Admixture Lesions in Congenital Cyanotic Heart Disease: Hemodynamic Rounds
Admixture Lesions in Congenital Cyanotic Heart Disease: Hemodynamic Rounds
Address for correspondence: Prof. Jaganmohan A Tharakan, Sree Chitra Tirunal Institute for Medical Sciences and Technology, Trivandrum 695 011, India.
E-mail: jaganmohan.tharakan@gmail.com
Congenital Cyanotic heart disease (CCHD) with Calculation of pulmonary vascular resistance (PVR)
admixture physiology is a cardiac defect which facilitates requires minute oxygen consumption (VO 2 ) and
complete mixing of the deoxygenated systemic venous hemoglobin concentration, the pulmonary artery (PA)
(SV) blood returning from the tissues and the fully pressure, and pulmonary blood flow.
oxygenated pulmonary venous blood from the lungs in Though the admixture cardiac lesions facilitate complete
a common receiving chamber. mixing in a common chamber, this is often not the
Basic concepts case. This can result in two scenarios. The pulmonary
venous return can preferentially stream into the aorta
As the mixing of the deoxygenated SV blood and the fully
(AO) precluding complete admixture and result in
oxygenated pulmonary venous blood is a simple physical
higher oxygen saturation in the AO than the PA. This
process, the resultant mix of blood will have saturation
is described as favorable streaming. Conversely, the
somewhere in between that of SV and pulmonary venous
pulmonary venous return can selectively enter the
blood oxygen saturation. When mixing is complete,
PA resulting in higher oxygen saturation in PA than
the resultant oxygen saturation will depend on the
AO. This can be described as unfavorable streaming.
relative contribution of the amount of blood from each
Thus, it is apparent that for identical pulmonary blood
circulation. As discussed earlier, the systemic blood flow
flow, the systemic arterial oxygen saturation can vary
is maintained within a narrow physiological range in the
considerably depending on the streaming in the common
basal state. Assuming the cardiac index to be within the
mixing chamber.
normal range, the effective saturation of the completely
admixed blood will be linearly related to the amount The relationship of arterial oxygen saturation to
of oxygenated blood from the lung (pulmonary blood pulmonary blood flow is influenced both by the total
flow).[1] Therefore, the systemic arterial saturation in pulmonary blood flow and the type and degree of
an admixture cardiac defect will reflect the pulmonary streaming in the mixing chamber. Cardiac catheterization
blood flow. and hemodynamic study is often necessary for assessing
PVR and operability.
It is safe to assume that for a normal cardiac index, the
artero-venous oxygen difference will be around 25% in Congenital cyanotic heart disease with admixture
the basal state. In admixture lesions, the aortic saturation physiology
and the pulmonary saturation will be identical. If the
The common CCHD with admixture physiology include
aortic saturation is 85%, PA saturation can be assumed
totally anomalous pulmonary venous connection
as 85% and PV saturation as 100%. If we assume normal
(TAPVC), atresia of one of the atrioventricular valves
cardiac index, then the artero-venous oxygen difference
(Tricuspid atresia, mitral atresia), single ventricle
will be approximately 25%, that is, the SV saturation
physiology (double inlet ventricle), semilunar valve
will be around 60%. QP/QS = (AO saturation - Systemic
atresia (pulmonary atresia including hypoplastic right
venous saturation)/(PV saturation – PA saturation) =
heart syndrome, aortic atresia including hypoplastic
(85-60)/(100 – 85) = 25/15 = 1.67 : 1. left heart syndrome), double outlet RV or double outlet
LV, complete deficiency of atrial septum as in common
Let us assume that SV saturation in the above example is
atrium, and complete deficiency of conotruncal and
70%, indicating a lesser arterio-venous oxygen difference
trunco-aortic septum as in truncus arteriosus.
and also reflecting a higher systemic flow. The Qp/Qs =
(85-70)/100-85 = 15/15 = 1. Common examples of admixture lesions and issues in the
hemodynamic assessment are discussed below:
This example highlights the importance of obtaining
the SV saturation as well as the systemic arterial Double outlet right ventricle
oxygen saturation in calculating flow ratios to compute
The commoner forms of double outlet right ventricle
pulmonary to systemic vascular resistance (SVR) ratio
(DORV) without pulmonary stenosis can have subaortic
and limitations of aortic oxygen saturation taken in
VSD or subpulmonic VSD. Though described as an
isolation as an indicator of pulmonary blood flow. For
admixture lesion, RV acting as the mixing chamber,
identical aortic oxygen saturation, reducing SV saturation
often complete mixing does not occur. The LV pumps
will in effect increase the calculated pulmonary to
into the great vessels, using RV as a conduit and little
systemic blood flow ratio.
opportunity to effect complete mixing in RV. Incomplete
Applying the same logic, if the aortic saturation in a mixing or streaming is commonly seen in DORV. In DORV
with subaortic VSD, LV blood preferentially enters the IVC can selectively stream into the LA across the ASD
AO and RV blood enters the PA, resulting in favorable (favorable streaming). This can result in dissimilar
streaming and aortic oxygen saturation significantly saturation in AO and PA. Thus, low arterial oxygen
higher than PA. When the VSD is subpulmonic in location, saturation can be due to reduced pulmonary blood flow
the LV blood preferentially enters the PA and the RV due to pulmonary vascular disease, or PV desaturation
blood preferentially enters the AO. This is unfavorable due to pulmonary venous channel obstruction, or due to
streaming with PA saturation more than the AO. In effect, passive pulmonary hypertension secondary to pulmonary
DORV with subaortic VSD presents like a large left to venous hypertension, or due to unfavorable streaming.
right shunt VSD, as the desaturation is mild and cyanosis Conversely, infradiaphragmatic obstructed TAPVC can
inapparent. DORV with subpulmonic VSD presents maintain fair systemic saturation despite being moribund
clinically as TGA with VSD, with significant systemic due to PVH and pulmonary edema (unfavorable anatomy,
desaturation and cyanosis despite increased pulmonary but favorable streaming).[6]
blood flow. The same argument is appropriate for DORV
Interestingly, when TAPVC is associated with conditions
with pulmonic stenosis. Though DORV is an admixture
like pulmonary atresia and complete endocardial cushion
lesion, due to variable streaming of blood, the systemic
defect as in visceral heterotaxy (two admixture lesions in
saturation may not accurately reflect the pulmonary
tandem), the clinical picture is dominated by the second
blood flow, and hemodynamic study is often necessary
lesion and TAPVC may be overlooked unless special care
to assess pulmonary blood flow and resistance.[2-4]
is taken to identify the pulmonary venous drainage. This
Total anomalous pulmonary venous drainage or is important when Glenn shunt is planned as TAPVC will
connection interfere with rerouting of SVC to PA.
Regardless of the site of drainage of the pulmonary When TAPVC, an admixture lesion, is associated with
veins (PVs), the RA acts as an effective mixing chamber. TGA, it may be beneficial as complete admixture of
Typically, the RA, RV, PA, LA, LV, and aortic oxygen oxygenated and deoxygenated blood will mitigate issues
saturation will be identical. This will also mask any shunt of lack of mixing, so characteristic of TGA.
downstream from the RA, as the saturations are identical
In the other pretricuspid admixture lesions, like common
in the upstream chambers, RA, and LA and additional step
atrium, TAPVC to RA and tricuspid atresia, streaming has
up or step down in saturation cannot occur. Assuming
not been well characterized.
complete admixture and assuming normal systemic
cardiac output, the aortic saturation will indirectly Single ventricle
reflect the pulmonary blood flow.[1] Alternately, if the In single-ventricle physiology with two patent AV valves,
aortic saturation is very low, then it indirectly indicates both favorable and unfavorable streaming is often seen
decreased pulmonary blood flow and hence pulmonary and does not necessarily depend on the ventricular
vascular disease. Conversely, if the pulmonary blood morphology or the great vessel relation. Some patients
flow is markedly increased, then the aortic saturations with DILV with aorta arising from the left-sided and
can be as high as 90% and cyanosis may be missed. It anterior rudimentary RV outflow chamber (inverted)
is not uncommon to make a clinical diagnosis of ASD have “favorable streaming,” with SV blood preferentially
as all other clinical features are like a large left to right directed into the PA and pulmonary venous return
shunt ASD and the minimal cyanosis can be missed.[5] It directed to the aorta. Similarly, patients with aorta
should be noted that only a minority of TAPVC remain from a right-sided and anterior rudimentary RV outflow
asymptomatic and present like an ASD, as majority chamber (non-inverted) may have “unfavorable”
will have some anatomic or functional obstruction to streaming.[7,8]
the anomalous channel resulting in pulmonary venous
hypertension early in life. Only 50% of TAPVC survive Patients with univentricular hearts characteristically
have a complete mix of systemic and pulmonary venous
3 months and 20% survive one year without surgery.
circulations at the ventricular level. If one assumes
Streaming in TAPVC: In fetal circulation, the IVC blood is a pulmonary venous oxygen saturation of 100% and
directed to the atrial septum and the fossa to LA, while the normal systemic blood flow (cardiac output), the arterial
SVC blood is directed to the tricuspid valve (TV) and RV. oxygen saturation will reflect pulmonary blood flow. As a
Similarly, the direction of flow from the coronary sinus is rule of thumb, values 85% and <75% signify increased
away from the fossa and toward the TV. This physiological and decreased pulmonary blood flow, respectively.
streaming is maintained to some extent in the postnatal
Truncus arteriosus
life when there is an associated TAPVC. Supracardiac
TAPVC draining into SVC or to coronary sinus can stream Streaming is well documented in truncus arteriosus and
selectively to the TV, RV, and into PA (unfavorable can result in substantial difference in aortic and pulmonary
streaming) and infradiaphragmatic TAPVC draining to arterial saturation. This should caution us when we use
systemic arterial saturation as indicator of pulmonary SVR ratio <0.7) may be offered surgery even when the
blood flow and pulmonary vascular disease.[9-11] PA and aortic systolic pressure are identical.[13,14]
Hypoplastic left heart syndrome The patients with near-normal PA pressures are generally
those with pulmonary stenosis (DORV with PS, SV with
In hypoplastic left heart syndrome, the only functional
PS). Biventricular surgical correction, when feasible,
ventricle RV acts as the main mixing and pumping
is most often limited by the adequacy of the PA size.
chamber. With a common pump, two resistance circuits
However, when single ventricle repair is planned, the
in parallel and flow returning to the same pump, this
is truly a parallel circulation. The output of the RV is pulmonary arteries should be of adequate size and the
distributed to the two circulations depending on the PA pressure should not exceed 15 to 20 mm and vascular
resistance of the two vascular beds (pulmonary and resistance should ideally be less than 2 wood units.m2
systemic). In a sick infant with hypoplastic left heart, and should not exceed 2 to 4 Wood units.m2.[15]
the systemic blood flow is markedly compromised with
postnatal reduction in PVR. A fine balance of PVR and EXAMPLES OF OXIMETRY STUDIES OF
SVR is to be maintained to ensure adequate systemic CYANOTIC HEART DISEASES
blood flow. In HLHS, it is best to keep the PBF equal to
SBF as well as keep the SBF near normal range so that the To simplify the discussion on systemic blood flow,
combined output of the ventricle will be twice normal. pulmonary blood flow and effective pulmonary (or
In admixture lesions, we discussed the normal arterio effective systemic) blood flow in various cyanotic heart
venous difference to be maintained at close to 25% to diseases, the following values are assumed:
maintain normal systemic blood flow. As the PA and An adult with body surface area, 1.6 m2 and assumed
aortic saturation are identical, aortic saturation 75% VO2, 200 ml/min; Hb, 14.75 gm%, with a cyanotic heart
usually ensures Qp/Qs close to unity (AO saturation – disease is the hypothetical patient.
systemic venous saturation/PV saturation-PA saturation).
However, this assumes PV saturation as 100% and SV VO2: 200 ml/min
saturation as 50%. Often, SV saturation will be very Hb: 14.75 gm%
low indicating poor tissue perfusion, even though the
AO saturation is 75%. Similarly, with increased PBF, O2 carrying capacity in ml/l of blood: 14.75 x 1.36 x 10
the systemic arterial saturation increases but may = 200 ml O2/l of blood
actually reduce the systemic blood flow due to steal Flow across vascular bed (l/min) = VO2/O2 carrying
by the pulmonary circulation, with tissue hypoxemia. capacity (ml O2/l of blood) x O2 saturation difference%
This steal often results in low diastolic pressure in the across vascular bed
AO, compromising coronary perfusion. This situation
can also cause rapid deterioration of hemodynamics. Flow (l/min) = 200/200 x O2 saturation difference%
This highlights the need for monitoring SV oxygen Flow (l/min) = 1/(O2 saturation difference%)
saturation along with arterial oxygen saturation. In the
first instance, the total cardiac output has to be increased Systemic blood flow [Qs] (l/min) = 1/(Aortic O 2
using positive inotropic agents, whereas in the second saturation% - PA O2 saturation%)
clinical scenario, PVR has to be increased usually using Pulmonary blood flow [Qp] (l/min) = 1/(PV O 2
controlled CO2 inhalation to cause mild hypercarbia saturation% - PA O2 saturation%)
or reducing inspired O2 concentration to cause mild
hypoxemia.[12] Effective pulmonary [Qep] or effective systemic [Qes]
blood flow = 1/(PV O2 saturation% – mixed venous O2
saturation%)
SURGERY IN CONGENITAL
CONGENITAL HEART DISEASE WITH To calculate the various flows, we need the oxygen
ADMIXTURE PHYSIOLOGY saturation in AO, PA, PV (often assumed as 100% or fully
saturated), and SV or mixed venous (MV) saturation
In patients with pulmonary hypertension and pulmonary (obtained as the average of three SVC and one IVC
vascular disease, the guidelines for surgery are generally saturation).
similar to an isolated VSD with pulmonary vascular
The following examples will have AO, PA, PV, and MV
disease: PVR index less than 4 Wood units.m2 having a
saturations, and with the VO2 and Hb% already given,
favorable outcome and those with PVR >8 Wood units.
we will proceed with calculation of the flows and
m2 having a poor outcome. Patients with PVRI dropping
interpretation.
to 6-8 wood units on 100% oxygen administered for 20
minutes and on nitric oxide are also offered surgical Please note that the O2 saturation difference between the
correction.[13] Patients with Qp : Qs ratio > 1.8 (PVR to AO and MV is kept at 20% to maintain normal systemic
blood flow (cardiac output) and PV assumed as 100%, R L shunt = 1.7 l/min and L R shunt = 6.7 l/min
excluding any pulmonary cause for PV desaturation.
Discussion: The oximetry run reveals equal aortic and PA
Example 1 saturation typical of an admixture lesion. This is seen in
patients with TAPVC, common atrium, single ventricle,
and truncus arteriosus. The high saturation in the AO
at 90% indicates significantly increased pulmonary
blood flow (twice the systemic), as evident by the flow
calculations. Thus, the PVR is less than half of SVR. In
truncus arteriosus, this may indicate a favorable PVR for
surgical correction.
Example 3
to determine the site of increased pulmonary resistance: MV 60%, AO 80%, PA 90%, PV 100%.
at the peripheral vascular level (pulmonary vascular
Calculated Qs = 5 l/min, Qp = 10 l/min, Qep = 3.3 l/min.
disease) or proximally at valvular, supravalvular, or
subvalvular level (sub pulmonic stenosis). R L shunt = 6.7 l/min and L R shunt = 1.7 l/min.
Example 5
CONCLUSION
CCHD with admixture physiology accounts for nearly 50%
of all cyanotic CHD. Proper assessment of hemodynamics
of admixture lesions require SV (mixed venous), connection, in Moss and Adams, Heart disease in
pulmonary venous, aortic and PA oxygen saturation and infants, children and adolescents. In: Allen HD, Driscoll
D, Shaddy RE, Feltes TF. Netherlands: Wolters Kluver;
pressures to calculate flows and pulmonary resistance.
2008. p. 1139.
The aortic saturation reflects the amount of pulmonary
blood flow, but streaming is an important component 8. Keane JF, Fyler DC. Single ventricle in Nadas’ Pediatric
Cardiology, In: Keane JF, Lock JE, Fyler DC. 2nd ed.
of admixture lesions resulting in minor to significant
Netherlands: Elsevier; 2006. P. 767-91.
difference between aortic and PA saturation. In
admixture lesions wherein the pulmonary and systemic 9. Cabalka AK, Edwards WD, Dearani AJ. Truncus
Arteriosus, in Moss and Adams, Heart disease in infants,
vascular bed form resistance in parallel, flow into the two
children and adolescents. In: Allen HD, Driscoll D,
vascular beds is determined by the resistance in the two Shaddy RE, Feltes TF. Netherlands: Wolters Kluver;
vascular beds and manipulation of individual resistance 2008. P. 916.
(systemic or pulmonary) can be used therapeutically to
10. Keane JF, Fyler DC. Truncus Arteriosus in Nadas’
optimize cardiac output and systemic oxygen delivery. Pediatric Cardiology, by Keane JF, Lock JE, fyler DC, 2nd
ed. Netherlands: Elsevier; 2006. P. 767-91.
REFERENCES 11. Kouchoukos NT, Blackstone HE, Doty DB, Hanley F,
Karp R. Truncus arteriosus, In: Kirklin and Barrat-Boyce
1. Burchell HB. Total anomalous pulmonary venous Cardiac Surgery. 3rd ed. Philadelphia (US): Churchill
drainage: Clinical and physiologic patterns. Proc Staff Livingstone; 2006. p. 1219.
Meet Mayo Clin 1956;31:161-7. 12. Tweddel JS, Hoffman GM, Ghanayen NS, Frommelt MA,
2. Hagler DJ. Double outlet Right Ventricle and Double Musatto KA, Berger S. Hypoplastic left heart syndrome.
outlet left ventricle in Moss and Adams, Heart disease in Moss and Adams, Heart disease in infants, children and
infants, children and adolescents. In: Allen HD, Driscoll adolescents. In: Allen HD, Driscoll D, Shaddy RE, Feltes
D, Shaddy RE, Feltes TF. Netherland: Wolters Kluver; TF, editors. Netherlands: Wolters Kluver; 2008. p. 1013.
2008. p. 916. 13. Grifka RG. Cardiac catheterization and angiography, in
3. Sridaromont S, Feldt RH, Ritter DJ, Davis GD, Edwards Moss and Adams, Heart disease in infants, children and
JE. Double outlet right ventricle: Hemodynamic and adolescents. In: Allen HD, Driscoll D, Shaddy RE, Feltes
anatomic correlation. Am J Cardiol 1976;38:85-94. TF, editors. Netherlands: Wolters Kluver; 2008. p. 220.
4. Walter H, Pacifico AD. Double outlet ventricles, In: 14. Mavroudis C, Backer CL, Idriss FS: Ventricular septal defect.
Mavroudis C, Backer CL editors. Pediatric Cardiac In: Mavroudis C, Backer CL, editors. Pediatric cardiac
Surgery. 2nd ed. United States: Mosby; 1996. p. 316-8. surgery, 2nd ed, United States: Mosby; 1996. p. 209.
5. Kouchoukos NT, Blackstone HE, Doty DB, Hanley F, Karp 15. Kouchoukos NT, Blackstone HE, Doty DB, Hanley F, Karp
R. Total anomalous pulmonary venous connection R. Tricuspid atresia In: Kirklin and Barrat-Boyce Cardiac
In: Kirklin and Barrat-Boyce Cardiac Surgery. 3rd ed. surgery 3rd ed. Philadelphia (US): Churchill Livingstone;
Philadelphia (US): Churchill Livingstone; 2006. p. 7589. 2006. p. 1161.