A STRANGER AT THE DOOR (TV movie 2004)
3.7 out of 10 stars Time to Read:1:33
BASIC PLOT:
Kathleen Norris's (
Linda Purl) son, whom she gave up for adoption when she was just sixteen, has returned to her life. Only it's not just her life he's returned to, she has a husband now, Greg (
Perry King) and a stepdaughter, Tara (
Meredith Henderson). Her "son" says his name is Jamie Fisher (
Andrew Kraulis), and he seems like everything Kathleen could hope for. But there's something that's just not right about his story, and it seems Tara is the only one who notices. Can she convince her parents he's not who he says he is in time to save them all?
WHAT WORKS:
*
Linda Purl &
Perry King have good couple energy. They seem comfortable in each other's personal space, and have a genuine kindness between the two. It adds to the believability of the story (it's about the only thing that does).
WHAT DOESN'T WORK:
*WHY IS TARA NORRIS SO SUSPICIOUS OF JAMIE FISHER? Right off the bat, Tara is suspicious for NO REASON! People need motivations, this has none! Teenagers tend to be wrapped up in their own lives, not concerned because it took someone several tries to get the nerve to knock on the door.
*WHY IS IT PEOPLE FREAK OUT ABOUT SHARING COMPUTERS WITHIN A FAMILY?
It always seems on these melodramas that people freak out whenever anyone uses their computer, even to check email, and that seems ridiculous. Why not catch him going through a checkbook, or a medicine cabinet to prove he's not trustworthy? That would be more suspicious.
*IF YOU'RE THIS INVESTED IN YOUR "NEW SON'S" LIFE, WOULDN'T YOU LIKE TO GO SEE HIS COLLEGE CAMPUS?
You've let a total stranger move into your home because he's your "long lost son", and because he's in college, wouldn't you at least like to see where he's going, what he's doing with his days? Wouldn't he be eager to show you?
*THERE'S NO NEED FOR THE OVERKILL
In so many of these melodramas, they use too much overkill, when a near miss accomplishes the same thing. You can't have people be this good, and then slaughter them without negative consequences to the audience. I've said it before, and I'll say it again, comas/hospitalizations accomplish the same thing (person is out of the way, and evil is revealed) without ANY negative feelings in the audience. The willingness to kill is equal to actual killing. You don't need to slaughter good/innocent people when there's no need to (a great example is (
El secreto de su hijo (2018) similar themes, better movie).
*CHARACTERS ARE ONE DIMENSIONAL
All of the characters have no depth, there's nothing to grab ahold of, so there's no motivation to care. The "evil" characters are comically evil (and not in a good way), and so the whole second half of the movie is an exercise in ridiculousness.
*PACING IS OFF
There's too much of the movie (half) where we're waiting around for an insurance check, there's no suspense building - nothing. Just sitting around waiting.
*MILLION DOLLAR TRANSACTIONS, TO ACCOUNTS THE BANK HAS NEVER SEEN, WOULD BE HELD FOR INVESTIGATION My bank withholds funds if I haven't bought from eBay for awhile. It's a precaution to make sure it's a legitimate transaction, and I'm glad it's there. So if banks flag a transaction that's for $100, what do you think they'd do for a million, especially since it's being sent to an out of country bank?
TO RECOMMEND, OR NOT TO RECOMMEND, THAT IS THE QUESTION:
*This is not terrible, but it is pretty flat. There's no depth to the characters, overkill when it's not needed, and in general, lacking. If you're looking for similar themes, with much better acting, writing etc, try (
El secreto de su hijo (2018) similar story, but much better movie.
CLOSING NOTES:
*This is a made-for-tv movie, please keep that in mind before you watch/rate it. TV movies have a much lower budget, and so your expectations should be adjusted.
*I have no connection to the film, or production in ANY way. This review was NOT written in full, or in part, by a bot. I am just an honest viewer, who wishes for more straight forward reviews (less trolls and fanboys), and better entertainment. Hope I helped you out.
