7.7 stars.
The daughter steals the show from scene 1.
I really enjoyed this movie, the casting was perfect. The lead female seemed to have an off day, no big deal, she is a bit wooden in this. She gets one free pass for the minor lack of charisma because she's drop dead gorgeous. The leading guy is probably one of the best looking men in Hallmark movies, and as a bonus he has a deep radio deejay voice. My hunch is the ladies find him to be a heartthrob. I enjoyed his performance, and feel he's the primary reason for high ratings.
The story is average, nothing special, but the interactions between the two families is really fun and inviting. I felt very comfortable with them, and if this were real life I'd wish to be a part of this little town of Hopewell full of people with such convincingly big hearts. It's something about the familiarity and cordial nature of everyone, bringing such good feelings, more than the run-of-the-mill. The book store owner, the mayor, they are so welcoming. The leading male's sister and family are so relaxed, yet very warm and likable. The whole town is chummy, and it feels genuine.
All of the usual requirements are met. The usual cliché is present: the interrupted kiss, the dead family members, the absentee father, one of the leads is an author, and one is disenchanted by Christmas, lighting the town tree, ginger bread contest, and someone owns a bookstore... The romance is only average, but it's the charisma and interactions between all of the people as a whole that brings me good cheer.