Carlemann
Joined Mar 2005
Welcome to the new profile
We're still working on updating some profile features. To see the badges, ratings breakdowns, and polls for this profile, please go to the previous version.
Reviews4
Carlemann's rating
I really have to support KWiNK in his statement, that this film was great but could have been much better.
I enjoyed this film very much and I can only recommend it to almost anybody, but it really has some flaws that keep gnawing on your mind when you leave the Theater... why the random nudity, what happened to his sisters son, where the hell did Jürgen go, why did Nora dress up for Tramitz, but not for Jürgen, where did all the eggs and tomatoes in the theater come from...
the result was the Beta-Version of a really really good movie.
7 out of 10 points from me
I enjoyed this film very much and I can only recommend it to almost anybody, but it really has some flaws that keep gnawing on your mind when you leave the Theater... why the random nudity, what happened to his sisters son, where the hell did Jürgen go, why did Nora dress up for Tramitz, but not for Jürgen, where did all the eggs and tomatoes in the theater come from...
the result was the Beta-Version of a really really good movie.
7 out of 10 points from me
This Film was really good work, the Actors (expecially DiCaprio and Damon) were perfect and the storytelling was as we'd expect from the director, however this film didn't bring anything new. It is a copy of Internal Affairs from 2002 and while some aspects are better (DiCaprio) some other aspects don't reach the original(check for PhoChris's comment).
This film is worth your 5$, but it's not something extraordinary... In the end I wouldn't rate it higher than the original, which got a straight 8. Check out: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0338564/ for the original.
PS: SPOILER : The end seems constructed to satisfy the audiences need for justice, but in my opinion it just was one head shot too much...
This film is worth your 5$, but it's not something extraordinary... In the end I wouldn't rate it higher than the original, which got a straight 8. Check out: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0338564/ for the original.
PS: SPOILER : The end seems constructed to satisfy the audiences need for justice, but in my opinion it just was one head shot too much...
Most negative comments criticized the lack of action or story in this film, which is totally true. However one wouldn't watch Rambo 1-3 for the character development or deep emotions either.
When you want to watch this film don't expect a story, but try to be open to the emotions presented in this movie. You will see 2 characters "stranded" in an alien environment, trying to find someone to hold on to.
There is some Character development, some comedy and even some action, but to me the essence of this movie are the strong emotions like loneliness, uneasiness (jet-lag, culture-shock, insomnia) and love.
This film moved me deeply and I give it 10 points for its realistic, strong yet subtle portrayal of emotion.
When you want to watch this film don't expect a story, but try to be open to the emotions presented in this movie. You will see 2 characters "stranded" in an alien environment, trying to find someone to hold on to.
There is some Character development, some comedy and even some action, but to me the essence of this movie are the strong emotions like loneliness, uneasiness (jet-lag, culture-shock, insomnia) and love.
This film moved me deeply and I give it 10 points for its realistic, strong yet subtle portrayal of emotion.