Proposal Rubrics (https://www.rcampus.com/rubricshowc.cfm?
code=YX62W64&sp=yes&)
Excellent Proficient Basic Below Basic
5 pts 4 pts 3 pts 2 pts
Student shows a deep Student shows an Student shows some Student shows
understanding of the understanding of the understanding of the very little
Subject subject matter and its subject matter and it subject matter but understanding of
Matter greater implications. is evident in the confusion is evident in the subject
Proposal or plan execution of the some aspects of the matter and
shows integration of proposal or plan. proposal or plan. thoroughly
some advanced or misinterprets the
researched concepts. requirements for
the class.
The project proposed The project proposed The project proposed is The project
is very original, is original, creative somewhat creative, proposed is not
Creativity/ creative and and somewhat original or ambitious creative, original
Ambition ambitious. The ambitious. The the student is not very or ambitious, the
student is highly student is motivated excited but not bored, student is
motivated, and the about the project, and project has some uninspired,
project has a good the project has a good potential for success. project has a low
potential for success. potential for success potential for
success.
Shows excellent Shows good effort, Shows some effort, Shows little or no
effort, care and care and creativity. care and creativity. effort, care or
creativity. creativity.
Final
Proposal or plan is Proposal or plan is
Product
Final product is finished and turned in finished and turned in, Project proposal
complete and well- on time. Shows good but is rushed and is is sloppy,
presented. Shows research, some poorly presented. illegible,
excellent research, planning, vision, and crumpled,
careful planning, and good execution. unfinished or
excellent execution. incomplete.
Proposal or plan is Proposal or plan is Proposal or plan makes Proposal or plan
clear, concise, and well organized, and general sense but is vague,
has a logical structure has a sensible flow requires some work to disjointed, and
Structure
and flow. and structure. organize and structure shows no sense,
and Flow
in a logical and sensible structure, or
Work shows deep Minor elements may manner. flow.
consideration of the need clarification but
execution of the otherwise well made Confusing to
project after the and ready for read, difficult to
proposal's approval. execution. understand.
Comments and suggestions: