Un silence
NOTE IMDb
5,9/10
491
MA NOTE
Astrid, l'épouse d'un avocat renommé, a été réduite au silence pendant 25 ans. L'équilibre de sa famille s'effondre soudain lorsque ses enfants commencent à demander justice.Astrid, l'épouse d'un avocat renommé, a été réduite au silence pendant 25 ans. L'équilibre de sa famille s'effondre soudain lorsque ses enfants commencent à demander justice.Astrid, l'épouse d'un avocat renommé, a été réduite au silence pendant 25 ans. L'équilibre de sa famille s'effondre soudain lorsque ses enfants commencent à demander justice.
- Récompenses
- 1 victoire et 2 nominations au total
Damien Bonnard
- Pierre
- (voix)
Histoire
Le saviez-vous
- AnecdotesThe film is inspired by the Victor Hissel case.
Commentaire à la une
It takes lots of time to get a clear view on the underlying plot. It may be that the filmmakers counted on our familiarity with the overarching court case, but for us living outside Belgium it particularly did not work. During the overly long pre-amble, I was pondering what the plot would lead to: (a) the child porn is planted to pressure Francois to do something in the context of the court case he is involved in. This course case is mentioned several times, but what it entails remained a mystery; OR (b) Francois studied the child porn on grounds of "need to know" in the context of said court case. By chance, Raphael discovered it many years ago, watched it out of curiosity, got hooked and kept looking for similar stuff on Internet, explaining the 7,700 views; OR (c) others in the family were sexually abused when they were young, but kept silent about it for many years, now suddenly coming forward for some reason; OR (d).... I can go on like this, randomly combining other plot elements that can be constructed out of the building blocks presented.
The background court case is a high profile one, given journalists who are waiting 24/7 before their house, overwhelming them with questions at the gate. It gives rise to suspicions from my side that political elements were trying to steer in a certain direction, but that Francois did not give in as a matter of principle, while TPTB heightened the pressure until their (hidden) goal is reached, no matter what it does to the personal lives of the family involved.
It takes lots of time to unconfuse us and make clear which direction the plot is going to take, and suddenly it hits us that the case is less convoluted than I thought at first. In other words, an anticlimax. Before that, I felt a light but continuous tension throughout, letting us wonder which development or turn of event would be next. Tantalizing when one of my assumed plots (see above) was to come out. It did not, in my opinion, a missed chance to get the story to a higher level.
All in all, I had the feeling when leaving the venue that we should be disappointed that the court case as well as the other family members were less involved, in other words that it was not exploited farther than done here. In the defense of the filmmakers, I can assume that they tried to remain true to the events of the background court case, which was well-known in Belgium, and did not want to paraphrase on it to arrive at a more interesting scenario. The latter could have given us novel insights into how such a court case works out on those involved. They could have elaborated freely, adding a footnote "Based on true events."
Because of missed chances of upgrading the plot, digressing from the original court case as it was known in Belgium, my score comes down to 3/5. We don't get a chance to delve deeper in the motives of the protagonists, what they did and why they did it. We only touch their surface. It's a pity, as it could have been much better. They could have turned it into a "based on true events" story, cutting loose from the original events. My final conclusion is that the protagonists remain bleak and non-interesting, leaving us indifferent what happens to them.
The background court case is a high profile one, given journalists who are waiting 24/7 before their house, overwhelming them with questions at the gate. It gives rise to suspicions from my side that political elements were trying to steer in a certain direction, but that Francois did not give in as a matter of principle, while TPTB heightened the pressure until their (hidden) goal is reached, no matter what it does to the personal lives of the family involved.
It takes lots of time to unconfuse us and make clear which direction the plot is going to take, and suddenly it hits us that the case is less convoluted than I thought at first. In other words, an anticlimax. Before that, I felt a light but continuous tension throughout, letting us wonder which development or turn of event would be next. Tantalizing when one of my assumed plots (see above) was to come out. It did not, in my opinion, a missed chance to get the story to a higher level.
All in all, I had the feeling when leaving the venue that we should be disappointed that the court case as well as the other family members were less involved, in other words that it was not exploited farther than done here. In the defense of the filmmakers, I can assume that they tried to remain true to the events of the background court case, which was well-known in Belgium, and did not want to paraphrase on it to arrive at a more interesting scenario. The latter could have given us novel insights into how such a court case works out on those involved. They could have elaborated freely, adding a footnote "Based on true events."
Because of missed chances of upgrading the plot, digressing from the original court case as it was known in Belgium, my score comes down to 3/5. We don't get a chance to delve deeper in the motives of the protagonists, what they did and why they did it. We only touch their surface. It's a pity, as it could have been much better. They could have turned it into a "based on true events" story, cutting loose from the original events. My final conclusion is that the protagonists remain bleak and non-interesting, leaving us indifferent what happens to them.
Meilleurs choix
Connectez-vous pour évaluer et suivre la liste de favoris afin de recevoir des recommandations personnalisées
Détails
- Date de sortie
- Pays d’origine
- Site officiel
- Langue
- Aussi connu sous le nom de
- Le Fils de la Loi
- Lieux de tournage
- Sociétés de production
- Voir plus de crédits d'entreprise sur IMDbPro
Box-office
- Budget
- 6 230 000 € (estimé)
- Montant brut mondial
- 1 868 483 $US
- Durée1 heure 39 minutes
- Couleur
- Rapport de forme
- 2.35 : 1
Contribuer à cette page
Suggérer une modification ou ajouter du contenu manquant