19 reviews
Grain entrapment is a dire, deadly, urgent emergency, as illustrated in various films over the years but most of all documented in real life cases. To build a film based simply on that scenario is a curious notion, but the inherent drama is ripe for storytelling possibilities. 'Silo,' such as it is, is a mixed bag.
In the depiction of the entrapment, and the rescue process, the movie feels in large part like a simple dramatization. We see steps undertaken to save the trapped boy, and the way it all becomes a community effort. Disagreements in how best to go about the procedure reflect a disparity of specific knowledge and lack of communication, elements which are undoubtedly real enough. The central narrative thrust is the strength of 'Silo,' and the movie would have greatly benefited from focusing purely on this aspect.
Unfortunately, that's not what we get. A straightforward, plainspoken story of disaster and rescue would have been compelling, without any need for embellishment. Instead we're also presented with glimpses at the lives of all the characters, back story, and the low-down on their various interpersonal histories and conflicts. 'Silo' could have been a low-key, forthright, human interest thriller, but every bit of extra flair, intended to add greater sense of drama, only waters down what the film could have been. That goes for the score, dialogue, superfluous character writing - almost everything beyond the crucial core.
There's really just not much more to say. I didn't have any particular expectations before watching, yet I find myself somewhat flummoxed. I understand the compulsion, the trend of dressing up a story with the idea of making it ever more dramatic and impactful for audiences. But balance is required, and too many features tip the scale to become overwrought. This is one of them. A far less refined cut of no more than half the final runtime would actually have been twice as absorbing. Sometimes less is more.
'Silo' isn't altogether bad, and I do hope other viewers get more out of it than I did. I just wish film-makers would take time to step back and consider what is truly most essential to the tale they want to tell.
In the depiction of the entrapment, and the rescue process, the movie feels in large part like a simple dramatization. We see steps undertaken to save the trapped boy, and the way it all becomes a community effort. Disagreements in how best to go about the procedure reflect a disparity of specific knowledge and lack of communication, elements which are undoubtedly real enough. The central narrative thrust is the strength of 'Silo,' and the movie would have greatly benefited from focusing purely on this aspect.
Unfortunately, that's not what we get. A straightforward, plainspoken story of disaster and rescue would have been compelling, without any need for embellishment. Instead we're also presented with glimpses at the lives of all the characters, back story, and the low-down on their various interpersonal histories and conflicts. 'Silo' could have been a low-key, forthright, human interest thriller, but every bit of extra flair, intended to add greater sense of drama, only waters down what the film could have been. That goes for the score, dialogue, superfluous character writing - almost everything beyond the crucial core.
There's really just not much more to say. I didn't have any particular expectations before watching, yet I find myself somewhat flummoxed. I understand the compulsion, the trend of dressing up a story with the idea of making it ever more dramatic and impactful for audiences. But balance is required, and too many features tip the scale to become overwrought. This is one of them. A far less refined cut of no more than half the final runtime would actually have been twice as absorbing. Sometimes less is more.
'Silo' isn't altogether bad, and I do hope other viewers get more out of it than I did. I just wish film-makers would take time to step back and consider what is truly most essential to the tale they want to tell.
- I_Ailurophile
- Aug 28, 2021
- Permalink
With a simple rope and pulley system, the young teenager, would be simply pulled up and out of the grain silo. The end. Doesn't get any easier than a rope and pully, to start and end the movie. Gee wiz, really.
- ryan-11985
- May 9, 2021
- Permalink
To ryan-11985 you must not be a grain farmer with storage on the farm or an emergency responder because if you tie a rope around him and pull him up, you will pull him in two and kill him. The weight of grain in an entrapment is unbelievable. Farmers die every year from this very thing because they get in a hurry, because farmer's work is never done, and those who survive all say the same thing, "I knew better". Farmers are the backbone of this country and it's wonderful to see a movie that is realistic and shows the dangers of being a farmer. #proudtobeafarmer #proudtobeafirstresponder.
- lilbc-51878
- May 14, 2021
- Permalink
Moving, well-written, well-acted original story and an important message combined; this film tells the risks that America's farmers face every day in the Heart Land. Not sure why this film has such low ratings here on IMDb; the cinematography is excellent, the scenes are all beautifully shot throughout the entire film, and the acting is top notch, especially considering I didn't recognize any of the members of the cast, aside from Chris Ellis in a small role, who also acts near the top of his career. I see now that IMDb has created a 600 character limit for reviews also, which is an extreme pity, since I've said all I came to say about this film, and is especially tragic when the NEGLECT that has been given to this site over the last 15 years is all been overlooked (bot reviews, reviews that are literally two lines long, troll reviews, etc.) but here we are, with me writing a legitimate review and I'm forced to chock out 94 more characters because now you you fkheads think we should have a limit. Choke. Anyway, the movie is good. Recommended.
SILO -----8/10.
SILO -----8/10.
"SILO" feels more like a documentary than a feature. The actors give very lived-in performances that make the characters seem like people you've known all your lives.
Though the setting is contained (no pun intended), this is the sort of "small" film with big ambitions that we complain "they" never make any more. A deceptively simple, straightforward story that contains the multitudes of the complex characters who live in the vast middle of this country.
Are the relationships between characters a little confusing at first? Yes, and I think that is by design. We the audience are privileged outsiders in this tight-knit world, and the movie isn't going to stop to explain everything on our behalf. How refreshing!
Though the setting is contained (no pun intended), this is the sort of "small" film with big ambitions that we complain "they" never make any more. A deceptively simple, straightforward story that contains the multitudes of the complex characters who live in the vast middle of this country.
Are the relationships between characters a little confusing at first? Yes, and I think that is by design. We the audience are privileged outsiders in this tight-knit world, and the movie isn't going to stop to explain everything on our behalf. How refreshing!
- eliotrouth
- May 9, 2021
- Permalink
Its refreshing to see a movie dedicated to a way of life I would never see. The movie packs a lot of action into 77 minutes leaving me with a new appreciation for the risks involved getting that delicious popcorn to this consumers hand.
SILO is a well-executed high concept thriller in which a teenage helping hand gets entrapped in a silo full of corn due to an accident and must be rescued as soon as possible, otherwise he will be crushed and suffocate to death.
As a city dweller, I must admit I did not know that grain entrapment was a thing, yet evidently nearly a thousand people have died of it already. So, this movie broadens our horizon by bringing attention to a danger you might not have known about, unless you are familiar with farm life.
But the movie doesn't just stop there: it also broadens our horizon by providing a window into how these small town folk think, talk and act. This is accomplished by means of several tangential plot lines which bring out the characters involved.
The cinematography is beautiful, and the movie is willing to ask deep questions, of which the deepest one turns out to be version of the problem of evil. I liked how the movie gently suggested a possible response without trying to impose it on us.
This is a worthwhile film which especially those will enjoy who know aspects of rural America or are open to learning more about it.
As a city dweller, I must admit I did not know that grain entrapment was a thing, yet evidently nearly a thousand people have died of it already. So, this movie broadens our horizon by bringing attention to a danger you might not have known about, unless you are familiar with farm life.
But the movie doesn't just stop there: it also broadens our horizon by providing a window into how these small town folk think, talk and act. This is accomplished by means of several tangential plot lines which bring out the characters involved.
The cinematography is beautiful, and the movie is willing to ask deep questions, of which the deepest one turns out to be version of the problem of evil. I liked how the movie gently suggested a possible response without trying to impose it on us.
This is a worthwhile film which especially those will enjoy who know aspects of rural America or are open to learning more about it.
- Armin_Nikkhah_Shirazi
- May 22, 2024
- Permalink
Watched it in Decatur Illinois and couldn't believe how well it moved. Not a soul there pulled out their phone or looked away.
I just viewed "Silo" a thrilling 75 minute movie about a small town firefighter who is called to save a teenager from being crushed/smothered within a grain silo while working on the farm. I found this to be a brilliant film when it comes to media that is calling out for awareness and change.
The story is well-written with a strong strong ensemble of actors. The characters are introduced quickly but believably and tension starts minutes after the opening scenes. It is a unique and powerful story, and the actors, writers, directors and other members of the production team make these relationships and circumstances highly relatable.
Love the length too! Many filmmakers believe their art is measured in epic lengths...but many times "Brevity is the soul of wit." - Bill Shakespeare.
The story is well-written with a strong strong ensemble of actors. The characters are introduced quickly but believably and tension starts minutes after the opening scenes. It is a unique and powerful story, and the actors, writers, directors and other members of the production team make these relationships and circumstances highly relatable.
Love the length too! Many filmmakers believe their art is measured in epic lengths...but many times "Brevity is the soul of wit." - Bill Shakespeare.
- kurtmuenstermann
- May 6, 2021
- Permalink
I'm so happy to finally see a movie that takes a serious dive into the real life of farming and the real dangers that are associated with farming. Best movie I've seen in a while.
- upnorthfarmgirl
- May 7, 2021
- Permalink
I had so much fun watching this movie! It was suspenseful and I genuinely cared about the characters. I'll admit there weren't really any "surprises" but that didn't effect my enjoyment in any way.
I'm glad they didn't try to make it longer. The timing was perfect through the whole movie without any unnecessary filler scenes.
Overall a fantastic movie and would definitely recommend.
I'm glad they didn't try to make it longer. The timing was perfect through the whole movie without any unnecessary filler scenes.
Overall a fantastic movie and would definitely recommend.
- katelinhollenbach
- May 10, 2021
- Permalink
I've seen this movie twice now and it is as entertaining as it is informative. Great acting and storyline also. I'd love to see more movies like this come out.
- tannym-11983
- May 6, 2021
- Permalink
Anyone with a brain knows that when a person is wedged in a silo, trying to pull them out with a rope will crush the lungs and kill them!! Unfortunate situation but many people succumb to a death such like this.
- milf-35135
- Jun 10, 2022
- Permalink
SILO is an exemplary film in that it bridges the gap between middle America and the East/West coast. The producers of this film clearly respected and learned everything they could about American farmers, and approached the topic with empathy and open minds--it shows in the storytelling that neither belittles nor aggrandizes the American farmer. It's a moving, effective story on why "feeding the world comes at a cost."
- leslie-r-gauthier
- May 23, 2021
- Permalink
This is a story that needs to be told! Coming from a farm family and raising my children around farm equipment is a daunting task in regard to safety. This film depicts a real-life scenario that happens all-to-often. The movie itself is beautifully made with intensity that rises and falls in the perfect moments. A must see!
- abbyfox-93461
- May 9, 2021
- Permalink
I've been sceptical, considering the shorter runtime and the seemingly simple story.
Luckily it turned out to be another gem. Great actors, each of them authentic and thus believable and emotionally engaging. Cinematography - perfect! Overall, this movie is so well done, as soon as it ended I watched it a second time immediately. Simply because I enjoyed the acting so much.
Luckily it turned out to be another gem. Great actors, each of them authentic and thus believable and emotionally engaging. Cinematography - perfect! Overall, this movie is so well done, as soon as it ended I watched it a second time immediately. Simply because I enjoyed the acting so much.
- gallmann-38827
- May 30, 2021
- Permalink
- christenmadrazo-19573
- May 21, 2021
- Permalink
Loved the move, but I have some questions. I hope someone connected to the film can answer them. Other than the grain bin interiors, was any part of the movie shot in Mason City or Clear Lake? Were any other interiors shot in the hanger? If not, where was the film shot? Of all the places to set up as a soundstage, why a hanger at an airport in a little town in Iowa? Was it because it's near the Sukup headquarters?
- williamrkirkham
- May 18, 2021
- Permalink