From the very first frame, it's obvious that this film is on a whole other level than the other Oscar nominated shorts. The lighting is simply outstanding, and the images are beautiful.
The acting is also excellent, and both characters are rendered with great depth.
Best of all though, is the script. The whole story is basically just two people in a room, talking. And still, the screenwriter manages to make it both exciting and moving. The plot toys with the audience, continuously changing our sympathies from one character to the other, and never attempts to simplify or cheapen the conflict.
I'll be very interested in seeing what this director does next, as this short promises great things in the future.