Why do people criticize this game? Sure its not great but its not terrible. Fight Club has brilliant graphics. The blood effects are very good as you see burst noses, blood and bruises on fighters faces and even swollen eyes. At the end of a match you can do a bonebreaking move where you can do things like snap a guys leg or arm in half. This is the highlight of the game. The fighting feels a little sluggish at times and it wouldn't hurt to put more things to unlock and moves but they're is still a decent amount. Fight Club will keep you playing for a while. I think its the lifespan thats the worst thing about the game but it'll take you a while to beat the game with all the characters and figure out all the bonebreaking moves. If they gave a story for each character then it would have been a lot better but its still good despite this. The Soundtrack is brilliant and also lets you listen to your own tracks.
Despite its flaws, Fight Club is a good fighter that is really brutal and fun. It defiently deserves at least a 3 and thats why I'm giving it a 4 and not a 5. Its not the best but its certainly not the worst. Its a decent game that you should pick up for a good price.