NOTE IMDb
6,9/10
1,6 k
MA NOTE
Prenant le train pour se rendre à un spectacle à Pottsville, les musiciens Stanley et Oliver rencontrent des problèmes une fois installés dans leur couchette.Prenant le train pour se rendre à un spectacle à Pottsville, les musiciens Stanley et Oliver rencontrent des problèmes une fois installés dans leur couchette.Prenant le train pour se rendre à un spectacle à Pottsville, les musiciens Stanley et Oliver rencontrent des problèmes une fois installés dans leur couchette.
Harry Bernard
- Train Passenger
- (non crédité)
Sammy Brooks
- Short Train Passenger
- (non crédité)
Baldwin Cooke
- Train Passenger
- (non crédité)
Eleanor Fredericks
- Lady in Berth
- (non crédité)
Paulette Goddard
- Train Passenger
- (non crédité)
Pete Gordon
- Train Passenger
- (non crédité)
Charlie Hall
- Train Passenger
- (non crédité)
Pat Harmon
- Stationmaster
- (non crédité)
John M. O'Brien
- Man who trips over briefcase
- (non crédité)
Hayes E. Robertson
- Train Porter
- (non crédité)
S.D. Wilcox
- Train Conductor
- (non crédité)
Grace Woods
- Train Passenger
- (non crédité)
Histoire
Le saviez-vous
- AnecdotesA silent version was also made for theaters that at the time were not equipped to show talkies.
- GaffesAs Stan and Ollie scramble to board the train, their fiddle is clearly smashed to pieces, yet it is intact for the rest of the film.
- Versions alternativesReissued in 1936 with a new musical score, including the "Cuckoo" song by Marvin Hatley over the main credits, as well as a 1932 version of the song played by the Van Phillips Orchestra over the first scene at the depot.
- ConnexionsEdited into Noche de duendes (1930)
Commentaire à la une
With their vaudeville careers slowly taking off, Messers Laurel and Hardy set off on a tour of small music halls. They arrange to meet at the train station with their instrument but find that the journey is not as comfortable or straightforward as they had first expected.
Laurel and Hardy's first short film with sound is clearly the start of a developing series of shorts. For the first few minutes there is almost no sound to speak of as they rely on their normal comedy style it feels a little like they want to stay with what they know for a while. When the sound does kick in, it is very grainy and is given limited use for that reason. However, considering it is now over 70 years old this is understandable and it doesn't really affect the film too much.
The routines are pretty good and show a keen imagination one running gap is left to run offscreen for five minutes before we are allowed to see it's extreme punchline! The routine in the train carriage berth has been reused to better effect by Laurel and Hardy but is still funny here. Both men are good and work well in the confines of the berth Laurel has the better of the material here though.
Overall I enjoyed this short but must admit that the sheer age of the film did shine through in regards sound quality and even film stock at times. Regards though it was still funny although I missed the verbal wit that is part of their comedy in other shorts.
Laurel and Hardy's first short film with sound is clearly the start of a developing series of shorts. For the first few minutes there is almost no sound to speak of as they rely on their normal comedy style it feels a little like they want to stay with what they know for a while. When the sound does kick in, it is very grainy and is given limited use for that reason. However, considering it is now over 70 years old this is understandable and it doesn't really affect the film too much.
The routines are pretty good and show a keen imagination one running gap is left to run offscreen for five minutes before we are allowed to see it's extreme punchline! The routine in the train carriage berth has been reused to better effect by Laurel and Hardy but is still funny here. Both men are good and work well in the confines of the berth Laurel has the better of the material here though.
Overall I enjoyed this short but must admit that the sheer age of the film did shine through in regards sound quality and even film stock at times. Regards though it was still funny although I missed the verbal wit that is part of their comedy in other shorts.
- bob the moo
- 30 juin 2003
- Permalien
Meilleurs choix
Connectez-vous pour évaluer et suivre la liste de favoris afin de recevoir des recommandations personnalisées
Détails
- Date de sortie
- Pays d’origine
- Site officiel
- Langues
- Aussi connu sous le nom de
- Berth Marks
- Lieux de tournage
- Palms Depot, Heritage Square Museum - 3800 Homer Street, Montecito Heights, Los Angeles, Californie, États-Unis(this is where the ending train station building was moved)
- Société de production
- Voir plus de crédits d'entreprise sur IMDbPro
- Durée19 minutes
- Couleur
- Mixage
Contribuer à cette page
Suggérer une modification ou ajouter du contenu manquant
Lacune principale
By what name was Laurel et Hardy en wagon-lit (1929) officially released in India in English?
Répondre