NOTE IMDb
7,6/10
2,9 k
MA NOTE
Ajouter une intrigue dans votre langueThis is the hard and shocking story of life in a British borstal for young offenders. The brutal regime made no attempt to reform or improve the inmates and actively encouraged a power strug... Tout lireThis is the hard and shocking story of life in a British borstal for young offenders. The brutal regime made no attempt to reform or improve the inmates and actively encouraged a power struggle between the 'tough' new inmate and the 'old hands'.This is the hard and shocking story of life in a British borstal for young offenders. The brutal regime made no attempt to reform or improve the inmates and actively encouraged a power struggle between the 'tough' new inmate and the 'old hands'.
Ray Winstone
- Carlin
- (as Raymond Winstone)
Philip DaCosta
- Formby
- (as Philip Da Costa)
Histoire
Le saviez-vous
- AnecdotesIn the Roy Minton original play of Scum, he had the Carlin character as a Glaswegian, someone who hales from Glasgow, Scotland. He cast Ray Winstone in both the TV and cinema versions for the way in which he walked.
- GaffesThis film was actually released in 1991. The new dress code for the legal profession in England didn't come into effect until 2007. Judges and barristers still wear them for criminal cases. Archer's description of the magistrate would actually be factually correct.
- Versions alternativesThere are differences between the TV and the theatrical version:
- It is shown in 1.33:1 aspect ratio.
- Any punches, slaps or kickings are muffled.
- There is a scene with the 3 new arrivals having a bath in the TV version and not in the theatrical version. Davis complains about the water being too warm and gets slapped.
- No strong language was used in the TV version.
- Archer and Carlin talking to each other for the first time differs between the two versions. In the TV version, they talk to each other in the laundry whereas in the theatrical version, a changing room.
- Banks bullying Davis is slightly different. In the tv version Banks grabs Davis and slaps him and tells him that he is the daddy here and pays his dues like the rest. When Davis says he doesn't smokes, Banks slaps him again. In the theatrical version, he does something similar but kicks Davis as he stood up and shoves him back onto the bench.
- In the TV version, Davis getting bullied again. Richards pours hot tea on him and Mr. Sands shouts at Davis for being a slob.
- The TV version omits a scene with Archer talking to the Matron about vetos on books.
- In the TV version, Mr Greaves asks Carlin about his bruised face. The theatrical version is similar but Mr Sands asks Carlin about his face.
- The TV version omits Meakin asks the Matron when is she going to call them by their first names.
- Bank's beating by Carlin is similar in both versions. In the tv version, Carlin dunks Bank's head in the sink and hits him a few times and calmly declares himself the new daddy. He finally kicks kicks him once in the groin. The theatrical is similar but Carlin is more angrier.
- Baldy's beating by Carlin is fairly brief. The sound effect when Carlin beats him with the pipe is muffled.
- Toyne's suicide is deleted in the TV version.
- There is a brief scene with Archer painting "I am happy" on a wall. This is not in the TV version
- Carlin's homosexual relationship with another inmate is in the TV version.
- Davis' rape is brief and non graphic compared to the graphic and prolonged film version. His suicide is not as graphic as the theatrical version.
- After the riots, Carlin is taken to the punishment block and beaten up. The theatrical version is similar but more graphic.
- The credits has music unlike the theatrical version.
- ConnexionsReferenced in Neverwhere (1996)
- Bandes originalesWide Boy
Written by Rick Lloyd
Performed by The Amazing Mike Kahn Band
Commentaire à la une
Carlin (Ray Winstone of "Nil by mouth" and "Sexy Beast") is a young criminal who after assaulting a police officer gets sent to a borstal (juvinial prison), with two other youth offenders, where they find life inside hell with the authoritarian system brutal and the criminal inmate hierarchy equally, if not more so. They must find a way to survive. Carlin is able to climb the hierarchy, the other two are not really that 'lucky' This TV movie was shelved by the BBC1 for 14 years before before being shown on Channel 4 exactly once, and then only in honor of a deceased Alan Clarke. Gritty, and depressing if a slight bit overly sensationalized. Still it's interesting to watch even if the feature film version IS better. In response to the shelving of the film Clarke and writer Minton remade it as a theatrical film in two years later in 1979. This movie can be found in Blue Undergrounds Alan Clarke Collection.
My Grade: B-
DVD Extras: Commetary with actors Phil Daniels & David Threlfall, and Producer Margaret Matheson; 2 Selected scenes commentary by Ray Winstone (one of which wasn't in the film)
My Grade: B-
DVD Extras: Commetary with actors Phil Daniels & David Threlfall, and Producer Margaret Matheson; 2 Selected scenes commentary by Ray Winstone (one of which wasn't in the film)
- movieman_kev
- 10 juin 2005
- Permalien
Meilleurs choix
Connectez-vous pour évaluer et suivre la liste de favoris afin de recevoir des recommandations personnalisées
Détails
Box-office
- Budget
- 125 000 £GB (estimé)
Contribuer à cette page
Suggérer une modification ou ajouter du contenu manquant