Will (Jermaine Clement), a somewhat introverted and pessimistic graphic novelist walks in on his partner, Charlie (Stephanie Allynne), having sex with another man while, downstairs, friends are enjoying a party to celebrate the fifth birthday of the couple's twin girls.
Fast forward a year and we find Will still coming to terms with his single status. However, following an awkward and initially misunderstood conversation with Kat (Jessica Williams), one of the students at the college where Will scrapes together a living as a part-time teacher, he finds himself set up on a dinner date with Kat's mother, Diane (Regina Hall). The date does not go well and Diane, herself a teacher at the prestigious Columbia University, is dismissive of Will's line of work both in literary terms, and as an art form.
The date, and the news that the now-pregnant Charlie is marrying her lover, leave Will contemplating both the possibilities for the future and the realisation that he still has feelings for Charlie, but he's unsure exactly what those feelings are.
Writer/director, Jim Strouse has written a sparky, quotable script which showcases Clement's comic timing, his understated acting style and his ability to show an entire confused train of thought with a fleeting facial expression. Allyne plays Charlie as a likeable woman and a good mother, but her self-focus ensures that our sympathies stay with Will. The twin girls (Aundrea and Gia Gadsby) quietly steal every scene they're in.
Strouse has a sure but light hand on the directorial tiller, and keeps the film on a course of relatable realism. We can understand Will being baffled by life at times and we feel his shock when reality bites him on the bum. None of the characters are larger than life, but all have ample substance to maintain our interest in them, and the fate of Will's on/off relationship with Diane keeps the audience curious about what the next act will bring.
Chris Teague's cinematography has a fresh, bright look to it, although when combined with the art direction and score, every frame leaves you in no doubt that you are watching an indie rom-com.
The story is told in such a way that not everything is spelled out for us and we must join the dots ourselves, just as when Will tells his students that the gaps between the panels in a comic can contain as much information as the panels themselves. The scenes in the classroom, along with Wills drawings (by artist Gray Williams), are used to illustrate Will's state of mind, with the students acting as a quasi-Greek-chorus to help the narrative along.
This sweet, good-hearted film is perhaps underserved by a wistfully equivocal ending, but Mark Orton's score over the final scene tells us that perhaps everything might just turn out all right after all.
