CHAPTER 1 General provisions                       PARTNERSHIP VS.
JOINT VENTURE
PARTNERSHIP                                        Being a form of partnership, a joint venture is
                                                   generally governed by the law on
     A contract wherein two or more               partnership.
      persons bind themselves to
      contribute money, property, or
      industry to a common fund, with the          DOCTRINE OF DELECTUS PERSONAE
      intention of dividing the profits            “The right to choose with whom a person
      among themselves.                            wishes to associate himself”.
        Two or more persons may also form a              Is the very foundation and essence of
        partnership for the exercise of a                 partnership
        profession.
Profession- is a group of men pursuing a           DELECTUS PERSONARUM “Choice of
learned art as a common calling in the spirit      persons”
of public service
                                                   DELECTUS PERSONAE “Choice of the
ESSENTIAL REQUISITES                               person”
              Valid contract                      BEST EVIDENCE OF THE EXISTENCE OF A
              Contribution of money,              PARTNERSHIP
        property, or industry
                                                   Unsold goods and uncollected receivables,
              Organized for gain or profit
                                                   which were presented to the trial court.
Have a lawful object or purpose, establish for
common benefit or interest
                                                                  1768
“Public instrument is necessary only where         ARTIFICIAL/JURIDICAL PERSON
immovable property or real rights are
contributed”.                                      Created by law and given certain legal rights
“An oral contract of partnership is as good as a   and duties of human being. The partnership
written one”.                                      itself which is the juridical person can:
                                                      1. Acquire and possess real and personal
CHARACTERISTICS of contract of a                         property
partnership                                           2. Incur obligations
    1. Consensual – perfected by mere                 3. Bring civil or criminal actions
       consent; had a meetings of minds.                          1769
    2. Commutative – contribution of each
       partner is considered as the                   RULES to determine partnership exist:
       equivalent of the other partners.
    3. Principal– does not depend on other             Persons who are not partners as to
       contract for its existence.                      each other are not partners as to third
    4. Bilateral– entered by two or more                persons.
       persons.                                         Example: If A and B say publicly that
    5. Onerous– each partner must                       they are not partners, then according
       contribute.                                      to Article 1825, if they told C that they
    6. Nominate- has name in law.                       are and C enters into a contract of
                                                        partnership with them, then A and B
   7.7 Preparation-for another contract.                are in Partnership of Estoppel
                                                      2. The profits shall be confiscated in
     Co-ownership or co-possession does                 favour of the government.
      not of itself establish a partnership.          3. The instruments or tools and proceeds
                                                         of the crime shall be forfeited in favour
    PARTNERSHIP VS. CO-OWNERSHIP                         of the government.
                Partnership      Co-ownership         4. The contributions of the partners shall
                                                         not be confiscated unless they fall
 Creation       Created by       Created by              under no. 3.
                contract         contact and
                                 law
                                                      Example: A and B are partners where A
 Juridical   It can be sue       None                 contributed P100,000 in cash and B
 personality or be sued                               contributes gambling paraphernalia. They
                                                      were raided and the gambling
 Purpose        For profit       Common               paraphernalia was confiscated, can the
                                 enjoyment of a       P100,000 also be confiscated? -No
                                 thing or right       because the P100,000 was not the reason
 Profit         It may be        Must always          for crime anyway. The state is therefore
                stipulated       depend on the        required to return this amount on A.
                upon             proportionate
                                 shares                            1771
 Dissolution    By death or      It is not        “A partnership may be constituted in any
                incacity of      dissolved by     form”
                partner          the death of
                                 co-owner         EXCEPTION: If real properties or real rights
                                                  in real properties are contributed regardless
 Form           When a real   No public           of the value. A public instrument is needed;
                property is   instrument is       otherwise, the contract of partnership is void.
                contributed, needed.
                a public                          REAL RIGHTS- connected with a thing rather
                instrument is                     than a person.
                required.
                                                  PUBLIC INSTRUMENT- a document prepared
                                                  by a notary public in the presence of the
                                                  parties who sign it before witnesses.
     The sharing of gross returns does not
      of itself establish a partnership.                           1772
                                                  Partnerships with a capital of 3,000 or more
     The receipt by a person of a share of
                                                  must register with the SEC. Registration
      the profits of a business is prima facie
                                                  requirement is not mandatory.
      evidence that he is a partner in the
      business                                    PURPOSE OF REGISTRATION
                 1770                             The registration is to set “a condition for the
“UNLAWFUL PARTNERSHIP is dissolved by a           issuance of licences to engage in business or
judicial decree; profits confiscated by State”.   trade.”
EFFECTS OF AN UNLAWFUL PARTNERSHIP                Example: A and B promise to contribute to
                                                  their partnership money worth P10,000 each
    1. The contract is void from the very
                                                  within one year from their agreement. A
       beginning.
contributes early but when the time comes for                      the one liable.   liable for the
B to contribute his share he refuses to do so.                                       debts of the
Can A compel B to give his contributions? -No,                                       association.
A cannot compel B to pay his contribution to
the partnership, because the contract or
agreement between two parties was purely           ASSOCIATION, cannot sue because it doesn’t
oral and never really written and it has           have legal personality”.
already been one year since they agreed to
their contract terms                                              1776
                                                   CLASSIFICATION OF PARTNERSHIP
                 1773                                 1. According to object
“A contract of partnership is void, whenever              a.) Universal partnership of all
immovable property is contributed thereto, if             profits.
an inventory of said property is not made,                - All partners may acquire by their
signed by the parties, and attached to the                    work
public instrument.                                        - Only the usufruct of the
                                                              properties of the partners
“This article was intended to protect third                   becomes common property.
persons”.                                                 - Less obligation because their real
                                                              and personal properties are
                  1774                                        retained by them in naked
IMMOVABLE PROPERTY                                            ownership.
   -   To be acquired must be in the name of                   b.)Universal partnership of all
       the partnership and if conveyed must                    present property
       also be in the partnership name.                   -    Contributes and divide the profits
                                                               among themselves.
                                                          -    Inheritance, Legacy or Donation
                 1775                                          cannot be included in the
PARTNERSHIP VS ASSOCIATION                                     stipulation, but the fruits can be
                                                               included(Art.1779)
                Partnership        Association            -    Future property cannot be
                                                               donated (Art.1779)
Juridical       It has             None
personality     juridical                                 2. According to liability
                personality                               General Partnership
Purpose         It is for profit   It may not be      -   Liable up to the extent of their
                                   for profit             separate properties after the assets of
                                                          the partnership have been exhausted.
Contribution    Money,             No
                                                          Limited Partnership
of members      property, or       contribution
                                                      -   Liable only to the extent of his
                industry or a      although fees
                                                          contribution.
                combination        are usually
                                                      -   Discussed in chapter 4.
                of these           collected to
                                   maintain the
                                   organization               3. According to Duration
Liability       The                Members are            Partnership at will
                partnership is     individually
      -   No fixed term, continued after the       1. As to Contribution
          termination of such term without any     a.) Capitalist partners
          express agreement.                           - Contribute money or property or
                                                          both
                                                   b.) Industrial partners
      Partnership with a fixed term                    - Contribute their labor or
      -   Period of existence agreed upon by              industry/service
          the partners                             c.) Capitalist-industrial partners
                                                       - Contributes money, property and
                                                          industry
Partnership for a particular undertaking
                                                   2. as to Liability
-     Exist until the purpose is accomplished
    4. According to representation to others       a.) General Partners
                                                       - Can be held liable to third persons
Ordinary Partnership                                      for partnership obligations, even
                                                          to the extent of their separate
*Insert partnership meaning*                              property.
                                                   b.) Limited Partners
Partnership by estoppel                                - Cannot held liable to third
      -   Person, by words spoken or written              persons
          or by conduct, represents themselves,    3. As to Management
          as partners in an existing partnership
                                                   a.) Managing Partners
5. According to the legality of its existence           - Manage actively the business
De Jure Partnership                                b) Silent Partners
                                                        - do not take active part in the
      -   Complied with legal requirements for             business though they share in the
          its creation                                     profit or losses.
                                                   c.) Liquidating Partners
De Facto Partnership                                    -   take charge of the winding up or
      -   Not complied with legal requirements             liquidation of the partnership
          for its creation                                 affairs after dissolution.
                                                   4. as to third persons
      PRESUMPTION IN FAVOR OF                      a.) Ostensible Partners
      UNIVERSAL PARTNERSHIP OF PROFITS                 - Take active part and known for
                                                          the public.
The universal partnership of profits imposes       b.) Secret Partners
less obligation because their real and                 - Not known to the public
personal properties are retained by them in        c.) Dormant Partners
naked ownership.                                       - Do not take active part and not
                                                          known to the public as partners.
                                                          Both silent and secret partners.
                 CHAPTER 2
                                                   5. As to membership
OBLIGATIONS of the partners                        a.) Real Partners
KINDS OF PARTNERS                                      - Existing legal right
                                                   b.) Partners by estoppel
       -   Not really partners but represents          -   Represents the minority interest
           themselves to anyone as partners
                                                SECTION 1 OBLIGATIONS OF
6. As to continuation of the businesses         THE PARTNERS AMONG
affairs after dissolution                       THEMSELVES
   a.) Continuing Partners                      Legal Relations created by a contract of
       - Continue the partnership after         Partnership
          dissolution
   b.) Discontinuing Partners                          1. Between partners
       - Do not continue the business                  2. Between partners and the
                                                          partnership itself
                                                       3. Between partners and third
                                                          persons
7. As to the nature of membership
                                                       4. Between partnership and third
   a.) Original Partners                                  person
       - Members from the time of its
                                                OBLIGATIONS OF PARTNERS
          constitution
   b.) Incoming Partners                            Give promised contribution
       - Members after its establishments           Not to convert partnership money for
   c.) Retiring Partners                             personal use
       - Withdraw from partnership                  To account and hold as trustee for any
                                                     profits derived without consent of
                                                     partners
8. As to state of survivorship
                                                    Not to engage same business with the
   a.) Surviving Partners                            partnership
       - Continue the partnership after the         Managing partners; credit to the
          dissolution by reason of death of a        partnership the payment made by the
          partner                                    debtor
   b.) Deceased Partners                            Share the partnership credit when
       - Died while being a member                   they receive from insolvent debtor
                                                    Pay damages
9. As to the effect of expulsion                Rights of Partners
   a. Expelled Partners                             Associate with another person in their
      - Expelled from partnership for a              share
         valid cause                                To have access, inspect and copy
                                                     partnership books
   b. Expelling Partners                            Demand formal account
       - caused the expulsion of a                  Ask for dissolution of the partnership
       partner with a valid reason                  Property rights
                                                      specific partnership property
                                                      interest in the partnership
                                                         participate in management
10. As to the value of the contribution
                                                “LIMITED PARTNERS have no right to
   a. Majority Partners
                                                participate in the management”.
      - Represents the majority or
         controlling interest
   b. Nominal Partners
                   1784                               Appraisal is necessary to determine
                                                       how much has been contributed by
      Partnership begins from the moment              the partners.
       of the execution of the contract.
                                                The appraisal is made by:
Future Partnership
                                                    Stipulation
      Partners may stipulate some other            If there’s no stipulation, expert chosen
       date for the commencement of the              by the partners according to the
       partnership.                                  current prices
                   1785
                                                               1788
Partnership with a fixed term
                                                ESSENCE OF PARTNERSHIP
      Life or period of the partnership that
       been agreed upon by the partners;        Being a contract of partnership, each partner
       automatically dissolved the              must share in the profits and losses of the
       partnership.                             venture.
Partnership for a particular undertaking        CASES COVERED OF THE LIABILITY FOR
                                                DAMAGES AND INTEREST
      Will exist until the purpose is
       accomplished
                                                       1. Money promised by a partner is
Partnership at Will                                       not given on time
                                                       2. Money of the partnership is
      Partnership that does not fix its term             converted to partners’ own use
                                                               1789
                   1786
                                                CAPITALIST PARTNER VS INDUTRIAL
Obligation of every partner                     PARTNER
                                                                     Capitalist     Industrial
       1. The obligation to contribute                               partner        partner
           what had been promised
      Remedy; specific performance with        Contribution         Money and      Industry
       interest and damages.                                         property
       2. The obligation to deliver the
           fruits                               Prohibition to       Cannot         Cannot
      Debtor for the interest and damages      engage in other      engage in      engage in
       from the time he should have             business             the same       business for
       complied.                                                     kind in        himself
                                                                     which the
       3. The obligation to warrant                                  partnership    Exception:
      Specific and determinate things which                         is engaged     if the
       a partner contributed                                                        partnership
                                                                                    expressly
                                                                                    permits
               1787
                                                                                    him to do
                                                                                    so.
Profits              Shares in        Shares in                        partners who refuse to
                     profits:         profits:                         contribute additional
                     agreement        agreement                        capital they shall be
                     or               or he shall                      obliges to sell their
                     proportion       receive                          interest to the other
                     from the         such share                       capitalist partner who are
                     contribution     as may be                        willing to contribute
                                      just and                         additional capital.
                                      equitable
                                                    “Not applicable for Industrial Partners
                                                    because they are already giving their entire
                                                    industry”.
Losses               Agreement        Not liable                       1792
                     as to losses     for losses.
                     or profits. If                            -   If there is debt to the
                     there is no                                   partnership and to the
                     agreement                                     managing partner, payment
                     in                                            shall be applied to both
                     proportion                                    credits proportionately.
                     to his
                     contribution                   “Not applicable to the partner who is not
                                                    managing partner”.
                                                    OBLIGATIONS OF A MANAGING PARTNER
REMEDIES OF CAPITALIST PARTNERS                     WHO COLLECTS DEBT
AGAINST AN INDUSTRIAL PARTNER WHO
ENGAGED IN BUSINESS FOR HIMSELF                            Requisites:
   1. The capitalist partners may exclude                           At least 2 debts ( one
      the industrial partner from the                                where the managing
      partnership plus damages.                                      partner is the creditor and
   2. The capitalist partners may avail                              the other where the
      themselves of the benefits which                               partnership is the
      the industrial partner may have                                creditor)
      obtained plus damages.                                        Both sums are
                                                                     demandable.
               1790                                                1793
Unless there is a stipulation to the contrary,                Article 19792 vs. article 1793
the partners shall contribute equal shares
to the capital of the partnership.                                   Art. 1792       Art. 1793
                                                      As the         Two distinct    Only one
               1791                                   numbers of     credits         credit, in
                                                      credits                        favor of the
GENERAL RULE: “Capitalist partners are not                                           partnership
bound to contribute additional capital”.
                                                      As to         Applies only     Applies to
EXCEPTION:                                            applicability if the           any partner
                Stipulation                                        partner is a
                In case of imminent loss of                        managing
                 the business, the capitalist
                partner                             1. DISTRIBUTION OF PROFITS
                                                       a. According to agreement
  As to         The debtor     The debtor              b. If there is no agreement
  debtor’s      is not         has become                  1. Capitalist Partners
  insolvency    insolvent      insolvent             Proportion on what they contributed
                                                           2. Industrial Partner
                                                     Just and equitable under the
               1794                                    circumstances.
    Mitigation of liability by the courts           2. DISTRIBUTION OF LOSSES
   In case of partners’ extraordinary                  a. According to agreement
    efforts in other activities of the                 Industrial partner shall not be liable
    partnership, unusual profits have been              for the losses.
    realized.                                           b. If there is no agreement
               1795                                         1. Capitalist Partners
                                                       Proportion on what they contributed
RISK OF LOSS                                                2. Industrial Partners
                                                       Not liable for the losses
   1. Specific and determinate things
      which are not fungible                                    1798
    Contributed here is only the use of the
      object.                                   “Third persons designating the share of
   2. Fungible things                           partners in the profits or losses.”
    Bears the risk of loss as there was        EXCEPTION:
      transfer of ownership.
   3. Things contributed to be sold             It is not valid and it may be questioned if it is
    Same meaning in number 2                   manifested inequitable, unless:
   4. Things brought and appraised in
                                                    1. A partner execute the decision of the
      the inventory
                                                       third person
      - Same meaning in number 2
                                                    2. A partner not questioned the said
                                                       decision of the third person within a
               1796
                                                       period of 3 months from the time he
“Every partner is an agent of the partnership          had knowledge.
for purposes of its business”.
                                                                1799
OBLIGATIONS OF THE PARTNERSHIP TO
EVERY PARTNER                                   “A stipulation which excludes one more
                                                partners from share in the profits or losses is
   1. Refund the amounts a partner may          VOID”.
      have disbursed on behalf of the
      partnership plus the interest.            EXCEPTION: Industrial partner is not liable
                                                unless he waived this right.
   2. Contracted into in good faith and for
                                                RATIONALE: Why an industrial partner is
      the risks in consequences of its
                                                not liable for losses?
      management.
                                                The industrial partner cannot withdraw any
                   1797
                                                labor or industry he had already exerted. He
RULES FOR DISTRIBUTION OF PROFITS               has already has shared in the losses in that, if
AND LOSSES OF A PARTNERSHIP                     the partnership shows no profit, this means
                                                that he has labored in vain.
                1800                              the acts and absence or disability of any
                                                  managing partner cannot be alleged.
“A MANAGING PARTNER of a partnership
may execute all acts of administration                  None of the managing partners shall
including the rights to sue the debtors”.                act without the consent of the others
                                                        This article is not applicable to third
If there is no agreement, management is
                                                         persons
vested in all of the partners.
TWO MODES OF APPOINTMENT
                                                                     1803
    1. Manager in the articles of
                                                  RULES WHEN MANNER OF MANAGEMENT
       partnership
                                                  HAS NOT BEEN AGREED UPON
     POWER is irrevocable without just or
       lawful cause                                  1. All the partners shall be considered as
    2. Made in an instrument other than                 managers. If the acts of a partners
       the articles of partnership                      opposed by the other, the majority
     Power to act may be revoked at any                shall prevail. In case if tie, then the
       time.                                            vote of the partners representing the
                                                        controlling interest shall prevail.
                1801                                 2. For important alterations in
GENERAL RULE:                                           immovable property, unanimity is
                                                        required.
Each one may separately execute all acts of
administration.                                                      1804
REQUISITES:                                       CONRACT OF SUB-PARTNERSHIP, the
                                                  consent of the other partners are not
    1. Two or more partners are managers          required. Hence, all partners can have an
    2. No specification of respective duties      associate in his share or sub-partner.
    3. No stipulation requiring unanimity,
       one of them should not act without         An associate or sub-partner shall not be
       the consent of all the other.              admitted into the partnership w/o the
                                                  consent of all the other based on following
                                                  reasons:
EXCEPTIONS: If any of the managers
should oppose:                                       a. Mutual Trust is the basis of
                                                        partnership
    1. Decision of majority
    2. In case of tie, managing partner who          b. Change in membership is a
       contributed more than 50%                        modification or novation of the
       controlling interest.                            contract.
“The right to oppose is not given to non-                            1805
managers”.
                                                    “A partner is given by law the right to have
                    1802                              access, inspect and have a copy of the
                                                                partnership books”.
STIPULATION REQUIRING UNANIMITY OF
ACTION                                                               1806
GENERAL RULE:                                     WHO CAN DEMAND TRUE AND FULL
                                                  INFORMATION?
Unanimous consent of all the managers’
partners shall be necessary for the validity of
   1. Any partner                                3. His right to participate in the
   2. Legal representative of any deceased          management
      partner
   3. Legal representative of any partner                         1811
      under legal disability                  A partner is co-owner with his partners of
                                              specific partnership property.
                 1807
                                              The incidents of this co-ownership are such
The partners are governed by fiduciary        that:
relationship, that is, mutual trust and
confidence.                                      1. A partner has an equal right with his
                                                    partners to possess specific
                 1808                               partnership property for purposes
EFFECTS OF VIOLATION                             2. A partner’s right in specific
                                                    partnership property is not
   1. The capitalist partner shall bring to         assignable.
      the common fund any profits accruing       3. A partner’s right is not subject to
      to him                                        attachment or execution.
   2. Capitalist partner shall bear all the      4. A partner’s right is not subject to legal
      losses                                        support
                1809                                             1812
GENERAL RULE:                                        “A partner’s interest in the partnership
                                                     is his share of the profits and surplus. “
“No formal accounting is demandable until
after the dissolution of the partnership”.                      1813
EXCEPTIONS:                                   EFFECTS OF CONVEYANCE BY PARTNER OF
                                              HIS WHOLE INTEREST IN THE
   1. If a partner is wrongfully excluded
                                              PARTNERSHIP:
      from the partnership business or
      possession of its property by his co-          1. If a partner conveys his whole
      partners.                                         interest in the partnership, it may
   2. If the right to demand for accounting             still subsist or it may be dissolved.
      exists under the terms of any                  2. The assignee:
      agreement                                         a. cannot interfere in the
   3. As provided by article 1807                            management
   4. Whenever other circumstances                      b. cannot require information of
      render it just and reasonable                          partnership transaction
                                                        c. cannot inspect partnership
                                                             books
   SECTION 2 PROPERTY
   RIGHTS OF A PARTNER
                                                             1814
               1810
                                              WHAT IS MEANT BY A “CHARGING ORDER”
   Property rights of a partner are:          UPON A PARTNER’S INTEREST IN THE
                                              PARTNERSHIP?
   1. His right in specific partnership
      property                                      Refers to the remedy available to a
   2. His interest in the partnership                judgment creditor of a debtor-partner
                                                     to charge the interest of the latter in
                                                     the partnership by means of a court
       order purpose of satisfying the           LIABILITY FOR INCLUSION OF NAME IN
       amount of the judgment.                   FIRM NAME
REDEMPTION                                             Persons who not being partners
                                                        include their name in the firm name
      The extinguishment of the charge or              do NOT ACQUIRE THE RIGHTS OF A
       attachment on the partner’s interest             PARTNER but is SUBJECT TO
       in the profits.                                  LIABILITY of a partner in so far as
RIGHT OF A PARTNER UNDER EXEMPTION                      THIRD PERSONS WITHOUT NOTICE
LAWS                                                    is concerned.
        A partner shall not be deprived of his                  1816
right under the exemption laws, as regards
his interest in the partnership.                 LIABILITY FOR CONTRACTUAL
                                                 OBLIGATIONS OF THE PARTNERSHIP
                                                 GENERAL RULE:
   SECTION 3 OBLIGATIONS OF
   THE PARTNERS WITH                              After all the partnership assets have been
   REGARD TO THIRD PERSONS                       exhausted, all the partners, including the
                                                 industrial ones, shall be liable for all the
                                                 contracts which may have been entered into
               1815                              in the name, for the account of the
                                                 partnership and under its signature and by a
REQUIREMENT OF A FIRM NAME                       person authorized to act for the partnership
Firm- the name, title, or style under which a    EXEMPTION:
company transacts business importance:
                                                 Any partner MAY ENTER INTO A SEPARATE
       1. It is necessary to distinguish the     OBLIGATION to perform a partnership
       partnership which has a distinct and      contract.
       separate juridical personality from
       the individuals composing the
       partnership
       2. To distinguish it from other           Q: WHO SHALL BE LIABLE FOR
       partnerships                              CONTRACTUAL OBLIGATIONS OF THE
                                                 PARTNERSHIP?
GENERAL RULE: The partners may adopt any           -the partnership shall shoulder the
firm name desired                                obligations
Provided:
       1. It is not misleading                   Q: MAY 1 PARTNER MAKE ALL THE
           *Partners cannot use a name that is   PARTNERS LIABLE FOR THE OBLIGATION OF
       to mislead the public by passing itself   THE PARTNERSHIP?
       off as another partnership or                -Yes, a partner may, by entering into a
       corporation, or its goods or services     contract in the name and for the account of
       as those of such other company            the partnership hold ALL THEPARNTERS
        2. Use of name of deceased partners      liable for the partnership obligation.
       is allowed as long as it is indicated
       that said partner is already deceased
  Reason: A partner is a PRINCIPAL WITH                  i.   Acts apparently for carrying on in the
RESPECT TO HIS CO-PARNTERS and at the                         usual way the business of the
same times and AGENT OF THE OTHERS                            partnership
AND OF THE PARTNERSHIP.                                 ii.   Acts not apparently for the carrying
                                                              on in the usual way of business of the
If he contracts with a 3rd person, he binds not               partnership
only the partnership but also the partners.            iii.   Acts of ownership
Just like an obligation contacted by an agent-         iv.    Acts in contravention of a restriction
the principal shall be liable.                                on authority
Q: MAY A PARTNER IS "personally" be
LIABLE?
                                                      *qualifies the authority of partners.
   -Yes. He may assume an undertaking in his
own name or bind himself solidarity with the          *authority must be in the usual course of
partnership to fulfil the obligation to a 3rd         business
person.
                                                      *transaction beyond a partner's authority is
                 1817                                 binding if it is in the usual course of the
                                                      business because the 3rd person is assumed
“Any stipulation against the liability laid down      to have no knowledge to his lack of authority.
in the preceding article shall be void, except as
among the partners.”                                  * When are transactions not binding?
* As to 3rd person, all partners are liable pro-      1) When a transaction is not in the usual
rata and subsidiary, but as to each other, they       course of business and has no consent from
are liable in proportion to their capital             all other partners
contribution.
                                                      2) When the 3rd person had knowledge of the
Examples:                                             lack of authority of the acting partner.
1) A,B and C are in a partnership where C is
the industrial partner and a sum of P26,000 is
owed to D. A and B contributed P15,000 and                            1819
P5,000 respectively. How shall the debt be            *Refers to the conveyance of immovable
shared?                                               property
Ans: As to D, the partners will share equally         *Suppose A, B and C are partners engaged in
in the debt left after exhausting all assets          the buying and selling of the property and the
(P6,000) so they will each have to pay P2,000         following situations occur:
regardless of C being an industrial partner. If
C is insolvent or if B is died or if A has left the   1) A, without authority, sells land to D in the
country, the liability of the partners cannot be      partnership's name but D immediately sells it
increased. As to each other, they are liable in       to E. The land title was originally under the
proportion to their capital contribution, so B        partnership's name. Can the partnership
and C will be reimbursed by A.                        recover the land?
                                                      Ans: title passes to D, then to E. The
                 1818                                 partnership cannot recover the land once it
                                                      has transferred to E but if the land was still
PARTNER AS AGENT OF THE                               with D, they could have recovered it if the
PARTNERSHIP                                           contract was not binding.
2) What if A sells the property under his             In short, notice to any of the partners
name?                                                  is notice to the partnership. (You
                                                       don’t have to notify every partner in
Ans: only the equitable title passes to D.             relation to partnership affairs.)
3) what if A sells the property and the land
title is registered under his name?                   Knowledge of a partner acting in a
                                                       particular manner (meaning the
Ans: title passes to D because land is                 partner is a managing partner), or
registered under the partner's names. This             knowledge of any partner who should
will hold true if A, B and C are co-owners of          have communicated it to the
the land, even if only A sold it to D.                 managing partner, is knowledge to
                1820                                   the partnership.
“An admission or representation made by any
partner concerning partnership affairs within         This is so even if the non-managerial
the scope of his authority in accordance with          partner does not communicate the
this Title is evidence against the partnership.”       information he knows regarding
                                                       partnership affairs. The partner
* Anything a partner says or admits, as long
                                                       should have communicated this. Non
as it is concerning the partnership affairs and
                                                       knowledge by other partners is not a
it is within the scope of his authority, is
                                                       reason to evade from obligations.
sufficient evidence against the partnership.
* This article is a rule of evidence                  If notice is delivered to a partner, that
                                                       is an effective communication to the
* In order that admission/representation               partnership, notwithstanding the
made can be used as evidence, the existence            failure of the partner to communicate
of the partnership must be established and             such notice or knowledge to the other
proved first.                                          partners.
* Examples:
                                                      EXAMPLE:
 (1) Partner A borrows money from the bank         1. A, B, and C are partners where B is the
and declares that the money borrowed is for           managing partner. D, a 3rd person,
the partnership.                                      filed a case against the partners and
                                                      the partnership for some unknown
ANS: This statement made by A, is enough              reason. Does D need to notify all of
evidence against the partnership and the              them?
bank may use this in case the partnership
does not pay back the money borrowed.
                                                          If this is done, D just needs to
(2) A, B, and C are partners. A told D, a 3rd              notify either A, B, or C, but doesn’t
person, that the debtor already paid this                  have to notify ALL OF THEM
obligation to the partnership. Is this enough              (imagine if there are 100 partners,
evidence against the partnership?                          it would be burdensome and
                                                           costly to notify all 100). So if A is
ANS: YES, since it concerns partnership                    notified about the case, this is
affairs and the partner has authority to say so.           considered by D as notify to
                                                           EVERYONE even if A is not a
                                                           managerial partner (since A
                     1821                                  should communicate this to all
                                                           partners).
                1822                              victim. He caused P50, 000 worth of
                                                  injury to D. What can D do? D can go
EXAMPLE: A, B and C formed a partnership.         to A for the full amount of P50, 000 or
One day, while C was negligently driving the      from B or C. B. Can D go to B for the
truck of the partnership to deliver goods to X    whole P50, 000 since B is the richest
(one of their customers) C bumped the             among the partners?
gateway of X causing damages to the latter.
-       In this case, the other partners and         This is allowable since the
the partnership are solidary liable with C.           partners have a solidary
However, the partners or the partnership can          obligation through A’s act of
recover from C.                                       omission. B will be entitled for
                                                      reimbursement from the one
                                                      responsible, A.
                1823
                                                          1825
EXAMPLE: Where one partner acting within
the scope of his apparent authority receives
money or property of a third person and           •2 Things being mentioned:
misapplies it. A, B and C formed ABC              1. Partnership by estoppels
partnership engaged in leasing of apartment
units. Subsequently, C received from              There is an existing partnership, and
customer X a deposit in the amount of P20,        partners misrepresent themselves
000. If C misapplied the amount, then partner     together with a third person.
A, B and the partnership ABC are solidarity       Example
liable to X.
                                                  Suppose there is a partnership, X,
           Of course, A, B and the               with partners A, B and C. D told E that
            partnership ABC can recover from      he is a partner of A, B and C. E verified
            C.                                    from the actual partners of X
            1824                                  partnership if D is really a partner, A,
                                                  B and C consented. E entered in a
        All partners are liable solidarity with   contract with D, believing he was a
        the partnership for everything            partner.
        chargeable to the partnership under
        Article 1822 and 1823.                        This is partnership by estoppels
                                                      since A, B and C verified D as a
               In the following cases,               partner. In this case, E can go after
                obligation is pro-rata or not         A, B and C.
                equal, but a solidary
                obligation. Any partner may
                pay for the obligation (unlike    2. Partnership by estoppels
                article 1816, each partner        Two or more persons pretend to be
                should only pay for their         partners in the eyes of third persons.
                share):
                                                  Example
   1.    When by an unlawful act or omission,
                                                  A, B and C said they were partners to
        loss or injury is caused to 3rd person.
                                                  D and entered in a contract with the
                                                  “partners”. When it was time to for
        Example: A, B and C are partners. A
                                                  them to pay D for their obligation,
        made an act of omission with D as the
       they cannot for the reason that they                      better right to the partnership
       are not partners. What is their                           property?
       obligation to D?
               Their obligation to D will be             -   In this case, D the partnership
           pro-rata , as if they were partners               creditor, has a better right to the
           (since they are partners by                       partnership property. When
           Estoppels)                                        obligation to D is paid, what will
                                                             be left for the partners to share is
                                                             p4, 000. If E, the personal creditor
                   1826.                                     of A, demands to be paid out of
   A new partner admitted to an existing                    partnership property, he will only
    partnership is also liable to the                        get P4, 000 from it since the
    obligations existing before he was                       priority is the partnership
    admitted, but his liability only extends to              creditor. The p2, 000 will be paid
    his contribution to the partnership                      out from A’s personal property.
    unless stipulated.
   A new partner is liable to his separate                  CHAPTER 3
    property when the obligation was                         DISSOLUTION AND
    incurred when he was already a partner.                  WINDING UP
                                                                     1828.
    Example A, B and C are the original
    partners of the partnership X with                  The partnership is going to end or it
    contributions of P 10,000 each. X                    will be dissolved.
    partnership owes D P 40,000. How shall        But before the partners can be paid their
    the debt be paid? P 34,000 will be paid to    shares, the creditors of the partnership must
    D out of the partnership assets, and the P    first be compensated. After all the creditors
    6,000 will be paid through A, B and C’s       have been paid, whatever is left of the
    personal assets. The P 6,000 will be          partnership’s assets will become the payment
    divided among the 3 original partners         for the partners.
    pro rata.                                     The share to be paid out to the partners is
                     1827                         necessarily limited to its total resources.
          Partnership creditors have better
           rights to partner obligation with      Dissolution
           regard to partnership property.              It is the time of the partners cease to
          Personal creditors of partners                carry on the business.
           have better right than a                     Basically means to end the
           partnership creditor with regards             partnership.
           to personal property of the
                                                  Winding up
           partner.
                                                        Process of settling business affairs
           Example:                                      after dissolution.
           1. A, B and C are partners. A                Sole purpose is to sell off stock, pay
              owes E P 6,000. The                        off creditors, and distribute any
              partnership owes D P 28,000.               remaining assets to partners or
              The total partnership assets               shareholders.
              amount to P 40,000. Who has         Termination
      Point in time after all the partnership               power conferred by the
       affairs have been wound up.                           agreement;
      The partnership has been legally
                                                  2. In contravention of the agreement
       ended.
                                                  between the partners, where the
Retirement                                        circumstances do not permit a dissolution
                                                  under any other provision of this article,
      The dissociation by a partner,             by the express will of any partner at any
       inclusive or resignation or                time;
       withdrawal, from the partnership that
       thereby dissolves it.                      3. By any event which makes it unlawful
                                                  for business to be carried on/for the
                    1829                          members to carry it on for the partnership;
      The partnership will not end until all     4. Loss of specific thing promised by
       its affairs/debt/credits are               partner before its delivery;
       completed.
      Ending a partnership is a step by step     5. Death of any partner;
       process.                                   6. Insolvency of a partner/partnership;
            1. Dissolution
            2. Winding up                         7. Civil interdiction of any partner;
            3. Termination
                                                  8. Decree of court under art 1831.
                    1830                          Kinds of dissolution
Dissolution is caused:                                  Extrajudicial dissolution
   1. without violation of the agreement          These are numbers 1 to 7 of the above-stated
      between the partners:                       article.
      a. By termination of the definite                 Judicial dissolution
         term/particular undertaking
         specified in the agreement;              These refers to number 8 above-stated in
                                                  relation to 1831 of the New Civil Code.
       b.    By the express will of
            any partner, who must act in
            good faith, when no definite          Partnership with a fixed term
            term or particular undertaking
            is specified;                               The life or period of existence of
                                                         the partnership has been agreed
       c.    By the express will of all the              upon by the partners.
            partners who have not assigned              Has a limited life.
            their interest/charged them for
                                                  Partnership for a particular undertaking
            their separate debts, either
            before or after the termination             It will exist until the purpose is
            of any specified term or particular          accomplished.
            undertaking
                                                  Partnership at will
       d. By the bona fide expulsion                    A partnership that does not fix its
          of any partner from the                        term.
          business in accordance with
      The birth and life of a partnership         1. A partner or any of the 1 to 6
       at will is predicated on the mutual            grounds for judicial dissolution in the
       desire and consent of the partners.            first paragraph.
      The right to choose with whom a
       person wishes to associate himself          2. The purchaser of a partner’s
       is the very foundation and essence of          interest in the partnership under
       this partnership.                              ARTICLE 1813 or 1814 after the
                                                      termination of the specified term or
                                                      particular undertaking or of the
Civil interdiction                                    partnership is at will when interest
                                                      was assigned or when the charging
      Deprives the offender during the               order was issued.
       time of his sentence of the right to
       manage his property and dispose                            1832
       such property by any act of any          Except so far as may be necessary to wind
       conveyance interior vivos.               up partnership affairs or to complete
                                                transactions begun but not then finished,
                     1831                       dissolution terminates all authority of any
                                                partner to act for the partnership.
On application by or for a partner the
court shall decree a dissolution whenever:         1. With respect to the partners:
                                                    When the dissolution is not by the
1. Partner declared insane in any judicial            act, insolvency or death of a
proceeding or shown to be of unsound mind;            partner
                                                      (Authority of partners to bind
2. Incapacity of partner to perform his part
                                                      partnership by new contract is
of the partnership contract;
                                                      immediately terminated when
3. Partner guilty of conduct prejudicial to           dissolution is not due
business of partnership;                              to ACT, DEATH or INSOLVENCY of a
                                                      partner); or
4. Willful or persistent breach                     When the dissolution is by such act,
of partnership agreement or conduct which             insolvency or death of a partner, in
makes it reasonably impracticable to carry on         cases where article 1833 so
partnership with him;                                 requires.
5. Business can only be carried on at a loss;      2. With respect to persons not
                                                      partners, as declared in the article
6. Other circumstances which render                   1834.
dissolution equitable.
                                                As a rule, when a partnership is dissolved,
Upon application by purchaser of                any of the partners cannot bind the
partner's interest under article 1813 or        partnership.
1814:
                                                Exceptions are those provide by ARTICLES
      After termination of specified term      1833 and 1834.
       /particular undertaking.
      Anytime if partnership at will when
       interest was assigned/charging                             1833
       order issued.
                                                      If dissolution is caused by an act,
Who can sue for judicial dissolution?                  insolvency or death, then each shall
                                                       share in the liability of the
    partnership due to the actions of a          The partnership is required to have
    partner, unless he had knowledge of           the dissolution be announced in
    an act, in solvency or death or notice        general circulation newspapers of the
    of the insolvency or death.                   place of operations. As long as they do
                                                  this, then it is sufficient notice to all
Ex. (1) B told A that he is resigning             third persons. (If you don’t read broad
TODAY. The partnership is thus dissolved.         sheet, that’s your fault not the
Should A enter into a contract with D,            partnership)
who shall be liable?
                                                 Liabilities shall be satisfied out of the
Ans: As among themselves, only A                  partnership assets alone if the partner
because he had knowledge of B’s                   being dealt with is a DORMANT
resignation, thus knowing that they are           PARNER.
no longer a partnership.                         Upon dissolution, the partnership is
                                                  no longer bound by transactions.
                                                  1. When it becomes unlawful to
Ex. (2) If B texts’ his resignation to A              carry on the business
because A is in Mindanao and A contracts          2. Insolvency of a partner
with D, was his authority terminated              3. Unauthorized winding up
when the text arrived?
                                                              1835
Ans: No, A’s authority was not terminated        Dissolution does not discharge the
as he has only received a notice. Mere            partnership and/or the partners from
NOTICE cannot terminate the authority of          existing liabilities.
partners because the grounds are BY AN
ACT, and because of this it should be            Considers a case wherein a partner
PERSONALLY KNOWN by the acting                    was induced to join the partnership
partner.                                          by means of fraud or
                                                  misrepresentation.
(3)The authority is terminated if the            The victim can ask for the recession
cause of dissolution is DEATH.                    or restitution of the contract of
                  1834                            partnership (return of all his
                                                  contributions)
   Partners may still bind the                  He has the right to the surplus for
    partnership to transactions ever after        certain purposes
    dissolution of the transactions is with
    respect to the winding up or the             He has the rights of a third person or
    completion of unfinished                      a subrogated creditor after the
    transactions.                                 liabilities have already been paid to
   The transaction will be landing if:           recollect what he paid when he
    1. Credit was extended without                entered into the partnership.
        knowledge of the dissolution
        before the dissolution.                  He is entitled to be indemnified for all
    2. No credit was extended but there           debts ab liabilities that he paid for
        was knowledge of the                      during his time in the partnership.
        partnerships existence and none
        of the dissolution.
      In order for the liability of a partner   What if the partnership was dissolved due to
       to discharged, the following must         EXPULSION?
       agree
                The partner                           Suppose that A was the one expelled
                The other partners                     from the partnership, then he can
                The creditors                          only get a share in the NET PROCEEDS
                                                        of the surplus that would have
                   1836                                 originally been his.
KINDS OF WINDING UP OR LIQUIDATION
                                                 What if that partnership was dissolved due to
  I.       Extrajudicial                         VIOLATION of AGREEMENTS?
      Liquidation is done without the
       intervention of the court                       Determine the rights of the
                                                        INNOCENT and GUILTY parties,
      Who will wind up?                                 suppose that in this situation, A was
      1. The liquidating partner or                     the one guilty of violation on
         partners as agreed upon by all of              agreement. Then B and C will be
         the partners                                   allowed the following rights;
      2. The partners who have not
         wrongfully dissolved the                       1. Apply partnership assets to
         partnership                                       partnership      liabilities  and
      3. The legal representative of the                   distribute the cash surplus among
         last surviving partner who is not                 themselves
         insolvent.                                     2. To e indemnified for the damages
  II.    Judicial                                          that A has caused
   Liquidation is done under the control               3. To continue the business up to the
      and direction of the court, upon                     agreed term
      proper cause that is shown to the                 4. The possess partnership properly
      court.
                                                 While A will have the following rights:
       Who will wind up?
       1. The person appointed by the               1. Partners decide not to continue the
          court                                        business
                                                       a. Right to claim his share in the
                         1837                             cash surplus, but only the net
        Supposed there is a situation where              proceeds of such meaning, the
         in A, B and C are in a partnership, X            cash surplus less damages.
         and Co., with total assets of 26,000
         and liabilities amounting 20,000. If       2. Continue the business
         the partnership is dissolved                  a. Ascertain his interest in the
         WITHOUT VIOLATION OF ANY                         business
         AGREEMENTS, naturally the                     b. Freedom from existing and future
         liability will be cleared because the            liabilities of the partnership.
         partnership assets are more than
         enough, and the surplus will be                            1838
         given to each of the partners in        3 rights of a partner who is entitled to
         proportion to their interest in the     rescind:
         partnership or as per their
         agreement.                                 1. Right of lien or right of retention
                                                    2. Right of subrogation
   3. Right of indemnification                       Required New Contribution:
                                                          - If the partnership asset were
      Considers a case wherein a partner                     exhausted partners shall
       was induced to join the partnership                    contribute the amount
       by means of fraud or                                   necessary to satisfy the
       misinterpretation                                      liabilities
      The victim can ask for the rescission         Individual Property of a Deceased
       or restitution of the contract of the          Partner
       partnership                                        - It shall be liable for his share
      He has the right to the surplus for                    of the partnership liability
       certain purposes                                       incurred while he was a
      He has the rights of a third person or                 partner. Take note that his
       a subrogated creditor after the                        separate creditors have
       liabilities have already been paid to                  preference over these
       recollect what the paid when he                        individual properties.
       entered into the partnership                  Where a partners has become
      He is entitled to be indemnified for all       insolvent or his estate is insolvent, the
       debts and liabilities that he paid for         claim against hi separate property
       during his time in the partnership.            shall rank:
                                                      1. Owing to separate creditors
                                                      2. Owing to partnership creditors
                    1839                              3. Owing to partners by way of
                                                          contribution
ASSETS OF THE PARTNERSHIP
                                                     INSOLVENY means than the assets are
   a. Partnership by property
                                                      less than the liabilities
   b. Contributions of the partners
      necessary for the payment of all
      liabilities
                                                                  1840
LIABILITIES OF THE PARTNERSHIP:
ORDER OF PAYMENT                                     Explains the rights of creditors in case
                                                      of partnership dissolution because of
   a. Owing to partnership creditors                  membership changes and the
      other than partners                             business is continued without
   b. Owing to partners                               liquidation.
   c. Owing to partners in respect of
      capital                                        The membership changes include:
   d. Owing to partners in respect of
      profits                                                    Retirement
                                                                 Expulsion
                                                                 Death
-       Considers the case of liquidation and                    Addition
the distribution of partnership assets
                                                     Note that the creditor of the OLD
-       Liquidation is when all the assets of         partnership will still be the creditor of
the partnership is converted to cash                  the NEW partnership, if there is still
-       Total assets will include goodwill as         an old partner/original partner with
well as the original contributions of partners        the NEW partnership.
      The creditors will continue to be the                    1843
       creditor of the remaining/new
       partnership in all cases except when:     Limited Partnership
                                                         Is one formed by two or more persons
       1. Rights are assigned to other
                                                 under the provision of the following article,
          people
                                                 having as members one or more limited
       2. Unless there is a promise to pay
          debt from the new partners or if       partners? The limited partners as such shall
          the creditor can set aside the right   not be bound by the obligations of the
          of the new partners on the ground      partnership.
          of fraud
                                                 Characteristics of Limited Partnership
                  1841                                 It is formed by compliance in good
                                                        faith with the statutory requirements.
Rights of a Partner Who Retires/Dies and               One or more general partners control
Business Is Continued Without Any                       the business and are personally liable
Settlement of Accounts                                  to creditors
   1. That his interest be ascertained as of           One or more limited partners (also
      dissolution date                                  known as special partners )
   2. Collect his interest in the partnership           contribute to the capital and share in
      plus interest or profits by the use of            profits but do not participate in the
      his right to these as a creditor                  management of the business
                                                       The limited partners are not
                                                        personally liable for partnership
                  1842                                  obligations beyond their capital
                                                        contributions
Who has the right to an account of his
interest?                                              The limited partners may ask for the
                                                        return of their capital contributions
          -   The right to an account of his           The partnership debts are paid out of
              interest shall accrue to any              the common fund and the separate
              partners; or his legal                    properties of the general partners
              representative
Who has an obligation to render an                              1844
account?
                                                 Essential requisites in the formation of a
   1. The winding up partners                    limited partnership
   2. Surviving Partners
   3. The person or partnership continuing             The certificate of the limited
      the business                                      partnership
                                                       The certificate of the limited
When to render an account?
                                                        partnership must be filed in the Office
          -   At the date of acquisition                of the Securities and Exchange
              except any stipulation to the             Commission
              contrary
                                                                1845
Chapter 4- LIMITED                               Contribution of a limited partner
PARTNERSHIP
       A limited partner can contribute only               The right to have dissolution and
money or property or both. Consequently,                    winding up by decree of court
an industrial partner can only become a                    The right to receive a share of the
general partner.                                            profits or other compensation by way
                                                            of income
        1846
                                                           The right to receive returns of his
The surname of a limited partner shall not                  contribution if the partnership assets
appear in the partnership name                              are in excess of the partnership
                                                            liabilities.
         A limited partner violating this article
is liable as a general partner only to the          General limited partner
partnership creditors who extend credit to
                                                           A person may be a general partner
the partnership without actual knowledge
                                                        and a limited partner in the same
that he is not a general partner.
                                                        partnership at the same time, provided
        1847                                            that this fact shall be sated in the
                                                        certificate of limited partnership.
Liability for a false statement in the
certificate                                         Rights of a general limited partner
        The one who suffers loss by reliance               His rights are those of a general
on such false statement may hold liable any             partner
party in the certificate of limited partnership
                                                    Liabilities of a general limited partner
who is in the bad faith.
                                                            His liabilities are those of a general
        1848
                                                        partner. Hence, as to partnership
Liabilityof a limited partner who takes                 creditors, he is liable up to the extent of
paer in the control of the business                     his separate property.
       The limited partner will be laible as a             Nevertheless, as regards his
general partner. However, said limited                  contribution, his rights are those of a
partner does not acquire the rights of general          limited partner insofar as the other
partner.                                                partners are concerned.
                                                                  Basahin ng mabuti ung libro,
                                                                   intindihin lang. Kung di
Rights of a limited Partner                                        maintindihan try nalang
       The right to have the partnership                          isearch sa dictionary ung
        book kept at the principal place of                        word na nagpapagulo sa
        business of the partnership, and at a                      pagiintindi mo.
        reasonable hour to inspect and copy                       Lalo na ung mga examples,
        of them                                                    kahit mahaba basahin parin.
       The right to have on demand true and                       Madalas kasi dun natin
        full information of all things affecting                   nagegets ung sinasabi ng
        the partnership, and a formal account                      libro.
        of partnership affairs whenever             Keywords ung nakabold
        circumstances render it and just and
        reasonable                                                 1854
Read and try to understand the allowable           2. Their compensation by way of
and prohibited.                                       income; or
                                                   3. Any other matter
Allowable business transaction of a
limited partner with the partnership:                  1856
            To lend money to the              A limited partner may receive from the
             partnership;                      partnership the share of the profits or the
            To transact business with         compensation by way of income stipulated
             the partnership; and              for in the certificate; provided that after such
            To receive on account of          payment is made, whether from property of
             resulting claims against the      the partnership or that of a general partner,
             partnership, with general         the partnership assets are in excess of all
             creditors, a pro rata share of    the liabilities of other partnership
             the assets.                       “except" liabilities to partners on account
                                               of their contributions and to general
Prohibited business transactions of a
                                               partners.
limited partner with the partnership:
                                               Share of the profits or compensation by
   1. Receive or hold as collateral security
                                               way of income of a limited partner
      and partnership property;
   2. Receive from a general partner or the           The requirement here is that the
      partnership any payment,                 partnership assets are in excess of all
      conveyance, or release from              liabilities of the partnership to third
      liability if at the time assets of the   persons after payment of the profits or
      partnership are not sufficient to        compensation by way of income of a
      discharge partnership liabilities to     limited partner.
      persons not claiming as general or
      limited partners.
Rationale: To prevent illegal competition                      1857
between the limited partner and general        Makakareceive lang ang limited partner
partnership creditors for the assets of the    ng kanyang contribution kung:
partnership.                                   (understand the requisites)
Note: Violation of the prohibition, as         Requisites for the return of contributions
enumerated, will give rise to the disputable   of a limited partner
presumption of fraud on the creditors of
the partnership.                                   1. All liabilities of their partnership,
                                                      except liabilities to general partners
       1855                                           and to limited partners on account of
Read and understand.                                  their contributions have been paid
                                                      or there remains property of the
Preference to some limited partners                   partnership sufficient to pay them.
                                                   2. The consent of all members is had,
    Preference may be given to some limited
                                                      unless the return of the contribution
partners over other limited partners as to:
                                                      may be rightfully demanded; and
   1. Return of their contributions;               3. The certificate is cancelled or so
                                                      amended as to set forth the
       withdrawal or reduction of the             A limited partner holds as trustee for the
       contribution.                              partnership:
When can the contributions of a limited               1. Specific property stated in the
partner be returned?                                     certificate as contributed by him, but
                                                         which was not contributed or which
   1. On the dissolution of a partnership
                                                         has been wrongfully returned, and
   2. When the date specified in the
                                                      2. Money or other property
      certificate for its return has
                                                         wrongfully paid or conveyed to him
      arrived; or
                                                         on account of his contribution.
   3. After he has given six months’
      notice in writing to all other
      members, if no time is specified in the
                                                  The liabilities of a limited partner as set forth
      certificate, either for the return of the
                                                  in this article can be waived or compromised
      contribution or for the dissolution of
                                                  only by the consent of all members; but a
      the partnership.
                                                  waiver or compromise shall not affect the
                                                  right of a creditor of a partnership who
                                                  extended credit or whose claim arose after
When may a limited partner have the
                                                  the filing and before a cancellation or
partnership dissolved and liquidated?
                                                  amendment of the certificate, to enforce
    A limited partner may have the                such liabilities.
partnership dissolved and its affairs
                                                  When a contributor has rightfully received
wound up when:
                                                  the return in whole or in part of the capital
   1. He rightfully but unsuccessfully            of his contribution, he is nevertheless liable
      demands the. Return of his                  to the partnership for any sum, not in
      contribution, or                            excess of such interest, necessary to
   2. The other liabilities of the partnership    discharge its liabilities to all creditors who
      have not been paid, or the                  extended credit or whose claims arose before
      partnership property is insufficient        such return.
      for their payment and the limited
                                                  Liability of a limited partner for unpaid
      partner would otherwise be entitled
                                                  contribution to the partnership
      to the return of his contribution.
                                                      1. For the difference between his
               1858                                      contribution as actually made and
A limited partner is liable to the                       that stated in the certificate as having
partnership:                                             been made; and
                                                      2. For any unpaid contribution which
   1. For the difference between his                     he agreed in the certificate to make
      contribution as actually made, and                 in the future at the time and on the
      that stated in the certificate as having           conditions stated in the certificate.
      been made; and
   2. For any unpaid contribution which           Read the example.
      he agreed in their certificate to           Liability of a limited partner as a trustee
      make in the future at the time and on       to the partnership
      the conditions stated in the certificate.
   1. Specific property stated in the                   transactions or to inspect the
      certificate as contributed by him,                partnership books.
      but which was not contributed or                 An assignee shall have the right to
      which has been wrongfully                         become a substituted limited
      returned, and                                     partner if all the members consent
   2. Money or other property                           thereto or if the assignor.
      wrongfully paid or conveyed to him               An assignee becomes a substituted
      on account of his contribution.                   limited partner when the certificate is
                                                        appropriately amended in
Liabilities of a limited partner may be
                                                        accordance with article 1865.
waived
                                                       The substituted limited partner has
The requisites are:                                     all the rights and powers, and is to
                                                        subject to all the restrictions and
   1. With the consent of all ther other
                                                        liabilities of his assignor. Except
      partners;
                                                        those liabilities of which he was
   2. The waiver or compromise shall
                                                        ignorant at the time he became a
      not affect ther right of partnership
                                                        limited partner.
      creditors who extended credit or
                                                       The substitution of the assignee as a
      whose claim arose after the filing and
                                                        limited partner does not release the
      before a cancellation or amendment
                                                        assignor from the liability to the
      of the certificate.
                                                        partnership under articles 1847
Liability of a limited partner despite                  and 1858.
return of his contribution
                                                 Rights of an assignee of a limited partner
A limited partner is nevertheless liable to
                                                    1. An assignee is only entitled to
the partnership for any sum necessary to
                                                       receive the share of the profits or
discharge its liabilities to all creditors who
                                                       other compensation by way of
extended credit or whose claims arose before
                                                       income, or their return of his
such return. However, the liability of that
                                                       contribution.
limited partner is up to the extent of his
                                                    2. An assignee acquires all the rights
contribution.
                                                       of the limited partner only when he
Read the example.                                      becomes a substituted limited
                                                       partner.
                                                 Note: An assignee, who does not become a
               1859                              substituted limited partner has no right to
A limited partner's interest is assignable.      require any information or account of the
                                                 partnership transactions or to inspect the
Substituted limited partner- is a person         partnership books.
admitted to all the rights of a limited
partner who has died or has assigned his         Assignee become a substituted limited
interest in a partnership.                       partner
      An assignee, who does not become a         The requisites are:
       substituted limited partner, has no          1. All the partners must consent.
       right to require any information or          2. The certificate of limited partner
       account of the partnership                      must be amended
   3. Must be registered in the Securities       On due application to a court of competent
      and Exchange Commission.                   jurisdiction by any creditor of a limited
                                                 partner, the court may charge the interest of
Rights and liabilities of a substituted
                                                 the indebted limited partner with payment of
limited partner
                                                 the unsatisfied amount of such claim, and
   1. The substituted limited partner has        may appoint a receiver, and make all other
      all the rights and powers.                 orders, directions and inquiries which the
      Exception: except those liabilities of     circumstances of the case may require.
      which he was ignorant at the time he
                                                 The interest may be redeemed with the
      became a limited partner.
                                                 separate property of any general partner, but
   2. The substitution of the assignee as a
                                                 may not be redeemed with partnership
      limited partner does not release the
                                                 property.
      assignor form liability to persons
      who suffered damage by reliance            The remedies conferred by the first
      on a false statement.                      paragraph shall not be deemed exclusive of
                                                 others which may exist.
                                                 Nothing in this Chapter shall be held to
               1860                              deprive a limited partner of his statutory
The retirement, death, insolvency, insanity or
                                                 exemption.
civil interdiction of a GENERAL PARTNER
DISSOLVES THE PARTNERSHIP, unless the                            1863
business is continued by REMAINING
GENERAL PARTNERS:                                 In setting accounts after dissolution the
                                                 liabilities of the partnership shall be entitled
1) Under a right so to do stated in the          to payment in the following order:
certificate, or
2) With the CONSENT of all members.              (1) THOSE TO CREDITORS, in the ORDER of
                                                 PRIORITY as provided BY LAW, EXCEPT
Note: The article speaks ONLY of GENERAL         those to limited partners on account of their
PARTNERS and did not INCLUDE a LIMITED           contributions, and to general partners;
PARTNER.
                                                 (2) Those to limited partners in respect to
                                                 their share of the profits and other
               1861                              compensation by way of income on their
                                                 contributions;
On the DEATH of a LIMITED PARTNER his
executor or administrator shall HAVE all the     (3) Those to limited partners in respect to the
rights of a limited partner for the purpose of   capital of their contributions;
setting his estate, and such power as the
deceased had to constitute his assignee a        (4) Those to general partners other than for
substituted limited partner.                     capital and profits;
The estate of a deceased limited partner shall   (5) Those to general partners in respect to
be liable for all his liabilities as a limited   profits;
partner.                                         (6) Those to general partners in respect to
               1862                              capital.
Subject to any statement in the certificate or      because he does not take control nor
to subsequent agreement, limited partners           participate in the management of the
share in the partnership assets in respect to       business of the partnership.
their claims for capital, and in respect to their
                                                    EXCEPTION:
claims for profits or for compensation by way
of income on their contribution respectively,       Where the object is to enforce a limited
in proportion to the respective amounts of          partner’s right against or liability to the
such claims.                                        partnership.
                1864                                                1867
CANCELLATION OF THE CERTIFICATE OF                  A limited partnership formed under the law
LIMITED PARTNERSHIP                                 prior to the effectively of this Code, may
                                                    become a limited partnership under this
     When the partnership id dissolved
                                                    Chapter by complying with the provisions of
     When all limited partners cease to be
                                                    Article 1844, provided the certificate sets
      limited partners. Take note that the
                                                    forth:
      composition of a limited partnership
      is that there should be at least one          (1) The amount of the original contribution of
      general partner and at least one              each limited partner, and the time when the
      limited partner.                              contribution was made; and
NOTE: In all other cases, ONLY                      (2) That the property of the partnership
AMENDMENT of the certificate of limited             exceeds the amount sufficient to discharge its
partnership is required.                            liabilities to persons not claiming as general
                                                    or limited partners by an amount greater
                1865
                                                    than the sum of the contributions of its
REQUIREMENTS FOR AMENDMENT:                         limited partners.
     It must be in writing as far as               A limited partnership formed under the law
      necessary to set forth clearly the            prior to the effectively of this Code, until or
      change in the certificate which it is         unless it becomes a limited partnership under
      desired to make                               this Chapter, shall continue to be governed by
     It must be signed and sworn to by all         the provisions of the old law.
      members
     The certificate of limited partnership,
      as amended, must be filed for record
      in the office of the Securities and
      Exchange Commission.
    REQUIREMENT FOR CANCELLATION:
    *The same requirements for amendment
                1866
GENERAL RULE:
A limited partner not a proper party to
proceedings by or against a partnership