Ryan Willer auditioned several different actresses (including Heidi Rhodes, Tiffany Hume and Sarah Vannest, all of whom were cast in other roles) for the role of Allison as he was not sure Kelli Ann Simpson could commit to playing the part. Eventually Simpson's schedule cleared up and she won the role.
The role of Margaret was written with actress Emily Edwards in mind.
When the original actress Ryan Willer wanted for the role of Fameke had a to step down, Willer offered the role to Tiffany Hume without auditioning her on the grounds that she had great auditions for the parts of Allison, Emma and Martha but hadn't quite made the cut.
Ryan Willer (Ira) told Brian Donohue (Bernie Sharp) to throw the tennis ball at him in any area of his choosing in the scene where Berine throws the ball at Ira. This was done because Willer would instinctively flinch when Donohue would throw the ball in rehearsals. Donohue nailed Willer in the crotch in one take and it was used in the film.
The jewelry worn by the actors in the film was provided by Stella & Dot.