YOU'RE ONLY YOUNG ONCE (Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer, 1937), directed by George B. Seitz, marks the second installment to what was initially noted to be the "Judge Hardy's Family" series. With a new cast replacing its original stars from the introduction film, A FAMILY AFFAIR (MGM, 1937): Lionel Barrymore by Lewis Stone (Judge Hardy); Spring Byington by Fay Holden (Emily Hardy); Margaret Marquis by Ann Rutherford (Polly Benedict); and Charley Grapewin by Frank Craven (Frank Redman), only Cecilia Parker, Mickey Rooney and Sara Haden have become the only hold-outs resuming their original roles. As for the Wayne Trent character, Eric Linden's picture is seen only through a photograph, while the eldest Hardy daughter, Joan (Julie Hayden) was dropped entirely. Mickey Rooney as Andy Hardy has more to do here than the previous entry, while Cecilia Parker's older sister, MariOn becomes MariAn. Selmer Jackson playing Hoyt Wells returns for the second and last time, while the Frank Redman character, originally played by Charley Grapewin, would be played for the only time by Frank Craven this time around.
For its plot summary, the story begins with a courtroom session with Judge Hardy (Lewis Stone) listening to his latest case. After the case is called to rest, Judge Hardy comes to a conclusion of taking his first vacation away from the bench in eleven years. He takes his wife, Emily (Fay Holden), Aunt Milly (Sara Haden) and their two teenage children, Marian (Cecilia Parker) and Andy (Mickey Rooney) off to Catalina Island where the judge intends on doing some fishing. While there, Marian (Cecilia Parker), still in love with Wayne Trent, finds romance with a young lifeguard named Bill Rand (Ted Pearson), unaware to the fact that she cannot marry him. Andrew (Mickey Rooney), the youngest and only son, becomes acquainted with Josephine "Jerry" Lane (Eleanor Lynn), regardless of the fact that he is now in serious with Polly Benedict (Ann Rutherford), his girl back home in Carvel. Because Josie comes from a respectable family of high society, Andy becomes somebody he isn't in order to make a good impression with her. While the family goes through their personal problems, Judge Hardy (after catching a marlin swordfish, a 280-pound fish which goes in the record book dated August 21, 1937), finds some unexpected news awaiting upon their return home. Looks for Charles Judels (Captain Swenson); Erville Alderson (Dave, the Bailiff); Robert Wayne (Ed Carper); Norman Phillips (Harold "Fish" Face); and Spec O'Donnell in supporting roles.
Although forgotten and overlooked among what was to become known as "The Andy Hardy Series," YOU'RE ONLY YOUNG ONCE was successful enough to produce more installments. Many situations provided are typical but somewhat dull in the proceedings. Lewis Stone makes a satisfactory head of the family, though his advanced age could be overlooked as appearing more grandfatherly than a father figure. Spring Byington would have made a great Mrs. Hardy, but was committed to another series, the now forgotten "Jones Family" (1936-1940) over at 20th Century-Fox Studios.
Never distributed to video cassette, this 79-minute restored edition of YOU'RE ONLY YOUNG ONCE (with the conclusion of Lewis Stone as Judge Hardy talking directly to the viewers thanking them for watching and to look forward for more in later installments in the "Judge Hardy's Family" series), can be found on the Turner Classic Movies cable channel. Next installment: JUDGE HARDY'S CHILDREN (1938). (**1/2)
