Operating The Severe Wastewater Analysis Testing Apparatus: Standard Practice For
Operating The Severe Wastewater Analysis Testing Apparatus: Standard Practice For
Copyright © ASTM International, 100 Barr Harbor Drive, PO Box C700, West Conshohocken, PA 19428-2959. United States
                                                                                         1
                                                                                  G210 − 13
   2.2 ISO Standards:3                                                                    agreed upon between the client and testing facility. Any
   ISO 16773 Paints- and Varnishes- Electrochemical Imped-                                deviations from this practice shall be reported.
     ance Spectroscopy (EIS) on High Impedance Coated
     Samples. Part 1: Terms and Definitions                                               5. Significance and Use
   ISO 16773 Paints- and Varnishes- Electrochemical Imped-                                  5.1 Domestic wastewater headspace environments are cor-
     ance Spectroscopy (EIS) on High Impedance Coated                                     rosive due to the presence of sewer gases and sulfuric acid
     Samples. Part 2: Collection of Data                                                  generated during the biogenic sulfide corrosion process.5 This
   ISO 16773 Paints- and Varnishes- Electrochemical Imped-                                operating procedure provides an accelerated exposure to sewer
     ance Spectroscopy (EIS) on High Impedance Coated                                     gases and concentration of sulfuric acid commonly produced
     Samples. Part 3: Processing and Analysis of Data from                                by bacteria within these sewer environments.6
     Dummy Cells
                                                                                            5.2 The results obtained by the use of this practice can be a
3. Terminology                                                                            means for estimating the protective barrier qualities of a
                                                                                          protective coating or lining for use in severe sewer conditions.
   3.1 Definitions of Terms Specific to This Standard:
   3.1.1 domestic wastewater, n—wastewater discharged from                                  5.3 Some protective coatings or linings may not withstand
residences and from commercial, institutional, and similar                                the exposure temperature specified in this practice but have
facilities.                                                                               demonstrated satisfactory performance in actual sewer
   3.1.2 sewer headspace, n—the air space between the water                               exposures, which are at lower temperatures.
surface and the top of the pipe (crown) or other enclosed
structure.                                                                                6. Apparatus
  3.2 For definitions of terms used in this practice, see                                    6.1 The testing apparatus consists of the following:
Terminology G193.                                                                            6.1.1 Glass Tank—Minimum diameter 16 by 12 in. (40 by
                                                                                          30 cm) tall. The glass tank, when fitted with a polypropylene
4. Summary of Practice                                                                    lid (tank cover) and elastomeric seal, creates an air-tight test
                                                                                          chamber. The glass tank is inert to the aggressive reagents at
   4.1 The corrosion protection of steel, ductile iron, and                               the testing temperature. The glass tank shall be transparent to
concrete by a protective coating or lining may be altered by                              permit visual examination of the test specimens throughout
exposure to sewer gases and by the composition of the                                     specified testing duration.
corrosive reagents found in headspace environments of domes-                                 6.1.2 Polypropylene Lid—Octagon or round shaped, mini-
tic wastewater conveyance and treatment structures.4                                      mum 1 in. (2.54 cm) thick by 18 in. (46 cm) span. The
   4.2 This practice provides a controlled corrosive                                      polypropylene lid has a 1.5 in. (3.81 cm) diameter center port
environment, which has been utilized to produce a simulated                               to accommodate the shaft of the sample carousel. The shaft
severe sewer headspace condition by wetting the coated                                    slides through an O-ring seal which is secured and tensioned
samples in a cyclic fashion with a corrosive solution and then                            with a polypropylene fitting (Note 2). The shaft slides easily up
exposing the samples to air containing sewer gas. This condi-                             and down through the O-ring seal while preventing the release
tion is responsible for reducing the barrier properties of                                of test gases. Silicone grease lubricant can be used to facilitate
protective coatings and linings.                                                          movement of the shaft.
  4.3 Test specimens are positioned on a carousel and placed                                 NOTE 2—Polypropylene has been found to be an acceptable material for
inside an airtight testing apparatus (chamber) maintained at a                            this service. Other materials, such as polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) or
temperature of 150 6 5°F (65 6 3°C). The chamber contains                                 polyetheretherketone (PEEK) may also provide acceptable service.
a prescribed aqueous solution (liquid phase) at the bottom and                               6.1.2.1 The polypropylene lid is designed with two ports for
a headspace (vapor phase) containing sewer gas. The test                                  fittings, which accommodate inlet and outlet lines.
specimens are immersed into liquid phase for a period of 15                                  6.1.2.2 The side of the polypropylene lid which faces into
min each. After immersion, the specimens are exposed to the                               the tank has a circular, shallow 1-in. (2.54-cm) wide groove.
vapor phase the balance of the time. This constitutes one                                 The groove accommodates a suitable corrosion resistant elas-
complete cycle with three cycles occurring per day. This cyclic                           tomeric seal (gasket) required to seal the lid of the glass tank.
exposure continues for a period of 28 days.                                                  6.1.2.3 The polypropylene lid also includes eight equally-
   4.4 The specified operating temperature, aqueous solution,                             spaced holes along the outer edge to accommodate eight
sewer gases, and duration parameters are considered the                                   threaded rod fasteners with wing nuts, nuts, and washers. The
standard for the purposes of this practice. The specifications                            eight threaded rods connect the polypropylene lid to a solid,
may be adjusted to replicate specific environments if mutually                            chemical resistant base plate made of laminated wood or
   3                                                                                         5
     Available from International Organization for Standardization (ISO), 1, ch. de            O’Dea, V., “Understanding Biogenic Sulfide Corrosion,” Materials
la Voie-Creuse, CP 56, CH-1211 Geneva 20, Switzerland, http://www.iso.org.                Performance, November 2007, pp. 36–39.
   4                                                                                         6
     O’Dea, V. et al., “Testing Permeation Resistance in Coatings for Wastewater               O’Dea, V. et al, “Assessing Coatings & Linings for Wastewater: Accelerated
Structures,” Journal of Protective Coatings and Linings, September 2010, pp.              Test Evaluates Resistance to Severe Exposures,” Journal of Protective Coatings and
16–28.                                                                                    Linings, April 2008, pp. 44–57.
                                                                                      2
                                                                 G210 − 13
equivalent materials, located under the glass tank, hence                   6.1.4.2 Gas supply line includes a polypropylene stopcock
clamping the lid to the glass tank, thereby creating an air-tight        valve with low-friction plug of PTFE and a polypropylene gas
testing chamber.                                                         check valve with a suitable fluoroelastomer (FKM)-coated
   6.1.3 Specimen Carousel—Constructed of polypropylene                  diaphragm.
(or other suitable corrosion-resistant material) to accommodate             6.1.5 Air Purge Inlet—An external flexible and resilient
the various types of samples. Coated steel specimens will sit in         polypropylene or polyethylene fresh air supply line connects
slots and rest vertically, arranged radially (Fig. 1). Coated            the air pump to the tank through a tee into the Gas Inlet line.
concrete specimens will sit in slots oriented vertically. Cast
                                                                            6.1.5.1 Air supply line includes a polypropylene stopcock
shapes and free films will be oriented either vertically or
                                                                         valve with low-friction plug of PTFE and a polypropylene gas
horizontally, depending upon their dimensions.
   6.1.3.1 The specimen carousel consists of a tray with a               check valve with FKM-coated diaphragm.
perpendicular central shaft, which facilitates raising and low-             6.1.6 Gas Outlet—An external flexible and resilient poly-
ering of the carousel within the chamber to the liquid phase             propylene or polyethylene line from the tank cover with a
(lowered position) or vapor phase (raised position).                     polypropylene connector is connected to caustic scrubbers to
   6.1.3.2 When the carousel is in the liquid phase (lowered             capture H2S from the effluent gases.
position) the specimen carousel, including the test specimens,              6.1.6.1 Outlet line includes a check valve, a polypropylene
must be completely immersed in the aqueous solution.                     stopcock valve with low-friction plug of PTFE, a pressure
   6.1.3.3 When the carousel is in the raised position, it is            relief valve (0.5 psi or 3.4 kPa), and a pressure gauge (0 to 1.5
locked in place with a retaining pin assembly outside the top of         psig range or 0 to 10 kPa) teed into the gas outlet line using
the oven. The aqueous solution must drain away from the test             PTFE coated isolation diaphragm. An air pump is teed into the
specimens through drain holes in the carousel.                           line to the caustic scrubbers to facilitate sewer gas removal
   6.1.4 Gas Inlet—A flexible and resilient polypropylene or             from the scrubber lines.
polyethylene gas supply line connects the sewer gas supply to               6.1.6.2 Secondary Containment—A polypropylene tray of
a polypropylene inlet fitting on the tank cover. The inlet fitting
                                                                         suitable volume may be placed under the test chamber as an
assembly accommodates a polypropylene extension tube,
                                                                         additional precaution against acid spillage.
which runs to the bottom of the chamber. The vertical
extension tube allows the sewer gas mixture to be sparged                   6.1.7 Oven—Convection (forced air) oven of sufficient ca-
through the aqueous solution.                                            pacity to accommodate the test chamber and be capable of
   6.1.4.1 Gas supply line includes a gas flow controller and            maintaining a temperature of 150 6 5°F (65 6 3°C) through-
indicator (for example, rotameter) to measure instantaneous              out the duration of the test exposure. This ensures a uniform
flow rate.                                                               temperature throughout the chamber for the testing duration.
                                                                         The top of the oven must have a 3-in. (75-mm) through-wall
                                                                         opening to accommodate the inlet and outlet gas lines and the
                                                                         shaft of the specimen carousel and its movement.
                                                                            6.1.8 Air Pump—Variable-flow air pump to purge the test
                                                                         chamber and outlet lines of the hydrogen sulfide gas (and other
                                                                         sewer gases) at the completion of the exposure time. Pump
                                                                         delivery pressure and pressure relief valve should be sized to
                                                                         avoid accidentally over-pressurizing the glass tank.
                                                                            6.1.8.1 An air flow rate of at least 1.5 litres per minute
                                                                         (L/min) is recommended.
                                                                            6.1.9 Caustic Scrubbers—Capable of removing H2S from
                                                                         the exhaust test gas. A typical scrubber consists of a 4-L
                                                                         polypropylene carboy, half filled with 15 % sodium hydroxide
                                                                         (NaOH). Bubble dispersion media is added to the carboy.
                                                                            6.1.9.1 “Percent” is defined as grams of solute per volume
                                                                         of solution. 15 % NaOH contains 150 g of sodium hydroxide
                                                                         per litre of solution, which is the same as 3.75 mol of sodium
                                                                         hydroxide per litre of solution.
                                                                            6.1.9.2 Carboy cap is equipped with polypropylene fittings
                                                                         which accommodate a 0.25 in. (6.35 mm) polyethylene inlet
                                                                         dip tube and outlet tube (exhaust).
                                                                            6.1.9.3 The use of two or more scrubbers in series improves
                                                                         removal efficacy and reduces the likelihood of accidental
                                                                         release of H2S when scrubber capacity is exceeded.
                                                                            NOTE 3—Carbon dioxide is also absorbed by the scrubber, reducing
      FIG. 1 Severe Wastewater Analysis Testing Apparatus                their capacity accordingly.
                                                                     3
                                                                G210 − 13
   6.1.10 Fume Hood—Ventilation apparatus of sufficient ca-                10.1.2 Insert the test specimens into the respective slots of
pacity to encase the oven and provide necessary negative air            the specimen carousel.
flow to evacuate the surrounding air of any fugitive gas                   10.1.3 Place the specimen carousel into the glass tank in the
emissions.                                                              aqueous phase (lowered position). Quickly complete the re-
   6.1.11 Gas Sensors—Hydrogen sulfide sensors and other                maining assembly of the chamber to minimize sample expo-
pertinent safety monitors to ensure operator safety.                    sure time to the aqueous solution.
                                                                           10.1.4 Fit the lid onto the glass tank by carefully sliding it
7. Reagents and Materials
                                                                        over the central shaft of the carousel through the O-ring seal.
   7.1 Aqueous Solution:                                                   10.1.5 As an alternative to 10.1.3 and 10.1.4, if the oven is
   7.1.1 10 % sulfuric acid (H2SO4)—Twelve litres or the                sufficiently tall, the top can be assembled onto the carousel at
volume required for the samples to be completely immersed               the “raised position” and the top/carousel assembly placed on
when the specimen carousel is in the liquid phase (lowered              top of the tank without exposing the test specimens to the acid
position).                                                              solution.
   7.1.1.1 “Percent” is defined as the volume of concentrated              10.1.6 Seal the lid onto the glass tank with the eight
sulfuric acid (at 95 %) per volume of solution. Ten percent             threaded rods that run between the base plate and polypropyl-
H2SO4 contains 100 ml of concentrated sulfuric acid per litre           ene lid. Wing nuts and washers are used to evenly tension the
of acid solution, which is the same as 1.8 mol of sulfuric acid         seal in the lid to create a gas-tight chamber. Caution—Tighten
per litre of acid solution. The solution is equivalent to 17 % by       the wing nuts in such a way that pressure is applied evenly
mass, and can be prepared on a mass basis by adding 170 g of            between the lid and the glass tank in order to avoid cracking the
concentrated sulfuric acid (96 %) to 830 g of water, producing          glass. Avoid excessive force.
a final solution mass of 1000 g.                                           10.1.7 Tighten the central O-ring seal on the lid.
   7.1.2 0.4 % (4000 ppmw) sodium chloride (NaCl)—Solute                   10.1.8 Slide the assembled wastewater chamber into the
by mass per litre of acid solution.                                     convection oven. Raise the carousel into the vapor phase of the
   7.1.2.1 “Percent” is defined as mass of solute per volume of         test chamber, through the 3-in. (75-mm) opening in the top of
acid solution. 0.4 % contains 4.000 g of sodium chloride per            the oven, and lock into place.
litre of 10 % acid solution, which is the same as 0.06897 mol              10.1.9 Connect the inlet and outlet lines.
of sodium chloride per litre of acid solution.                             10.1.10 Check the gas-tight seal of the test chamber by
  7.2 Sewer Gas:                                                        pumping air into the chamber, closing the valves, and moni-
  7.2.1 500 6 50 ppmv analyzed hydrogen sulfide (H2S) gas.              toring the chamber pressure. Caution—Do NOT over-
  7.2.2 10 000 6 200 ppmv analyzed carbon dioxide (CO2)                 pressurize the chamber.
gas.                                                                       10.1.11 Turn on the oven and allow the wastewater chamber
  7.2.3 5 000 6 100 ppmv analyzed methane (CH4) gas.                    to achieve a testing temperature of 150 6 5°F (65 6 3°C).
  7.2.4 Balance dry air (for example, 78 % nitrogen, 21 %               (This normally takes 1 to 1.5 h.)
oxygen, 0.93 % argon, 0.039 % carbon dioxide).                             10.1.12 Repeat a check on the gas-tight seal of the test
  7.2.5 Gases are based on volume percent and shall be                  chamber as per 10.1.10.
commercially purchased as a gas mixture with accompanying                  10.2 Testing Procedure:
assay.                                                                     10.2.1 Lower the test specimens into the aqueous solution
8. Hazards                                                              for 15 min.
                                                                           10.2.2 Raise the carousel to the vapor phase (raised posi-
   8.1 This practice can be extremely hazardous. The glass              tion). Open the inlet and outlet stopcock valves and initiate
chamber must not be over-tightened or over-pressurized. Ex-             flow of the test gas directing the exhaust gases through the
treme caution needs to be taken when working with hydrogen              caustic scrubbers. Continue to purge the test chamber with the
sulfide gas, sulfuric acid, and any other gases incorporated into       test gas delivered at a rate of 1.5 6 0.25 litres per minute
the wastewater testing chamber. It is highly recommended that           (Lpm) for a minimum of 4 h to achieve saturation. Then
this procedure only be performed by a professional testing              terminate the gas flow and close the inlet and outlet stopcock
laboratory with experience and provisions for safe handling of          valves.
these dangerous gases and reagents.                                        10.2.3 After the sewer gas purge, the scrubbers shall be
9. Test Specimens                                                       purged with air to minimize the risk of caustic flow back.
                                                                           10.2.4 The test panels are immersed two more times for 15
   9.1 Test specimens shall be the type, quantity, and dimen-
                                                                        min at evenly spaced time intervals over the remaining
sions as agreed upon by all parties. Appendix X1 discusses
                                                                        duration of the day after the gas sparge is complete.
various testing specimens that can be utilized in this practice.
                                                                           10.2.5 This completes day one.
10. Operating Procedure                                                    10.3 Testing Procedure for Subsequent Weekdays:
  10.1 Preparation of the Wastewater Testing Chamber:                      10.3.1 At the first of each subsequent weekday, lower the
  10.1.1 Add the aqueous solution to the glass tank. It is              test specimens into the liquid phase (lowered position) for a
convenient to have the tank on a table in front of the oven,            period of 15 min.
where the table is set at the same height as the bottom of the             10.3.2 Raise the carousel to the vapor phase (raised posi-
oven.                                                                   tion). Open the inflow and outflow stopcock valves and sparge
                                                                    4
                                                                      G210 − 13
the test chamber with the wastewater gas delivered at a rate of               purge until the chamber is cool and the hydrogen sulfide has
1.5 6 0.25 Lpm for 50 min to re-saturate solution. Then                       been reduced below five ppm. (This may take up to 2 to 4 h.)
terminate gas flow and close the inlet and outlet stopcock                       10.5.3 Check the effluent air with appropriate gas detectors
valves.                                                                       to ensure the levels are within pertinent safety limits.
   10.3.3 After the sewer gas purge, the scrubbers shall be                      10.5.4 Release the carousel shaft and gently drop the
purged with air to minimize the risk of caustic flow back.                    carousel into the aqueous phase. Release the gas flow lines, and
   10.3.4 Immerse the test panels two more times for a period                 remove the test chamber from the oven. Continue with disas-
of 15 min each at 3 h intervals (61 h) for each working day and               sembly of the test chamber.
return to the vapor phase (raised position).                                     10.5.5 Remove the test specimens and rinse with tap water.
   10.3.5 Repeat the cycle testing for each working weekday                      10.5.6 Proceed with testing. Suggested testing procedures
for the 28 day testing duration.                                              are detailed in Appendix X1.
APPENDIXES
(Nonmandatory Information)
X1.1 General                                                                  shall not exceed the capabilities of the carousel. Examples of
   X1.1.1 A variety of testing specimens may be used in this                  useful specimen types and dimensions are described below.
practice. Specimens constructed of coated steel, coated ductile
iron, coated concrete, cast coating materials, or coating free                X1.2 Steel Specimens
films are commonly used to assess the polymer’s performance                      X1.2.1 For each coating to be tested, abrasive blast clean
and barrier qualities.                                                        four Specification A36 hot-rolled flat steel panels, minimum
   X1.1.2 It is important that the test specimens be smooth,                  size 3 by 4 by 1⁄8 in. (7.5 by 10 by 0.32 cm) to the surface
completely-continuous films or castings of uniform thickness                  cleanliness and anchor profile recommended by the coating
throughout the test area. The coating thickness shall not vary                manufacturer.
by more than 10 % of the total thickness recommended by the                     X1.2.2 Apply the candidate coating or lining system at the
manufacturer.                                                                 recommended thickness to the front and back of the panels.
   X1.1.3 All coating materials to be tested or compared shall                Dip the edges (sides, top, bottom) using the candidate coating
be applied to the same type and grade of substrate for a given                system (or other compatible material) to protect the edges from
test series.                                                                  corrosion break-through.
   X1.1.4 The size and shape of the test specimens may vary to                  X1.2.3 Test specimens shall provide a minimum of 24 in.2
conform to the dimensions of the chamber. The total weight                    (61 cm2) front and back of coated surface area.
                                                                          5
                                                                              G210 − 13
  X1.2.4 Steel test specimens are convenient when changes in                            X1.3.2 Apply recommended resurfacing material to fill
barrier properties of coatings are to be determined using the                         bugholes and surface irregularities of the concrete specimens
EIS technique (ISO 16773).7                                                           as recommended by the coating manufacturer.
                                                                                        X1.3.3 Apply the candidate coating or lining system at the
X1.3 Concrete Specimens
                                                                                      recommended thickness to all surfaces, taking care to ensure
   X1.3.1 For each coating to be tested, cast four concrete                           good coverage of edges.
cylinders using minimum 5000 psi (34 MPa) compressive
strength Portland Type 1 design mix conforming to Specifica-                          X1.4 Mechanical Testing Specimens
tion C387. The cylinders are to be a minimum size of 11⁄2 by                            X1.4.1 Tensile Testing—For each coating to be tested, cast
4 in. (4 cm diameter by 10 cm tall). Abrasive blast clean the                         two sets of the minimum number of samples specified by the
concrete cylinders as recommended by the coating manufac-                             ASTM standard using the candidate coating or lining in
turer.                                                                                accordance with Test Methods C307, D638, or D2370.
                                                                                        X1.4.2 Flexural Testing—Cast two sets of the minimum
  7
    Gray, Linda G. S., and Appleman, B. R., “EIS: Electrochemical Impedance
                                                                                      number of samples specified by the ASTM standard using the
Spectroscopy: A Tool to Predict Remaining Coating Life?,” Journal of Protective       candidate coating or lining in accordance with Test Method
Coatings and Linings, February 2003, pp. 66–74.                                       C580 or Test Method D790.
                                                                                  6
                                                                              G210 − 13
  X2.4.2 Describe the color, appearance, (that is, rough,                             X2.4.6 Evaluate fluid permeation of the coating using the
smooth, irregular) and any abnormalities.                                            method described in X2.3.8.
  X2.4.3 Evaluate checking using Test Method D660.
  X2.4.4 Evaluate cracking using Test Method D661.
   X2.4.5 Evaluate tensile strength, elongation, and compres-
sive strength using the applicable mechanical Test Method
C307, D638, D2370, or other suitable standard method.
                 ASTM International takes no position respecting the validity of any patent rights asserted in connection with any item mentioned
             in this standard. Users of this standard are expressly advised that determination of the validity of any such patent rights, and the risk
             of infringement of such rights, are entirely their own responsibility.
                 This standard is subject to revision at any time by the responsible technical committee and must be reviewed every five years and
             if not revised, either reapproved or withdrawn. Your comments are invited either for revision of this standard or for additional standards
             and should be addressed to ASTM International Headquarters. Your comments will receive careful consideration at a meeting of the
             responsible technical committee, which you may attend. If you feel that your comments have not received a fair hearing you should
             make your views known to the ASTM Committee on Standards, at the address shown below.
               This standard is copyrighted by ASTM International, 100 Barr Harbor Drive, PO Box C700, West Conshohocken, PA 19428-2959,
             United States. Individual reprints (single or multiple copies) of this standard may be obtained by contacting ASTM at the above
             address or at 610-832-9585 (phone), 610-832-9555 (fax), or service@astm.org (e-mail); or through the ASTM website
             (www.astm.org). Permission rights to photocopy the standard may also be secured from the ASTM website (www.astm.org/
             COPYRIGHT/).