According to Wikipedia MAGIC VALLEY was screened at the Rome Film Festival in October 2011 and then released online on May 2013, all signs that this might be a terrible movie which might not seem like this since the only four reviews here give a 5 and three 10s. But as usual with these sort of movies you have to watch them yourselves and then say the truth.
The story is set in a small community in a rural area of Idaho. When during a trip in the woods two young boys find the body of a dead woman, they decide it's the best thing to bury it, and during the course of the movie we see the lives of the various other characters. In particular the family and Sheriff Ed Halfner (Scott Glenn) show huge lack of indefference in her disappearence and finding out the cause of death.
While I have seen at least thousands of worse movies, I kinda save this one for the following reasons: the scenery was nice, the cinematography was good for its budget and Glenn as usual looked like the only one that tried with the material given.
In particular, there is one funny moment I'd love to mention: while two young thugs are committing a robbery, Halfner and his deputy stay sit in the car and Ed starts discussing about RENEGADE and WALKER TEXAS RANGER. First, not only I assume that in the US there must be some channel that airs them connected (like channel 22 here in Italy) but it was unintentionally hilarious. Why? Because instead of going out of the car and see what was going on, the Sheriff discussed about those two TV shows and an episode of each. And just for this the movie gained few points.
Overall, one of those movies projected at a festival and then released online with the assumption that if released in theaters would stink. While it's far from a good movie, it's still watchable trust me.