What do you think?
Rate this book
Claiming Her Legacy
With her family’s legacy on the line, a woman with everything to lose must rely on a man hiding from his past…
Oklahoma, 1890
Frontier women don’t ride off alone to track an outlaw—not even women as capable as tomboy spinster Willa Malone. But Willa desperately needs the bounty money offered for her father’s killer if she’s to keep their homestead and take care of her sisters. That means she needs an expert tracker's help. Gideon Hartley has the skill, but the handsome trail guide also has a troubling secret…
Gideon has spent years trying to numb his pain with whiskey. Little by little, their quest—and Willa’s belief in him—is restoring the sense of purpose he thought he’d lost. Journeying into the heart of danger, they’ll have to face down the past together if they hope to protect their future…
“Linda Goodnight is a writer who pulls readers into her stories with characters who come off the pages with life.”
—Jodi Thomas, New York Times bestselling author
Oklahoma, 1890
Frontier women don’t ride off alone to track an outlaw—not even women as capable as tomboy spinster Willa Malone. But Willa desperately needs the bounty money offered for her father’s killer if she’s to keep their homestead and take care of her sisters. That means she needs an expert tracker's help. Gideon Hartley has the skill, but the handsome trail guide also has a troubling secret…
Gideon has spent years trying to numb his pain with whiskey. Little by little, their quest—and Willa’s belief in him—is restoring the sense of purpose he thought he’d lost. Journeying into the heart of danger, they’ll have to face down the past together if they hope to protect their future…
“Linda Goodnight is a writer who pulls readers into her stories with characters who come off the pages with life.”
—Jodi Thomas, New York Times bestselling author
368 pages, Paperback
Published April 26, 2022
About the author
Linda Goodnight
216 books495 followersNY Times and USA Bestseller, Linda Goodnight writes novels of faith and family that point to hope through Christ. Her emotional stories have won the RITA , the Carol, the Reviewer’s Choice, and numerous other industry awards. Her two great passions are faith in Jesus and her large extended family. (And pie. she loves pie.)
Readers may connect with Linda through her website at www.lindagoodnight.com or on Facebook.
Readers may connect with Linda through her website at www.lindagoodnight.com or on Facebook.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 66 reviews
July 9, 2022
Evangelical Christian author Linda Goodnight is a new writer to my wife Barb and I, but not new to the craft; she's an established Goodreads author with 160 distinct works listed on her profile, at least some of them best sellers. This particular novel was newly published early this year; I hardly ever buy new releases, but this was an impulse purchase, picked as a belated (long story!) Christmas present for Barb, on the strength of the cover and a recommendation blurb from a favorite author of ours, Mary Connealy. After reading a ways into it, Barb suggested we read it together, having guessed that it's the sort of book we both like. That guess proved to be right on the mark; we loved it!
Our setting here is Oklahoma Territory in 1890. (At that time, the latter territory occupied the western part of the present-day state; the eastern part was the even more scantily-settled and lawless Indian Territory.) The author lives in Oklahoma (so writes about the setting with assurance); according to an online interview with her, this book was inspired by a photograph in the Territorial Museum at Guthrie, showing a lone pioneer woman toting a rifle in front of a tent as she stood guard over her claim in the 1889 Land Rush. Her spirit imbues Willa Malone, our heroine here.
30 years old, Willa sees herself as an "old maid." She's the eldest of three half-sisters, daughters of peripatetic ne'er-do-well Finn Malone, who outlived two wives (and was deserted by a third) in the course of his wanderings, which in 1889 led him to a homestead in the small community of Sweet Clover. Like many of the townsfolk, he was heavily in debt to conniving banker Theodore Pierce, and used his land as collateral. But he's now recently dead, murdered after he took off on his latest quest for gold. At the moment, the farm isn't productive; without him, the sisters won't be able to repay the loan, and they'll lose their home within months. His killer, though, has been identified as notorious outlaw Charlie Bangs, rumored to be hiding out in Indian Territory, and there's a $1,000.00 price on his head. When Willa, early on, conceives the idea of tracking him down and claiming the bounty, nobody can talk her out of it. The idea's not as hare-brained as some folks think. Tough and practical, "tomboy" Willa's a good shot with a rifle whose hunting skills keep her family supplied with meat; she can ride, and she's got guts. As even she recognizes, though, the enterprise she's contemplating is a deadly dangerous one. At the very least, she'll need the services of an experienced trail guide. Enter one Gideon Hartley.
Gideon's about 35; he's fairly new in town, but the reputation that precedes him confirms that he's highly competent as a trail guide in rough terrain --when he's sober. But his reputation also suggests (correctly) that he drinks a lot. In fact, his alcohol abuse problem is longstanding and deep-seated. He and Willa meet in Chapter 1. Surprisingly (or maybe not, depending on how familiar readers are with "romance" genre conventions; this was published under the "Love Inspired" imprint, though I approached it as a Western, and it works on those terms) there's some chemistry between them; but neither is looking for that sort of thing, nor inclined to nurture it. More to the point, Willa's not thrilled with the idea of a "drunk" for a guide; and Gideon (who hasn't done any guiding for about a year) is pretty well convinced that he's not up to the job and that Willa would be embarking on a suicide mission anyway. But before long, it becomes clear to her that he's the only prospective guide she's going to get, and to him that she's going whether he goes with her or not.
Goodnight gives serious attention to developing her characters (including the secondary ones, along with our H/h) and bringing the community to life, and she takes the time needed to do that in depth. We don't get started on our actual quest until a bit more than 200 pages in (and the book has 363 pages). Some readers, who expect the adventure of the trail to be the main warp and woof of the tale, won't like this aspect. Barb and I, however, fully appreciated the textured, in-depth approach. Both main characters (who alternate as viewpoint characters, though third-person narration is used throughout) are fully round and three-dimensional. Gideon in particular has a lot of psychological baggage, which is believable, and gradually disclosed. Western-style action, once it kicks in, isn't stinted; there are plenty of jeopardies on the trail, and the climactic confrontation will test our leading couple's mettle on more than one level. The author writes very well; her plotting is excellent, and her re-creation of the time and place masterful. (It features a cameo appearance by real-life person Bass Reeves, the first African-American deputy U.S. marshall.)
In keeping with the standards of the ECPA, this book poses no content issues for bad language, sexual content (we do have reference to prostitution, and to the ugly trade of sex trafficking, which is a very contemporary reality, but which goes back a lot longer than that), or ultra-gory violence. Christian faith (which both main characters were raised with, though Gideon's faith has been long neglected) plays a positive role here, though the book isn't "preachy" and delivers its spiritual messages by example.
I'd recommend this to fans of Westerns, Western romance, and clean (especially Christian) romance in general, as well as to fans of strong heroines. The story arc here is complete, and the book isn't said to be part of a series (though I suspect that both of Willa's sisters might eventually get her own sequel). Although some characters, such as Belle Holbrook, obviously have very intriguing backstories, I couldn't find any indication that they were in prior books by the author. (But if they were, or if they eventually get prequels, I'd be interested in reading those books!)
Our setting here is Oklahoma Territory in 1890. (At that time, the latter territory occupied the western part of the present-day state; the eastern part was the even more scantily-settled and lawless Indian Territory.) The author lives in Oklahoma (so writes about the setting with assurance); according to an online interview with her, this book was inspired by a photograph in the Territorial Museum at Guthrie, showing a lone pioneer woman toting a rifle in front of a tent as she stood guard over her claim in the 1889 Land Rush. Her spirit imbues Willa Malone, our heroine here.
30 years old, Willa sees herself as an "old maid." She's the eldest of three half-sisters, daughters of peripatetic ne'er-do-well Finn Malone, who outlived two wives (and was deserted by a third) in the course of his wanderings, which in 1889 led him to a homestead in the small community of Sweet Clover. Like many of the townsfolk, he was heavily in debt to conniving banker Theodore Pierce, and used his land as collateral. But he's now recently dead, murdered after he took off on his latest quest for gold. At the moment, the farm isn't productive; without him, the sisters won't be able to repay the loan, and they'll lose their home within months. His killer, though, has been identified as notorious outlaw Charlie Bangs, rumored to be hiding out in Indian Territory, and there's a $1,000.00 price on his head. When Willa, early on, conceives the idea of tracking him down and claiming the bounty, nobody can talk her out of it. The idea's not as hare-brained as some folks think. Tough and practical, "tomboy" Willa's a good shot with a rifle whose hunting skills keep her family supplied with meat; she can ride, and she's got guts. As even she recognizes, though, the enterprise she's contemplating is a deadly dangerous one. At the very least, she'll need the services of an experienced trail guide. Enter one Gideon Hartley.
Gideon's about 35; he's fairly new in town, but the reputation that precedes him confirms that he's highly competent as a trail guide in rough terrain --when he's sober. But his reputation also suggests (correctly) that he drinks a lot. In fact, his alcohol abuse problem is longstanding and deep-seated. He and Willa meet in Chapter 1. Surprisingly (or maybe not, depending on how familiar readers are with "romance" genre conventions; this was published under the "Love Inspired" imprint, though I approached it as a Western, and it works on those terms) there's some chemistry between them; but neither is looking for that sort of thing, nor inclined to nurture it. More to the point, Willa's not thrilled with the idea of a "drunk" for a guide; and Gideon (who hasn't done any guiding for about a year) is pretty well convinced that he's not up to the job and that Willa would be embarking on a suicide mission anyway. But before long, it becomes clear to her that he's the only prospective guide she's going to get, and to him that she's going whether he goes with her or not.
Goodnight gives serious attention to developing her characters (including the secondary ones, along with our H/h) and bringing the community to life, and she takes the time needed to do that in depth. We don't get started on our actual quest until a bit more than 200 pages in (and the book has 363 pages). Some readers, who expect the adventure of the trail to be the main warp and woof of the tale, won't like this aspect. Barb and I, however, fully appreciated the textured, in-depth approach. Both main characters (who alternate as viewpoint characters, though third-person narration is used throughout) are fully round and three-dimensional. Gideon in particular has a lot of psychological baggage, which is believable, and gradually disclosed. Western-style action, once it kicks in, isn't stinted; there are plenty of jeopardies on the trail, and the climactic confrontation will test our leading couple's mettle on more than one level. The author writes very well; her plotting is excellent, and her re-creation of the time and place masterful. (It features a cameo appearance by real-life person Bass Reeves, the first African-American deputy U.S. marshall.)
In keeping with the standards of the ECPA, this book poses no content issues for bad language, sexual content (we do have reference to prostitution, and to the ugly trade of sex trafficking, which is a very contemporary reality, but which goes back a lot longer than that), or ultra-gory violence. Christian faith (which both main characters were raised with, though Gideon's faith has been long neglected) plays a positive role here, though the book isn't "preachy" and delivers its spiritual messages by example.
I'd recommend this to fans of Westerns, Western romance, and clean (especially Christian) romance in general, as well as to fans of strong heroines. The story arc here is complete, and the book isn't said to be part of a series (though I suspect that both of Willa's sisters might eventually get her own sequel). Although some characters, such as Belle Holbrook, obviously have very intriguing backstories, I couldn't find any indication that they were in prior books by the author. (But if they were, or if they eventually get prequels, I'd be interested in reading those books!)
April 27, 2022
This is a Western Historical Romance. This book takes place in Oklahoma during 1890. I have a love hate relationship with Historical Romance. I have learn that I need more then the romance driving the book. I hate the flowering writing that is in some historical fiction book, but this book does not having it. I do not know if it is because it takes place in the Old West in American. I love the action and the suspense in this book. The characters are so great in this book. I also love that this book shows a lot of the problems that happen in the Old West. Great Read and Very Well Written. I was kindly provided an e-copy of this book by the publisher (Love Inspired Trade) or author (Linda Goodnight) via NetGalley, so I can give an honest review about how I feel about this book. I want to send a big Thank you to them for that.
May 6, 2022
Ever since Maggie Osborne retired from writing I've been on the fruitless trail to find authors who write historical western romances in a similar vein. After reading the back cover blurb of what is, presumably, the first in a new series from Goodnight - I downloaded the ARC, even though I knew going into the story that this was an inspirational, and not exactly Osborne-like (per se) for that reason. This was mostly a success.
"Mostly" because it takes a good long while to get going. The heroine wants to track down the outlaw who murdered her pa - yes, pa deserves justice but more so for the bounty on the outlaw's head. Willa desperately needs the money to pay off a bank loan. Otherwise? Her and her two sisters will be homeless, left with nothing but undesirable options stretching out before them. For this she needs a guide and the only one in the area is the hero - who is a drunkard who has to dry out first. Hence, the man hunt / road romance portion of this story doesn't start until you're 60% into the story.
But Goodnight creates an interesting backdrop in the tiny Oklahoma town of Sweet Clover, with plenty of interesting characters that could populate later books in a series. Also, she knows her hero has to dry out - and while I would have preferred that happen on the trail, it makes a logical bit of sense that he does so before they even set off.
This is an inspirational, but it's not of the ilk where you feel like the author is trying to convert the reader. The characters have faith, and I found Willa's "God helps those who help themselves" attitude particularly refreshing. Gideon, naturally, has a tragic past and his return to faith stems from his need to give and receive forgiveness. Also, because it's an inspirational, readers shouldn't expect any sexy times although we do get a well-deserved, and much anticipated!, kiss between our main couple.
It wasn't exactly what I was hoping it would be, but the final 40% really closed out to be solid finish. If Goodnight continues the series, I'll be reading.
"Mostly" because it takes a good long while to get going. The heroine wants to track down the outlaw who murdered her pa - yes, pa deserves justice but more so for the bounty on the outlaw's head. Willa desperately needs the money to pay off a bank loan. Otherwise? Her and her two sisters will be homeless, left with nothing but undesirable options stretching out before them. For this she needs a guide and the only one in the area is the hero - who is a drunkard who has to dry out first. Hence, the man hunt / road romance portion of this story doesn't start until you're 60% into the story.
But Goodnight creates an interesting backdrop in the tiny Oklahoma town of Sweet Clover, with plenty of interesting characters that could populate later books in a series. Also, she knows her hero has to dry out - and while I would have preferred that happen on the trail, it makes a logical bit of sense that he does so before they even set off.
This is an inspirational, but it's not of the ilk where you feel like the author is trying to convert the reader. The characters have faith, and I found Willa's "God helps those who help themselves" attitude particularly refreshing. Gideon, naturally, has a tragic past and his return to faith stems from his need to give and receive forgiveness. Also, because it's an inspirational, readers shouldn't expect any sexy times although we do get a well-deserved, and much anticipated!, kiss between our main couple.
It wasn't exactly what I was hoping it would be, but the final 40% really closed out to be solid finish. If Goodnight continues the series, I'll be reading.
April 9, 2022
Publisher has requested review not be posted until 30 days before publish date. Full review will be posted Mar 26. #NetGalley
Merged review:
My Sketch ...
The only thing left for Willa and her sisters is the farm. It’s their legacy and their lives depend on making the bank payment. But a woman does not go after an outlaw for the bounty. Gideon is the one man that can help her but his past eats at him & whiskey makes it go away… The year 1890; the location is Oklahoma Territory.
My Review ...
This reviewer was dubious when I read the full synopsis of the book. How could the author make the reader believe that Willa would plan to hunt down the outlaw that killed her father to collect the bounty? Could the author make it believable? Linda Goodnight did exactly that.
I loved the first two sentences. Only four words that draw you into the story immediately. Willa is the oldest and she is stubborn, opinionated, filled with self-doubt but tough as she needs to be. The town banker is slimy with nary a drop of human kindness. Willa must make the next payment.
The characters are given time to develop and grow. The reader begins to know them as people. Scenes are well-developed so the reader can see it in their mind’s eye. The pacing, though, at times dragged. Especially in the beginning when Gideon is struggling with his drinking. Multiple failures are meant to show Gideon is a full-blown alcoholic. However, this reviewer felt several of them could be removed or merged.
I enjoyed this book, but it didn’t keep me as engaged as most of my five-star reads do. I also found that the pursuit of the outlaw actions done by Gideon were not believable. Gideon and Willa did not want the outlaw to learn they were searching for him. Yet, every place they went Gideon would show the wanted poster and specifically ask if anyone had seen him. Not what you do when you don’t want word to get back.
Then, the author would deal brilliantly with another situation.
Readers will enjoy this story. And will, I believe, like the supporting characters, especially Isaac. Isaac is Gideon’s friend and lives his beliefs completely. He guides Gideon thoughtfully and without criticism. The words of the Holy Bible are used wisely. In reading, the Biblical use felt like the characters would *really* say that. Yes, I recommend Claiming Her Legacy.
I received a complimentary e-ARC* copy of Claiming Her Legacy via NetGalley and HARLEQUIN – Romance (U.S. & Canada), Love Inspired. A positive review was not required; the opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
#ClaimingHerLegacy #NetGalley #LindaGoodnight
Title: Claiming Her Legacy
Series: N/A
Author: Linda Goodnight
Genre: Historical Fiction, Western Romance
Publisher: HARLEQUIN – Romance (U.S. & Canada), Love Inspired Trade
Release Date: April 26, 2022
Format: Kindle (read), Paperback, Audio CD
Pages: 381
Source: NetGalley
Cover: Striking, brooding. Immediately catches the eye. Fits the storyline.
Merged review:
My Sketch ...
The only thing left for Willa and her sisters is the farm. It’s their legacy and their lives depend on making the bank payment. But a woman does not go after an outlaw for the bounty. Gideon is the one man that can help her but his past eats at him & whiskey makes it go away… The year 1890; the location is Oklahoma Territory.
My Review ...
This reviewer was dubious when I read the full synopsis of the book. How could the author make the reader believe that Willa would plan to hunt down the outlaw that killed her father to collect the bounty? Could the author make it believable? Linda Goodnight did exactly that.
I loved the first two sentences. Only four words that draw you into the story immediately. Willa is the oldest and she is stubborn, opinionated, filled with self-doubt but tough as she needs to be. The town banker is slimy with nary a drop of human kindness. Willa must make the next payment.
The characters are given time to develop and grow. The reader begins to know them as people. Scenes are well-developed so the reader can see it in their mind’s eye. The pacing, though, at times dragged. Especially in the beginning when Gideon is struggling with his drinking. Multiple failures are meant to show Gideon is a full-blown alcoholic. However, this reviewer felt several of them could be removed or merged.
I enjoyed this book, but it didn’t keep me as engaged as most of my five-star reads do. I also found that the pursuit of the outlaw actions done by Gideon were not believable. Gideon and Willa did not want the outlaw to learn they were searching for him. Yet, every place they went Gideon would show the wanted poster and specifically ask if anyone had seen him. Not what you do when you don’t want word to get back.
Then, the author would deal brilliantly with another situation.
Readers will enjoy this story. And will, I believe, like the supporting characters, especially Isaac. Isaac is Gideon’s friend and lives his beliefs completely. He guides Gideon thoughtfully and without criticism. The words of the Holy Bible are used wisely. In reading, the Biblical use felt like the characters would *really* say that. Yes, I recommend Claiming Her Legacy.
I received a complimentary e-ARC* copy of Claiming Her Legacy via NetGalley and HARLEQUIN – Romance (U.S. & Canada), Love Inspired. A positive review was not required; the opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
#ClaimingHerLegacy #NetGalley #LindaGoodnight
Title: Claiming Her Legacy
Series: N/A
Author: Linda Goodnight
Genre: Historical Fiction, Western Romance
Publisher: HARLEQUIN – Romance (U.S. & Canada), Love Inspired Trade
Release Date: April 26, 2022
Format: Kindle (read), Paperback, Audio CD
Pages: 381
Source: NetGalley
Cover: Striking, brooding. Immediately catches the eye. Fits the storyline.
May 31, 2022
This historical western romance made me feel like I was thrown back in time with these characters and experiencing things right along with them. The book started with a slow build, showing the desperate financial situation the Malone sisters found themselves in. Willa’s determination to find the man who killed her father and bring him in for the bounty was an unheard of thing for a woman to attempt and extremely dangerous.
What a great twist for Willa’s one hope for an experienced tracker to be a man who was in the clutches of an addition to alcohol. I couldn’t help but like Gideon! He had some extremely tragic events from his past that drove him to drink. His journey to freedom from the hold that the alcohol had on him lasted throughout the entire story and was not an easy one. He was a great character who ended up eventually showing great strength both in character and in faith. His faith journey was beautifully woven into the book naturally, too.
I loved the way the romance grew between these two. It was realistic and slow building, with two people who were full of doubts regarding whether they were worthy of the other person’s love. There were some harrowing moments of danger in this story, as well, and a very satisfying conclusion.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
You can read this review on my blog:
https://brittreadsfiction.wordpress.c...
What a great twist for Willa’s one hope for an experienced tracker to be a man who was in the clutches of an addition to alcohol. I couldn’t help but like Gideon! He had some extremely tragic events from his past that drove him to drink. His journey to freedom from the hold that the alcohol had on him lasted throughout the entire story and was not an easy one. He was a great character who ended up eventually showing great strength both in character and in faith. His faith journey was beautifully woven into the book naturally, too.
I loved the way the romance grew between these two. It was realistic and slow building, with two people who were full of doubts regarding whether they were worthy of the other person’s love. There were some harrowing moments of danger in this story, as well, and a very satisfying conclusion.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
You can read this review on my blog:
https://brittreadsfiction.wordpress.c...
April 26, 2022
This book was so very good! I am always so happy when a book starts off well, with believable characters and plots. Linda Goodnight has a definite winner here in my book. I'm very happy that Love Inspired decided to put out a trade-length line.
Goodnight has fashioned these characters so that I felt as if I could almost see inside their hearts and feel their emotions. Her way of describing their feelings and emotions was amazing and I felt as if I had known them for years. Gideon was a really well done male character; his hurts, his anger, his addiction. I don't think he could have been done better at all. And Willa, who is convinced she is never to be loved and cherished and thinks of herself and plain and simple; it was such fun watching her be developed. This one is great, folks. Full and rich seems a paltry way to describe it, but that's exactly what it was. I kid you not.
My thanks to the publisher for a copy of this book via the Net Galley platform. The opinion here is entirely my own.
Goodnight has fashioned these characters so that I felt as if I could almost see inside their hearts and feel their emotions. Her way of describing their feelings and emotions was amazing and I felt as if I had known them for years. Gideon was a really well done male character; his hurts, his anger, his addiction. I don't think he could have been done better at all. And Willa, who is convinced she is never to be loved and cherished and thinks of herself and plain and simple; it was such fun watching her be developed. This one is great, folks. Full and rich seems a paltry way to describe it, but that's exactly what it was. I kid you not.
My thanks to the publisher for a copy of this book via the Net Galley platform. The opinion here is entirely my own.
May 3, 2022
A Western romance with a strong redemptive thread. In fact, the first half of the book is Gideon's struggles to overcome his reliance on whiskey. The bounty hunter adventuring comes much later.
We have a damsel in distress who is intent on rescuing herself, thank you very much. And a hero who pretends that he doesn't care but just can't bring himself to wash his hands of Willa and her outrageous bounty hunting notion. It's none of his business, but the woman is is a 'persistent gnat' and won't leave him alone.
For her part, Willa would just as soon hire anybody other than the 'debauched and troubled soul' who happens to be a tracking legend. But since Gideon's all she's got and time is of the essence she makes it her mission to pester him into compliance. Snicker. There's some great sniping and bantering going on here. Along with more vulnerable, heart-tugging moments too which really balance out the romance.
There's a bit of a 'True Grit' vibe once these two set out on their quest which I really enjoyed. Could almost taste the dust of the trail and feel the saddle sores on my posterior. :-) The action came fast and furious during the last third of the book, but I found the overall resolution felt rushed. I would have liked more 'real time' details to flesh things out.
I can't find any indication that this is the first in a series, but I'm sure hoping it is because Willa has two sisters who deserve happily ever afters too and I'm definitely intrigued by what I've learned about both of them. Here's hoping Love Inspired Trade and the author have plans for a series!
I listened to the audible edition narrated by Carly Robins who added just the right touch of Wild West to her performance. Very enjoyable.
We have a damsel in distress who is intent on rescuing herself, thank you very much. And a hero who pretends that he doesn't care but just can't bring himself to wash his hands of Willa and her outrageous bounty hunting notion. It's none of his business, but the woman is is a 'persistent gnat' and won't leave him alone.
For her part, Willa would just as soon hire anybody other than the 'debauched and troubled soul' who happens to be a tracking legend. But since Gideon's all she's got and time is of the essence she makes it her mission to pester him into compliance. Snicker. There's some great sniping and bantering going on here. Along with more vulnerable, heart-tugging moments too which really balance out the romance.
There's a bit of a 'True Grit' vibe once these two set out on their quest which I really enjoyed. Could almost taste the dust of the trail and feel the saddle sores on my posterior. :-) The action came fast and furious during the last third of the book, but I found the overall resolution felt rushed. I would have liked more 'real time' details to flesh things out.
I can't find any indication that this is the first in a series, but I'm sure hoping it is because Willa has two sisters who deserve happily ever afters too and I'm definitely intrigued by what I've learned about both of them. Here's hoping Love Inspired Trade and the author have plans for a series!
I listened to the audible edition narrated by Carly Robins who added just the right touch of Wild West to her performance. Very enjoyable.
April 20, 2022
These characters! "Plain and simple" Willa Malone is a tough little woman who considers herself a spinster who must care for her younger sisters since their father has been murdered. She will do anything to protect them and their property. The local banker is calling in a loan their father took out. The only way Willa can see fit to pay that loan is to go after the outlaw who stole his life. The bounty will provide the money she requires. She just needs a guide to go with her.
Gideon Hartley, poetry spouting gambler, an alcoholic who daily drowns his heart, tamping down horrific nightmare inducing memories, has a reputation for the best guide in the territory.
What a battle of wills when these two tangle. Two flawed and broken people who's stories lead to a magnetic plot with endearing, at times heart-rending, scenes throughout. What a powerful story! Wonderful characters and a smooth flow to the story from the first page drew me in. The handling of the alcoholic illness is accurate and honest in my opinion.
I want to thank the publisher, Love Inspired, author Linda Goodnight and NetGalley for my advanced reader's copy of this book. This is my unsolicited opinion, I enjoyed this book very much and want to read the stories of the two younger Malone sisters.
Gideon Hartley, poetry spouting gambler, an alcoholic who daily drowns his heart, tamping down horrific nightmare inducing memories, has a reputation for the best guide in the territory.
What a battle of wills when these two tangle. Two flawed and broken people who's stories lead to a magnetic plot with endearing, at times heart-rending, scenes throughout. What a powerful story! Wonderful characters and a smooth flow to the story from the first page drew me in. The handling of the alcoholic illness is accurate and honest in my opinion.
I want to thank the publisher, Love Inspired, author Linda Goodnight and NetGalley for my advanced reader's copy of this book. This is my unsolicited opinion, I enjoyed this book very much and want to read the stories of the two younger Malone sisters.
April 25, 2022
I picked up Claiming Her Legacy because I love Linda Goodnights writing style. Its always clean, heart touchingly relatable and something I know I can pick up and it won’t have something unexpected in it.
In this book I really was impressed by the mix of strength and vulnerability Willa and Gideon both show. Throughout the story you can really see them growing as characters and I LOVED the quiet respect Gideon showed Willa.
The story overall was interesting, and a relaxing read that helped my calm down after a day at work. I recommend read this book and how there will be a sequel (hint, hint).
4 Stars.
*I volunteered to read this book in return for my honest feedback. The thoughts and opinions expressed within are my own.
In this book I really was impressed by the mix of strength and vulnerability Willa and Gideon both show. Throughout the story you can really see them growing as characters and I LOVED the quiet respect Gideon showed Willa.
The story overall was interesting, and a relaxing read that helped my calm down after a day at work. I recommend read this book and how there will be a sequel (hint, hint).
4 Stars.
*I volunteered to read this book in return for my honest feedback. The thoughts and opinions expressed within are my own.
June 8, 2022
A wonderful new historical book by Linda Goodnight. I absolutely loved it!!!!!
April 8, 2022
Thank you in advance to the publisher, Love Inspired (Harlequin Books), for providing an advanced review copy through JustRead Publicity Tours. A positive review was not required nor requested, and all words are my own.
I have to admit – I’m drawn to purple covers. There is just something about them I LOVE. Even better? Storm clouds. A lady with a rifle? That’s giving off some strong old western TV show (or movie) vibes. I’m not into westerns, but this cover truly grabbed me.
As of note, my mom grew up on westerns – especially “family” type ones like Bonanza and The Big Valley. I have to admit, this book kind of gave me The Big Valley vibe, which was my favorite of the western series.
Another, interesting reference – the Malone family got their land in the Oklahoma Land Rush in 1889, roughly a year before the story takes place. The Oklahoma Land Rush was also mentioned, and a HUGE part of the Far and Away (1992) plot.
So, those who have seen the series and movie I referenced might be interested in this.
That said …
Those not familiar to the LOVE INSPIRED (LI) line (trade – books like this, or the smaller monthly ones) – these are generally a “Christian” themed line from Harlequin. As a result, these will have strong tenets of the Christian faith, some more so than others. There will be mentions of God, trusting Jesus, using or mentioning prayer.
This book is the first “trade” version I’ve read, although I do have another one I bought, it is stuck in the never-ending TBR stack. While I don’t know how that one fares with regard to the “Christian” element – this one definitely has FAR stronger themes than the smaller books. As this author is new-to-me, I don’t know if that is her particular writing style or with this being expanded, it is more heavily mentioned.
That didn’t bother me as it really fit the story and the situations, but it MIGHT bother some readers. I didn’t find it too “preachy”, but some readers might. There is a reference Willa makes about her sister Mercy being a better Christian than she is because of the thoughts she has. This has been a contentious point for some reviewers.
LI books are also “cleaner” reads – there are no off-page or referenced intimate scenes and language is kept mild (even free from common “barnyard” language).
And, given that this is “historical” or western, there is some language that could “offend” today’s readers, especially in today’s climate where the words and tone are different. Words used: lame, cripple, gimp(y). Even the term “Indian” could be offensive when applied towards Native Americans.
Some of the themes and elements are authentic to the time and not necessarily accepted today – particularly when it comes to Native Americans, “First People”, or “Nations” and incidents between them and the settlers. The author remains authentic to the time period, though not taking a stand one way or the other.
Another notion that might offend some – Willa’s age of 30 being considered as an old spinster. There were expectations of women with regard to their ages. Also, it was believed that women were delicate and weak, thus unable to do things – hence why a man was needed and often required. In addition, there is reference to an older man attempting to use Savannah as a “brood mare”. While reprehensible, that was the time back then. Saying that does not excuse it, but rather puts it into perspective for understanding and clarity – as well as being “realistic”.
One caveat about creating a story set in such times is adhering to authenticity in language, social settings, as well as the culture. The author manages to do this incredibly well with the characters. Though one complaint of mine is that some of the language seemed far too modern for the book, set in 1890 Oklahoma.
The characters are in line with the genre of the book:
🏡 Willa Malone (30; old spinster, tomboy, head of the household)
🩺 Mercy Malone (age unknown; middle sister; the “healer”)
🏡 Savannah Malone (20; the “lame” sister, cook, and lover of fanciful things; the one Homer has his eye on)
🐎 Gideon Hartley (former tracker, currently a drunk)
⛪ Isaiah Baker (a friend of Gideon’s; Godly man)
🏦 Theodore Pierce (banker, smarmy)
💰 Charlie Bangs (man who shot Finn Malone; bounty on him could pay off the Malone loan)
👒 Belle Holbrook (widow, enigma, business partner of Gideon)
Despite the myriad of characters, the story is told only from Willa and Gideon’s POV. Though I would’ve loved Mercy’s POV as well as Belle’s.
As far as “trigger” and content warnings – there are also elements and/or mentions of: prostitution, mail order brides, excessive drinking, mentions of slavery and aftermath, thoughts of suicide expressed, graphic description of a burn victim, as well as a child orphaned when his entire family dies (common occurrence in those days).
The characters are wonderfully crafted and portrayed – from the bad guys to the good guys. I have to admit that Willa was definitely a favorite of mine. Gideon was an on/off favorite of mine.
Claiming Her Legacy is appropriately titled given the plot of the story. And, the first two lines really got my attention: “Papa was dead. Murdered.”
Finn Malone has been murdered by Charlie Bangs in what appears to be a case of claim jumping. But, Finn left his three daughters with a note on their land – if they can’t pay it, they will lose their home. They are also barely getting by. The only option Willa has – get the outlaw and collect the bounty. She gets the idea after a bounty hunter, who was looking for Charlie, is killed.
To do that – she needs a guide/tracker. That brings her to Gideon.
Unfortunately, Gideon is in no condition to lead Willa. Even if he was – he doesn’t want to. He’s out of the business for personal reasons. He’s also a drunk. He can’t seem to quit drinking without severe side effects (today’s common withdrawal symptoms).
Willa is desperate and hounds Gideon. It isn’t revenge driving her, it is the fact that Pierce (the banker) has called in the loan sooner – due two months earlier than he agreed. He does offer to buy the property but Willa doesn’t want to sell. In addition, the elderly Homer Baggley seems set on “courting” Savannah, even telling Willa they’re engaged (they’re not).
After seeing Willa with Pierce, Gideon decides to agree to help Willa. Of course, he doesn’t say “when” they’ll set out on their “hunt”. That is until an issue with one of Isaiah’s kids puts Gideon’s drinking problem into perspective.
Willa gets Gideon through a rough and traumatic process. (Those who’ve watched family members might be disturbed by it – which is the only reason I mentioned it).
Willa doesn’t understand why Gideon is drinking – it has to do with his family. Still, he tries to warn her about what she is getting into with hunting Charlie Bangs. Still, Willa has no choice.
There are some sweet moments between Gideon and Willa before they set out on their journey. Willa even admits to herself she’d loved to be wanted and chosen but feels she’s been on the shelf too long. [Back in that time – she actually was].
The “bounty-hunting” doesn’t start until about 58% of the way in. The trip isn’t free of calamity – even the death of some travelers leave the two with a hard decision to make.
As the two hunt down Charlie, Gideon begins to think he might want a future with Willa, but he has to resolve a past with his father, though that won’t be easy given what happened in that past.
The ending is somewhat predictable overall, but there are some surprises I didn’t see coming. There are a few loose ends – Homer, who I wonder what happened to; and figuring out about the boy who drowned because of Gideon.
Given the type of book this is, the chapters – except for a few – are relatively short. This keeps the story on pace without slugging along or racing towards the end. The author uses engaging dialogue, and some unique “big” words – one of my favorites was “vexatious”. The author definitely drew me right in and kept me reading until the very end.
I couldn’t put it down and finished it inside of a 15-hour period with a few breaks. I did read most of it (about 70%) inside of a 2-hour period. Quick note – the book shows no sign of wear. That’s how fast I read it.
I loved the realistic feel the author brought to the novel and at times felt like I was watching a movie or a mini-series. Of course, one aspect that could be funny or downright annoying – Willa seemingly wanting to shoot people who irritated her or annoyed her. Is it bad to say I almost agreed with her?
The issue of prostitution (sex workers in the brothels/bordellos) is addressed through the human trafficking angle. While it is true that did happen, there were women who did willingly work at saloons.
There were two types to be honest – the ones who worked at brothels and the dance girls. Dance girls wouldn’t be caught with the “workers”. In fact, “many were widows or needy women of good morals, forced to earn a living in an era that offered few means for women to do so.” (https://www.legendsofamerica.com/we-p...)
Claiming Her Legacy is an intensely deep and rich book that delves into the harshness of what settler life was like, sacrifices that families made. It is emotionally gripping, suspenseful, as well as inspiring.
That’s not to say there weren’t moments of levity or humor:
Page 22 – “Homer was sixty if he was a day and only washed once a year if the creek was high and warm.”
Page 167 – (Gideon) “I was out for a stroll and saw three lovely ladies walking alone. Perhaps you’d allow me to walk with you.”
Willa snorted “Why would you walk? You have a horse.”
“Well, look at that. He must’ve followed me.”
I definitely wouldn���t hesitate to read another book by Linda Goodnight, and since this seems like a standalone book, I am a bit disappointed in not being able to revisit these characters again.
I have to admit – I’m drawn to purple covers. There is just something about them I LOVE. Even better? Storm clouds. A lady with a rifle? That’s giving off some strong old western TV show (or movie) vibes. I’m not into westerns, but this cover truly grabbed me.
As of note, my mom grew up on westerns – especially “family” type ones like Bonanza and The Big Valley. I have to admit, this book kind of gave me The Big Valley vibe, which was my favorite of the western series.
Another, interesting reference – the Malone family got their land in the Oklahoma Land Rush in 1889, roughly a year before the story takes place. The Oklahoma Land Rush was also mentioned, and a HUGE part of the Far and Away (1992) plot.
So, those who have seen the series and movie I referenced might be interested in this.
That said …
Those not familiar to the LOVE INSPIRED (LI) line (trade – books like this, or the smaller monthly ones) – these are generally a “Christian” themed line from Harlequin. As a result, these will have strong tenets of the Christian faith, some more so than others. There will be mentions of God, trusting Jesus, using or mentioning prayer.
This book is the first “trade” version I’ve read, although I do have another one I bought, it is stuck in the never-ending TBR stack. While I don’t know how that one fares with regard to the “Christian” element – this one definitely has FAR stronger themes than the smaller books. As this author is new-to-me, I don’t know if that is her particular writing style or with this being expanded, it is more heavily mentioned.
That didn’t bother me as it really fit the story and the situations, but it MIGHT bother some readers. I didn’t find it too “preachy”, but some readers might. There is a reference Willa makes about her sister Mercy being a better Christian than she is because of the thoughts she has. This has been a contentious point for some reviewers.
LI books are also “cleaner” reads – there are no off-page or referenced intimate scenes and language is kept mild (even free from common “barnyard” language).
And, given that this is “historical” or western, there is some language that could “offend” today’s readers, especially in today’s climate where the words and tone are different. Words used: lame, cripple, gimp(y). Even the term “Indian” could be offensive when applied towards Native Americans.
Some of the themes and elements are authentic to the time and not necessarily accepted today – particularly when it comes to Native Americans, “First People”, or “Nations” and incidents between them and the settlers. The author remains authentic to the time period, though not taking a stand one way or the other.
Another notion that might offend some – Willa’s age of 30 being considered as an old spinster. There were expectations of women with regard to their ages. Also, it was believed that women were delicate and weak, thus unable to do things – hence why a man was needed and often required. In addition, there is reference to an older man attempting to use Savannah as a “brood mare”. While reprehensible, that was the time back then. Saying that does not excuse it, but rather puts it into perspective for understanding and clarity – as well as being “realistic”.
One caveat about creating a story set in such times is adhering to authenticity in language, social settings, as well as the culture. The author manages to do this incredibly well with the characters. Though one complaint of mine is that some of the language seemed far too modern for the book, set in 1890 Oklahoma.
The characters are in line with the genre of the book:
🏡 Willa Malone (30; old spinster, tomboy, head of the household)
🩺 Mercy Malone (age unknown; middle sister; the “healer”)
🏡 Savannah Malone (20; the “lame” sister, cook, and lover of fanciful things; the one Homer has his eye on)
🐎 Gideon Hartley (former tracker, currently a drunk)
⛪ Isaiah Baker (a friend of Gideon’s; Godly man)
🏦 Theodore Pierce (banker, smarmy)
💰 Charlie Bangs (man who shot Finn Malone; bounty on him could pay off the Malone loan)
👒 Belle Holbrook (widow, enigma, business partner of Gideon)
Despite the myriad of characters, the story is told only from Willa and Gideon’s POV. Though I would’ve loved Mercy’s POV as well as Belle’s.
As far as “trigger” and content warnings – there are also elements and/or mentions of: prostitution, mail order brides, excessive drinking, mentions of slavery and aftermath, thoughts of suicide expressed, graphic description of a burn victim, as well as a child orphaned when his entire family dies (common occurrence in those days).
The characters are wonderfully crafted and portrayed – from the bad guys to the good guys. I have to admit that Willa was definitely a favorite of mine. Gideon was an on/off favorite of mine.
Claiming Her Legacy is appropriately titled given the plot of the story. And, the first two lines really got my attention: “Papa was dead. Murdered.”
Finn Malone has been murdered by Charlie Bangs in what appears to be a case of claim jumping. But, Finn left his three daughters with a note on their land – if they can’t pay it, they will lose their home. They are also barely getting by. The only option Willa has – get the outlaw and collect the bounty. She gets the idea after a bounty hunter, who was looking for Charlie, is killed.
To do that – she needs a guide/tracker. That brings her to Gideon.
Unfortunately, Gideon is in no condition to lead Willa. Even if he was – he doesn’t want to. He’s out of the business for personal reasons. He’s also a drunk. He can’t seem to quit drinking without severe side effects (today’s common withdrawal symptoms).
Willa is desperate and hounds Gideon. It isn’t revenge driving her, it is the fact that Pierce (the banker) has called in the loan sooner – due two months earlier than he agreed. He does offer to buy the property but Willa doesn’t want to sell. In addition, the elderly Homer Baggley seems set on “courting” Savannah, even telling Willa they’re engaged (they’re not).
After seeing Willa with Pierce, Gideon decides to agree to help Willa. Of course, he doesn’t say “when” they’ll set out on their “hunt”. That is until an issue with one of Isaiah’s kids puts Gideon’s drinking problem into perspective.
Willa gets Gideon through a rough and traumatic process. (Those who’ve watched family members might be disturbed by it – which is the only reason I mentioned it).
Willa doesn’t understand why Gideon is drinking – it has to do with his family. Still, he tries to warn her about what she is getting into with hunting Charlie Bangs. Still, Willa has no choice.
There are some sweet moments between Gideon and Willa before they set out on their journey. Willa even admits to herself she’d loved to be wanted and chosen but feels she’s been on the shelf too long. [Back in that time – she actually was].
The “bounty-hunting” doesn’t start until about 58% of the way in. The trip isn’t free of calamity – even the death of some travelers leave the two with a hard decision to make.
As the two hunt down Charlie, Gideon begins to think he might want a future with Willa, but he has to resolve a past with his father, though that won’t be easy given what happened in that past.
The ending is somewhat predictable overall, but there are some surprises I didn’t see coming. There are a few loose ends – Homer, who I wonder what happened to; and figuring out about the boy who drowned because of Gideon.
Given the type of book this is, the chapters – except for a few – are relatively short. This keeps the story on pace without slugging along or racing towards the end. The author uses engaging dialogue, and some unique “big” words – one of my favorites was “vexatious”. The author definitely drew me right in and kept me reading until the very end.
I couldn’t put it down and finished it inside of a 15-hour period with a few breaks. I did read most of it (about 70%) inside of a 2-hour period. Quick note – the book shows no sign of wear. That’s how fast I read it.
I loved the realistic feel the author brought to the novel and at times felt like I was watching a movie or a mini-series. Of course, one aspect that could be funny or downright annoying – Willa seemingly wanting to shoot people who irritated her or annoyed her. Is it bad to say I almost agreed with her?
The issue of prostitution (sex workers in the brothels/bordellos) is addressed through the human trafficking angle. While it is true that did happen, there were women who did willingly work at saloons.
There were two types to be honest – the ones who worked at brothels and the dance girls. Dance girls wouldn’t be caught with the “workers”. In fact, “many were widows or needy women of good morals, forced to earn a living in an era that offered few means for women to do so.” (https://www.legendsofamerica.com/we-p...)
Claiming Her Legacy is an intensely deep and rich book that delves into the harshness of what settler life was like, sacrifices that families made. It is emotionally gripping, suspenseful, as well as inspiring.
That’s not to say there weren’t moments of levity or humor:
Page 22 – “Homer was sixty if he was a day and only washed once a year if the creek was high and warm.”
Page 167 – (Gideon) “I was out for a stroll and saw three lovely ladies walking alone. Perhaps you’d allow me to walk with you.”
Willa snorted “Why would you walk? You have a horse.”
“Well, look at that. He must’ve followed me.”
I definitely wouldn���t hesitate to read another book by Linda Goodnight, and since this seems like a standalone book, I am a bit disappointed in not being able to revisit these characters again.
April 11, 2022
Claiming Her Legacy had the perfect pace as it set the scene and introduced the characters before they embarked on their adventure. Linda Goodnight wrote each side character with just the right amount of story and mystery that I found myself throughout the book hoping that each of them gets their own story. Willa and Gideon are my new favourite couple, two strong people battling their own weaknesses and insecurities while longing for love and meaning. I just love Willa, she’s tough, practical and no-nonsense but deep inside she’s like every other female who just wants to be treasured and beautiful. She felt so real with her mix of staunchness and vulnerability. If you’re like me and love a ‘reformed bad boy’ trope, then Gideon will hit you in all right places. There’s a delightful romantic tension throughout the book and though the build up is slow I didn’t even notice or mind because I was so caught up in the story. And like any slow build up, the ending is sooo satisfying!
I was gifted a copy of this book but all views and opinions are my own.
I was gifted a copy of this book but all views and opinions are my own.
March 29, 2022
I am so very happy to see that Love Inspired is publishing the historical line again, even though it is only temporary. The Historical line is what drew me to read Love Inspired books. Now, they are publishing full length trade books. You will get the same Clean, Christian books, but at full length.
Claiming Her Legacy is written by Linda Goodnight. It is set back in 1890 Oklahoma. Willa and her two sisters, Mercy and Savannah are struggling to keep their family farm afloat after their father is murdered. Willa, the tomboy and headstrong of the sisters, wants to hunt down her father's killer so that they can collect the bounty that is on his head and save their farm. Willa, does not know a thing about tracking nor the danger that awaits her.
Gideon is a seasoned trail guide. He is in Sweet Clover numbing the pain of his past with whiskey. When he is first approached to be Willa's guide, he tells her no way, and she is crazy for wanting to do so. However, Gideon is captivated by Willa. He is battling his own demons and does not feel he is worthy to protect her on the journey. Eventually, he agrees
The journey that these two take is quite the interesting one. Willa is learning so much and she is tough. Gideon is battling nightmares and trying to keep them both safe. The book is well written, the characters are well developed. This was a great Western Historical Romance. The author has done a fine job with her descriptions of scenes. I love when I can close my eyes and see what I am reading.
I would love to see the sister's story continue. I am hoping that the author writes their stories also.
Thank you to the publisher, author, NetGalley and JustRead Publicity tours for allowing me to read a copy of this book. All thoughts are my own.
Claiming Her Legacy is written by Linda Goodnight. It is set back in 1890 Oklahoma. Willa and her two sisters, Mercy and Savannah are struggling to keep their family farm afloat after their father is murdered. Willa, the tomboy and headstrong of the sisters, wants to hunt down her father's killer so that they can collect the bounty that is on his head and save their farm. Willa, does not know a thing about tracking nor the danger that awaits her.
Gideon is a seasoned trail guide. He is in Sweet Clover numbing the pain of his past with whiskey. When he is first approached to be Willa's guide, he tells her no way, and she is crazy for wanting to do so. However, Gideon is captivated by Willa. He is battling his own demons and does not feel he is worthy to protect her on the journey. Eventually, he agrees
The journey that these two take is quite the interesting one. Willa is learning so much and she is tough. Gideon is battling nightmares and trying to keep them both safe. The book is well written, the characters are well developed. This was a great Western Historical Romance. The author has done a fine job with her descriptions of scenes. I love when I can close my eyes and see what I am reading.
I would love to see the sister's story continue. I am hoping that the author writes their stories also.
Thank you to the publisher, author, NetGalley and JustRead Publicity tours for allowing me to read a copy of this book. All thoughts are my own.
April 4, 2022
Her dead father's debt is being called in, which puts Willa and her sister's livelihood at risk. But she will need the help of tracker Gideon Hartley in order to stand a chance bringing her father's killer to justice.
Willa is capable and determined, knowing that her sisters depend on her to keep their homestead going. She is understandably cautious and intrigued by the enigmatic Gideon, who despite all of his faults is one of the few people who sees her and treats her with respect.
The sisters are very close despite their differing upbringings, and I liked that they all are determined to do what it takes to save their land. The beginning is slower in pace to the rest of the book, but it helps to set the scene, introduce the characters establish the relationships.
Overall, this was an entertaining read with compelling characters, strong family ties, faith and grit. I liked how Gideon treats Willa right from the beginning, making her feel respected and seen. The story builds as it goes along with strong faith and character growth. Definitely a solidly enjoyable read!
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
Willa is capable and determined, knowing that her sisters depend on her to keep their homestead going. She is understandably cautious and intrigued by the enigmatic Gideon, who despite all of his faults is one of the few people who sees her and treats her with respect.
The sisters are very close despite their differing upbringings, and I liked that they all are determined to do what it takes to save their land. The beginning is slower in pace to the rest of the book, but it helps to set the scene, introduce the characters establish the relationships.
Overall, this was an entertaining read with compelling characters, strong family ties, faith and grit. I liked how Gideon treats Willa right from the beginning, making her feel respected and seen. The story builds as it goes along with strong faith and character growth. Definitely a solidly enjoyable read!
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
April 7, 2022
Claiming Her Legacy is a wonderful story filled with redemption, justice, love, and healing. The characters of Willa & Gideon are portrayed by showing their strengths as well as their flaws. I enjoyed reading about their growth as the story unfolded. Willa is independent, and strong beyond what she should be, also very determined. Gideon, taken over by hatred, regret, and alcohol lives haunted by the past. Together, they bring out the best in each other.
The storyline is filled with adventure, peril, and times of great danger. Also, times of compassion. The story had me running all the emotions. A very well-written and inspirational God-filled story which I highly recommend.
I received a complimentary copy of the book and a positive review is not required. All opinions are my own.
The storyline is filled with adventure, peril, and times of great danger. Also, times of compassion. The story had me running all the emotions. A very well-written and inspirational God-filled story which I highly recommend.
I received a complimentary copy of the book and a positive review is not required. All opinions are my own.
April 3, 2022
alright here’s the thing, there were many things in this book i didn’t like that i am well aware came along with the time period of which this is written.
for instance,
1. our naive main character assuming that girls in the saloon working, actually want to be there and chose that life- when indeed that’s not the case for many. i was glad that was addressed at the end of the book.
2. the amount of times the women are described as “delicate” making them “unable” to do things.
3. or the sister with a disability that is called “lame” like that of a horse in that time period. didn’t like it, but i also feel like i can’t criticize it too much because no one is claiming that it’s right- only describing things how they were often “portrayed” in that period. like a woman being too “delicate” to do certain things (definitely goes back to a patriarchal based time)
4. comments of “indian territory” and not having good run ins with “them”, and what not. clearly prejudice comments that were unfortunately the more widespread opinion of the time- especially to those uneducated. it didn’t sit well with me.
5. speaking of uneducated, our main girl referring to herself as “stupid” because she couldn’t read. i didn’t like it- but, i unfortunately have to keep the time period in mind on how things were described and what people said about those not going to school and crap (though I’m most definitely not saying it’s right, bc we all know it’s not [or should know by now]).
there are more things but i’m not going to go on and on
i liked that our main girl challenged a lot of the norms of that time.
completely unrelated but i wish our first kiss scene was better but i suppose i’ve been spoiled with all my other romance novels lmao. i suppose the minimal sentence description of her first kiss with the guy is because it is “christian-based.” personally, i wish the scene was a bit better/longer bc of all the build up, but i am keeping in mind that the author is older and is writing in what she is probably most comfortable with and raised “good” or not, for someone to be writing. also i know that writing anything sensual is highly discouraged for certain christians so i wasn’t surprised in the slightest.
i didn’t realize going into the book that it was christian based. i myself am a christian and i will admit that normally i don’t read many christian books for fear of the writing being taken in the most extreme way (srry it’s difficult to explain). for instance, there was a time in the book our girl was saying her sister was a better christian than her because she had more bad thoughts like wacking men over the head and what not. i personally don’t believe that made our girl any less christian- only human. i know i have those thoughts atleast 10 times a day. in those same scenes i was thinking the same thing as our mc. maybe for the author that would make me appear as not “as good of a christian” in her eyes, but i disagree. everyone has thoughts and sins all of the time with or without knowing and that doesn’t make you a “better” or “worse” christian than someone else. there are no levels of christianity in someone being higher or lower up than the other.
shortening this review, i definitely felt like i could actually resonate with our main girl who was openly opinionated and strong willed- so i’m grateful she was our mc because had she not i probably would have found it much harder to connect (personally). i liked that bible verses and things were brought up that i myself haven’t heard in some time. overall i liked it, didn’t love it- but am happy that this random ass book i picked up purely for the cover (bc currently watching 1883 😗) turned out to be not as bad as i thought
i’ve got two more mom books from walmart to read so GET READY 🤓😎🥵🤭🤯
for instance,
1. our naive main character assuming that girls in the saloon working, actually want to be there and chose that life- when indeed that’s not the case for many. i was glad that was addressed at the end of the book.
2. the amount of times the women are described as “delicate” making them “unable” to do things.
3. or the sister with a disability that is called “lame” like that of a horse in that time period. didn’t like it, but i also feel like i can’t criticize it too much because no one is claiming that it’s right- only describing things how they were often “portrayed” in that period. like a woman being too “delicate” to do certain things (definitely goes back to a patriarchal based time)
4. comments of “indian territory” and not having good run ins with “them”, and what not. clearly prejudice comments that were unfortunately the more widespread opinion of the time- especially to those uneducated. it didn’t sit well with me.
5. speaking of uneducated, our main girl referring to herself as “stupid” because she couldn’t read. i didn’t like it- but, i unfortunately have to keep the time period in mind on how things were described and what people said about those not going to school and crap (though I’m most definitely not saying it’s right, bc we all know it’s not [or should know by now]).
there are more things but i’m not going to go on and on
i liked that our main girl challenged a lot of the norms of that time.
completely unrelated but i wish our first kiss scene was better but i suppose i’ve been spoiled with all my other romance novels lmao. i suppose the minimal sentence description of her first kiss with the guy is because it is “christian-based.” personally, i wish the scene was a bit better/longer bc of all the build up, but i am keeping in mind that the author is older and is writing in what she is probably most comfortable with and raised “good” or not, for someone to be writing. also i know that writing anything sensual is highly discouraged for certain christians so i wasn’t surprised in the slightest.
i didn’t realize going into the book that it was christian based. i myself am a christian and i will admit that normally i don’t read many christian books for fear of the writing being taken in the most extreme way (srry it’s difficult to explain). for instance, there was a time in the book our girl was saying her sister was a better christian than her because she had more bad thoughts like wacking men over the head and what not. i personally don’t believe that made our girl any less christian- only human. i know i have those thoughts atleast 10 times a day. in those same scenes i was thinking the same thing as our mc. maybe for the author that would make me appear as not “as good of a christian” in her eyes, but i disagree. everyone has thoughts and sins all of the time with or without knowing and that doesn’t make you a “better” or “worse” christian than someone else. there are no levels of christianity in someone being higher or lower up than the other.
shortening this review, i definitely felt like i could actually resonate with our main girl who was openly opinionated and strong willed- so i’m grateful she was our mc because had she not i probably would have found it much harder to connect (personally). i liked that bible verses and things were brought up that i myself haven’t heard in some time. overall i liked it, didn’t love it- but am happy that this random ass book i picked up purely for the cover (bc currently watching 1883 😗) turned out to be not as bad as i thought
i’ve got two more mom books from walmart to read so GET READY 🤓😎🥵🤭🤯
April 13, 2022
I am a sucker for a good frontier story. I blame Little House on the Prairie for a portion of that devotion, but I think it’s more about the grit and determination it must’ve taken to live during such primitive times, and Claiming Her Legacy shows a side that is hard to imagine.
Willa Malone is not only mourning the death of her father, who was killed in a senseless robbery while mining for gold, but is also tasked with caring for her two younger sisters, working their flailing homestead, and trying to repay the many debts that were left by her father. The desperation this poor woman feels is palpable, and my heart went out to her, almost feeling the weight mount on my own shoulders. She didn't ask for this lot in life, but she is fighting with everything she has, as this is truly her last shot. Talk about strength! I can only imagine that desperation!
Gideon Hartley, the washed up bounty hunter that Willa pesters like a gnat to help her find her father’s killer, is a character we all can identify with. He has quit the tracking life and has succumbed to escapism in the form of drinking, a vice that he can’t seem to free himself from. Though not all of us can understand that kind of thirst I believe we all have had a similar struggle in some form or another, and thus can identify the inner struggle that Gideon endures throughout the story.
Claiming Her Legacy is a novel that has it all. Suspense, intrigue, love, and hope shroud this story, enveloping you in this world. You will find yourself cheering for the girls, hoping that they will all get their happily ever after. They are truly inspiring in their own right, flaws and all. The ending is sheer perfection and I found myself with a goofy grin on my face, completely satisfied with this novel.
It’s truly a charming read and one that I highly recommend.
*I have voluntarily reviewed a copy of this book which I received from the author/publisher through JustRead Tours. All views and opinions expressed are completely honest, and my own.
Willa Malone is not only mourning the death of her father, who was killed in a senseless robbery while mining for gold, but is also tasked with caring for her two younger sisters, working their flailing homestead, and trying to repay the many debts that were left by her father. The desperation this poor woman feels is palpable, and my heart went out to her, almost feeling the weight mount on my own shoulders. She didn't ask for this lot in life, but she is fighting with everything she has, as this is truly her last shot. Talk about strength! I can only imagine that desperation!
Gideon Hartley, the washed up bounty hunter that Willa pesters like a gnat to help her find her father’s killer, is a character we all can identify with. He has quit the tracking life and has succumbed to escapism in the form of drinking, a vice that he can’t seem to free himself from. Though not all of us can understand that kind of thirst I believe we all have had a similar struggle in some form or another, and thus can identify the inner struggle that Gideon endures throughout the story.
Claiming Her Legacy is a novel that has it all. Suspense, intrigue, love, and hope shroud this story, enveloping you in this world. You will find yourself cheering for the girls, hoping that they will all get their happily ever after. They are truly inspiring in their own right, flaws and all. The ending is sheer perfection and I found myself with a goofy grin on my face, completely satisfied with this novel.
It’s truly a charming read and one that I highly recommend.
*I have voluntarily reviewed a copy of this book which I received from the author/publisher through JustRead Tours. All views and opinions expressed are completely honest, and my own.
September 2, 2022
Claiming Her Legacy by Linda Goodnight is a Love Inspired Trade historical romance.
I love historical westerns, so I’ve been looking forward to reading this story. While it wasn’t exactly what I was expecting, I loved it! It deep and captivating and so well written.
Gideon is an amazing hero. Flawed and wrestling with his demons, but seeing how he cared for those round him was definitely swoon-worthy. And Willa’s strength and sacrifice is well-balanced with a compassionate side no one would expect.
The story has lots of danger and sweet romance as well as spiritual lessons. I’ll add a trigger warning for anyone battling sobriety issues, as Gideon is, too, but I liked that he doesn’t find an easy fix. It shows the complex nature of his situation.
If you’re looking for a historical western romance with plenty of danger, and great characters, then definitely try Claiming Her Legacy.
—
I received a complimentary copy of this book from JustRead Tours. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with FTC guidelines.
I love historical westerns, so I’ve been looking forward to reading this story. While it wasn’t exactly what I was expecting, I loved it! It deep and captivating and so well written.
Gideon is an amazing hero. Flawed and wrestling with his demons, but seeing how he cared for those round him was definitely swoon-worthy. And Willa’s strength and sacrifice is well-balanced with a compassionate side no one would expect.
The story has lots of danger and sweet romance as well as spiritual lessons. I’ll add a trigger warning for anyone battling sobriety issues, as Gideon is, too, but I liked that he doesn’t find an easy fix. It shows the complex nature of his situation.
If you’re looking for a historical western romance with plenty of danger, and great characters, then definitely try Claiming Her Legacy.
—
I received a complimentary copy of this book from JustRead Tours. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with FTC guidelines.
May 2, 2022
Claiming Her Legacy is the first book I’ve read by Linda Goodnight even though she’s authored a good number of books.
Goodnight brings the reader along as Willa and her two half-sisters fight to keep their home and Gideon fights his demons with whiskey. The first half of the book is focused on character development and setting up the second half of the book and drags once in a while, but the wait is worth the payoff.
And I can’t help but wonder whether we’ll see some of these secondary characters in future books.
Disclosure statement: I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book and was not required to write a positive review. All opinions are my own.
Goodnight brings the reader along as Willa and her two half-sisters fight to keep their home and Gideon fights his demons with whiskey. The first half of the book is focused on character development and setting up the second half of the book and drags once in a while, but the wait is worth the payoff.
And I can’t help but wonder whether we’ll see some of these secondary characters in future books.
Disclosure statement: I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book and was not required to write a positive review. All opinions are my own.
May 12, 2022
Ohhhh! How I hope this is book #1 of many! :)
July 3, 2022
After her father's murder, Willa is left to manage the ranch and her two younger sisters. Trouble with a slippery banker whose calling in their loans and a pushy suitor she's not interested in, lead her to conclude the only way out is to hunt down her father's kill and use the bounty to pay off her debts.
But she needs help.
Gideon's well-known as the best tracker in the region, but he's stuck in a rut of alcoholism. If she can convince him to guide her, can he get sober, and stay that way to accomplish their mission. Trust is hard to earn.
Willa's a strong, independent woman who considers herself well into spinsterhood. But as they travel together her heart begins to hope, until she finally realizes the danger she's put them in. If you enjoy action in a western setting you'll like this one!
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for the ARC and the opportunity to post an honest review.
But she needs help.
Gideon's well-known as the best tracker in the region, but he's stuck in a rut of alcoholism. If she can convince him to guide her, can he get sober, and stay that way to accomplish their mission. Trust is hard to earn.
Willa's a strong, independent woman who considers herself well into spinsterhood. But as they travel together her heart begins to hope, until she finally realizes the danger she's put them in. If you enjoy action in a western setting you'll like this one!
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for the ARC and the opportunity to post an honest review.
April 12, 2022
Willa is determined to find her father’s killer and in turn save their home. She needs Gideon who was a tracker to help her. Can the two together find her father’s killer?
I don’t read a lot of westerns but this one was really good!
I liked Willa, her toughness and her desire to do what is right. Gideon wrestling with his own demons finds his way too. It’s a good story you will definitely enjoy
Thanks to the publisher for the early copy
I don’t read a lot of westerns but this one was really good!
I liked Willa, her toughness and her desire to do what is right. Gideon wrestling with his own demons finds his way too. It’s a good story you will definitely enjoy
Thanks to the publisher for the early copy
April 1, 2024
-I LOVE THIS STORY SO MUCH!
-When I read the book description I had a feeling that this was a Christian Fiction version of True Grit and boy I was SO excited to read that! I was NOT disappointed! For me it is EXACTLY that!
-I LOVE the Faith woven throughout the whole thing with the scriptures and prayers, but also with the real life struggles of the characters!
-I LOVE these characters, and the twists and turns of the plot, and the toughness of the female lead!
-I LOVED that I could relate to Willa on SO many levels and how raw certain parts of the plot are.
-I long for more from these characters and to see what happens with some of the sub characters!
-I am SO happy The Lord blessed me with finding and reading this new to me author and her story! In five simple words: I just LOVE this book!
-When I read the book description I had a feeling that this was a Christian Fiction version of True Grit and boy I was SO excited to read that! I was NOT disappointed! For me it is EXACTLY that!
-I LOVE the Faith woven throughout the whole thing with the scriptures and prayers, but also with the real life struggles of the characters!
-I LOVE these characters, and the twists and turns of the plot, and the toughness of the female lead!
-I LOVED that I could relate to Willa on SO many levels and how raw certain parts of the plot are.
-I long for more from these characters and to see what happens with some of the sub characters!
-I am SO happy The Lord blessed me with finding and reading this new to me author and her story! In five simple words: I just LOVE this book!
April 17, 2024
This month’s prompt of “No place like home” took me straight into a gritty Western that worked well for me. I’m not sure I would have picked up Claiming Her Legacy were it not for Wendy’s review back in 2022. However, that review made me throw it into my next book order, and this turned out to be the perfect time to finally read it.
Home lies right at the center of this novel. Willa Malone and her two younger sisters have been left alone following the murder of her father. Willa’s late father was off hoping to hit it rich in the silver mines and after his death, the women learn that he had mortgaged their small farm to fund his expedition. The bank is ready to foreclose the loan, but Willa has one, last desperate idea to save the small, cramped cabin that she describes as nicest place she has ever lived.
Her last chance to save her home involves hunting down her father’s killer and bringing him to justice – a feat that will entitle her to a $1000.00 reward, a princely sum in 1890 Oklahoma. Willa is no curl tossing fool; she knows she will need a good, experienced person to help her if she's going to save her family's home. And she quickly learns that one of the best trackers in the business is right there in town. He may have retired, but Willa is determined to get Gideon Hartley to help her.
While this novel does feature a grueling and difficult trip through the wilderness to catch the outlaw, Ms. Goodnight spends a larger portion of the book setting up her story world. It’s a narrative choice that could have dragged the story down, but it worked curiously well for me. As the author introduces us to Willa’s family and the town of Sweet Clover, she does a good job of setting up various tensions and secrets in town, as well as creating characters I wanted to know more about.
This is a partial review. You can find the complete text at All About Romance: https://allaboutromance.com/book-revi...
Home lies right at the center of this novel. Willa Malone and her two younger sisters have been left alone following the murder of her father. Willa’s late father was off hoping to hit it rich in the silver mines and after his death, the women learn that he had mortgaged their small farm to fund his expedition. The bank is ready to foreclose the loan, but Willa has one, last desperate idea to save the small, cramped cabin that she describes as nicest place she has ever lived.
Her last chance to save her home involves hunting down her father’s killer and bringing him to justice – a feat that will entitle her to a $1000.00 reward, a princely sum in 1890 Oklahoma. Willa is no curl tossing fool; she knows she will need a good, experienced person to help her if she's going to save her family's home. And she quickly learns that one of the best trackers in the business is right there in town. He may have retired, but Willa is determined to get Gideon Hartley to help her.
While this novel does feature a grueling and difficult trip through the wilderness to catch the outlaw, Ms. Goodnight spends a larger portion of the book setting up her story world. It’s a narrative choice that could have dragged the story down, but it worked curiously well for me. As the author introduces us to Willa’s family and the town of Sweet Clover, she does a good job of setting up various tensions and secrets in town, as well as creating characters I wanted to know more about.
This is a partial review. You can find the complete text at All About Romance: https://allaboutromance.com/book-revi...
March 23, 2022
Willa Malone and her sisters are left in a hard place after their father is killed by a wanted outlaw. His debts threaten to take away their land, the only thing the sisters have left. Without any other option to pay back the loan on their farm, Willa decides she must hunt her father's killer for the reward money. When she asks handsome, troubled trail guide Gideon Hartley for help, she finds there is much more to him than he shows. Battling inner turmoil, dark pasts, rough wilderness, and dangerous gunmen, the two press on in an unforgettable and life-changing adventure.
Author Linda Goodnight writes a book that immediately catches your attention. I knew this was going to be a good read after just a few pages. Willa Malone and her sisters are relatable and feel like real people. Their struggles, along with Gideon and other characters, are raw and heartfelt. I truly enjoy when I feel like I can relate with the fictional people I am reading about. The action, adventure, and suspense throughout the book was well paced and addicting. The redemption, forgiveness, and grace rooted in scripture throughout was refreshing and inspiring. A sweet, clean romance tops off a wonderfully written western Christian fiction novel.
Author Linda Goodnight writes a book that immediately catches your attention. I knew this was going to be a good read after just a few pages. Willa Malone and her sisters are relatable and feel like real people. Their struggles, along with Gideon and other characters, are raw and heartfelt. I truly enjoy when I feel like I can relate with the fictional people I am reading about. The action, adventure, and suspense throughout the book was well paced and addicting. The redemption, forgiveness, and grace rooted in scripture throughout was refreshing and inspiring. A sweet, clean romance tops off a wonderfully written western Christian fiction novel.
April 13, 2022
Willa Malone thought it was a good idea to track down her father’s killer so she could claim the reward for his capture. She would use the money to pay her father’s debts and save the family’s homestead. The only things is she needs Gideon, a broken and has been tracker to help her locate this outlaw.
Gideon has so much guilt for a family tragedy and hatred for his father that he let it nearly ruin his life. It was rewarding to see that he was able to put the past behind him once and for all. It was so encouraging to see that his past did not need to affect his future. Allowing God to help him overcome his weakness and find forgiveness made this an uplifting story.
Relying on her strong sense of justice and Christian conviction, Willa accomplishes the impossible task of going into the unlawful west to look for her father’s killer. If you are familiar with the story of True Grit, Willa reminds me of Maddie Ross. She was my favorite character because of her determination and spunk.
I received a copy of this book by the publisher through NetGalley. I was not required to write a positive review. All opinions are my own.
Gideon has so much guilt for a family tragedy and hatred for his father that he let it nearly ruin his life. It was rewarding to see that he was able to put the past behind him once and for all. It was so encouraging to see that his past did not need to affect his future. Allowing God to help him overcome his weakness and find forgiveness made this an uplifting story.
Relying on her strong sense of justice and Christian conviction, Willa accomplishes the impossible task of going into the unlawful west to look for her father’s killer. If you are familiar with the story of True Grit, Willa reminds me of Maddie Ross. She was my favorite character because of her determination and spunk.
I received a copy of this book by the publisher through NetGalley. I was not required to write a positive review. All opinions are my own.
March 3, 2022
Every once in a while I long to read a good Western romance, and this one hit the spot. Willa Malone is a strong heroine, determined, and fiercely independent. She's tough yet vulnerable. Gideon is a broken man, running from his past, escaping through the whiskey bottle. He is charming and a renowned trail guide, but he has lost his way. Together, these two characters, with their realistically portrayed problems, will discover that with the right person, one can overcome even the most difficult personal trials.
This book had it all: frontier life with all its tough themes, clean romance with a touch of faith, flawed characters the reader could root for, danger and adventure, and a good storyline and plot. It was the perfect escapism for the long winter nights and I thoroughly enjoyed reading it. The author writes well and the characters were well developed and believable. And I just love that cover.
I am glad to have discovered this author and I would definitely read her again. If you like Western romances this one is not to be missed.
This book had it all: frontier life with all its tough themes, clean romance with a touch of faith, flawed characters the reader could root for, danger and adventure, and a good storyline and plot. It was the perfect escapism for the long winter nights and I thoroughly enjoyed reading it. The author writes well and the characters were well developed and believable. And I just love that cover.
I am glad to have discovered this author and I would definitely read her again. If you like Western romances this one is not to be missed.
April 23, 2022
This book was simply so, so good. I was immediately gripped and drawn into the story by the desperation of Willa, a young tomboy spinster who carries the burden of paying off her murdered father’s staggering debt or else losing her family’s homestead to an unscrupulous banker. Her plight weighed on me heavily especially when her only option for raising the needed money was to hire unwilling Gideon, a handsome and charming trail guide who was haunted by his past and was living from drink to drink as he battled his demons. Their journey was filled with suspense and it kept me turning pages late into the night. I loved the way the author skillfully helped the reader understand her characters’ thoughts, motivations, and changing feelings throughout the book as they grew close and began to care for one another. This book is definitely a keeper and one I will read again. Highly recommend! I received an advance copy from the publisher via Netgalley and this voluntary review contains my honest opinions.
November 17, 2022
3.5 stars. This was such a fun story! I loved Willa, she was such a great MC. And Gideon was really well written, too! I loved that he wasn't the typical unrefined male interest, and she wasn't the typical well-bred lady who tries to reform him. Willa was such a strong, brave character -I loved her bold, direct attitude! Though she had some insecurities, she was also strong in her convictions, and happy with who she was. And Gideon, though he battled his demons, was so charming with his poetry infused throughout his conversations. It was a bit predictable, but it still had exciting parts, and the end was really perfect! I'll definitely read more by this author.
I received this book free from the publisher/author. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own.
I received this book free from the publisher/author. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own.
August 28, 2022
I really enjoyed this book by Linda Goodnight. I received this book for my honest review from Netgalley. Although it took me awhile I was able to finish it:). Just needed time! Willa is a spinster, plain and simple she thinks. Her dad is killed by an outlaw and she is determined to get the killer and bring him to justice. She hires Gideon after a lot of talking, and helping him with his alcohol addiction. He has to be clean in order to be focused on the task of finding the killer. Gideon of course does not want Willa to go with him, but she will not take no for an answer. I liked all of the scenes and parts in the book that Willa went into to help Willa get the thieves. Although both her and Gideon almost died. Great Read!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 66 reviews