Estres Parental
Estres Parental
ISSN: 0214-9915
                                                                          psicothema@cop.es
                                                                          Universidad de Oviedo
                                                                          España
How to cite
Complete issue
                                                                                                      Scientific Information System
More information about this article           Network of Scientific Journals from Latin America, the Caribbean, Spain and Portugal
Journal's homepage in redalyc.org                          Non-profit academic project, developed under the open access initiative
Psicothema 2007. Vol. 19, nº 4, pp. 687-692                                                                                      ISSN 0214 - 9915 CODEN PSOTEG
www.psicothema.com                                                                                                                    Copyright © 2007 Psicothema
                            As a specific measure to assess levels of parental stress is lacking in Spain, the aim of this study was
                            to develop the Spanish version of the Parental Stress Scale (PSS). After translating it from English in-
                            to Spanish using the forward-backward translation method, it was administered to a sample of 211
                            first-time parents (105 males and 106 females). A factor analysis was carried out to assess its dimen-
                            sionality. After refining the scale, we obtained a two-factor solution that accounted for 33.5% of the
                            variance, with the factors Stressors and Parenting Rewards. No gender differences were found either
                            in the scale or in the dimensions. Criterion-related validity was tested by means of correlations with
                            anxiety and depressive symptoms and, with regard to internal consistency, adequate alpha coefficients
                            were obtained for both factors.
    The birth of the first baby is one of the events that most                      review, see Lessenberry & Rehfeldt, 2004). Among those specific
influence exerts over the couple dynamics. As the first baby                        measures for parental stress used in English, we may highlight
comes, couples should face several changes that remarkably affect                   both Parenting Stress Index (PSI; Abidin, 1995) and Parental
different areas of their lives (personal, marital, family, and work).               Stress Scale (PSS; Berry & Jones, 1995) because of their adequate
Thus, in the process of adapting to this new role, both members of                  psychometric properties. Although no full psychometric
the couple, but especially women, may experience high levels of                     properties are provided, a Spanish adaptation of the PSI scale has
stress (Belsky, Lang, & Rovine, 1985; Berry & Jones, 1995;                          already been used with a sample of mothers of autistics (Pozo,
Coltrane, 2000; Cox, 1985; Yogev, 1986). As a consequence of                        Sarriá, & Méndez, 2006). Nevertheless, the use of the PSS (Berry
these stress levels, the transition to parenthood might be more                     & Jones, 1995) is especially recommended because it displays
difficult, and psychological problems may arise at different levels:                better applicability: a) being a shorter and more easily
individual, couple relationship, and relationship with the baby.                    understandable self-report, and b) covering parents’ stress levels
    An early detection of a couple’s difficulties due to high levels                even from childbirth. The Parental Stress Scale is an assessment
of stress may help us to prevent more serious consequences in                       tool designed to measure the level of stress that parents experience
terms of each partner’s psychological health —depressive and                        as a result of having to rear children. It focuses specifically on the
anxiety symptoms— (Garret, 2003; Windle & Dumenci, 1997), in                        stress generated by the parenting role, as opposed to other
the couple relationship (Lavee, Sharlin, & Katz, 1996), and in the                  instruments that fail to separate parenting stress from the stress
baby’s welfare (Benzies, Harrison, & Magill-Evans, 2004). In this                   that be a result of other roles and situations, such as financial or
context, it is necessary to obtain valid and reliable assessment                    marital problems, or to those instruments that assess the stress
tools of new parents’ stress.                                                       generated by the parenting role only in a very specific situation
    The measurement of parents’ stress levels has been                              (i.e., during child hospitalization, Ochoa, Repáraz, & Polaino-
traditionally carried out with different assessment tools (for a                    Lorente, 1997). The PSS is made up of 18 items rated on a Likert-
                                                                                    type scale that describe the parent-child relationship and how each
                                                                                    parent feels about it.
Fecha recepción: 2-10-06 • Fecha aceptación: 9-4-07                                     Regardless of the existence of reliable assessment tools in
Correspondencia: Itziar Alonso-Arbiol                                               English, we do not have a specific measure of parental stress in
Facultad de Psicología
                                                                                    Spanish. Therefore, the aim of this study is to adapt the PSS to
Universidad del País Vasco
20018 Donostia (Spain)                                                              Spanish so that it can be used confidently with Spanish-speaking
E-mail: itziar.alonso@ehu.es                                                        people.
688                                             BEATRIZ ORONOZ, ITZIAR ALONSO-ARBIOL AND NEKANE BALLUERKA
                                        Method                                                (item 16, ‘Having a child(ren) has meant having too few choices
                                                                                              and too little control over my life’) was considered by the
Participants                                                                                  researchers as too vague and ambiguous, a 17-item Spanish
                                                                                              version was considered for the translation phase. In order to
   The sample comprised 211 married or cohabiting heterosexual                                increase linguistic equivalence between the existing English-
participants living in Gipuzkoa (Spain) —both members of the                                  language PSS and the new Spanish-language PSS, a forward-
couple in 106 dyads1— who had a baby between 3 and 8 months                                   backward translation method was used. Each English item was
(M= 5.37; SD= .72). The mean for the total time living with their                             translated into Spanish by a bilingual researcher familiar with the
partner was 4.7 years (SD= 2.65), and age ranged from 20 to 39                                field of parental stress. A bilingual linguist familiar with both
years (M= 31.5; SD= 3.46) for women, and from 24 to 53 (M=                                    societies and parenting process then translated the proposed
33.4; SD= 4.40) for men. As for work status, 84% of women and                                 Spanish-language items back into English. The two translations
98% of men were paid workers.                                                                 were compared, discussed, and reduced to a single mutually
                                                                                              agreeable wording, and carefully examined by us to determine
PSS Item Forward-Backward Translation                                                         whether the items seemed to be essentially the same as the
                                                                                              English-language originals.
    Before translating the items of a questionnaire into another                                  Some small changes were made during this process to adjust
language to be used in a country with its own culture, conceptual                             the items’ ability to fit into contemporary Spanish. For example,
equivalence and content equivalence of the underlying construct                               we used the wording «padre/madre» (father/mother) when
should be considered. Conceptual equivalence refers to having                                 «parent» was used in English items, because the exact translation
similar meanings in different cultures (Flaherty, Gaviria, Pathak,                            for this gender-neutral term (progenitor) would have sounded too
Mitchell, Wintrob, Richman, & Birz, 1988). Two researchers who                                formal for the context in Spanish (see items 1, 15, and 17).
are experts in the field agreed that the meaning of the parental                              Another change took place in item 13, where «incómodo»
stress construct underlying the PSS scale was meaningful in                                   (uncomfortable) was preferred in the Spanish version instead of
Spanish culture.                                                                              the exact equivalent word (embarazoso) for «embarrassing» from
    Content equivalence is established by showing that the content                            the English version. The final wordings of all items are shown in
of each item is relevant to the culture being considered and likely                           Table 1.
to have similar meanings in both cultural contexts. In our case,                                  Once the item wording had been decided, the items were placed
two bilingual researchers who were fluent in both English and                                 in a questionnaire format in which participants were asked to rate
Spanish and were involved in the back-translation process                                     each one on a 1-to-5 Likert-type response scale ranging from 1
evaluated the content equivalence of each item. All 18 items of                               (strongly disagree [totalmente en desacuerdo]) to 5 (strongly agree
the existing English-language PSS were thought to be relevant to                              [totalmente de acuerdo]). The items appeared in the same order as
parenting stress relationships in Spain but, since one of them                                in the English-language PSS (except for the eliminated item).
                                                                                       Table 1
                                    Factor weights of items from the factor analysis of generalized least-squares estimation with oblimin rotation
                                                                                                                                                     Factors
 Item                                                                                                                                        1          2       3
 01. Me siento feliz en mi papel como padre/madre (R)                                                                                      -.034      .051     -.706
 02. No hay nada o casi nada que no haría por mi hijo/a si fuera necesario (R) (D)                                                          .018      -.096    -.248
 03. Atender a mi hijo/a a veces me quita más tiempo y energía de la que tengo                                                              .107      .635     .139
 04. A veces me preocupa el hecho de si estoy haciendo lo suficiente por mi hijo/a (D)                                                      -.115     .252     .001
 05. Me siento muy cercano/a a mi hijo/a (R)                                                                                                .189      -.008    -.313
 06. Disfruto pasando tiempo con mi hijo/a (R)                                                                                              .388      .090     -.458
 07. Mi hijo/a es una fuente importante de afecto para mí (R) (D)                                                                           .954      -.013    -.095
 08. Tener un hijo/a me da una visión más certera y optimista para el futuro (R) (D)                                                        .165      .207     -.191
 09. La mayor fuente de estrés en mi vida es mi hijo/a                                                                                      .112      .620     -.032
 10. Tener un hijo/a deja poco tiempo y flexibilidad en mi vida                                                                             .045      .674     -.011
 11. Tener un hijo/a ha supuesto una carga financiera                                                                                      -.043      .350     .077
 12. Me resulta difícil equilibrar diferentes responsabilidades debido a mi hijo/a                                                          .005      .649     -.083
 13. El comportamiento de mi hijo/a a menudo me resulta incómodo o estresante                                                              -.059      .570     -.205
 14. Si tuviera que hacerlo de nuevo, podría decidir no tener un hijo/a (D)                                                                 .115      .172     -.011
 15. Me siento abrumado/a por la responsabilidad de ser padre/madre                                                                         .029      .422     -.137
 16. Me siento satisfecho/a como padre/madre (R)                                                                                           -.005      .186     -.792
 17. Disfruto de mi hijo/a (R)                                                                                                             -.032      .103     -.726
measures can be expected to show gender differences (e.g., Brody                      Parental Stress Scale (PSS). The results show that the final 12-
& Hall, 1989; Hovanitz & Kozora, 1989; Remor, 2006). In our                           item Spanish version of the PSS has adequate factor and criterion-
sample, means and standard deviations for males and females are                       related validity, as well as adequate internal consistency reliability.
respectively as follows: 20.3 (SD= 4.7) and 22.3 (SD= 6.0) for the                    Furthermore, the latest data about new parents in the Basque
total score for Parental Stress; 7.1 (SD= 1.6) and 6.9 (SD= 1.9) for                  region in 2004, showed that 87% of women and 99.9% of men
Baby’s Rewards; and 13.2 (SD= 3.9) and 15.4 (SD= 4.9) for                             were paid workers, which are very similar percentages to those of
Stressors. As for gender, no differences were found, as it can be                     our sample. Thus, although we did not use a random design for the
seen in Table 3. In fact, although statistically significant                          data collection, our study may have produced quite similar data to
differences emerged for the Parental Stress Scale and for the                         that obtained in the target population. Moreover, assessment
Stressor subscale in the Mann-Whitney’s U analysis, the effect                        performance with the parents in this study confirms that the
size was small in both cases (η2= .03 and η2= .04, respectively).                     Spanish version of the questionnaire is easy to understand and
    The second issue we examined was the association between                          quick to administer, supporting its feasibility in everyday clinical
Parental Stress and its subscales, and two related variables                          and research practice.
—anxiety (STAI) and depressive symptoms (BDI)—. Before                                    When factor structures of our Spanish version and of the
calculating these correlations, we examined whether possible                          original American version were compared, some differences were
gender differences for anxiety and depressive symptoms appeared.                      highlighted. Specifically, authors included four subscales in the
In our sample, means and standard deviations for males and                            original American version: the two subscales we found in our
females were respectively as follows: 14.0 (SD= 8.1) and 16.4                         study (i.e., ‘baby’s rewards’ and ‘parental stressors’), and two
(SD= 10.1) for anxiety; and 3.5 (SD= 3.5) and 5.7 (SD= 4.7) for                       additional short subscales (i.e., ‘lack of control’ and ‘parental
depressive symptoms. As for the gender differences test, only                         satisfaction’). Nevertheless, these two subscales proved to be
depressive symptoms were significantly higher for women than                          somewhat problematic because they showed a considerable
for men (Mann-Whitney’s U= 3,693.50; p<.001; η2= .08). Thus,                          empirical overlap with the two scales that also appeared in our
we computed zero-order correlations among target variables                            study and furthermore, they are not based upon a clear theoretical
without making any gender distinction (see Table 4).                                  distinction. Therefore, a two-dimensional structure seems much
    Previous studies (e.g., Wilkie & Ames, 1986; Windle &                             appropriate in the design of an assessment tool for parental stress.
Dumenci, 1997) have found that parental stress is related to                              The transition to parenthood becomes a complicated period
depressive symptoms and to anxiety. The results obtained in our                       where changes and redefinitions take place in men and women’s
study pointed in the same direction, where all correlations were                      lives in order to adjust to the new role of being a father or mother.
moderate or high (ranging from -.29 to .51).                                          In this adaptation process, members of the couple may experiment
                                                                                      both negative and positive sides of parenthood, which Fawcett
                                   Discussion                                         (1988) called «costs and benefits» of motherhood/fatherhood. In
                                                                                      this respect, the two dimensions of PSS in our study —‘baby’s
   The purpose of this study was to examine the psychometric                          rewards’ and ‘parental stressors’— cover that combination of pros
properties (validity and reliability) of the Spanish version of the                   and cons that accompany the transition to parenthood. While the
                                                                                      baby’s reward dimension refers to the satisfaction that
                                                                                      mothers/fathers find in the parental role, parental stressors refers
                                                                                      to the stress levels parents find in this new role. This cost-benefit
                                     Table 3                                          idea also appears in the Parent Stress Index (PSI, Abidin, 1995),
       Mean differences on parental stress scale and dimensions for gender
                                                                                      where two subscales, called «parental stress» and «child’s
                           Mean range                 Mann-                           reinforcement of parent», also emerged.
                          Men     Women              Whitney’s U            p   η2        The relationship of parental stress with both anxiety and
                                                                                      depressive symptoms provided a basis for the criterion-related
 Parental Stress          095.55      116.35            4,468.000       .013    .03   validity of the questionnaire. These results are in line with the
    Baby’s Rewards        111.62      100.43            4,975.000       .114    .01   extensive scientific literature that pointed out that the emotional
    Stressors             092.96      118.92            4,195.500       .002    .04   expression of general stress is characterized by anxiety and
                                                                                      depression (Bados, Solanas, & Andrés, 2005; Lazarus, 1993;
                                                                                      Lovibond & Lovibond, 1995), and that parental stress is
                                     Table 4                                          associated with anxiety (Wilkie & Ames, 1986) and with
      Correlations among parental stress, subscales, anxiety, and depressive
                                                                                      depressive symptoms (Windle & Dumenci, 1997).
                                   symptoms
                                                                                          Regarding the possible relationship between gender and
                                                              Variables               parental stress, our data shows some differences in comparison
                                     1           2           3          4       5     with earlier findings with American samples (e.g., Belsky et al.,
                                                                                      1985; Berry & Jones, 1995; Coltrane, 2000; Cox, 1985; Yogev,
 1. Parental Stress                  —
                                                                                      1986). In these previous studies, when the core dimension of
 2. Baby’s Rewards                 -.56**       —                                     parental stress was examined, it seemed that women suffered
 3. Stressors                      -.97**      -.34**        —                        higher levels of stress. This has been accounted for within a
 4. Anxiety                        -.49**      -.32**      .47**       —              complex context, where women’s high levels of stress are a
 5. Depressive symptoms            -.51**      -.29**      .50**     .69**      —     consequence of multiple individual, couple and social factors,
                                                                                      such as work overload, conflict of family-work roles, and the
 ** p<.001, two-tailed
                                                                                      involvement of the husband/partner in child-rearing (Lewis &
                                       A SPANISH ADAPTATION OF THE PARENTAL STRESS SCALE                                                              691
Cooper, 1988). However, the much smaller differences found in                  and social applied settings, and especially as a first screening to
our study might be explained in terms of a general growing                     detect couples with high levels of stress or related difficulties in
involvement of men in child-rearing, and also a possible cultural              the transition to parenthood.
distinctiveness may be underlying, as suggested by Hofstede’s
(1998) studies. According to Hofstede’s ranking of countries as                                          Acknowledgements
regards the masculinity/femininity dimension, Spain is a less
masculine country than the United States, so the rigidity of gender               This research was supported by a grant from the Research
roles should be somewhat lower in Spain — and especially in the                Bureau of the University of the Basque Country to the first author
Basque region (Alonso-Arbiol, Shaver, & Yárnoz, 2002) —                        for the completion of her doctoral dissertation under the second
leading to an equal involvement of men and women in child-                     author’s supervision (1/UPV 00218.230-H-13680/2001). The
rearing.                                                                       authors wish to thank Bide Etxeberria, Aloña Goiburu, Vanesa
   The Spanish version of the PSS is the first instrument that                 Mangas, Idoia Otaegi, Laura Sepúlveda, Pilar Valor, Isabel Vila,
assesses the stress levels suffered by Spanish parents as a                    Sandra Villagrá, and Saioa Zarrazquin for invaluable help
consequence of the parental role. Nevertheless, it is important to             collecting parents’ data.
warn of the study’s limitations. The main limitation is the small
size of the sample. Therefore, future research should focus on                                                   Notes
obtaining data from more specific samples, which should include
other groups not represented in the study (i.e., parents with more             1     Data from one man was not collected because he did not show
than one child, parents of older children, adoptive parents). On the                 up at the assessment interview.
other hand, in future studies, temporal stability should be explored           2     The previous Spanish version of PSS was made up of the 17
and confirmatory analyses carried out to ratify the model.                           items that were translated into Spanish.
   To sum up, the Spanish version of the PSS seems to be an                    3     These two items did not fit in any dimension of the English
accurate instrument for assessing parental stress in both clinical                   version of the PSS.
References
Abidin, R.R. (1995). Parenting Stress Index: Professional manual (3rd ed.).    Garrett, R. (2003). Measures of anxiety, stress, marital satisfaction, and
   Odessa, FL: Psychological Assessment Resources.                                depression among first time expectant fathers living in a rural commu-
Alonso-Arbiol, I., Shaver, P. R., & Yárnoz, S. (2002). Insecure attachment,       nity: an antepartum and postpartum study. Unpublished doctoral dis-
   gender roles, and interpersonal dependency in the Basque Country.              sertation, Capella University.
   Personal Relationships, 9, 479-490.                                         Hofstede, G. (1998). Masculinity and femininity. Thousands Oaks: Sage.
Bados, A., Solanas, A., & Andrés, R. (2005). Psychometric properties of        Hovanitz, C.A., & Kozora, E. (1989). Life stress and clinically elevated
   the Spanish version of depression, anxiety and stress scales (DASS).           MMPI scales: Gender differences in the moderating influence of cop-
   Psicothema, 17, 679-683.                                                       ing. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 45, 766-777.
Beck, A.T., Ward, C.H., Mendelson, M., Mock, J., & Erbaugh, J. (1961).         Lavee, Y., Sharlin, S., & Katz, R. (1996). The effect of parenting stress on
   An inventory for measuring depression. Archives of General Psychia-            marital quality: An integrated mother-father model. Journal of Family
   tric, 4, 561-571.                                                              Issues, 17, 114-135.
Belsky, J., Lang, J.M., & Rovine, M. (1985). Stability and change in mar-      Lazarus, R.S. (1993). From psychological stress to emotions: A history of
   riage across the transition parenthood: A second study. Journal of Mar-        changing outlooks. Annual Review of Psychology, 44, 1-21.
   riage and the Family 47, 855-865.                                           Lessenberry, B.M., & Rehfeldt, R.A. (2004). Evaluating stress levels of
Benzies, K.M., Harrison, M.J., & Magill-Evans, J. (2004). Parenting               parents of children with disabilities. Council for Exceptional Children,
   stress, marital quality, and child behavior problems at age 7 years. Pub-      70, 231-244.
   lic Health Nursing, 21, 111-121.                                            Lewis, S.L., & Cooper, C.N. (1988). The transition to parenthood in dual-
Berry, J.O., & Jones, W.H. (1995). The Parental Stress scale: Initial psy-        earner couples. Psychological Medicine, 18, 477-486.
   chometric evidence. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, 12,       Lovibond, P.F., & Lovibond, S.H. (1995). The structure of negative emo-
   463-472.                                                                       tional states: Comparison of the Depression Anxiety Stress Scales
Brody, L.R., & Hall, J.A. (1989). Gender and emotion. In M. Lewis & J. M.         (DASS) with the Beck Depression and Anxiety Inventories. Behavior
   Haviland (Eds.): Handbook of emotions (pp. 447-460). New York: Guilford.       Research and Therapy, 33, 335-343.
Coltrane, S. (2000). Research on household labor: Modeling and measur-         Ochoa, B., Repáraz, Ch., & Polaino-Lorente, A. (1997). Estudios prelimi-
   ing the social embeddedness of routine family work. Journal of Mar-            nares de validez de la escala PSS: Cuestionario de estrés en padres de
   riage and Family, 62, 1208-1233.                                               niños hospitalizados. Clínica y Salud, 8, 423-446.
Conde, V., Esteban, T., & Useros, E. (1976). Revisión crítica de la adapta-    Pozo, P., Sarriá, E., & Méndez, L. (2006). Estrés en madres de personas
   ción castellana del cuestionario de Beck. Revista de Psicología Gene-          con trastorno del espectro autista. Psicothema, 18, 342-347.
   ral Aplicada, 31, 469-497.                                                  Remor, E. (2006). Psychometric properties of a European Spanish version
Cox, M.J. (1985). Progress and continued challenges in understanding the          of the Perceived Stress Scale (PSS). The Spanish Journal of Psycholo-
   transition to parenthood. Journal of Family Issues, 6, 395-408.                gy, 9, 86-93.
Fawcett, J.T. (1988). The value of children and the transition to parent-      Spielberger, C.D., Gorsuch, R.L., & Lushene, R.E. (1970). STAI manual.
   hood. In R. Palkovitz & M.B. Sussman (Eds.): Transition to parent-             California: Consulting Psychologists Press, 1970.
   hood. N.Y.: Harworth Press.                                                 Spielberger, C.D., Gorsuch, R.L., & Lushene, R. (1994). Manual del
Flaherty, J.A., Gaviria, M., Pathak, D., Mitchell, T., Wintrob, R., Richman,      Cuestionario de Ansiedad Estado/Rasgo (STAI), 4ª edición. Madrid:
   J., & Birz, S. (1988). Developing instruments for cross-cultural psy-          TEA.
   chiatric research. The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 176,          Yogev, S. (1986). Relationship between stress and marital satisfaction
   257-263.                                                                       among dual earner couples. Woman and Therapy, 5, 313-330.
692                                BEATRIZ ORONOZ, ITZIAR ALONSO-ARBIOL AND NEKANE BALLUERKA
Windle, M., & Dumenci, L. (1997). Parental and occupational stress as   Wilkie, C.F., & Ames, E.W. (1986). The relationship of infant crying to
  predictors of depressive symptoms among dual-income couples: A           parental stress in the transition to parenthood. Journal of Marriage and
  multilevel modeling approach. Journal of Marriage and the Family,        the Family, 48 , 545-550.
  59, 625-634.