Sensitivity Characteristics of Fabry-Perot Pressure Sensors Based On Hollow-Core Microstructured Fibers
Sensitivity Characteristics of Fabry-Perot Pressure Sensors Based On Hollow-Core Microstructured Fibers
   Abstract—In this paper, the sensitivity characteristics of                        the transverse geometry is greatly simplified [3], [4]. Its guid-
Fabry-Perot (F-P) hydrostatic pressure sensor based on two                           ance relies on the antiresonance between the core mode and the
different hollow-core (HC) microstructured optical fibers are                        mode of the silica wall around the core.
experimentally and theoretically investigated. The sensors are
fabricated by simply splicing a length of HC fiber to single-                           HC-PBGFs have been exploited as photonic sensors in the
mode fibers. Hydrostatic pressure is measured by monitoring                          recent years, taking advantage of their unique guidance mecha-
the wavelength shifts of the interferometric fringes as a result                     nism and microstructured geometry [5]. For example, an inter-
of the two reflection beams at the splicing points. The measured                     ferometric fiber optic gyro has been implemented based on this
pressure sensitivities of F-P sensors fabricated on the simplified                   fiber, which has reduced Kerr effect, temperature sensitivity and
HC microstructured fiber and hollow-core photonic bandgap
fiber (HC-PBGF) are 17.3 and 23.4 pm/MPa, respectively.                              Faraday effect [6]. Fiber grating sensors can be fabricated on the
Theoretical investigation is then carried out based on the analysis                  bandgap fibers through heat treatment. The long period grating
of elastic properties for the individual fibers. The calculated result               sensors, which contain periodic           -laser-induced deforma-
suggests that the pressure sensitivities are dominantly determined                   tions, are sensitive to axial strain and insensitive to environ-
by the induced changes in cavity length. In comparison, the con-                     mental temperature [7], [8]. Hydrostatic pressure measurement
tribution of mode-index change is slight. The mechanisms behind
the mode-index changes for the two fibers are clarified by ana-                      has been realized with a HC-PBGF by monitoring the spectral
lyzing the deformation of the fiber structure under pressure. The                    shift of its transmission band or the change in phase difference
holey microstructure is highly deformable compared to the solid                      between orthogonal polarizations [9]–[11].
fiber, which provide another dimension for the implementation of                        In-line Fabry-Perot sensors have also been implemented on
tunable photonic devices.
                                                                                     HC-PBGFs for the measurement of temperature, axial stain vi-
  Index Terms—Fabry–Perot sensors, fiber optic sensors, photonic                     bration, ultrasound signal, and even magnetic field [12]–[16].
bandgap fibers, pressure sensors.                                                    The sensors present advantages including low cost, simple fab-
                                                                                     rication process and the ability to work under high temperature.
                             I. INTRODUCTION                                         The low-loss transmission in the PBGF is beneficial for its mul-
                                                                                     tiplexing capability. The air guiding also allow the F-P etalon to
                                                                                     have a length of mm or cm order to obtain dense interferometric
II. EXPERIMENT
blue shift with applied pressure for all the three sensors. The
measured sensitivities for fibers I and II are 17.3 and 23.4
pm/MPa, respectively.
                                                                (1)    Fig. 3. Ressembled fiber transverse geometries for the calculation of the stress
                                                                       and strain distributions. (a) Simplified HC bandgap fiber. (b) HC-PBGF. The
where is the cavity length, is wavelength and         is the ef-       holey cladding is considered as a uniform material in elasticity.
fective index of the fundamental mode of the HC fiber. The in-
terference signal reaches its maximum intensity when the phase
difference satisfies             , where   is integral, and the                          and                . The parameter represents
peak wavelengths are determined by                                     the ratio between the area defined by the outer radius and the
                                                                       actual cross sectional area of the silica ring. With the conditions
                                                                (2)
                                                                                                                                                (6a)
When the cavity is perturbed, the phase difference changes as a
                                                                                                                                                (6b)
result of the changes in cavity length and effective index. The
                                                                                                                                                (6c)
pressure sensitivity for the th peak can be expressed by
                                                                       the constants A, C and D can be found and the stress and strain
                                                                (3)    field can be expressed as follows
                                                                                                                                                   (5)
JIN et al.: SENSITIVITY CHARACTERISTICS OF FABRY-PEROT PRESSURE SENSORS BASED ON HOLLOW-CORE MICROSTRUCTURED FIBERS                   2529
tens of layers. The material is inhomogeneous and its Young’s        contributes 21.2 pm/MPa out of the pressure sensitivity. We
modulus and Poisson’s ratio can be expressed by [22]                 also found that if the holey cladding is removed, the sensitivity
                                                                     only changes by 0.5%, through further calculation. This is be-
                                                                     cause the holey cladding has a large air-filling ratio and small
                                                              (9)    effective Young’s modulus, and the longitudinal strain is almost
                                                                     determined by the outer silica cladding.
and
                                                                     B. The Effect of Effective-Index Change
                                                             (10)       The applied hydrostatic pressure subjected to the HC fiber
                                                                     can also induce a mode-index change, which can possibly con-
                                                                     tributes to the round-trip phase change and the pressure sensi-
The small amplitudes of         and      suggest the fact that the   tivity, according to (3). The mode-index change comes from the
honeycomb structure is highly compressible for a directional         changes in fiber transverse geometry and the refractive-index
in-plane stress.     is proportional to the actual cross sectional   change of the silica walls. In this subsection, this effect is dis-
area of silica glass.                      and                       cussed for both fibers.
indicates that the applied directional in-plane strain can induce       1) FiberI: For fiber I, considering the cell walls are too thin,
identical strain along the orthogonal in-plane direction but can     the deformation of the microstructure and the refractive-index
hardly induce a change in longitudinal strain. The stress over       change of the silica walls are determined by the deformation of
the individual regions can also be expressed by                      the outer silica ring. The calculation of pressure-induced mode-
                                                                     index change is performed with the following steps: First, the
                                                                     deformation of the silica ring are calculated with the single-layer
                                                             (11)    structure. Second, the geometrical parameters and the mate-
                                                                     rial-index of the microstructure are determined by the deformed
                                                                     silica ring. Third, mode solving is carried out for the deformed
Substituting their respective Young’s Moduli and Poisson’s ra-       microstructure.
tios, the strain field over the silica outer cladding can be ex-        The radial strain at the inner boundary of the silica ring is cal-
pressed by                                                           culated as 2.95      for an applied pressure of 1 MPa, based on
                                                                     (8). That means the diameter of the silica ring becomes slightly
                                                                     larger when the cavity is under pressure, because the longi-
                                                                     tudinal component of the applied pressure tends to enlarge it,
                                                           (12-a)    due to the positive Poisson’s ratio. The silica ring stretches the
and over the holey cladding                                          bridges between the core and the ring, which causes a defor-
                                                                     mation of the microstructure and corresponding material-index
                                                                     change of silica walls. Fig. 4 shows a one-sixth model for fiber
                                                           (12-b)    I. The applied displacement at point C is determined by
                                                                                . Since the angles between AD, BD and CD are all
                                                                     120 , the silica bridges and the core walls experience normal
The amplitudes of , , and         can be found with the fol-         stresses with identical amplitude . Assume the radial dis-
lowing conditions, including the boundary conditions at the          placement at point D is . For section CD, we have
inner and outer surface
(13-a) (14)
                                                           (13-b)
                                                                     For sections AD and BD,
the requirement of continuity
                                                                                                                                     (15)
                                                           (13-c)
                                                           (13-d)    With (14) and (15), the amplitudes of and can be obtained.
                                                                     Note that the thickness of the walls are also changed considering
and the requirement at the end face                                  the Poisson’s ratio. The mode index of the deformed microstruc-
                                                                     ture is calculated and its contribution to the pressure sensitivity
                                                           (13-e)    is estimated as                          . We found that the con-
                                                                     tribution of the refractive-index change to mode-index change
With the plane strain approximation,
                                                                     is about two orders lower than the effect of the microstructure
                                                           (13-f)    deformation and can be ignored.
                                                                        2) FiberII: For fiber II, the bandgap guidance in the air core
With the found constants ,    and , the longitudinal strain          relies on the cladding structure and the mode property is largely
can be determined. We found that the change of cavity length         determined by the geometry of the holey cladding. In addition,
2530                                                                                     JOURNAL OF LIGHTWAVE TECHNOLOGY, VOL. 31, NO. 15, AUGUST 1, 2013
Fig. 4. Calculated deformation of the silica walls and first order principle stress
over the microstructure for fiber III when the radial displacement of the inner
boundary of the silica ring is 1     .
                                                                                      Fig. 5. Left: The ressembled fiber transverse geometry for the calculation
                                                                                      of mode indexes for fiber II. Right: Schematic deformations of two selected
                                                                                      cladding cells. The dashed curves define the orignal cells and the solid curves
the mode index is also affected by the size and shape of the                          represents the deformed ones.
air core. Generally speaking, larger core results in higher mode
index (closer to 1). The microstructure change under pressure is
quite complicated for the two-layer structure. The strain distri-                     of 6.25      . The effective index of the fundamental mode is
bution can be characterized by (11) and (12). With the calculated                     first calculated by use of finite element method. Then the mode
    ,   and     , we found that the amplitude of the latter terms                     solving process is performed for a fiber structure with a slightly
are much smaller than the former ones and the in-plane strain                         reduced core, but the cladding structure remains unchanged, in
distribution can be approximately expressed by                                        order to estimate the index change under pressure. The pres-
                                                                                      sure sensitivity contributed from the index change is estimated
                                                                             (16)     as only                            .
                                                                                                                   IV. DISCUSSION
where                            is calculated based on (11)–(13).
Eq. (16) suggests that the in-plane strain is nonuniform over                            We found that the cavity-length change plays a dominate
the holey cladding. The region near the core experiences much                         role for both the sensors by comparing the calculated and mea-
higher strain than at near the silica outer cladding, since the                       sured result in Fig. 2(c). The pressure-induced cavity length
strain is proportional to      . For example, both the radial and                     is largely determined by the cross sectional area of the outer
azimuth strain at                    (at the inner boundary of the                    silica cladding. The enhancement can be measured with the
holey cladding) is about 30 times higher than at                 (at                  amplification factor . The definition of indicates that the
the outer boundary).                                                                  pressure sensitivity can be effectively enhanced by reducing
   Since       has a negative value, the cladding cells are com-                      the thickness of the silica outer cladding.
pressed along the azimuth direction and stretched along the ra-                          In contrast, contributions of mode-index change to the sensi-
dial direction. Fig. 5 demonstrates the schematic deformation of                      tivities are much smaller. Note that the simplified bandgap fiber
two selected cells when the cavity is under hydrostatic pressure.                     presents a much higher and positive index change rate than the
However, since the in-plane strain is of microstrain order with                       HC-PBGF and we intend to discuss the different mechanisms
an applied pressure of 1 MPa, the deformation can hardly affect                       of mode-index changes between the two fibers. The elementary
the bandgap. The cell walls are bent when the holey cladding is                       unit of the microsturcture is the hexagonal air-hole cell for the
deformed and the refractive index of the silica walls may change                      both fibers. This difference is mainly due to the existence of
as a result of the elasto-optic effect. However, this change is                       the defect core for fiber II, which is created by omitting seven
relatively small, compared with the silica-air index difference                       air holes from the holey structure. If the air core is excluded in
which is a critical parameter in the determination of the profile                     the microstructure, i. e., the fiber contains an ideally uniform
of the bandagp. This analysis indicates that the induced defor-                       hexagon array, all the cell walls experience normal stresses and
mation of the holey cladding is too small to induce the bandgap                       strains when the fiber is under pressure, like the case for fiber
shift and mode-index change.                                                          I. The air-hole cells can keep their hexagonal profile rather than
   On the other hand, the air core also deforms when the cavity                       deforms like those in Fig. 5. The introduction of the defect core
is under pressure. The calculated radial strain at the inner wall of                  significantly changes the elasticity of the fiber. The longitudinal
the air core is                based on (16), which suggests that                     component of the applied pressure tends to induce expansion of
the core shrinks due to the deformation of the holey cladding.                        the holey cladding. The defect core provides a freedom for the
With the composed transverse fiber geometry in Fig. 5, we cal-                        expansion. As a result, the air holes surrounding the core can
culated the mode index for the HC-PBGF. The core has a radius                         not hold ideal hexagonal shape.
JIN et al.: SENSITIVITY CHARACTERISTICS OF FABRY-PEROT PRESSURE SENSORS BASED ON HOLLOW-CORE MICROSTRUCTURED FIBERS                               2531
   [22] V. Dangui, H. Kim, M. Digonnet, and G. Kino, “Phase sensitivity to          Bai-Ou Guan received the B.Sc. degree in applied physics from Sichuan Uni-
        temperature of the fundamental mode in air-guiding photonic-bandgap         versity, Chengdu, China, in 1994, and the M.Sc. and Ph.D. degrees in optics
        fibers,” Opt. Exp., vol. 13, no. 18, pp. 6669–6684, Sep. 2005.              from Nankai University, Tianjin, China, in 1997 and 2000, respectively.
   [23] M. Pang and W. Jin, “Detection of acoustic pressure with hollow-core           From 2000 to 2005, he was with the Department of Electrical Engineering, the
        photonic bandgap fiber,” Opt. Exp., vol. 17, no. 13, pp. 11088–11097,       Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Hong Kong, first as a Research Associate,
        Jul. 2009.                                                                  then as a Postdoctoral Research Fellow. From 2005 to 2009, he was with School
   [24] M. Pang, H. Xuan, J. Ju, and W. Jin, “Influence of strain and pressure to   of Physics and Optoelectronic Engineering, Dalian University of Technology,
        the effective refractive index of the fundamental mode of hollow-core       Dalian, China, as a full professor, where he established the PolyU-DUT Joint
        photonic bandgap fibers,” Opt. Exp., vol. 18, no. 13, pp. 14041–14055,      Research Center for Photonics. In 2009 he joined Jinan University, Guangzhou,
        Jul. 2010.                                                                  China, where he founded the Institute of Photonics Technology. His current
   [25] C. Wu, B. O. Guan, Z. Wang, and X. Feng, “Characterization of pres-         research interests include fiber-optic biochemical sensors, micro/nanofiber op-
        sure response of Bragg gratings in grapefruit microstructured fibers,”      tical sensors, polarimetric fiber grating laser sensors, microstructured optical
        J. Lightw. Technol., vol. 28, no. 9, pp. 1392–1397, May 2010.               fiber sensors, photonic microwave generators, and photonic components for
   [26] C. Wu, H. Y. Fu, K. K. Qureshi, B. O. Guan, and H. Y. Tam, “High-           sensing and telecommunication. He has authored and coauthored more than
        pressure and high-temperature characteristics of a Fabry-Perot interfer-    160 technical papers and presented more than 10 invited talks at international
        ometer based on photonic crystal fiber,” Opt. Lett., vol. 36, no. 3, pp.    conferences.
        412–414, Feb. 2011.                                                            He is a member of IEEE and OSA, served as the General Co-Chair of the
   [27] S. H. Aref, M. I. Zibaii, M. Kheiri, H. Porbeyram, H. Latifi, F. M.         10th International Conference on Optical Communications and Networks
        Araújo, L. A. Ferreira, J. L. Santos, J. Kobelke, K. Schuster, and O.       (ICOCN2011), the General Co-Chair of the 2nd Asia-Pacific Optical Sensors
        Frazão, “Pressure and temperature characterization of two interfero-        Conference (APOS2010), and the Technical Program Committee Co-Chair of
        metric configurations based on suspended-core fibers,” Opt. Commun.,        the 5th Asia-Pacific Microwave Photonics Conference 2010 (APMP2010).
        vol. 285, no. 3, pp. 269–273, Feb. 2012.
                                                                                    Huifeng Wei received the M.S. degree from the College of Physics Science,
                                                                                    Nankai University, Tianjin, China, in 2006. Currently, he is with the State Key
Long Jin received the B.S. degree in applied physics and the Ph.D. degree in        Laboratory of Optical Fiber and Cable Manufacture Technology, Yangtze Op-
fiber optics from Nankai University, China, in 2003 and 2008, respectively. He      tical Fiber and Cable Company Ltd. (YOFC), Wuhan, China, and he is the
joined the Department of Electrical Engineering, Hong Kong Polytechnic Uni-         leader of photonic crystal fiber project with YOFC, and the executive leader
versity in 2008, as a research assistant and then a Postdoctoral Research Fellow.   of the project of the national Key Basic Research and Development Program
Since 2010, he has been with Institute of Photonics Technology, Guangzhou,          of China under Grant 2010CB735904. His research interests include fabrica-
China as an associate professor. He has published more than 50 journal and          tion and characterization of photonic crystal fiber, photonic crystal fiber-based
conference papers. His research interests include fiber grating devices, photonic   super continuum source, and research and development of Rare Earth-doped
crystal fibers and optical fiber sensors.                                           fiber and fiber laser.