'A Mrs Miracle Christmas' was watched with mixed expectations. Really liked the idea of the story and Hallmark have done a lot of films with serious themes and mostly very well (the best of them being among their best work). Have liked the cast in other things and the themes were relatable. With a few exceptions, sequels don't have the best of reputations and Hallmark's follow ups are variable. Was not sure as to whether a Mrs Miracle film would work without Doris Roberts and the 2021 Hallmark Christmas output up to this point was very up and down.
Luckily, 'A Mrs Miracle Christmas' is very much one of the ups. It's not perfect, but as far as Hallmark follow ups go it's in the better half, and of the 2021 Hallmark Christmas films of the ones that had aired up to this point it to me is one of the stronger faring ones. Perhaps second best after 'Christmas in My Heart', another film to tackle a serious subject. Ranking it with the other Mrs Miracle films, they are actually quite close together in quality, with such a major casting change part of me of dreading it would be vastly inferior as is too often the case with films etc that have drastic cast changes (especially with Roberts being so good).
Is 'A Mrs Miracle Christmas' perfect? No. It is not hard to figure out how it is all going to map out, with what is covered being familiar ground.
Did think too that it was a little bit of a slow starter in terms of pace and that Kaitlin Doubleday's character was not easy to warm to straightaway.
However, a lot is great. The acting is very good, with Caroline Rhea being a more than worthy successor to Roberts, bringing the same amount of sincerity and fun and making it her own without straying too far. The other standout is Paula Shaw, who has great comic timing (which never jarred) and warmth. Doubleday and Stve Lund give moving performances and Doubleday's character did become a lot more relatable as the film went on. The chemistry is never awkward or disconnected and it was hard to not connect with the characters in such a difficult scenario that will resonate with anybody who's been through it.
Furthermore, it is an attractive looking film, nothing rushed or static looking whatsoever about it. The music is pleasant and appropriately festive and the direction accomodates while never stalling. The script is well meaning and avoids over-heavy melodrama, sugar overload and being juvenile. The story may be predictable and could have been tighter, but it is also very poignant and honest and that it tackled a topic like this while still making it accessible and heart-warming is laudable.
Overall, didn't amaze me but on the whole it left me very pleasantly surprised and impressed. 7/10.
