I read some comments, and think I played different game. But I guess everyone is seeing it in their own eyes.
Let me start by saying this game is the worst of last three.
/+ Settlement upgrading and overall feel of home base. It was fun and interesting to find all these activities, to decorate it and so on.
/- Shop system. How in the hell I can't see what kind of Tatoo or decoration I am buying before I buy it?
/+ Weapon and Armor upgrades. Simple to understand and to use. Can use the same Axe during whole game if I want to and it won't be under powered.
/- Arrows. The fact that I can't make arrows, but have to find them in the woods infuriated me more than it should have.
/+ Voice acting. Played as Male. Loved it.
/- Mistakes in dialog. I was called "SHE" more times than once or twice. Hard to imagine how simple things like that can slip during test runs.
/+ Fighting it self. Quite simple and easy to do. Doesn't require a lot of practice.
/- LOGIC
This one is a big one. And I am not talking about reality VS game. Some examples:
1. I climb a wall to open some gates and let my troops in, but somehow they already fighting on this side of the gates.
2. Prisoners have their weapons on them then I rescue them. I know you can do better cause in Odyssey prisoners would take weapons from racks after I freed them.
/+ Size. It is really big world to run around.
/- MAIN story. No spoilers so won't go into details, but I was extremely disappointed how ending was.. blunt and dull. I was like: "What do you mean, "thats it?"" .
/- SIGURD story. It has a big build up and felt it's gonna be something special but it as well was awkwardly disappointing.
/- PRESENT story. I guess we are divided in those who like present and those who doesn't. I personally think that after Desmond they didn't find a proper idea. And now they are just holding on to it as strange identity thing, that I really hate.
/+ QUEST for conquering. Most of them felt good and fun to complete. Enjoyed most of them.
+/- RAID. I guess raids are like identity for Valhalla.and mostly they are fun to do. However had to load a game more than enough times to be annoyed by the bugs then could not get my crewmates to help me open door or chest.
+/- SIDE quest. (Blue dots). Trying to engage you but most of them don't succeed in capturing your focus and interest.
/- Hunting. the fact that i need to kill 2 or 3 hares just to get 1 hare foot is laughable, irritating and to be fair - cruel. Feels like devs decided to make ti grinding experience for those who wants to finish all hunter quests. (PS: Killed 5 black bears - didn't get fur even once.)
/- Cinematic. I was so disappointed then at one point Eivor in the cinematic (and short fighting sequence that followed) was with different hair and beard style and even different color than the one I played with.
Could really talk more but I think it will be enough. To summarize I will say that this game feels like no one played it after it was made, so there are so many bugs, glitches and simple mistakes that at some times I would just save and turn it off. I say that while understand that big and large games like that can't be without false. I played 100+ hours so I got my money worth for sure. However, I would not call this game triple A game. Not by the standards some other games raise today.
