Ajouter une intrigue dans votre langueFollows a group of thieves as they plan the biggest heist of their lives against the most dangerous crime ring in the kingdom.Follows a group of thieves as they plan the biggest heist of their lives against the most dangerous crime ring in the kingdom.Follows a group of thieves as they plan the biggest heist of their lives against the most dangerous crime ring in the kingdom.
- Réalisation
- Scénaristes
- Vedettes
Deoudoné Pretorius
- Juniper
- (as Deoudoné van der Merwe)
Tony Caprari
- Baron Fitz-Oesterlen
- (as Toni Caprari)
4,82.9K
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Avis en vedette
When Grit Turns to Gloss
Netflix's The Rats misses the essence of what made the group disturbing and memorable in Sapkowski's books. In the novels, the Rats were never heroes but violent survivors-thieves, killers, and the inevitable offspring of a continent destroyed by war. Their brutality was a reflection of their world, not a rebellion against it.
The film, however, sanitizes them. The characters look too clean, too polished, too staged to be believable products of chaos. They act like stylized outlaws instead of broken youths shaped by trauma. This cosmetic approach kills the authenticity that defined them in the source material.
Visually, the movie fits the Witcher universe, but thematically it betrays it. What could have been a harsh, uncomfortable look at moral decay becomes a glossy adventure. The result is a story that entertains the eyes but not the mind.
The Rats had potential to expose the rot beneath the surface of the Continent. Instead, it offers glamour where there should be grit.
The film, however, sanitizes them. The characters look too clean, too polished, too staged to be believable products of chaos. They act like stylized outlaws instead of broken youths shaped by trauma. This cosmetic approach kills the authenticity that defined them in the source material.
Visually, the movie fits the Witcher universe, but thematically it betrays it. What could have been a harsh, uncomfortable look at moral decay becomes a glossy adventure. The result is a story that entertains the eyes but not the mind.
The Rats had potential to expose the rot beneath the surface of the Continent. Instead, it offers glamour where there should be grit.
I Really, Really Wanted to Like This.
I'm a long time fan of The Witcher games and books. The Series wasn't so good, departing from the titular character in favour of an ensemble cast that leaned way too much on modern writing tropes for my liking.
I first heard about The Rats from Dolph Lundgren's Insta, and was immediately drawn in. Man, that guy would make a fantastic Witcher! He's tall and imposing, and actually looks tough, even at his age. I sat down to watch it the following day.
That's the good stuff out the way. Now on to the negatives.
I've never hated a group quite so intensely or immediately as 'The Rats', the supposed good guys of the story. They fall into all the same annoying, overdone pit falls as the main series.
The men are generally soft and clumsy, the women gruff and foul mouthed (perhaps an interesting twist once, not any more). They all speak and act largely like modern people (one of them even calls another one 'babes' at one point - I am now dying of terminal cringe).
They also complain about not having the money to buy food early on, even though one of the crew is heavily overweight. - threw me right off.
The characters do not look, feel or act like characters from the setting. They're essentially a soft, comfortable person's idea of what starving rogues are supposed to be. Dangerous characters, written by people who need safety scissors to open their crisps.
Overall, it's an interesting premise, a medieval heist backed up by a down on his luck mutant, but falls totally short in just about every way, hampered by poor actors and script writers. (Maybe i'm being harsh, the actors might have been better under different circumstances)
Watch it for Dolph, but if you didn't like the Witcher series, give this one a miss.
I first heard about The Rats from Dolph Lundgren's Insta, and was immediately drawn in. Man, that guy would make a fantastic Witcher! He's tall and imposing, and actually looks tough, even at his age. I sat down to watch it the following day.
That's the good stuff out the way. Now on to the negatives.
I've never hated a group quite so intensely or immediately as 'The Rats', the supposed good guys of the story. They fall into all the same annoying, overdone pit falls as the main series.
The men are generally soft and clumsy, the women gruff and foul mouthed (perhaps an interesting twist once, not any more). They all speak and act largely like modern people (one of them even calls another one 'babes' at one point - I am now dying of terminal cringe).
They also complain about not having the money to buy food early on, even though one of the crew is heavily overweight. - threw me right off.
The characters do not look, feel or act like characters from the setting. They're essentially a soft, comfortable person's idea of what starving rogues are supposed to be. Dangerous characters, written by people who need safety scissors to open their crisps.
Overall, it's an interesting premise, a medieval heist backed up by a down on his luck mutant, but falls totally short in just about every way, hampered by poor actors and script writers. (Maybe i'm being harsh, the actors might have been better under different circumstances)
Watch it for Dolph, but if you didn't like the Witcher series, give this one a miss.
Grade A garbage
There still potential in the Witcher world for interesting storytelling. However this movie fails so miserably I had secondhand embarrassment for the whole crew. Dolph Lungdren had an easy payday thats for sure! The writers never had any real conversations in the real world with real people and by that I mean the dialogue is so profoundly mentally challenged I almost got brain cancer.
Horrible Idea
After watching the controversial 4th Season of the Witcher, which is a lot better as it's ratings, I was glad that it was over. Season 2, 3, 4 should have been 2 hour movies, especially when one deviates from the lore so radically as the untalented showrunners.
While I have enjoyed the storyline of Geralt and the artificially added story of Yennefer, the Rats story was nothing but atrocious, with was literally unbearable to watch due to it's cast and the poor execution. The fact that the showrunners pitched this exact cast and execution to Netflix, tells you everything how demented their decision making is.
The Witcher Universe needs a brand new approach, maybe even a reboot because this is not going to work.
The Rats: is a forgettable show, if you are coming from the games, you watch poorly designed NPC's doing things you don't care about. None of the actors has enough charisma, none of them are capable of carrying the show.
I get the desire to tell more stories about the characters, people would love to see the details of Yennefer in detail but they literally took the worst part of Season 4 and made it worse.
While I have enjoyed the storyline of Geralt and the artificially added story of Yennefer, the Rats story was nothing but atrocious, with was literally unbearable to watch due to it's cast and the poor execution. The fact that the showrunners pitched this exact cast and execution to Netflix, tells you everything how demented their decision making is.
The Witcher Universe needs a brand new approach, maybe even a reboot because this is not going to work.
The Rats: is a forgettable show, if you are coming from the games, you watch poorly designed NPC's doing things you don't care about. None of the actors has enough charisma, none of them are capable of carrying the show.
I get the desire to tell more stories about the characters, people would love to see the details of Yennefer in detail but they literally took the worst part of Season 4 and made it worse.
Downfall of a Could've been Great Story
I have read the books, I don't know if it's the acting or the story line, it's just plain. Lacks the Witcher world vibe.
But it's not as bad as the other reviews are , it's a good watch, all new characters being shown up is good.
They're The Rats , it's an OK watch and Bonhart is Bonhart.
Could've been alot better tho.
But it's not as bad as the other reviews are , it's a good watch, all new characters being shown up is good.
They're The Rats , it's an OK watch and Bonhart is Bonhart.
Could've been alot better tho.
Le saviez-vous
- AnecdotesDuring Brehen(Dolph Lundgren) training montage, he is seen training with a log over his shoulders. This is a callback to Rocky IV(1985), which he starred in. But in that movie the title character Rocky( Sylvester Stallone) does it in his training montage.
Meilleurs choix
Connectez-vous pour évaluer et surveiller les recommandations personnalisées
- How long is The Rats: A Witcher Tale?Propulsé par Alexa
Détails
- Durée
- 1h 20m(80 min)
- Couleur
Contribuer à cette page
Suggérer une modification ou ajouter du contenu manquant


