User reviews

The entire soundtrack of Gold Diggers of Broadway is now posted online for all to hear for free, and of course I've seen the same two reels everyone else has, which is all that is known to survive from the film and consists of the reconciliation between Jerry (Nancy Welford) and "Uncle Steve" (Conway Tearle) and the musical finale.

It's true that there are many similarities between "Gold Diggers of Broadway" and "Gold Diggers of 1933", but I really can't say that one is a remake of the other for the following reason. It is just amazing to "see" what a difference the onset of the Great Depression and the improvement of sound technology and cinematic choreography made in popular entertainment in the four short years between these two films - 1929 to 1933.

"Gold Diggers of 1933" was a rowdy romantic comedy punctuated by innovative musical numbers. "Gold Diggers of Broadway" was a series of musical numbers - and any true cinematic musical number was innovative in 1929 - punctuated by a rowdy romantic comedy. The basis of the tale is the same in both films - a young man from a wealthy family (William Bakewell as Wally) wants to marry a chorus girl (Helen Foster as Violet). Wally's guardian and uncle, Steve Lee (Conway Tearle), says all chorus girls are immoral layabouts that smoke and drink and is on his way up to Violet's apartment, along with the family attorney (Albert Gran as Blake), to put an end to this relationship. Violet can't face "Uncle Steve" so friend Jerry agrees to face him and stand up for her friend. Just as in Gold Diggers of 1933, Steve will not hear any of Jerry's explanation and rattles off his objections all the while assuming Jerry is Wally's fiancé. The rest of the movie is based on this mistaken identity routine, with Jerry's objective being to make herself look so bad that Steve will be glad that Wally is actually marrying someone else. But alas, she cannot shock him no matter what she does. Instead Steve is having the time of his life. Meanwhile Winnie Lightner really steals the show here as Mabel, a loud chorus girl who sets her cap for Blake, the family lawyer.

The only choreography we can "see" here shows how much Busby Berkeley did for musical film. The dancing largely consists of chorus girls walking about or gently swinging to the beat of the music. Two acrobats at the end do the only real "dance moves" in the entire finale. The musical numbers are realistic in the sense that they could have been performed on a stage, and some more realism is injected as we actually see the electrician flip the switch on the lights between scenery set-ups. What Berkeley did in "the remake" four years later was to come up with numbers and shots that could only be done in a film, but it was still much more interesting to watch.

As for the precode era, it's just beginning here. Nobody wakes up and thinks they slept with anyone the night before, but likewise other than Wally and Violet, it is not entirely clear any of the other couples are headed straight to the altar as is true in the 1933 film. The girls here are mischievous and bubbling with energy rather than mischievous and hungry for a meal as they are four years later.

I'm grateful to have the soundtrack of this early sound film, but not seeing the film probably really blunts its comic effect. Lilyan Tashman and Winnie Lightner have some hilarious banter here, and it would have been great to be able to actually see their facial expressions during their exchanges. Likewise, the wild party at Jerry's with Anne Pennington dancing on a table and Winnie Lightner serenading Albert Gran and then jumping into his lap is hard to convey with just a soundtrack.

Here's hoping the rest of it is found someday, but time has probably run out on Gold Diggers of Broadway since it was nitrate film. It's just a crying shame that Jack Warner didn't bother to preserve such a big money maker and huge part of the history of Warner Brothers while Louis B. Mayer was so sentimental that he preserved just about everything MGM ever did. Imagine that - not being as sentimental as Louis B.!

Most interesting is the big production number in the final reel, with all kinds of show dancing and some acrobatics. Also good as a sample of what a New York musical stage production of the day looked like.

In two color (red/green) Technicolor, though not always well preserved.

Except for two clips that are on The Jazz Singer DVD, this movie is lost. One of them begins with a man and a young woman who calls him uncle but is being proposed marriage. Then it's a big finale with many men in top hats and tails and a couple of acrobats doing somersaults. The screen then goes black but the surviving audio continues. The other surviving sequence has a bunch of ballerinas performing on stage with swans in a pond at the end. All this was in two-strip color. It was all fascinating to watch and hear. Since I'm not so sure the entire movie will ever be found, I'm reviewing this now and giving my rating which you'll see above. So on that note, those surviving Gold Diggers of Broadway clips were sure fascinating to watch.

When you think of the early talkies you might think of Al Jolson in ‘The Singing Fool' or the MGM 1929 Musical ‘Broadway Melody'. Both of these films are still with us and are frequently quoted in film histories. They are always quoted, partly out of legend and partly because they still exist as films. Yet, there are many early talkies lost to time and neglect. Warner Bros. Vitaphone production - ‘ The Gold Diggers of Broadway' is one of these and was surely partly lost because it was made in early Technicolor. What is remarkable is that this single film was in the top ten grossing films of the 1929 to 1939 period, yet is forgotten today. Until the 1980's this film was thought to be completely lost, yet due to chance (a private collector and an Australian archive) there exists two 35mm nitrate reels and a disk soundtrack for the whole film (plus trailer). From these we can get a picture of what the film was like. This film is so poorly documented that I thought it important to describe in detail what is left. The basic storyline was lifted for ‘Gold Diggers of 1933' and was well worn even by 1929, however whereas the 1933 ‘remake' was steeped in Depression references, it's original counterpart sang with breezy tunes and snappy dialogue and all coated in primitive, but alluring Technicolor (being the second full length color sound feature film ever made). In the surviving soundtrack portion of the film, we meet a group of man hungry Gold-digging showgirls comprising of the sly (Nancy Welford), snob (Lillian Tashman), the screwy (Gertrude Short) and the desperate show-off (Winnie Lightner). Add to this a wealthy lawyer (Albert Gran), and an angry Uncle (Conway Tearle) and his Nephew (William Bakewell) who has an eye for a blonde showgirl. They all meet eventually at an archetypal 20's party at Welford's flat, in which Nick Lucas notably croons two songs written for the film ‘Painting the Clouds with Sunshine' and ‘Tiptoe Thru the Tulips'. Both songs are supported by excellent backing arrangements that sing out the atmosphere of the crazy 20's. Dancer Ann Pennington hoofs on the kitchen table! Drink eventually goes to the heads of all concerned. After much backstage bickering, following the sleepy events of the previous night, the cast is in preparation for the opening night. At this point we have the surviving footage, in which we see the female comedy lead – Winnie Lightner, rehearsing her finale – she can't remember her sole two lines. Then we have Nick Lucas singing under an enormous moon in the elaborate production number reprise of ‘Tulips', which also breaks out into a giant large-scale greenhouse with human tulips and chorus! Living Terracotta pots against a glass paned emerald backdrop. We also then have some bitchy backstage banter between Lillian Tashman and Lightner. Then on to the finale. Nancy Welford and Conway Tearle exchange and make up for ‘love making' antics of the previous night, just in time for the big production number. In a make believe distorted Paris by night we see and hear a reprise of all the songs used in the film Then, in an almost delirium making finale a whole host of specialist acrobatic acts and dancers literally throw themselves around the stage. An almost frenzy like kaleidoscope of pastel reds, coral pinks and mint greens. Behind them swirl Larry Ceballos choreographic patterns made up from Top Hatted men and Feather boa clad Women. Spotlights flash around the set, almost invisible because of the literally human carpet of dancers. Just as the whole show builds breakneck speed, suddenly the picture is lost (for the film exists as but a fragment), but the sound carries on. Sharp eyes will spot Male dancers moving into position with Winnie Lightner, just before the blackout. We can now only imagine that they must lift her up, dressed as the Statue Of Liberty and then she forgets her line for the finale – ‘I am the spirit of the ages and the progress of…..darn it …..I forgot that second line..'. In retrospect, what is important about this film is that it does many things which have been previously been accredited to other, later musicals (long before the Busby Berkley era), we also have a summation of what was fun about 20's pop culture. Add to this some very snappy and pre-code dialogue and we have something special. So special at the time that it was one of the first films to gain revenue from people coming back for a second screening. Its impact at the time can be judged by the American gross of 3.5 Million Dollars (unadjusted to today's inflation!). It is a loss to film history that there is no complete print in existence, but what does survive sparkles far in advance of many other films in the dawn of sound.

I recently purchased the newly released 3-disc DVD set of Al Jolson's "The Jazz Singer." One of the extras was of found excerpts of the otherwise lost "Gold Diggers of Broadway." I had seen other musicals from 1929/30 era which all had a cumbersome, boring execution in style and musical presentation before the snap of Busby Berkeley breathed life into the musical. I fully expected the cumbersome quality in this excerpt. I was stunned at how wonderfully entertaining the number was....how talented these different dancers were to say nothing of the energy involved including the delivery in the available bits of dialog. Everyone seemed to be having genuine fun. I also enjoyed the ballet sequence although my guess is that fewer people might appreciate that sequence. The female ballet dancers were very beautiful in it. The quality of these excerpts adds to the tragedy of "Gold Diggers of Broadway" being a lost film. Other lost films have been found. We can only hope that will be the case here.

I have heard portions of the Vitaphone soundtrack in the past and recently seen the extant film clips featuring Nick Lucas singing "Tip toe through the tulips" and the Finale. Whilst these musical numbers are not like the grand designs as later seen in Busby Berkeley cinematic choreographed numbers they are still spectacular and more like one would see on a real stage. The action is fast and breezy. The costumes and sets look gorgeous. Warners did a great job despite the limitations of early colour and sound movies.

The finale is a reprise of most of the featured songs that were in the film. The colours though muted still look fantastic and there is tremendous energy and life in the dancers. Nancy Welford blew me away with her charm when singing the "Song of the Gold Diggers" in the Finale. I never appreciated "Tip toe through the tulips" until I saw this original version. Keep humming it all the time now. Does anyone know who the lovely lady is that Nick Lucas is serenading? I think it could be Lilyan Tashman who passed way several years after making this film.

Given the success of the stage remake of 42nd Street, it would not be a bad idea if this film was also revived into a stage show. All the ingredients for success are there. The mystique of a lost treasure, a snappy story with a suite of fantastic musical numbers and easily adaptable for the stage. The dialogue and songs still exist on Vitaphone disks and we have a feel of what the film looked like from the clips. It would be a fantastic visual experience to see it in similar two strip Technicolor hues as in the film. All pastels, pinks, greens, turquoise, browns, sepia, reds, oranges and gold. Would make a surreal visual experience.

this film is lost! well... partially lost, it is. so how do I know Gold Diggers of Broadway? thanks to the wonderful invention of the DVD (in this case the Busby Berkeley Collection Volume 2). It had the song 'Tip Toe through the Tulips' and the song of the climax of the movie.

the last weeks, I've been repeating the song 'Tip Toe through the Tulips' in my head. why? because I saw the fantastic trailer of Jack Smith's 'Flaming Creatures' on the music of the song mentioned before. however, that song is not in the movie (Flaming Creatures) itself. so I returned home very sad and I searched the net on the song (many times I found the version of the song sung by Tiny Tim - a revelation in fact).

but now I bought vol2 of Busby Berkeley and on the DVD of Gold Diggers of 1937 it was one of the extra's. what a beautiful extra this is! probably the best performed version of the song. wasn't Berkeley one of the crew members? it does have some of the known Berkeley factors, like the opening roses with dancers/singers in.

it's really a shame this movie is lost and I certainly hope one day somebody will find a secret place with all lost films ever made. in the hidden vault of Jack Warner perhaps (just joking)?

This musical comedy was the third movie released by Warner Bros. in color, and it was a box office smash, making Winnie Lightner a star and bringing greater fame to guitarist crooner Nick Lucas as he sang two songs that became 20th-century standards: "Tiptoe Through the Tulips" and "Painting the Clouds with Sunshine." Of interest mostly to film history buffs. --Musicals on the Silver Screen, American Library Association, 2013