Democratic Politics - Ii Chapter-1 Power Sharing
Democratic Politics - Ii Chapter-1 Power Sharing
CHAPTER-1
                                              POWER SHARING
                                                                          Speak
         Tamil
                                                                        German, 1
        Speaker                                                             %                 Speak French
           s
          6%                                 Sinhala                          Speak
                                             Speakers                        French,          Speak Dutch
                                                                               40%
                                             Tamil            Speak
                                   Sinhala   Speakers        Dutch,5                          Speak
                                  Speaker                      9%                             German
                                      s
                                    74%
             Dutc        Bruss
              h           els
             20%          0%
                                 French
                    Frenc
                      h          Dutch
                     80%
SRILANKA BELGIUM
(Majoritarianism)                                                                      (Accommodative)
Independent in 1948
(i) Democratically elected Government                           (i)         Equal No. of Ministers from
     (Sinhala community dominated the ministry)                             Dutch and French speaking
(ii) Adopted a series of Majoritarian                                       in central Government
     measures to establish Sinhala supremacy:                   (ii)        No single community can Like
     1956 Act, recognized Sinhala as the only                               make decisions for itself official
     language
(iii)Favoured Sinhala applicants for university positions       (iii)       State Govt.not subordinate to
     and Govt. jobs                                                         Central Govt.
(iv) Constitution- to protect and foster Buddhism               (iv)        Brussels: Govt. too had
                                                                            Equal representation –
 Srilankan                           Sinhalas
  Tamils                            Supremacy
                                                        48
Result:-                                              Result:-
a) Increased the feeling of distrust                  Country united respecting the
   Among the Srilankan Tamils, CIVIL WAR              feelings of different communities
   STARTED                                            and regions
b) Constitution and the government ignored their      Brussels chosen as headquarters
   Interests-denied equal political rights            of European Union
c) Sri Lankan Tamils launched parties and demand      COUNTRY UNITED
   Tamil Ealam State, Tamil as an official language,
   regional autonomy, equality in securing education
    and jobs
                   Civil war causes
    Fought for recognition of Tamil as
       an official language.
    Wanted regional autonomy
    Equal opportunity in securing education and jobs
    1980-demanded an independent Tamil Eelam
       in northern and eastern part of Srilanka
BELGIUM
Accommodation –Three kind of Government
Horizontal Distribution
                                             49
                                                 organs of Govt.
                                                 Power is shared among different
Power is shared among                                                                            Power is shared among political
different social groups.       Forms of Power sharing                                            parties, pressure groups, and
                                                                                                 movements in influencing those
                                                                                                 inpower
                                                   of different levels.
                                                   Power is shared among Govt.
Examples: Community Govt. in Belgium                                               →Central
          ‘Reserved constituencies’ in                                             →State
          assemblies and parliaments                                               →Local
                                                           50
  2. List the three merits of Power Sharing?
     • Power sharing is a good way to ensure the stability of political order.
     • It is the very spirit of democracy.
     • It brings in the unity of the nation.
  4. Why has Brussels ,been chosen as the headquarters of the European Union?
     • They recognized the existence of regional differences and cultural diversities and the
        arrangement [Accommodation] they worked out is different from any other country
        and is innovative.
     • It has avoided Civic problems and division on linguistic basis, instead brought
        stability.
     • Though complicated, this arrangement has enabled everyone to live together within
        the same country.
   5. How is the system of ‘ checks and balances’ maintained among the different organs of
the government?
       • Power is shared among the different organs of the government such as the
       • legislature, executive and judiciary.
       • It allows different organs of the government placed at the same level to exercise
         different powers.
       • Such a separation ensures that none of the organs can exercise unlimited power. Each
         organ checks the other .This result in balance of power.
                                               51
Q.2- Explain the four forms of Power Sharing with examples.
   • Horizontal distribution of power.[between the organs of the government-Legislature,
   • Executive and Judiciary]- India
   • Vertical distribution of power. [among Central level, state level and local level] -
      India
   • Power sharing among different social groups.[ Community Government, [Belgium]
   • reserved seats, Women ]- India
   • Power sharing among different political parties, Pressure groups and Movements.- In
      India [Coalition government]
QUESTION BANK
Q.1 Why is power sharing good for democracies? Why is it desirable in the modern
    world?
Q.2 Explain how the Civil War can be turned down and peace be restored in Srilanka .
Q.3 Explain different forms of power sharing in modern democracies.
Q.4 Explain the drawbacks of majoritarianism.
Q.5 Give a comparative analysis between Belgium and India.
Q.6 What is a ‘Community Government’- How is this formed in Belgium.
Q.7 How is the balance of power maintained among the three organs of the government?
Q.8 Why do we have ’reserved constituencies’?
**********
                                           52
                                      CHAPTER - 2
                                      FEDARALISM
Types of Government
Unitary Federal
Can pass orders to                                  works for the common       Looks into the
the state or subordinate                            National interest   administration of the local
Government
Features of Federalism:-
 •   Two or more levels of government
 •   Each level has its own jurisdiction (power)
 •   Jurisdictions Specified in the Constitution
 •   Changes in the provisions of Constitution require the consent of both the govt’s.
 •   Courts acts as an umpire if any dispute arise between the levels of government.
 •   Sources of revenue specified (Financial autonomy) – Every state has its own revenue to
     look after its welfare.
 •   Dual objective – promote the unity of the country by accommodating regional diversity
                                              53
                             Two routes through which federation have been formed
Three lists
                                                    54
        Defence                               Agriculture                               Marriage
Residuary Subjects:
   Computers
  • Subjects that do not fall in any of the three lists, laws of union Govt. will prevail.
Centre State
Coalition Government.-A Government formed together with two or more political parties.
They adopt a common programme.
National Party A
National Party C
                                                     55
    Decentralization
    Power taken away from centre and State given to local government
    Reason for Decentralization in India –
        • Large country
        • Three - Tier govt., - local govt. formed
        • Large no: of problems and issues
        • Local people-better knowledge of local problems
        • Democratic participation – local self – govt.
        • 1992- Amendment – third tier made – more powerful
    Steps taken to make third-tier more powerful
         • Regular elections
         • Reservation of seats for SC, ST, OBC
         • Reservation for women
         • Creation of state EC to control elections
         • State govt. to share power & revenue with local govt.
    Formation of Panchayati Raj (Rural local government)-
         • Group of each village have a panchayat
         • President or Sarpanch
         • Directly elected by the people
         • Works under the supervision of gramasabha (all voters of the village)
         • Meets twice or thrice a year to approve the budget of Grama Panchayat
                                                   56
ANSWER THE FOLLOWING-                                                       [3-MARKS]
1. What are the two routes through which federation have been formed?
 • There are two kinds of routes through which federations can be formed.
 • First one is ‘Coming together Federation’ in which independent units comes closely
    to each other to form a union in which both centre and states vis-à-vis powerful.
 • Second one is ‘Holding together Federation’- here a large country decides to divide its
    powers between the constituent states and the national government.
                                               57
       •   Source of revenue of each level of government are clearly specified.
       •   The dual objectives of federal system -[a]To safeguard and promote unity of the
           country [b] accommodate regional diversity.
2 What are the three-fold distribution of Legislative powers between the Union and the
State governments. What are ‘Residuary Subjects’?
        Constitution has clearly demarcated the powers between different levels. Every level
is given certain subjects to make laws related to its jurisdiction.
        • Union List: Union List is a list of certain subjects on which Central government
            can make laws.
        • State List : State list is a list of certain subjects on which state government can
            make laws.
        • Concurrent List : Concurrent list is a list of subjects which are of common interest
            for both central and state government.
        • Residuary Subjects : There are certain subjects which are not included in any of
            the three lists only central government can make laws on these subjects.
QUESTION BANK -
Q.1- Explain the composition of Panchayathi Raj in India?
Q.2- Trace the history of the formation of the Linguistic States in India?
Q.3- Does a country like India need decentralization – Justify?
Q.4- What are Union Territories? Name two Union Territories of India.
Q.5- Define ‘Coalition Government’? How has this led to a new culture of Pwer Sharing?
**************
                                             58
                                  CHAPTER - 3
                            DEMOCRACY AND DIVERSITY
                                                                                           Protestants     Catholics
    Black          White               Sinhala          Srilankan Tamil
                                                                          Unionists
                                     Nationali
                                                                          Party
                                     sts Party
                                       45%            Unionist            Nationalists
                                                       s Party            Party
                                                         55%
•      Social Division
       Division of the society on the basis of language, region, caste, colour, race or sex. It
       signifies linguistic and regional diversity.
•      Civil Rights Movement in the USA(1954-1968)
       A series of events and reform movements with the aim of abolishing legal, racial
       discrimination against African-Americans. Martin Luther King Jr. started
       themovement in 1954.This movement practiced non-violent methods of
       civildisobedience against racially discriminatory laws and practices.
•      African-Americans
       Afro-American, Black American or Black are the terms used to refer mainly to the
       descendents of Africans who were brought into America as slaves between early 17th
       and 19th century.
•      The Black power.
       It was a movement started by black people in 1966(1966-1975) against racism and
       the practice of apartheid.It was a militant movement advocating even violence if
       necessary to end racism in the US .
•      Migrants
       Anybody who shifts from one region or country to another region within a country or
                                                 59
       to another country for the purpose of work or other economic opportunities.
   •   Minority
       It refers to communities who are less than half of the total population of the
       country.The idea of minority at national level is totally different from what it is at
       state level.
   •   Homogenous Society.
       Homogenous Society signifies absence of significant ethnic differences. It is a society
       that has similar kinds of people or inhabitants.
   •   Multi- Cultural Community
       Social community formed on the basis of different cultures is known as theMulti-
       cultural community. This happens mostly due to the practice of migration when
       people bring with them their own culture.
       During the National Anthem they stood with clenched fists upraised and heads
       bowed, - wore black socks and no shoes, -Symbolize Black power
        (The athletes in the example above were responding to social divisions and
       inequalities)
                                             60
 • Raise their issues in a peaceful manner for seeking votes
ANSWER THE FOLLOWING -
Q1. Mention three similarities between Tommie Smith and John Carlos.
  • Both were African – Americans.
  • Both won medals at the Mexico Olympic Games in 1968.
  • Stood against racial discrimination which was practiced against the Africans in
    America.
Q2. Who was Peter Norman? Why did he support Carlos and Smith? What punishment
did he get for this?
  • Peter Norman was an Australian Athlete.
  • Norman wore a human rights badge on his shirt during the ceremony to show his
     support to the dissent of two American athletes.
  • Norman was not included in the Australian team for the next Olympic.
Q 3. How do class and religion overlap with each other in Northern Ireland?
 • In Northern Ireland the population is divided into two major sects of Christianity – 53%
     are Protestants and 44% are Roman Catholics. The Catholics are more likely to be poor
     and suffered a history of discrimination. On the other hand, the Protestants are rich.
     This resulted in conflicts between the two.
Q4. Explain two advantages and two disadvantages of social divisions in democracy.
Advantages
    • Political expressions of social divisions is very normal and can be healthy. This
       allows various disadvantaged and marginal social groups to express their grievances
       and get the government to attend to these.
    • Expression of various kinds of social divisions in politics often results in their
       canceling one another out and thus reducing their intensity.
Disadvantages
   • In a democracy the different social groups organize themselves to bring equality,
      social justice and other vested interests. Sometimes their protest results into violence
      or conflicts.
   • For the society which has high social divisions, becomes very difficult to ensure
      integrity and unity.
                                             61
LONG ANSWERS QUESTIONS : [5 MARKS]
1.    ‘Overlapping social differences create deep social divisions and Cross-cutting
      differences are easier to accommodate’- Justify the given statement.
 • Social divisions take place when some social difference overlaps with other differences.
 • The difference between Blacks and Whites becomes a social division in US because the
   Blacks tend to be poor, homeless and discriminated against.
 • When one kind of social difference become more important than the other, this produces
   social divisions. In Northern Ireland, class and religion overlap with each other.
 • If social differences cross cut one another, it is difficult to pit one group of people
   against the other. In Netherlands class and religion tend to cut across each other.
2. Explain the three determinants in deciding the outcome of politics with examples.
  • How people perceive their identities.
  • How Political leaders raise the demands of any community.
  • How the government reacts to demands of different groups. (To explain)
QUESTION BANK-
  1. How can social divisions be normal and can be healthy in a democracy?
  2. How do Migrants play a role in bringing social divisions in a country?
  3. Every social division does not lead to social differences – Explain.
  4. How is political expression of social divisions in democracy beneficial?
  5. Taking the example of Carlos, Smith and Norman explain how social differences
     divide similar people from one another but also unite very different people.
**********
                                            62
                                    CHAPTER 4
                           GENDER , RELIGION AND CASTE
GENDER
   • Sexual Division of labour – Woman do all the work inside the home or take the help of
     domestic helpers and men do work outside home.
  • Feminist Movement- A movement aimed at equality in personal and family life as
     well.(believe in equal rights and opportunities).
  • Role of Women in the society-
     a) Belief that responsibility of woman is house work and brining up children
     b) Their work were not valued and recognized
     c) Though constitute half the population their role is minimal especially in politics.
     d) Gender issue raised in politics – for equal rights, for voting, improve the political and
          legal status of women – for education &career (Feminist Movement)
  • Changing the Scenario of women’s role in public life
     a) Women working as Scientist, doctors, managers and college and university teachers.
     b) The participation of women in public life is high in developed Countries like Sweden,
          Norway and Finland.
  • Ways in which women are discriminated and oppressed –
     a) Literacy rate among women 54% and men 76% Reason – Girl students going for higher
          studies is less, More drop outs – as parents prefer to spend more for boys education
     b) Proportion of women in highly paid jobs are small –
     c) The Equal Wages Act provides that equal wage must be paid – but women are paid less
          than men
     d) Parents prefer to have sons and so decline in six – ratio
     e) Women are harassed and exploited in rural & urban areas – domestic violence
     f) Family laws of religions show discrimination against women
     g) Ours is still a male dominated , patriarchal society.
  • Women’s political representation
     a) Elected women member in Lok Sabha has not reached 10% and in State Assemblies 5% -
          very low
     b) A different scenario in Panchayatraj in India
       (i) 1 / 3 Seat in the local government is in Panchayat’s and Municipalities – reserved for
             women- more than 10lakh women representatives in their bodies.
     c) Proposal of bill before the parliament:-
       Reservation of at least 1/3 of seats in Lok Sabha and State Assemblies for women
Communalism –
          o The division based on religious differences.
          o A major challenge to democracy.
                                               63
        •   Religious prejudices – belief in the superiority of one’s religion over other religions
        •   A communal mind leads to political dominance of one’s own religious Community-
        •   Special appeal in electoral politics involving the use of Sacred symbols, religious leaders,
            emotional appeal and plain fear to bring the followers together.
3) Constitutional provisions given in the Constitution base on Secularism, to crub communalism:-
        • No official religion for the Indian state – no special status.
        • Freedom to profess, practice and propagate any religion.
        • Prohibits discrimination on the grounds of religion.
        • Ensures equality within religious communities.
4) Communal politics-
        • based on the idea that religion is the principle basis of social community-
        • State power is used to establish domination of one religious group over the rest.
        • One religion and followers are pitted against another.
Caste :-
        • Caste division based on – hereditary occupational division – exclusion and discrimination
            against ‘our caste’ groups – Causing social inequality.
        • Social reformers – who fought against Caste System are Gandhiji, Jotibaphule,
            B.R.Ambedkar, Periyar Ramaswami Naicker.
        • Reasons for changes undergone in Caste system – Urbanization, -occupational mobility, -
            breaking down of caste hierarchy(old notions) – Constitution of India prohibited any caste
            based discrimination – Ban on un touchability – access to modern education.
5. Various forms of Caste in politics –
        • To win elections parties choose candidates from different castes and tribes
        • Make appeals to caste sentiments – favour some caste, and are seen as their
            representatives
        • One person – one vote, No parliamentary constituency in the country has majority of one
        • Single caste – so they need more than one caste, to win election.
        • It brought a new consciousness among the people of caste that they were treated low
        • The ruling party MP or MLA frequently loose election – will not happen if it was not
            Caste bias.
Result –
            Caste group become bigger by incorporating with other caste or sub caste
            Some Caste enter into dialogue and negotiation with other
            Formation of new caste groups –backward, forward caste groups.
Q2. Give any three provisions that make India a secular state ?
       • There is no official religion for Indian state.
       • The constitution provides to all individuals and communities freedom to profess, practice
           and propagate any religion.
                                                  64
       •   The Constitution prohibits discrimination on grounds of religion.
Q3.Explain any three factors responsible for breaking down the caste hierarchy in our country?
      • With economic development, large scale urbanization, growth of literacy and education.
      • Occupational mobility and weakening of the positions of landlords in the villages, the
          caste hierarchy is breaking down.
      • The Constitution of India prohibited any caste-based discrimination. We don’t see the
          practice of untouchability anywhere today.
      • Caste system also weakened due to the efforts of our political leaders and social reformers
          like Jyothiba Phule, Gandhiji, B.R. Ambedkar and Periyar Ramaswami Naicker.
Q.2. What are the various forms that communalism can take in politics in India?
      • Communalism in daily beliefs – These routinely involve religious prejudices,
         stereotypes of religious communities and belief in the superiority of one’s religion over
         other religions. This is so common that we often fail to notice it, even when we believe in
         it.
      • Formation of Political parties based on religious communities- A communal mind
                                                65
           often leads to a quest for political dominance of one’s own religious community. For
           those belonging to majority community, this takes the form of majoritarian dominance.
           For those belonging to the minority community, it can take the form of a desire to form a
           separate political unit.
       •   Political mobilization on religious lines- It is another frequent form of communalism.
           This involves the use of sacred symbols, religious leaders, emotional appeal and plain
           fear in order to bring the followers of one religion together in political arena. In electoral
           politics this often involves special appeal to the interests or emotions of voters of one
           religion in preference to others.
       •   Communal Riots- Sometimes communalism takes its most ugly form of communal
           violence, riots and massacre. India and Pakistan suffered some of the worst communal
           riots at the time of the Partition. The post- Independence period has also seen large scale
           communal violence.
Q-3. What are the various ways by which women face discrimination, disadvantage and
oppression in our society today?
       • The proportion of women among the highly paid and valued job is still very small.
       • Parent’s prefer to spend their resources for their boys education rather than spending
           equally on their sons and daughters. Thus the literacy rate among the women is low.
       • Women are paid less than men, even when both do exactly the same work.
       • In many parts of India parents prefer to have sons and find ways to have the girl child
           aborted
       • They are not safe even in their home today. Beating, harassment and other forms of
           domestic violence continue.
       • Women are paid less than men, even when both do the same work.
QUESTION BANK
  1. What was Gandhji’s view on religion and politics?
  2. Describe the ways in which Communalism poses a great threat to the Indian democracy?
  3.  List the main aims of the Feminist Movement?
  4.  Why did our Constitution framers choose the model of a secular state?
  5.  Suggest steps to improve the status of women in Indian society?
  6.  What is sexual division of labour?
**********
66