User reviews

I believe that what reviewers of this film may have missed is addressed on the DVD in the Bonus Section. As recently as 1998, the government of China, officially the PEOPLE'S REPUBLIC OF CHINA, had strong policies about approving the production and release of commercial films. This should be read as CENSORSHIP. As a consequence, a film like SO CLOSE TO PARADISE could not be scripted nor shot if it was done through channels.

To get this film done AT ALL, the director had to rely on cameras and film that were begged or borrowed. And actors, for the most part, were paid ,,,,, NOTHING. If there is some clumsiness, especially in the film's first half, chalk it up to factors such as this, which make movie-making less than ideal for someone with a story to tell. A story, mind you, that is critical, via the art of story-telling, of the government, of social policy, and of progress towards China's vaunted goals of building a perfect society.

A recent report in major USA newspapers (recent as of July '04) addresses the frightful gap in wealth between China's rural poor and urban rich. In this film, the gap is the motivation for two men to move to the city to look for work. (A figure to keep in mind is that, despite all the manufactured products we Americans buy that bear the label MADE IN CHINA, the number of (rural) peasants in China is still 750 million!)

Other Users have described the film. I would only add that the greater emphasis is on the fate of those two men; one confines himself to "honest" hard work -- and gets nowhere. The other slides easily into a life of crime. A social observer might say that these choices and their consequences are mirrored in the life of young men and women in the very poorest parts of America's cities. China has no monopoly on this terrible no-win situation. I'll leave that for each viewer to explore through this movie.

Those looking for a film PRIMARILY about the plight of women in China will, I think, not find it here. However, these choices are presented as gender-neutral. If you start poor in the city, where do you turn?

The general attitude of urban Chinese is discriminative against the migrant workers from rural areas. This film gives a sympathetic look at the discriminated rural female workers who are forced into bad situation against their will. A sense of social criticism of the wrong attitude of the urban population is therefore also presented.

SO CLOSE TO PARADISE starts off on the wrong foot, with poor acting by some of the leads, but ends strongly by bringing home the message. A film about loneliness and the people who voluntarily throws themselves headlong into it because there's nothing else, PARADISE is an effective an engaging film. To really appreciate the movie, one must endure its terrible beginning, because the finally hour is worth the price of admission.

A strong film, deserving of some attention. It's impossible not to be affected by the movie.

8 out of 10.

What prompted me to re-watch this film which I bought on dvd in 2003, still remains a mystery, but I'm glad I did. I didn't remember much of it, so it came to me as a big surprise. Due to its slow pace and gritty images, SO CLOSE TO PARADISE or BIANDAN GUNIANG may not be to everyone's taste, but if you like films such as SUZHOU RIVER, SUMMER PALACE, STILL LIFE, TOUCH OF SIN, HOLLYWOOD/HONG KONG, CHONGQING EXPRESS, you will definitely want to check this one out. For all melancholy romantic souls out there who love Chinese cinema I urge you to watch this film. Maybe its not as famous and successful as some of the other titles I mentioned above, but it will certainly touch your heart. I hope one day it will get remastered in high definition and find the audience it deserves.