8/10
When Los Angeles Was Just a Small Pueblo
26 June 2011
John Carroll's charming, but very coldblooded villain steals the film from stoic hero Wild Bill Elliott. But in doing so Carroll guaranteed Old Los Angeles a place among the top Elliott westerns of his career.

Old Los Angeles takes place during the year of 1850 just prior to California's admission to the union. Things moved at a rapid pace in those years in California. A decade earlier California was Mexican territory. In 1848 it came along with the rest of the Mexican cession to the USA, in 1849 gold was discovered and the place rapidly filled up with population and in 1850 it was ready to admitted to the Union as a free or slave state depending on what the politicians in Washington, DC decided.

Successful prospector Henry Brandon is relieved of his work of many months and then shot in the back by his good friend Carroll who heads an outlaw band. At least up front he does. The US marshal Grant Withers actually does and behind him where even Carroll doesn't know about it is gambler/saloon owner Joseph Schildkraut who dreams big about a California Empire. He's descended from both Mexican and Czarist Russian people and believe me having Schildkraut being even part Russian is no accident in 1948.

But Brandon had written to brother Bill Elliott back in Missouri where Elliott was a lawman to come west and join him. Elliott does along with sidekick Andy Devine and when he hears about his brother's death, there's no stopping him in finding out who the guilty ones are.

Although she generally played a lot of comic characters in Republic Pictures, Estelita Rodriguez strikes a real poignant note as the woman who stands by her man even though her man John Carroll is no good. She's got quite a bit on Catherine McLeod who is a more traditional western leading lady for Bill Elliott.

Carroll with a bit better breaks could have had a far more successful career. Among other things he had a great singing voice which you hear a bit of in Old Los Angeles. You can hear more of it in Rio Rita opposite Kathryn Grayson. As for playing rogue he did that well too in such films as Randolph Scott's Decision at Sundown and Flying Tigers with John Wayne.

This is a great film from Republic Pictures and a great introduction to Wild Bill Elliott westerns.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed