Aquella noche en Río

"That Night in Rio" is a good comedy musical with Don Ameche as an American entertainer who is a look-alike for a prominent Brazilian. When he does an impersonation of Baron Manuel Duarte at the nightclub, he sets the stage for a later engagement when the baron's associates will require a stand-in while the baron is away.

That's the gist of this story, but much of the film is filled with song and dance numbers, with Alice Faye, Carmen Miranda, and Ameche singing. Miranda's numbers often include short but elaborate choreographed routines with several dancers in costume. The comedy occurs on two fronts, but there isn't much of it. The first is in the lover's feuding between Ameche's Larry Martin and Carmen. The second is in Ameche's substitute role as the baron, with Alice Faye, the Baroness Cecilia Duarte, and a business rival of the baron's, Machado (played by J. Carrol Naish).

This may be a familiar theme to movie buffs - it was in "Folies Bergere de Paris" of 1935 with Maurice Chevalier and Merle Oberon, "On the Riviera" of 1951 with Danny Kaye and Gene Tierney, and "Let's Make Love" of 1960 with Yves Montand and Marilyn Monroe. The plot is essentially identical for all of these films but the last. And, the original was the best one going into 1951 when "On the Riviera" was made. That is by far and away the best of all of these. It received two Academy Award nominations, and Danny Kaye won the best actor Golden Globe for his performance.

While this film can't hold a candle to either the 1935 or 1951 versions, it is entertaining. Those who especially like the beat and rhythm of South American music should enjoy this film. That overpowers the comedy and takes up much of the story.

Here's the best line in this film. Arthur Penna (S. Z. Sakall) is watching Larry Martin as he's impersonating the baron with the baron's wife, played by Alice Faye. Penna says to Felicio (played by Curt Bois), "It's hard to tell when he leaves off and she begins."