Welcome to the new profile
We're still working on updating some profile features. To see the badges, ratings breakdowns, and polls for this profile, please go to the previous version.
Reviews14
alex-187's rating
This must be a real masterpiece for I like it a lot and, speaking about Von Trier, this is the first time I do. Having also seen recently Vinterberg's Festen the differences between the two Dogma directors are evident. While Vinterberg is rather explicit, Von Trier's greater gift is to lead the attention astray more than once distracting the viewer from where the director finally means to aim. Von Trier manages a few times to have you think that he's missing the point, forcing you to concentrate more attention on the screen. And the final lesson is: too strong are our bindings with our culture, with our education, with our family and neighbourhood traditions, too strong for us to be able to betray them (and us) behaving differently from how we're expected. Only few can reach the goal of effective freedom from bourgeois chains, for only few can see their vacuity and even less are those brave enough to break them definitively. An apology of revolution? Or anarchy? Or, to put it more easily, a story about the distance usually running between intention and action? However, a good film from the idea to the final result.
A love letter, sincere though not lacking criticisms, from the director to his country. I love the style of this Cuban director whose work I see for the first time though this is not his first one. In it three stories evolve, while a narrator decides the sakes of the characters, with the whistling acting as a trait d'union working as the image of a much wished freedom of expression. Original is the idea of depicting as orphans all the characters, maybe with the intention of suggesting to the world that Cuba starts suffering for lack of affection, because of the isolation she is forced to, by the manouevres of those who believe the capital is more important than the people. And while this image might seem too tender with Cuba, not so is the story of Julia, a woman who faints any time she hears the word "sexo", and of Dr. Fernando who shall show her, causing a comic carnage of passers-by, that a lot are the words which aren't willfully heard on the island. Then there's the story of choices to be done: she is a dancer who has to choose between him, dancing, God, orienting herself amongst a myriad of overridings and troubles. Eventually there's Elpidio, who dreams of a mother by the name of Cuba, has a true declaration of love tattooed on his back, then feels betrayed and has the tattoo burnt. ("Nobody is perfect", he reassures an ugly beggar at the end of the film, attempting to find a consolation statement for both) refusing a possible escape to another place and another love, no matter what. The final meeting of the characters in an unusually deserted Plaza de la Revoluciòn is, like most of the film, a mix of melancholy and hope for a future with more freedom and opportunity.
This is what it takes to spend the night with a rodent devouring your ugly, dirty occidental conscience. Would you leave family, study, anything to save a friend's life in a faraway land? A strong look at youth, at the clash between the wish of experiencing everything and that of avoiding any responsibility. The film is great in depicting the inner struggle of both the boys involved, never giving the audience any assurance about who's going to leave and save a life and who's going to give up. Thrilling and thought-provoking.