Metacritic reviews

[A] winning film ... Genre fans won’t want to miss it.

Plus One isn’t much more than consistently amusing and sweetly romantic, but in the right hands, those qualities can still feel like a lot.

For romance junkies, the film checks all the boxes. For those who want a little more, it comes complete with a smart script, likeable leads, and a willingness to occasionally tweak a trope or two. My only complaint about Plus One is that the ending feels a little rushed.

Developments give Erskine a chance to play hurt and wounded, and she handles this as beautifully as she does the light comedy. She’s the plus in Plus One.

Plus One is nothing if not formulaic. ... But what Plus One lacks in originality it at least partially makes up for in warmth and watchability.

Maya Erskine is hilarious, which is no surprise, given how funny she is on Hulu’s Pen15.

The movie’s real showcase gold lies in the magnetic appeal of screwball comedy natural Erskine (Hulu’s “PEN15”); she’s a major talent who rightly runs away with the movie, conjuring in the viewer’s head a constellation of wishful star turns to come.

The wedding of strong actors with a solid script is what makes Plus One worthy of saying “I do” to enjoying it.

Despite its flaws, it goes down easy and guiltlessly, like cheap champagne.

Every minute Erskine isn’t on screen is a minute wasted.