German director Paul Leni (1885-1929), almost a century after his death, is finally getting the recognition he deserves. His 4 most important films are now available on home video with the last two in quality Blu-Ray/DVD editions from Flicker Alley. For the record the films are 1) WAXWORKS (made in Germany in 1924) and the 3 surviving Hollywood films, THE CAT AND THE CANARY (1927), THE MAN WHO LAUGHS (1928), and THE LAST WARNING (1929). A fourth Hollywood film, the early Charlie Chan mystery THE CHINESE PARROT, is still considered lost.
While these movies had been around awhile for people to see, they were usually in substandard, low budget VHS editions. With the dawn of the 21st century came DVD versions of the first 3 films which allowed these movies to be viewed as they should be with restored visuals, correct running speed, and a proper soundtrack. This confirmed what only still photos had shown before, that Leni was a master of settings, lighting, and cinematography and provided the blueprint for the classic Universal horror films of the 1930s.
THE LAST WARNING was meant to cash in on the huge success of THE CAT AND THE CANARY. Instead of an old dark house, it's an old dark theater which gives Leni the opportunity to indulge in a number of stylistic tricks borrowed from German Expressionism and especially F. W. Murnau. 2 of the performers, Montague Love and Mack Swain, even bear a striking resemblance to Emil Jannings. Laura La Plante is back as the heroine along with a masked killer whose identity is not revealed until the final 10 minutes.
THE LAST WARNING's weakest element is its storyline. It's a pretty good mystery until the final revelation which really doesn't make a whole lot of sense but then its the visual flair that matters the most to us today. Thanks to Universal's new 4K restoration that flair positively jumps out at us from the film's opening Broadway montage to the finale shot from the killer's POV as he swings on a rope. The restoration is a composite print taken from 2 different sources. There are a few rough places but overall it looks great for a 90 year old film.
It takes more than a visual restoration to make a silent film successful. It also needs a music score to accompany the visuals in such a way as to enhance them. In the previous two reviews for this release, one reviewer loved the score while the other positively hated it. While I agree with the latter that the Flicker Alley Mary Pickford scores are rather inappropriate, I lean more toward the former in that, while not finding the score as great as he says, I found nothing objectionable as this movie is light entertainment not a heavy drama.
In summary I find this, along with FA's simultaneous release of Paul Leni's THE MAN WHO LAUGHS, to be another triumph for Flicker Alley. In addition to the best looking prints that we have ever seen, both releases come with numerous extras including a short video documentary on director Leni along with a 24 page booklet full of photos and background info. Now if FA can only persuade Universal to do a 4K restoration on the the original 1925 release of THE PHANTOM OF THE OPERA, the Universal silent horror collection would be complete...For more reviews visit The Capsule Critic.
