As a dyed-in-the-wool G & S fan, I'm always happy to see any version of the operas, and will find merit in just about all (speaking as a participant in the "Starship Pinafore" so disliked by Hannah here!). From traditional to updated, bring them on! I hadn't come across this one until very recently, and am DELIGHTED that a friend introduced me to it.
It's camp, hugely energetic and a romp pretty much from start to finish, and as such, a very successful piece of undiluted entertainment. I couldn't help but feel sheer goodwill to it. It's not flawless, and there were things that irritated me - some of the tempos seemed pulled about for no good reason (especially in the "straighter" numbers), and some of the dialogue cuts and rewrites seemed intrusive and/or unnecessary - but at the same time, many of the changes were hilarious, and I certainly had no objection to the interpolation of some numbers from different G and S shows. The acting performances were in keeping with the overall over-the-top nature of the production, and only occasionally grated, and in general I loved the raunchier interpretations. Particular pleasure was derived from the three fabulous "sisters and cousins and aunts", whose costumes were a delight and whose energy and slickness in the dancing I could only admire.
Strict purists will hate it- D'Oyley Carte it's not. And yes, the synthesized accompaniment does not bear comparison with a full orchestra. And yes, some of the singing could be criticised technically. But this uber-Broadway, almost cartoonish rendition fitted those things, and this version of Pinafore stands in its own right as fabulously entertaining. Some, I'm sure, will imagine Gilbert and Sullivan turning in their graves. Others of us will wonder whether it's not in fact just how they might do it if they'd been writing for the musical theatre today.
