DeathOfCompetition 8
DeathOfCompetition 8
Stephan Stavrakis
DEATH OF COMPETITION :: Why competing is KILLING BUSINESS Stephan Stavrakis 2
“Businesses are dying In the early days of business, people thought that business was like sports or war.
You had to do whatever you could to stomp or kill the competition. Back then that
because of
may have made sense because the supply and demand chain was completely
competitive and
different.
bottom-line thinking”
The choices a consumer had were maybe a few dozen. There were competitors
but nowhere near as many as we have today.
Times are changing and many great businesses are falling by the wayside. When a
business fails it s quite easy to blame outside factors, like the industry, the product,
the economy and, let s not forget, the competition.
Most businesses today are dying a slow death because owners are
generally focusing on exactly the wrong things - the competition and
the bottom line.
This is why customers are losing trust and respect for business in
general!
“Every minute focused on Millions of dollars are spent every hour of every day on marketing, advertising/PR
competitors or the trying to out-do, out-hustle, out-maneuver and one-up the competition, wasting
bottom-line, is one minute vital resources that could be used in creating an amazing customer experience,
taken away from creating a
magnificent customer This purpose of this paper is to debunk the dangerous mindsets and activities that
experience” create commoditized markets due to competitive and bottom line thinking. In other
words, why your best intentions are actually killing your business.
The goal is to put the focus back on the customer and begin to position businesses
to restore trust and respect from the customer.
Commodity definition:
A commodity is a product or service for which there is a demand but which is
supplied without any real differentiation by multiple suppliers. Commodities have
pricing that is basically universal no matter who produces it. To customers
commodity items are all the same.
As such, goods and services that could formerly command a premium price have
become commodities because their brands have been white-washed in the mind of
the consumer.
Competition definition:
Competition is a contest between individuals, groups, nations, animals,
etc. for territory, a niche, or a location of resources. It arises whenever
two or more parties strive for a goal which cannot be shared.
Or what if your brand was going off the market? Now what?
There are so many styles and brands to choose from. Why? Because the
market has too many players doing exactly the same thing: trying to sell
tooth paste.
An example of a virtually new market in the toothpaste market is sensitive
teeth toothpaste.
“If we charge more money,
we can increase the quality Currently there are only about 3 different toothpastes for the sensitive
to create a win-win teeth market so there is not that much of selection.
situation between customer
and business owner” If a company uses the words better or best in their marketing it might
work for a while because there is less competition.
However, when other companies finally notice and the sensitive teeth
market becomes riddled with competitors (like the whiter teeth market)
the bloodbath will start anew.
The last thing the market needs is another cell phone, another plumber,
another insurance agent, another computer company…
This doesn t mean that these people can t go out and become profitable in
the market, they just have to create a distinct differentiation through
innovative thinking and positioning.
The competition mindset creates nothing but stress and anxiety for the business
owner, and ultimately forces them to think about what the competition is doing
rather than what the customer really wants and would be willing to pay anything for.
Let s face it, if business owners listened to their customers and focused on the
quality of the experience instead of the quantity of deliverables, they would have
more fun creating more value for the customer.
The positioning mindset is different. It focuses all the business owner s attention
on providing the most USEFUL and UNIQUE experience the customer could ever
want. The idea is to appeal to a single niche of a market rather than everyone with
a pulse.
Every moment of the day we are being bombarded by advertising and marketing
messages. These messages that sound, look and feel the same.
However you slice it, or say it, the message you are left with is
Pick my business because it s BETTER . As consumers we are
bombarded with this nonsense thousands of times a day.
This type of activity is a common thing in the cell phone market. When some
company comes out with a cool feature, then you get a slew of other companies
trying to outdo them by adding more features to the phone, or making better
features.
Although the company won t die (at least not soon) it will surely lose major market
share in the next few years. They need positioning and fast....
As tempting as this may seem, all feature positioning does is confuse the market,
destroy customer loyalty and again makes the product or service into a commodity
that can be price shopped.
This is a last resort that most businesses default to in order to position themselves
differently in the marketplace by being the Best Price. But this isn t
differentiation. It s desperation!
Although sometimes the we have the better price message can work as a short
term positioning strategy, more often than not when the company tries to
differentiate on price, it forces everyone else in the market to follow suit, like
airline fare wars.
When this happens the profit margins suffer and, ultimately, the quality to the
customer suffers.
These three common positioning practices are slowly killing market share,
marketability and ultimately the business itself.
When the profit margins suffer, the customer suffers from poor quality of product/
service thereby ultimately decreasing the trust the customer has in that product or
service and the market as a whole.
The economy is not the problem. The method of marketing is not the problem. The
medium used for advertising is not the problem.
Because of the increase of focus on competition, businesses have lost the ability to
create innovative and distinctive messages that speak to the exact wants and
needs of the customer…you know, the people who actually buy the stuff!
Sameness is making all products and services into commodities in the mind of the
consumer, forcing them to make buying decisions based on the lowest common
denominator: price.
The problem with this level of thinking is far more costly to you, the business
Something to ponder...
owner, than you realize.
Honor that thinking, give The slices of the market pie get thinner and thinner
them something worth and if you don t have enough money to out-spend
paying for.
the competition you ll go hungry.
We think of him as the man behind Apple s differentiation position. The man builds
UNIQUE and different products and services with giddy enthusiasm.
I don t know this for fact, but I believe his prime directive is to build elegant
distinctions in Apple s products/services.
Positioning = Profit
The main way to gauge the success of a company is to look at their stock
performance.
When Mr. Jobs returned to Apple in 1997 (Arrow 1), the stock skyrocketed from 20
dollars to 300 dollars in just 10 years. (As a side note, while Steve was away he
bought Pixar Inc. for 5million and later sold it to Disney for 7.4Billion)
Rarely do you ever find Apple products on sale NOT EVEN ON BLACK FRIDAY.
$300+ Increase
Apple sets prices, and the customer experience. Mr. Jobs makes sure that all
distribution channels are
customer experience
focused. Mr. Jobs Comes Back To Apple
Although companies are generally in business to create more income, the fear of
differentiating and carving a unique niche market is avoided because specialization
Do you feel that is seen as going after a market that isn t big enough and profitable enough to
by “competing” in maintain, let alone grow, a business.
the broad market
you give yourself The broader the market, the more the competition. The more competition, the more
the opportunity to commoditization. The more commoditization, the lesser quality and lower price. The
a bigger market lesser the quality, the worse the customer experience. The customer ends up
share? suffering and their trust and respect for your company plummets.
Unfortunately, the
exact opposite is Broader Market = Competition = Commoditization = Less Quality =
true... Bad Customer Experience
By focusing on quality, the value to the consumer increases, thereby allowing the
price for the product/service to increase. This drives higher profit margins. This
allows the owner to make more money with less effort.
Based on this focus, businesses that make themselves unique become The Only
business that offers what they offer.
By being The Only , businesses can increase profit margins, lower costs, increase
quality and ultimately increase the level of trust and respect by the customer.
This, in turn, creates a LOYAL customer for the life of that business.
Although there are many methods to position your business to be The First in a
market. We believe that it s no longer good enough to be the first. The new solution
is to become The Only
1. Credibility
Creating a credibility perceptual position allows the business owner to create
credibility in the prospects mind so that the customers feel they ve made the right
decision.
For many years the credibility of safe & reliable vehicle is associated with Volvo.
Volvo spent millions of dollars creating the credibility position that their product
the safest vehicle on the road. This customer focus, made Volvo the worlds most
reliable vehicle in the mind of the consumer
2. Identity
When this perceptual position is established correctly, the customer feels like they
are a part of something bigger, something that goes beyond your product or
service.
A good example of identity perceptual positioning is Nike. Nike has create a zealot
like following by making people that wear their clothing feel like TOP athletes so
the Nike customer goes through a virtual identity change when they put on the
clothes.
3. Value
The value perceptual position is about making something valuable the moment
the customer sees it, hears about it, or experiences it. You automatically have a
general idea of the value of a Ferrari, the moment you lay your eyes on it. There
are several factors at play to create a value perceptual position.
4. Categorical
The Categorical perceptual position is when you create a category in the target
market that makes you first to market with the particular product or service. This
perceptual position is your niche, and what makes you unique in the market place.
There are many elements to creating a new category. The last page of this paper
shows you how to get a complimentary video on how to create a categorical
position
5. Image
When positioning your business, your target market usually already has a
preconceived notion about it. When your image doesn t match that preconceived
notion you are creating Psychological Incongruence . This is when you or your
message don t match what the customer expects.
Example - Mercedes is a Luxury Car. However, they also sell mid-market(low priced)
vehicles with the Mercedes brand name. This doesn t match what the customer
thinks about Mercedes and therefore creates psychological incongruence
6. Familiarity
This perceptual position is based on the fact that you or your business message is
being disbursed in as many exposure media as possible. Exposure mediums are
anywhere your message can be seen or exposed. Newspapers, email,
articles, podcasts, blogs, websites, radio, t.v. facebook, twitter etc. are
exposure mediums.
7. Continuity
This perceptual position is based on the idea that trust is built through
consistency. The continuity position is created by picking the mediums that
captures your market and exposes your message to them over and over, so that
the market knows they can rely on, and get comfortable with, the way you
communicate to them.
Combine the 7 elements together, and you ll EARN trust and respect from your
marketplace which in turn gives you The Only position.
Each area is a building block that builds on the last. When we build the entire
perceptual position your company becomes The Only company to do business
with. Period!
You'll be banging your head and wondering: "Why didn't I think of that?"
Stephan has worked with 1000 s of businesses owners and has logged over 13,000
hrs of one-on-one coaching and consulting, moving business owners from "me,too"
positions to being The Only business in their market, while exponentially
increasing their sales and bottom line.
Stephan has worked with many well-know best-selling authors, speakers and
trainers as well as high profile brick & mortar businesses. Stephan is a highly
sought after speaker for the insights and humor he brings to the stage. He is
consistently rated as thought provoking and practical by the business audiences he
addresses.
As Founder and CEO of 3D Thinking & Training Ltd, Stephan designed a straight
forward, practical approach to increasing sales and profits, called Perceptual
Positioning .
Part 2: is for the business owner who would like an easy way to
create a new and distinctive market to dominate simply by
becoming The Only
Video
Click To See The Videos...