. There is so much that we can't control, and if we exhaust ourselves trying, we miss out on the life passing us by. In typical Amy Matayo style it has great emotion, humor, and clean romance.
I have read every single one of Amy's books, and they never disappoint. This one is no different!
At first I was a little confused about the title, but once it made sense it was so perfect! How often do we lose so much time to the "what ifs" and "whys" of life?
If I were to sum up this book, I would say that it is a lesson in not letting your circumstances dictate your future. There is so much that we can't control, and if we exhaust ourselves trying, we miss out on the life passing us by. In typical Amy Matayo style it has great emotion, humor, and clean romance.
I have read every single one of Amy's books, and they never disappoint. This one is no different!
January 29, 2018
And why did I wait so long to read this? I loved it! Hit all the right emotions and that chemistry between Cory and Sam? *swoon* Ms. Matayo just knows how to write a bad boy with a soft heart, doesn't she? I loved seeing these two characters deal with the fall out of decisions out of their control and how they helped each other through it. Their guilt and uncertainty felt real. And the way they grew closer, almost unconsciously, in spite of the hurt they caused each other. Like I said, their chemistry is amazing!
Both have had it rough, especially Sam, but they endured. And it's that very strength that endeared both of them to me. Faced with situations that seem to constantly beat them down, both Sam and Cory refuse to stay there. They pick themselves back up and move forward. Oh, it's not easy, but they do it. And as they strive harder, they slowly begin to realize how much better they are together instead of alone. Their character growth is beautiful to behold and I was cheering, by the final chapter, to see them making wiser choices and loving so well! This story is Amy Matayo at her best and I can't wait for more of her books! :)
Both have had it rough, especially Sam, but they endured. And it's that very strength that endeared both of them to me. Faced with situations that seem to constantly beat them down, both Sam and Cory refuse to stay there. They pick themselves back up and move forward. Oh, it's not easy, but they do it. And as they strive harder, they slowly begin to realize how much better they are together instead of alone. Their character growth is beautiful to behold and I was cheering, by the final chapter, to see them making wiser choices and loving so well! This story is Amy Matayo at her best and I can't wait for more of her books! :)
July 1, 2017
Sad until it isn't
This story just tugged and tugged on my heartstrings. The good girl doesn't make it. Her sister, the heroine who has lost so much, loses some more. The hero struggles to shake a memory that shattered his life a decade before. Not much good going on here. And still the heroine's light shines through. Very well written. Each scene explains a facet of the problem that has become their lives. The words deftly expose the emotions of the moment. Overall, the tale is rewarding, if not fun. Time well spent.
This story just tugged and tugged on my heartstrings. The good girl doesn't make it. Her sister, the heroine who has lost so much, loses some more. The hero struggles to shake a memory that shattered his life a decade before. Not much good going on here. And still the heroine's light shines through. Very well written. Each scene explains a facet of the problem that has become their lives. The words deftly expose the emotions of the moment. Overall, the tale is rewarding, if not fun. Time well spent.
June 23, 2017
Beautifully written story; but a definite slow-burn without ANY sexy times, which was very disappointing!!!
June 30, 2017
Wow! Well done!
Content: Innuendo, Cory lives the stereotypical life of a teen heartthrob, sex is talked about but no scenes on the pages of the book
Content: Innuendo, Cory lives the stereotypical life of a teen heartthrob, sex is talked about but no scenes on the pages of the book
July 5, 2017
Life is full of challenges. For Cory and Sam in The Whys Have It, life dealt them unfortunate tragedies and pain. Ironically, each of them chose to react in opposite ways: Sam, to forge ahead, sometimes in bitterness, even at the cost of her own happiness. Cory, to run away, try to dull the pain with vices, and give in to self-loathing. The contrast between these responses is brought to life in the dynamic of their unlikely friendship. They gradually learn from each other, realizing hope is really worth the risk and second chances are possible through forgiveness.
Amy Matayo's style is brilliantly complex. She portrays the emotional turmoil of grief, the lingering shadows of regret, and the ache of loss in the most relatable of ways. A light of joy shines through it all for Cory and Sam, though, sometimes in a small moment of camaraderie or friendship, eventually growing into a romance. I liked how their relationship showed what it means to accept another person for who they are, disregarding expectations or what they might deserve because of mistakes.
I'm beginning to recognize Amy's signature snarky sense of humor she pours into her novels. At times it's laugh-out-loud sarcastic, at others it had Sam (and maybe me) blushing from the double entendré of Cory's unfiltered flirting. :)
The Whys Have It cleverly sits on a blurred line between secular and Christian fiction. Just enough portrayal of faith and a belief in a higher purpose combined with just enough grittiness and candor to push me out of my reading "comfort zone", so to speak. I believe this novel will have a broader appeal because of its relatable style and the way it handles subjects like grief, forgiveness and even romance with a raw honesty. If you're a fan of contemporary drama/romance, indie Christian ficiton, or even new adult romance, this is one story not to be missed!
Thank you to Relz Author Support Services and the author for a complimentary review copy of this novel. This is my honest review.
Amy Matayo's style is brilliantly complex. She portrays the emotional turmoil of grief, the lingering shadows of regret, and the ache of loss in the most relatable of ways. A light of joy shines through it all for Cory and Sam, though, sometimes in a small moment of camaraderie or friendship, eventually growing into a romance. I liked how their relationship showed what it means to accept another person for who they are, disregarding expectations or what they might deserve because of mistakes.
I'm beginning to recognize Amy's signature snarky sense of humor she pours into her novels. At times it's laugh-out-loud sarcastic, at others it had Sam (and maybe me) blushing from the double entendré of Cory's unfiltered flirting. :)
The Whys Have It cleverly sits on a blurred line between secular and Christian fiction. Just enough portrayal of faith and a belief in a higher purpose combined with just enough grittiness and candor to push me out of my reading "comfort zone", so to speak. I believe this novel will have a broader appeal because of its relatable style and the way it handles subjects like grief, forgiveness and even romance with a raw honesty. If you're a fan of contemporary drama/romance, indie Christian ficiton, or even new adult romance, this is one story not to be missed!
Thank you to Relz Author Support Services and the author for a complimentary review copy of this novel. This is my honest review.
June 22, 2017
The Whys Have It is one of those books that you can't stop reading, but it's also hard to read because it's just so emotional. I'm not kidding—I cried at least three times while reading it. The last time was the worst, as I was reading on my lunch break at work, so I was trying to cry without anyone noticing!
Cory is a womanizing rockstar ... so why did I care so much about him? It's because there's more to Cory than meets the eye. Inside, he's a wounded 17-year-old doing everything he can to outrun the pain and guilt.
And then he meets Sam.
Sam is a strong-because-she's-had-to-be, grieving woman when she meets Cory. And somehow, they seem to bring out the best in each other.
The story is told in first person present tense, which sometimes doesn't work at all but seems perfect here. We hear from both Cory and Sam, and their voices are unique, making the point of view shifts easy to follow.
Sam is pretty much an open book—we (and Cory) learn about her tragic family situation fairly quickly—but Cory is an enigma. His story comes out very slowly, and it ended up being even more heartbreaking than I'd imagined.
The Whys Have It is ultimately a story of forgiveness and redemption wrapped up in a love story. If you like edgier Christian fiction, you'll want to check it out.
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received a copy of this book from the author. I was not required to write a positive review, and the opinions expressed are my own.
Cory is a womanizing rockstar ... so why did I care so much about him? It's because there's more to Cory than meets the eye. Inside, he's a wounded 17-year-old doing everything he can to outrun the pain and guilt.
And then he meets Sam.
Sam is a strong-because-she's-had-to-be, grieving woman when she meets Cory. And somehow, they seem to bring out the best in each other.
The story is told in first person present tense, which sometimes doesn't work at all but seems perfect here. We hear from both Cory and Sam, and their voices are unique, making the point of view shifts easy to follow.
Sam is pretty much an open book—we (and Cory) learn about her tragic family situation fairly quickly—but Cory is an enigma. His story comes out very slowly, and it ended up being even more heartbreaking than I'd imagined.
The Whys Have It is ultimately a story of forgiveness and redemption wrapped up in a love story. If you like edgier Christian fiction, you'll want to check it out.
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received a copy of this book from the author. I was not required to write a positive review, and the opinions expressed are my own.
June 20, 2017
Having read and loved other novels by Amy Matayo, I knew I had to jump on board to read this one as well. Ms Matayo did not disappoint.
At first glance, this appeared to be another 'famous-person-has-crisis-of-conscience-and-returns-home' love story. While it does have an element of that plot, the author does a fantastic job of drawing the reader in, building suspense, and thickening the plot so there's more to it.
Sam and Cory are linked by tragedy. This tragedy may be the one thing each of them needs in order to find what they've been missing in their lives. They are troubled souls who have loads of responsibility heaped upon their shoulders. One fateful night, their lives change forever. How will they respond to this tragic event?
Told in alternating perspectives, we learn about their pasts and life stories. We learn the experiences that have made them who they are. We learn how certain decisions have haunted them.
Will Sam and Cory find the peace they desperately desire? Read the book to find out. You will be glad you did!
I was provided a copy of this book by the author. All opinions in this review are my own.
At first glance, this appeared to be another 'famous-person-has-crisis-of-conscience-and-returns-home' love story. While it does have an element of that plot, the author does a fantastic job of drawing the reader in, building suspense, and thickening the plot so there's more to it.
Sam and Cory are linked by tragedy. This tragedy may be the one thing each of them needs in order to find what they've been missing in their lives. They are troubled souls who have loads of responsibility heaped upon their shoulders. One fateful night, their lives change forever. How will they respond to this tragic event?
Told in alternating perspectives, we learn about their pasts and life stories. We learn the experiences that have made them who they are. We learn how certain decisions have haunted them.
Will Sam and Cory find the peace they desperately desire? Read the book to find out. You will be glad you did!
I was provided a copy of this book by the author. All opinions in this review are my own.
June 14, 2017
Talk about a page turner! (Well, in my case, a page swiper since I had the ebook.) I read the whole thing in 24 hours on a family trip to the waterpark.
Amy Matayo's latest romance delves into the mystery category as you try to untangle the backstory of a the lead male character, Cory, and then cry harder and harder in your Cheerios as you learn the unrelenting life the main female character, Sam.
Cory is America's hottest country singer, both in record sales and good looks. Sam is a selfless daughter and sister trying to care for both her teenage sister and ailing father.
The story is definitely a romance but as with this author's other novels, I find myself more engrossed in the emotional and healing journeys the characters travel throughout the novel.
Some of my favorite quotes:
“Isn’t that the motto of most people’s lives? Later. As though later is a given rather than a moment in time that slips easily through the fingers."
“Sometimes that’s the hardest thing to accept about life: you can’t go back. You can’t undo mistakes. You don’t get re-dos, even if you beg the maker of the universe for a million second chances. ”
And, possibly a sneak peek into the author's innermost thoughts:
“That’s the way with writers—every word on a page like a window into their private places, exposing a great deal of vulnerability when they allow others to see inside. Even fiction is made of up of the truthful scars of the people telling the story.”
Wonder if Amy is secretly plucking away at a guitar when she's not writing? ;-)
P.S. I was provided a copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for an honest review. And, trust me. I honestly thought it was earth-shattering – in the best possible way. You should read it.
Amy Matayo's latest romance delves into the mystery category as you try to untangle the backstory of a the lead male character, Cory, and then cry harder and harder in your Cheerios as you learn the unrelenting life the main female character, Sam.
Cory is America's hottest country singer, both in record sales and good looks. Sam is a selfless daughter and sister trying to care for both her teenage sister and ailing father.
The story is definitely a romance but as with this author's other novels, I find myself more engrossed in the emotional and healing journeys the characters travel throughout the novel.
Some of my favorite quotes:
“Isn’t that the motto of most people’s lives? Later. As though later is a given rather than a moment in time that slips easily through the fingers."
“Sometimes that’s the hardest thing to accept about life: you can’t go back. You can’t undo mistakes. You don’t get re-dos, even if you beg the maker of the universe for a million second chances. ”
And, possibly a sneak peek into the author's innermost thoughts:
“That’s the way with writers—every word on a page like a window into their private places, exposing a great deal of vulnerability when they allow others to see inside. Even fiction is made of up of the truthful scars of the people telling the story.”
Wonder if Amy is secretly plucking away at a guitar when she's not writing? ;-)
P.S. I was provided a copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for an honest review. And, trust me. I honestly thought it was earth-shattering – in the best possible way. You should read it.
June 15, 2017
I received an advanced reader copy from the publisher via Net Galley in exchange for my honest review.
The Whys Have It is a one of a kind tale of two people finding love during a time of extreme grief. Ms. Matayo did a wonderful job of really conveying every emotion Cory and Sam felt.
Typically, in books you have a hero and a villain. However in this story, the villain is unseen; a twist of fate, a pure tragedy. There were no good guys or bad guys just victims of unfortunate circumstances.
Those situations individually and collectively bind Sam and Cory together in a way that isn't typical to the standard HEA romances.
I think that's why this book is so good.
Right away you think you know how it's going to proceed and end but you're wrong.
The resiliency that Sam displays is mind blowing. She has every right to wallow and let her grief consume her but she doesn't. I know I wouldn't be able to cope with the crappy hand she had been dealt.
Then there is Cory. He is a runner and he's been running from his past for a decade. Until he literally can not run anymore. When his current mess collides with a past he can't hide from, he must decide if he is going to continue to run or finally face the music.
My favorite part of this book is Cory and Sam's friendship. They share a natural bond that doesn't take any work. Their teasing banter shows how comfortable they are together. Sam gets a glimpse of Cory's lavish lifestyle and Cory gets to feel what it's like to be seen as a person and not a dollar sign.
Initially, you think Cory is going to save Sam from her new found sad existence. Again, you'd be surprised at the ending!
You'll have to read it to see what happens!
The Whys Have It is a one of a kind tale of two people finding love during a time of extreme grief. Ms. Matayo did a wonderful job of really conveying every emotion Cory and Sam felt.
Typically, in books you have a hero and a villain. However in this story, the villain is unseen; a twist of fate, a pure tragedy. There were no good guys or bad guys just victims of unfortunate circumstances.
Those situations individually and collectively bind Sam and Cory together in a way that isn't typical to the standard HEA romances.
I think that's why this book is so good.
Right away you think you know how it's going to proceed and end but you're wrong.
The resiliency that Sam displays is mind blowing. She has every right to wallow and let her grief consume her but she doesn't. I know I wouldn't be able to cope with the crappy hand she had been dealt.
Then there is Cory. He is a runner and he's been running from his past for a decade. Until he literally can not run anymore. When his current mess collides with a past he can't hide from, he must decide if he is going to continue to run or finally face the music.
My favorite part of this book is Cory and Sam's friendship. They share a natural bond that doesn't take any work. Their teasing banter shows how comfortable they are together. Sam gets a glimpse of Cory's lavish lifestyle and Cory gets to feel what it's like to be seen as a person and not a dollar sign.
Initially, you think Cory is going to save Sam from her new found sad existence. Again, you'd be surprised at the ending!
You'll have to read it to see what happens!
January 2, 2019
2.5 stars but rounding up to three since Goodreads still doesn't have half stars.
This book is ANGSTY with a capital A. Both main characters have tragic backgrounds and they're brought together by another tragedy. Cory and Sam weren't completely two-dimensional characters but not quite well-rounded to be anything but average. I enjoyed the book enough to read it all in one sitting (which is always nice) and the writing is nicely done. I'd likely read something else by the author. I just think this story was missing a little passion and started to fast-forward near the end, making it feel rushed.
This book is ANGSTY with a capital A. Both main characters have tragic backgrounds and they're brought together by another tragedy. Cory and Sam weren't completely two-dimensional characters but not quite well-rounded to be anything but average. I enjoyed the book enough to read it all in one sitting (which is always nice) and the writing is nicely done. I'd likely read something else by the author. I just think this story was missing a little passion and started to fast-forward near the end, making it feel rushed.
July 4, 2017
This was a great read. First, I really connected to this author's writing style. It's pure and honest. She does a fantastic job of bringing her characters to life with heart-pulling emotion and raw honesty. Second, I just flat out loved the story line. I liked the way it wasn't focused on Cory's stardom so much as it was the time spent between him and Sam, and all the issues both needed to work out. This was my first book by this author but it won't be my last.
June 30, 2017
As usual I cried. Sam and Cory are such deep characters, whom I loved. Maybe not from the first moment - but they got there. It's a story about forgiveness - both of yourself and of other people. Mostly of yourself.
July 4, 2017
-"Nothing good happens after midnight."-
Extremely well written. Very dark. Very moving. Gripping. Hard to read but excellent. A drama. Heartbreak.
Extremely well written. Very dark. Very moving. Gripping. Hard to read but excellent. A drama. Heartbreak.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 90 reviews