This game would have been well received if it was a new IP but alas, it's Dragon Age and this 2024.
People who are surprised by the gameplay and mechanics somehow missed how DA has changed over its iterations. DAO was 15 years ago and this not a retreating to DAO.
First off, the game is GORGEOUS. Whoever hates the environment is salty that it's not brown and grey "gritty". The environment design is on top, it tells stories just like it should while looking great. I don't mind the character's looks as the customization is crazy, sadly BG3 spoiled us on mo cap and it does fall flat in VG at several points and for some of the characters (Bellara's model can't capture the VAs work she's putting in). While we're at the VAs, outstanding work, they're all killing it. The writing? Yeah. Could be better. A lot better. But people who whine about "MCU dialogue" apparently missed quipping has always been a huge part of Bioware humor.
The combat is ... fine. It's defenitely improved on Inquisition and a far cry from DAOs iteration. If one can accept this RPG has a capital A in front, the combat doesn't disappoint.
Story. World ending threat, gather a party, venture worth to chase red herrings, defeat villain. It's the regular DA fare and does it good. The foundations are solid and the villains creepy.